Incredible. We visited at the end of summer last year to discover new ownership and a revamped menu. Everything was incredible. Our family literally talked about it for weeks. We came back to town this weekend and had our fingers crossed that it wasn't just a one hit wonder. AND IT WAS EVEN BETTER!!! Everything was incredible. From the salads to the appetizers to the pizza and even the desert pizza! The service was perfect. Totally accommodating to our large group and even encouraged my wife and niece to dance while the song they selected on the jukebox played and our server turned the volume up for them! We talked with the new owner as she shared her vision for the place and how important quality ingredients were for her recipes. You can absolutely tell. The food rivals any pizzeria we frequent in Tulsa or any other place we've been. So excited to eat here all summer and enjoy evenings on the deck listening to the live music they book after a day on the lake. So happy this legend of a restaurant is up and running and I can honestly say it has never been better!! Great job and kudos Pizza Port! Couldn't recommend more!!! read more

Pizza is really good!!! Foosball and other outdoor games fun w the kiddos Great stop after long day on the lake Service is great considering it's always a weekend night when we go .. can take a while to get food when busy but worth it Good kids working hard so be patient :-) We also order pickup pizza for the boat sometimes Wish they had wine read more

Pizza Port - Outside dining .. - Pizza Near Me - Wagoner, Oklahoma

See all

Looks like Yelp has two sites for this very yummy place, so let's add the review here too! From arrival to departure our experience was fantastic! We were immediately greeted by a very nice server who took care of all the tables, and kept up with incoming customers amazingly well. We ordered wine and beer, a limited selection but just fine in this welcoming atmosphere. The pizzas, and we ordered Smalls, were very generously topped, and not just thrown together. Hand tossed crust with a satisfying crunch and delicious, savory, fresh toppings. We couldn't stop telling our server how very good they were! The owner visited with us and gave us a delightful sample of German chocolate cake, spongy sweetness. We can't wait to visit again! read more

Pizza Port - Meat Mania, easy on cheese - Pizza Near Me - Wagoner, Oklahoma

See all

How do you stay in business in a remote location? Make your product worth the drive... This pizza place is worth the drive! Just do it! You know you want some outstanding, mouth watering pizza in a friendly environment. Live music on Saturdays. read more

Pizza Port - Meat pizza with pineapple and black olives added. - Pizza Near Me - Wagoner, Oklahoma

We stopped in because it's the perfect spot for dinner after a round of golf at Sequoyah! We got there only about 40 minutes before they closed, but they were very nice! We weren't rushed at all and our server was young and super great. It's got the best little patio to eat outside! And a juke box inside! Now, the pizza! It's SO good. Like seriously good pizza. We had a pesto chicken one with bacon. Delicious. And the sausage roll is like a calizone appetizer that is also tasty! I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

We stopped in here for lunch today and we really enjoyed it. We each had a small pizza, he had pepperoni and I had chicken with pesto. Crust was perfect for us. Thin, crispy and delicious. Pesto is delicious! Had a size to dip bread in also. We also shared a piece of pecan pie and OMG-my husband said it taste like when his Grandma made it. Truly delicious piece of pie that I highly recommend. We also had great service! Overall great stop and we look forward to coming back again. read more

We were looking for a place to take the grandkids for pizza on the last night of our camping trip, and decided to try Pizza Port tonight. What a great choice it was! The service was fast, friendly, and accurate. The pizzas were awesome! This was definitely the best pizza that I have eaten in quite some time! We enjoyed sitting outside on the deck. We would love to come back if we are ever in the area. read more

