Stopped on our way up north during the middle of a snow storm and everyone was starving. Even that didn't really have an impact on how the pizza tasted. When we came in, there was no seating however, a family was taking up two tables unnecessarily and they quickly left. It is a very casual place, you can see the entirety of the restaurant including the kitchen from about anywhere you stand. There were only two other smaller parties that ordered before us but it still took 30+ minutes for us to get two pizzas, which felt long. They ended up throwing in the cheese bread because we apparently ordered some type of combo without knowing. I'm not going to say it's the worst pizza I've ever had, yet questionable of if I'd rather have a frozen. Pizza was floppy, not necessarily in a good way. The employees were very nice. We were able to grab our own drinks from the fridge and pay for it all at the end. We saw another group order calzones & being able to see them being made, looked a lot better than the pizzas. So if we are ever stuck coming here again we will go for that, semi decent spot if needed. read more

See all

Service was friendly, the pizza was perfection. The decor and old fashioned feel was like stepping into the past. I felt like a kid eating there. read more

I'm not a huge fan of thin crust pizza. But it feels like a ma and pa pizza places. It does get a lot of business though. The service is always great. It's a nice small homie place. read more

Pizza and subs are amazing. The people were so nice, and loved the small family own restaurant they got inside.

I was looking forward to trying this place. We called and were told a hour and a half wait. Fine as we wanted to try it. We get there at exactly 1.5 hours later. Our pizza is ready and cold. Seriously the box wasn't even warm. I was a little disappointed but the place smelled good so I was still excited. It was terrible. The cheese was congealed, the crust was so crispy that it broke as you picked it up. Soooooo disappointed. read more

Pizza Plus - Congealed cheese and crispy crust. This was right as we got it. - Pizza Near Me - Cadillac, Michigan

I am clearly in the minority here, but this pizza is just not good and I don't understand the hype. I ordered a large vegetarian pizza for pickup. I am not picky about my toppings, but it was nearly 100% covered in olives-- both black and green. There were a few mushrooms buried under there, but the olives were seriously overwhelming. What's more, there were so many olives and sauce, the pizza was incredibly soggy and floppy. So I already wasn't impressed, but thought, okay, the end of the crust will at least be good, you can't really mess that up. Unfortunately, even that was hard as a brick. I absolutely hate wasting food but could only conquer one piece before I had to cut my losses. My parents got a supreme and were equally unimpressed. read more

Always fresh, high quality ingredients. Fast and courteous service. Never stingy. My pizzas, salads, burritos, and sandwiches are always loaded. Great portions, food at an affordable price. Thanks Pizza Plus! read more

There is a reason they are #1 in Cadillac, they are an excellent pizza. We had four teens and four adults eating; we split 3 large pizzas and had a bunch left over. I cannot day when I will be I will be back to Cadillac but I would eat here again. read more

I personally am really picky about pizza. Decided one night we was tired of the same old pizza places and decided to try this place. Went in and placed our order...An olive pizza and a pepperoni pizza..and the staff was very friendly. We waited for about 25 minutes and received our order and continued home. I will say the boys and the Boyfriend loved it. I didn't care much for the crust. So in conclusion...yes I would recommend this place for off the beaten path pizza. I personally would only order for another family get together..but its not for me. The staff is why this place is 4 star. read more

I've been going to Pizza Plus since I was a little kid. It was "Dave & Jim's" back then - we still call it that! The quality and value of food has remained great over the years, which is really impressive. I don't think the decor has changed in the last ~25 years either, but that's part of the charm! Whenever I visit home, I always want to stop by. The pizza is really good, but my favorite is the toasted Original Sub. The special sauce is truly amazing, I always ask for an extra side! read more

Another fantastic pizza from Pizza Plus. Thank you as always. Here is a place you can count on for superior products!!! Always happy after I've made a visit. Cya soon. Just made another visit to the best pizza in 3 counties!! Pizza Plus, should be called Perfect Pizza!! Hank says job well done. 27 Oct 18 another Perfect pizza. It was our color tour pie! I love just walking in, you never let us down. read more

Good pizza, staff ( owners) are one reason we come in. Food is great, wet burritos are more than filling. Friendly people even when busy will take the time to talk to you. read more

Best pizza in town. Hands down worth the wait. Everyone says G&D is the staple of Cadillac. They are so wrong. This place is seriously the best. read more

Heard good things so I thought I'd give them a try. As I was waiting for order the cook made change for someone and went back to placing toppings on a pizza without washing his hands. Pizza was Subpar. Will never go back. read more

Excellent pizza!!! I travel all over the country with my job and eat pizza in a lot of different cities. This pizza is up there with some of the best. We got three 16" pizzas, two had 5 toppings each and one had 2 toppings. Also got two orders of cheesy garlic bread. Total was only $49. Fed 8 of us and we have leftovers. Will certainly go back next time we r in town!! read more

Pizza Plus - Menu inside as of 7/24/15... - Pizza Near Me - Cadillac, Michigan

The only pizza place we go to in Cadillac. We live 45 minutes away and try to make it a point to get a pizza from there before we head home. Not very many Mom & Pop places tossing there own dough anymore. The pizza there are definitely made with a passion and I love the crispy cracker like crust. There is just about it. Still remember it from the Dave & Jim days; it's still the same. Good as ever! read more

Best pizza in Cadillac and the Pizza pouches! If you like thin and oven baked piping hot pizza the way it should be, don't miss a stop here! We have to eat it once a week or go into withdrawals . read more

The pizza was AWESOME! Nice thin crust, flavorful sauce, good toppings, generous amount of toppings too! Perfect hometown flavor! read more

Pizza Plus - Fabulous pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Cadillac, Michigan

See all

Well 30 minutes times three, And don't try using the app, FYI they delivered to the wrong house never confirming A name or number. The other house who didn't order even called and they blew us off like we were to error. Cadillac call local pizza. Dominos at their prices is not it. read more

Best pizza in town and locally owned! The prices are reasonable and the staff is always very friendly. We love it here.

