Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    4.0 (2 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Tony V.
    0
    20
    71

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kim F.
    1
    16
    1

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 227 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Simple Simon's Pizza

    Simple Simon's Pizza

    5.0(3 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    After living here for two years, I still haven't tried Simple Simon's Pizza... so I fixed that and…read moreordered take out from the Wagoner location. I wished I had tried it earlier. They explained the make all their dough fresh everyday and that stood out in the flavor. I look forward to trying the lunch buffet soon.

    A deep bass-baritone voice resonated on a small speaker tucked in the cornice above our table…read more Unmistakably Johnny Cash, strumming the song about an old cowboy chasing the mythical devil's herd, "Ghost riders in the Sky." At the end of the song the local radio station breaks in to identify itself and remind the listeners that they play both kinds of music, Country and Western. You are in the real Oklahoma. If it happens to be the Simple Simon's in Wagoner, you made a good choice! First of all did you know that this franchise started in Sand Springs, OK? Yep, 1987. They have hundreds of franchise locations, in small towns across several states. Locations, history and menu can be found online. Not cooking today. It is a muddy gloomy day at the camp ground. Wagoner is a short distance and a pizza brightens almost any day. The reviews on Google favored Simple Simon's in Wagoner over the competition. Nice, clean, roomy little restaurant, easy to find on the main drag going into town. We picked a large, thin crust sausage, with a one trip salad bar side. The pizza was a "simple," unpretentious pan of old school pizza parlor delight. The large, enough food for a meal today and tomorrow, at a small-town price. The one trip salad bar was another amazing bargain. It had a full variety of veggies, meats and dressings. An old-time salad bar spread that I haven't seen for years. The price $2.99. The plate was large, A skilled food stacker could make a filling meal in one trip. Delicious pizza and salad bar, a good variety of menu items, friendly staff, clean restaurant, value pricing, relaxing small-town ambiance. From my iPhone

    Photos
    Simple Simon's Pizza
    Simple Simon's Pizza - Triple pepperoni with extra cheese, black olives, and stuffed crust.

    Triple pepperoni with extra cheese, black olives, and stuffed crust.

    Simple Simon's Pizza - Lunch buffet!

    See all

    Lunch buffet!

    Pizza Port - Cinnamon sticks

    Pizza Port

    4.3(34 reviews)
    6.1 mi

    Incredible. We visited at the end of summer last year to discover new ownership and a revamped…read moremenu. Everything was incredible. Our family literally talked about it for weeks. We came back to town this weekend and had our fingers crossed that it wasn't just a one hit wonder. AND IT WAS EVEN BETTER!!! Everything was incredible. From the salads to the appetizers to the pizza and even the desert pizza! The service was perfect. Totally accommodating to our large group and even encouraged my wife and niece to dance while the song they selected on the jukebox played and our server turned the volume up for them! We talked with the new owner as she shared her vision for the place and how important quality ingredients were for her recipes. You can absolutely tell. The food rivals any pizzeria we frequent in Tulsa or any other place we've been. So excited to eat here all summer and enjoy evenings on the deck listening to the live music they book after a day on the lake. So happy this legend of a restaurant is up and running and I can honestly say it has never been better!! Great job and kudos Pizza Port! Couldn't recommend more!!!

    Pizza is really good!!! Foosball and other outdoor games…read morefun w the kiddos Great stop after long day on the lake Service is great considering it's always a weekend night when we go .. can take a while to get food when busy but worth it Good kids working hard so be patient :-) We also order pickup pizza for the boat sometimes Wish they had wine

    Photos
    Pizza Port - Outside dining ..

    Outside dining ..