Let's start with the most pressing urgent issue. The summer heat of 2024. If you are camping in your sweat lodge tent, Easy Bake Oven RV, boating in the blistering sun or simmering in the scalding waters of nearby Ft. Gibson Lake's, Taylor's Ferry Beach, you need to find cool. The Pizza Port is your port of call, a haven of endless refrigerated air. My wife and I pulled up at the Pizza Port midafternoon. It is hot. I checked the batteries in my Life Alert, in case I went down from the heat on the trip to the front door of the restaurant. We jumped out and made a run for it. We are inside and it feels good! The Pizza Port is a safe harbor from the heat with magnificent air-conditioning! You can't eat in the heat. (However, outside dining on a cozy deck is available, if you are wet and smelly from camping.) We are cool; this feels good. Let's get some pizza. Keep it simple. Medium, thin crust sausage pizza for us. The medium is big. The large is about the size of a boat trailer tire. The pizza was flooded with waves of sausage and melted cheese. As I pulled a big slice from the pan the mooring ropes of Mozzarella stretched long to prevent the slice from drifting away. The first bite, the crispy bottom of the crust meets the top of your tongue. You know this pizza going to be good. Then comes the armada of flavor: fresh savory sausage, melted cheese and tomato sauce. This is a delicious loaded meaty pizza. The good kind of pizza, not that NY stuff. Plenty left over. We filled up the cargo hull of a cardboard to go box and left port with half of the remaining pizza. When we got home, I had to have one more slice before putting the leftovers in the refrigerator. After the pizza was served, the Pizza Port Harbor Master (the owner), dusted the flour off of his hands and came out from the gally to visit with us. A very nice guy, truly interested in providing good food and a pleasurable dining experience for his customers. He has an interesting business background. After years of managing his successful businesses in the Tulsa area, he sold them and moved to the lake. Obviously not to retire. His experience working with people and a familiarity with operating ovens probably made it and easy transition to dealing with the public and cooking pizza. Say hello to him if you get the opportunity. The Pizza Port is open for business. The best pizza between Wagoner and Tahlequah. Conveniently located near Sequoyah State Park and Tailors Ferry on Highway 51. read more

See all

One word to explain this place would be fantastic!. My son and I always like to try new pizza places whenever we travel, so on our trip to Fort Gibson Lake for a boys fishing trip, we had to find a pizza joint. From the reviews, I read prior to our visit. It looked like it was out spot this year and so glad for Yelp because they came through with flying colors. The service was exceptional and the pizza was delicious. We also got the sausage bites which were exceptional. This place is must go when you are visiting Fort Gibson Lake, if you're looking for a great pizza. read more

While the food is okay the prices of the drinks are exorbitant, a large drink for three dollars almost 1/3 the cost of a sandwich. Although the server was nice she gave me a blessing which I thought was strange. Doubt I will return. read more

First the ambiance is great casual and welcoming, Dining indoors and patio with live entertainment on weekends. We came strictly for great pizza and that is exactly what we were served. Spouse had his favorite a Hawaiian pizza and I had the chicken Alfredo but tweaked it with a pesto replacement for the Alfredo. The crust was perfection and the pies were so good we ended up eating the leftovers later that day. Now the staff were outgoing and helpful regarding the questions on local places and also menu. Aside from those topics we all enjoyed chatting like long lost friends about everything else. The owner came out in apron and flour dusting from hand tossing pizza to inquire on our dinner experience. Again talking with him was so much fun and we readily saw how much pride he takes in his place and menu. I do not plan to seek another pizza or sandwich place. This will be my go to from now on! And coming from east coast origin I do know regional pizza and believe me when I say this is like going home and true hand made tastes. read more

Best pizza Great owners Good service Clean environment and fun activities with live entertainment on weekends read more

PIZZA PORT IF YOURE READING THIS PLEASE OPEN BACK UP!!! Pizza port is exactly the meal you want and need after a day on Fort Gibson Lake. The pizza is delicious and one of a kind, and they also have great ranch dressing, which any pizza lover knows is key. Unfortunately Pizza Port seems to be shut down now. I called last week and it said the number was out of service. :( read more

The pizza and apps were really great. Live music, on the loud side. But it was really busy, take that as a good sign

Great atmosphere, super friendly servers, and fantastic food. I highly recommend the supreme pizza and calzone. There are plenty of options to choose from. Lake view on the patio is very pleasing. read more

They have re-opened and their pizza is actually better than it was. They really cleaned the place up and the staff are awesome.