My first time at Pizza Plus was this last Monday evening---WOW what a find---great pizza, My girlfriend has been coming there for many years on trips up to Petoskey---A MUST STOP PLACE TO EAT (we called ahead and our pizza was ready when we walked in the door)---a few minutes off 131---but well worth it. The decor has not changed over the years--simple decor--super clean--great baseball pictures) a fantastic mom and pop place. The owners were fantastic and very friendly---we will be back and again---a great friendly place, clean, great pizza and great prices. This is why they have been in business for over 50 years !! Support Small Local Businesses like Pizza Plus !!! read more

Pizza plus is awesome! Reasonable prices, the pizza is thin crust style with plenty of toppings. The original Sub is fantastic if you are in the mood for that instead. Love it read more

Pizza plus is a local pizza place with a long history. We love it! If you like a thin crispy outer crust, but yet you can fold your pizza like a New York style this is right up your alley. The garlic bread with cheese can be a meal in itself. The menu is simple and very reasonable. read more

Really gross, thin pizza. I love a greasy slice of pizza every now and again but this pizza was overly greasy. It is super cheap so there's that read more

Great little corner pizzeria near the riverfront in Downtown Cadillac. Cheesy and gooey and hot! Typical American style pizza. Delicious...

A favorite amongst Cadillac locals who still call it by its previous name Dave & Jim's. This is the only pizza where I look forward to eating the crust. read more

Just wanted to let the owners know that when open yelps app there's a picture of a pizza and it's got three or four hairs on it! Does not look very appealing read more

Passing through to Upper Peninsula and we happened to run across this place by accident but we're glad we did! Small, genuinely friendly mom and pop pizza joint with excellent pizza. Family loved the flaky, crispy dough with plenty of cheese and topping- New York style. Great price too. Very refreshing difference away from Dominos, Papa Johns and the likes- support your local merchant that provides quality food! read more

This is a no frills pizza joint with great pizza. It took about 20 min for the pizza to be done and it had great flavor and a good crust. My only complaint is the place is super small read more

This is the best place for pizza in Cadillac, with the Timbers and BC Pizza coming in second and third respectively. I've been a regular since it was called Dave and Jim's and they've always had the best sauce in town. Completely unpretentious, too! I just got back to Cadillac for some time on the lake and had to renew my appreciation. They are still the best in town. read more

These guys have been in town forever - and theres a reason for it ! Cant go wrong here... always well topped and cooked to crispy crust perfection. Take couple home every visit !! read more

Pizza Plus is delicious! My friends and family love the special sauce on the sandwiches! I also feel great supporting a local family's business. The inside of the place is worn down, but that's part of its charm and small-town feel. Some things never change :) May Pizza Plus live long and prosper. read more

Love Pizza Plus!! The best place for hand tossed thin and crispy pizza. Even if you prefer thick crust like I do, this place is still yummy. Family ran and the family is friendly and great workers. read more

What a pleasant surprise in what was looking like a food dessert. We had a very good sausage and mushroom pizza on a delicious cracker style crust. And the owners could not be nicer. This is a genuine local place that was a joy to share. read more

By far the best pizza in Cadillac! The homemade crust is AMAZINGLY, and the toppings are always fresh and abundant! Their original hot sub is also to die for!! I would recommend this to anyone that loves pizza & Subs! read more

Great thin crust pizza! Hand rolled crust and comes out very cheesy and crust is crisp but chewy too. Definitely my favorite! They have a great GF pizza and wife says best in town and orders it with extra sauce. Great family owned and operated business that has been around for years. read more

Always the best. Dave and Jim make the best pizza in Cadillac...hands down. Three item pizza for $10.99. I got a ham, pepperoni and mushroom pizza and three of us could just eat half of it. For a regular crust pizza (not deep...not thin)....this is the best pizza that I have eaten in Cadillac. Keep up the great work guys! read more

Hands down THE best Pizza in town! I have tried all the pizza places in town and NONE come close to Pizza Plus. The thing I like the most about it is their thin crust. I was always a thick crust kinda guy until I came here. Can't stand it now (too doughy). Great sauce and toppings. Love the cheese! Pockets are great and subs are good. Fave is basic pepperoni and cheese. 8" personal is perfect for lunch. read more

Stopped for lunch on the way to Northern Michigan based on other reviews and the pizza and sandwiches didn't disappointed. Both kids loved their cheese pizza and my chicken sandwich with ranch dressing hit the spot. Sandwich was huge , I ate half and my husband devoured the other half. My husband's pizza was good as well. We had to wait for the food a little bit, but it was worth the wait. read more

I am surprised that this place has so many positive reviews. Maybe I just caught them on an off day? Hmmm. Well, my pizza was an overly greasy craptastical looking mess. Dripping grease, burned cheese, undercooked dough and mystery meat. It was gross, even by Cadillac standards. Um, not sure what else to say, other than it was disgusting and I wouldn't go there again... read more