Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Plaisterers Arms

    3.5 (2 reviews)
    ModeratePubs

    Plaisterers Arms Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Plaisterers Arms

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Tom S.
    369
    2488
    4210

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    17 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pubs 308 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Wesley House - Oddly, my room was also the fire exit for all other rooms on the floor.

    The Wesley House

    4.3(3 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    The Wesley House is no longer a pub or a restaurant. It remains a 15th century Merchant's House…read morewith lodging still happening upstairs from the former pub and restaurant. There was nothing exactly wrong with The Wesley House as a place of lodging but see if it's for you: * My bags were on the ground floor when I arrived. Nobody offered to bring them up the narrow stairway so I dragged them up myself. * The rooms are small but functional. Somewhat amusingly, the second floor emergency fire exit was in/through my room with the door to that exit ominously labeled "FINAL EXIT". Thankfully there was no need for anyone to run through my room on the night of my stay. * Though The Wesley House had someone on site when I arrived, that person gave me a key for the front entry door for later, when nobody is on-site. One lets themselves into and out of the building, walking through the former bar area to get up to the rooms. * There was nothing wrong with the breakfast that's included in the price of lodging but I will note that it was my least favorite breakfast of the 7 I had at other places during my time in the Cotswolds. The Wesley House is fine (no more, no less) but if you want something a little more than fine I'd keep searching.

    Outstanding! Superb gourmet English food at day tripper prices…read more 15th century building that oozes history. Cozy bar area entrance that leads up & into a more spacious dining room, further back is a bright dining atrium. The servers are personable, friendly, genuine, knowledgeable and helpful. Their attention to detail is truly well done. The food is extraordinary. I'm here renting a house in Winchcombe for the week. Getting a good lay of the land. Spent the previous week in London. My dinner here tonight was more delicious and better presented than any meal that I had in the big city. My wife & I each had 4 courses, 4 glasses of wine plus one dessert wine. The total tariff was 71 quid. Simply amazing. In my home, 60 miles north of San Francisco, an equivalent meal would cost 2.5X more. I am a monarchist. I want England to take us Americans back into the kingdom. Failing that I want to plead for political amnesty and immigrate here. (Sssshhhhh, It's really not about the politics. I want to enjoy the superior food for the remainder of my life). If you are in the Cheltenham area and desire a memorable meal, this place will satisfy & delight you.

    Photos
    The Wesley House
    The Wesley House - Black cod, crayfish, new potatoes, broccoli, savory white sauce.

    Black cod, crayfish, new potatoes, broccoli, savory white sauce.

    The Wesley House

    See all

    Sherborne Arms - Beautiful to look at but that is it

    Sherborne Arms

    3.3(4 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    Lovely inside. The restaurant is in a wonderful sleepy town of Northleach. Service was great, but…read morewhen we asked on the history of the location the server didn't know. She did ask a local and we learned it was an old armory. Go for the ambiance and a drink but skip the food. This was the worst meal we had on our Cotswold trip. The Chips tasted as though they were fried in very old oil and the pie had an overwhelming flavor of the spice- not sure what is was, but that was all that you could taste and it took away from the flavor of the pie. The chicken was very dry. My suggestion is stop here for a drink and then eat across the street at The Wheatsheaf Inn.

    Sherborne Arms is a small (3 rooms) pub/restaurant in North Leach, a charming little market town in…read morethe Cotswald. The back banqueting area of the pub was a blacksmiths shop until the late 1960s. The front area is a typical village pub. It filled with locals having a pint or two, and couples out for dinner while we set by the fireplace in cozy arm chairs. There was a contingent of younger, louder patrons later, but by 9:30pm, most had gone home and the barkeep was cleaning up for the night. Our room was neat, large and clean. The beams over the bed and rock walls showed their age (15-16th century), but everything was up to modern standards. The electric tea kettle and bisquits were perfect to get us going in the morning. A full English breakfast was included in th £70 price. It was great!

    Photos
    Sherborne Arms - Chicken was dry

    Chicken was dry

    Sherborne Arms - Tart was ok, Fig was bland

    Tart was ok, Fig was bland

    Sherborne Arms - Eaton Mess had to much Meringue and not enough berries to offset the sweet

    See all

    Eaton Mess had to much Meringue and not enough berries to offset the sweet

    Plaisterers Arms - pubs - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...