My wife, Alice Ellington and I went to the Pizza Port today for lunch and it was a great experience! Great service and outstanding food! Pizza was cooked perfectly and lots of toppings! Will definitely go back and even drove from Tulsa! Worth the drive!!! Just recently reopened under new ownership and worth trying! read more

Called to place order and immediately placed on "hold" She just put the phone down. As she and other employee had discussions about bedrooms and full bars. Hung up after several minutes Will give them one more try on another day read more

Don't go with first impressions. When we walked in a table still had dishes on it from a previous group but know one in sight. The waitress may have been new because she seemed a little unsure of things. There were 4 of us and she brought one menu. Didn't ask us what salad dressing we wanted on our salads. However, the waitress was really nice and did a great job of making sure we had everything once we ordered. The pizzas were very good, perhaps one of the better pizzas I have had in a while. I would recommend this place for a good pizza when in the area. read more

Each time that we come to Lake Fort Gibson we come to Pizza Port. The food is great and the people are super nice. Our boys love to play pool and foozeball while we wait. Try the cheese sticks. We can't wait to come back next summer. read more

If you like pizza, then this is the spot to be on Fort Gibson Lake. The pizzas here are made with love. read more

Pizza Port - a slice taken out of a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wagoner, Oklahoma

We have been here before and it was good. Went back today and waited an hour and all we got was drinks. We paid for the drinks and left. There was one other family in there and that's it. No reason for them to be that backed up. We never even got our appetizers. read more

Service was apathetic and slow. Phone line was busy to call in the order ahead of time. The order was inaccurate.

Best pizza East of Tulsa! Homemade dough at the ready and fantastic sauce made on site. Great location with an outdoor deck for seating with a beautiful view of the lake. Kudos to a new staff for the season. So glad this place made it through the disaster of the pandemic. Family owned and operated for 33 years!! Highly recommend the sausage rolls too. read more

Closed but not forgotten. Really miss it hope it opens again. It's a fixture in Taylors Ferry.

Great service and pizza. Dogs are allowed on the patio!! Cherry Limeades and good as well.

As a European I can say this is the best pizza ever my US experience. Thin crust, not too loaded, great stuff. I recommend, hands down. read more

Pizza Port - Nice patio where you can enjoy a relaxing atmosphere. - Pizza Near Me - Wagoner, Oklahoma

Was okay. Hot and fresh. Could have used more sauce. Staff was friendly. Wouldn't drive out if my way to eat there but would stop again Thin crust pepperoni and sausage. Good value for the price!!!!! read more

Cheese sticks are AMAZING! Restaurant had kind of an old fun classic feel. Pizza was great and since our eyes were bigger than our stomachs we also learned it is just as good left over. read more

Poor service and unfriendly waitstaff. Waited over an hour for my pizza, longer than a wait in Chicago for a deep dish

My grandpa asked for ice and waited for like 5 minutes he ended up getting up and asking staff at the front counter. We understand there are only 4 people there two people training and one wittiness and one cook we are the only ones in the restaurant And we had to get up and get our waitress to take our order because she was making a drink for the chef which out of a qt bottle staff is only talking to each other haven't said a word to us . We've been here an hour we walked in at 3:04 and it's now 3:55 my grandpa ended up eating a candy bars Because it Took so long for our food . Just food at 4:00 Fries on my with my burger looks to done my ranch burger had burly any ranch the food was just mea at best not good not bad a girl in a white shirt part of the for or five people who just walked in to work noticed my little 7 year old Cousin then ignored her. When she was just standing there doing nothing we'll never come back! Just giving you A warning read more

Great little out of the way Pizza Place. Definitely for the lake crowd, but if that's your type of people this ace can't be beat. Really good Pizza also willing to deliver. read more

I've been to lots of pizza places and this is the best. They easily have the best cheese sticks of any pizza place. The buffet is awesome. I've been eating there since I was 12. It's great lol read more

Awesome food and service! Does tend to take awhile to get your food if your dinning in and even though you maybe the only family there, however the food is great! Lake lovers retreat! read more

The food is good. Cheeseburger in paradise is by far my favorite. But the service is horrible! Took over an hour to get our food and that was the appetizer! The waitress never checked on us unless she was bringing food to our table. Again good food! HORRIBLE SERVICE! read more