The place smells amazing when you walk in. Customer service is great. A very easy straightforward…read moremenu. You can order by the slice or get a whole pie for yourself. This pizza is absolutely delicious and has a unique crust that is not mass produced. Highly recommend.

wow i saw the sign that the owners from New York and I wanted to come in and try in New York slice…read moreand it did not disappoint at all their 2 slice and a drink special hit the spot! service was awesome too!!

The pizzas I ordered were the large version of Woody Allen (vegetarian) and I also got a split half…read moreand half sausage and cheese. Also some garlic toast. To go. The bill was $73 w a small tip. Worth it? We'll.. It's definitely tasty pizza. I would bring the right audience to this place in a heart beat.

I ordered ham and pineapple got pepperoni and sausage. They closed in 20 minutes by the time I got…read morehome and they wouldn't even answer the phone call. Worst place to get a pizza in Sioux Falls. I recommend a highly against it. No accountability for their mistakes no way to get a hold of them. They just let the phone ring and ring

Build your own pizza had the thin crust tasty and reasonably priced !!…read moreHave gone there twice on trips and would go again

Food was amazing , place an order for delivery on their website. They did forget to add my addition…read moreof pepperoni to my 14" pizza but it was still yummy.

Ordered two pizzas tonight, a custom 2-topp and a specialty. Pizza makers followed the special…read moreinstructions accurately with attention to detail. Pizzas came out fresh while I waited. Sadly, I got home to discover that one of the pizzas in our order was mistakenly switched out with another customer's. Even more sadly, the missing pie was the special preference of our 4 year old, who, being already sick and exhausted, promptly began weeping at the surprising absence of his anticipated pepperoni pizza. To our good fortune, manager Chris was professional and accommodating in making things right. In the end, lo and behold! we had a frozen pepperoni pizza buried in our chest freezer, so the evening ended rather satisfactorily! We'll certainly be returning before too long!

We order pickup, they messed up our order but promptly fixed it at no charge. It's a cool little…read morepizza joint. I enjoyed my sausage pizza.

Hostesses welcomed us but when she sat us she left the table without a word. Once our waitress came…read moreshe was very pleasant. Pizza was good. Garden Salad amazing. Spicy buffalo wings were good. Tap beer IPA was really good as well. We will be back definitely to try other foods on the menu.

Worst place ever, bartender didn't acknowledge us. Waited 20 minutes and no one around to seat…read moreus. Left and went someplace else. A customer at the bar came and talked to us and said she waited 30 minutes for a beer. Will never go there again.

Getting a new manager and assistant manager along with a kitchen manager they need to clean up the…read moreway the people are they let employees stand around they don't clean the bathrooms like they're supposed to they also have employees that pick their nose and wipe their nose with gloves on and then they proceed to go back to work ... there is mold in the sink and in the ice machine the cappuccino machine is never cleaned ... there are no outside lights the place is being run down to the ground they also food in the corners when they are busy. They have so much talking and nothing being done ... you can talk to the manager both and never around all three people sit there and talk and ignore the customer.

Tonight I order pizza from Casey's online for delivery and I got a receipt and an email…read moreconfirmation that it be delivered and 40 minutes but then I got a call 5 minutes later they were telling me that they been delivered tonight and I have to pick up my pizza in an hour . So I walked a mile to go get my pizza cause my car was in the shop and when I get there I asked her manager there is no manager and I can't have a phone number to call a manager because they charge me a delivery fee on this pizza that was supposed to be delivered in they made me come pick up it is not my fault but the manager cannot manage their employees so I would like to be reimbursed

It's definitely not the same as the old Valentinos, but it's still very, very good. I like the…read morelasagna with meat sauce. It's my go-to every time I order. Be sure to take a look at the lunch specials as there's a ton of food and the prices are hard to beat. I wish they would bring the s'mores desert pizza back!! It's worth a visit!

What is going on with Valention's? I have been ordering the same pizza since they opened. Even…read moreafter I broke my tooth on something in there beef. We order beef, mushroom and extra mozzarella cheese. Each time we ordered the toppings got smaller and skimpier each time. today I was met with a pizza with pretty much no sauce, very little cheese ( definitely not extra cheese) and hardly any beef or mushrooms. I don't think I'm going to order from them anymore. This is ridiculous. the same thing happened with their pastas. Godfathers anyone?

We love the food, ambiance, and the grocery! Fun place to go in Sioux Falls! Try the salads!read more

Saw this restaurant on Guy Fieri and it was only 6 min from our hotel so had to try it! Order at…read morecounter and take a seat with your number and they will bring out your dinner. Sunday is an additional menu with steak, filet and prime rib ( which they were out of by 6 pm!). My husband had the pricey filet which did not come with sides! It was excellent cooked over oak on grill but for $50 they could have thrown in a potato at least. We shared a beet salad which was very good. I had the shaved steak sandwich which came with seasoned fries. Sandwich was on a large ciabatta roll baked in house. Both were delicious. The dining area we sat is was so noisy! We did not realize the was a smaller room off of it that was quieter. Outside would have been great but it was too windy. The store, bakery, butcher shop and deli were cool but prices were definitely higher than we are used too. Food was 5 star, ambiance 3 star. If they are going to serve pricey food- have a sit down service area!

Me as a black man wasn't greeted when I walked in but the white folks were like this is 1926 and…read morethe bathroom didn't have no soap. Do better bc I'm not paying 15-20 for bullshit. Yall can improve a lot but start with the service and make sure the bathroom is clean. Some ppl like to wash their hands before they eat

they fricking messed up my order . The workers were not pleasant. Dont go there. Ambiance was bad…read more Food was awful.

This fairly new location offered a good selection of on-the-go foods and drinks including a nice…read morecoffee area, a pastry case and a Casey's kitchen with pizza by the slice. I also noticed clean and nice restrooms, a laundry area and showers. Overall, very nice.

First off, you need to stop offering delivery on your online ordering. Three times I tried to place…read morea delivery order and your website made it seem as if my order was processed. Casey's online order app took all of my credit card information, etc. Only after I decided to call the store back 20 to 30 minutes after each order did somebody finally tell me (after I called them 3 times) that they don't deliver? (WTF do you advertise delivery!!?? They just DoorDash. Casey's needs to take delivery off of their online ordering. Also they need to hire people that can cook more than one pizza every 30 minutes. I called the store that's literally six blocks away from me and was told they couldn't make my order because they were too busy!!???!! This has happened multiple times at the store on Brian Street in Tea, South Dakota.