    Pizza Port - All meat calzone

    All meat calzone

    Pizza Port - View of the lake

    See all

    View of the lake

    Pizza Port - Veggie pizza

    Pizza Port

    5.0(4 reviews)
    6.1 mi

    Let's start with the most pressing urgent issue. The summer heat of 2024…read more If you are camping in your sweat lodge tent, Easy Bake Oven RV, boating in the blistering sun or simmering in the scalding waters of nearby Ft. Gibson Lake's, Taylor's Ferry Beach, you need to find cool. The Pizza Port is your port of call, a haven of endless refrigerated air. My wife and I pulled up at the Pizza Port midafternoon. It is hot. I checked the batteries in my Life Alert, in case I went down from the heat on the trip to the front door of the restaurant. We jumped out and made a run for it. We are inside and it feels good! The Pizza Port is a safe harbor from the heat with magnificent air-conditioning! You can't eat in the heat. (However, outside dining on a cozy deck is available, if you are wet and smelly from camping.) We are cool; this feels good. Let's get some pizza. Keep it simple. Medium, thin crust sausage pizza for us. The medium is big. The large is about the size of a boat trailer tire. The pizza was flooded with waves of sausage and melted cheese. As I pulled a big slice from the pan the mooring ropes of Mozzarella stretched long to prevent the slice from drifting away. The first bite, the crispy bottom of the crust meets the top of your tongue. You know this pizza going to be good. Then comes the armada of flavor: fresh savory sausage, melted cheese and tomato sauce. This is a delicious loaded meaty pizza. The good kind of pizza, not that NY stuff. Plenty left over. We filled up the cargo hull of a cardboard to go box and left port with half of the remaining pizza. When we got home, I had to have one more slice before putting the leftovers in the refrigerator. After the pizza was served, the Pizza Port Harbor Master (the owner), dusted the flour off of his hands and came out from the gally to visit with us. A very nice guy, truly interested in providing good food and a pleasurable dining experience for his customers. He has an interesting business background. After years of managing his successful businesses in the Tulsa area, he sold them and moved to the lake. Obviously not to retire. His experience working with people and a familiarity with operating ovens probably made it and easy transition to dealing with the public and cooking pizza. Say hello to him if you get the opportunity. The Pizza Port is open for business. The best pizza between Wagoner and Tahlequah. Conveniently located near Sequoyah State Park and Tailors Ferry on Highway 51.

    Food and service was great! Cute place with indoor and outdoor seating. Pizza and nachos were very…read moregood! Will be back soon!!!

    Photos
    Pizza Port
    Pizza Port
    Pizza Port

    See all

    Subway

    Subway

    2.6(8 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $

    2 employees working. 2 orders a total of 3 sandwiches…read more This took 30 minutes. I am not exaggerating. The other lady who puts the meat on the bread went out for a smoke during all of this. The lady making the sandwich's took for freaking ever. I can't believe this. The meat lady - before she went to it for a smoke warmed the chicken up and left it on the counter for 5 minutes and by then the chicken was cold again. I wanted to ask for fresh hot chicken but that would have taken another 10 minutes. I'm not being ugly or mean. I am simply stating the facts. This was like the twilight zone.

    I usually loved this place. Today I decided to go through the drive thru, which was a mistake. Upon…read moretrying to pay, I gave them my debit card, they came back three times saying my bank was declining. I ended up calling my bank only to be told that nothing was even going through to the bank, therefore something going on with their machine inside. Keep in mind , it's been around 10 -15 min at this point. It's 100 degrees outside and my car has no AC, just wanted to make a quick trip for lunch. Upon letting the employee know that the problem was most likely with the machine inside, she looked at me confused , then said "okay well, I'll try to swipe it instead?" As if asking me . I said whatever needs to be done do it as it's not my card. A few minutes later another employee comes up to the window and lets me know that the machine disconnected from the internet, therefore resulting in it not working, I had to wait for it to turn back on so they could charge me. I was okay with it, but by this point I was very visibly sweating, and a little frustrated. Mind you I was never rude not once even with my annoyance and them knowing it was their fault and not apologizing either, because I know it's not their fault my car doesn't have AC, but I would've loved some sense of urgency, especially being close to 15 minutes in the sun at this point. After a few more minutes, she gave me my card and receipt. I looked at her confused , where's my sandwich? She says they were barely making it. It's been 20 minutes of me waiting here, and your barely making my sandwich? I was fuming for sure. Now I am pregnant so I do everything to have a good attitude as I don't want to be mean. I know it shouldn't be expected, but I at least hoped they would ask me if I wanted a free cookie or something even a coupon for my next sandwich since I was sitting there waiting for over 20 minutes for something that was not my fault. But nope. She brought me my sandwich, said have a nice day, and left. I tried to see the positive through it, at least I received my sandwich. But the customer service was really unorganized, seemed like they didn't care that it was their fault, and never offered anything to apologize. Will definitely be avoiding this subway and will let anyone know around me that the service sucks.

    Photos
    Subway
    Subway
    Subway

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...