First time to eat a pizza from here...IT WON'T be the last time! AMAZING pizza! A tiny shop in the corner of Elkton's square that was a little hard to find at first (I'm not from Elkton), but.... THIS is what pizza is supposed to be!
I called in an order and the lady that answered said it would be 45 mins to an hour for pick-up. Wasn't a problem as I live in Hopkinsville and was taking the pizza to family in Russellville. When I got there, I really understood why the other reviewer may have thought the people who answered the phone were rude.... Probably didn't mean to sound rude...this place is just incredibly busy! I mean "one-armed paper hanger" busy! The counter had 12 written orders on it and the man took 6...SIX phone orders in the 10 minutes I was standing there! You can see the kitchen from the counter (did I mention "tiny place") and one lady was making pizza and stromboli and steadily feeding them into the pizza oven.
The man taking orders asked my name and said my pizza was almost ready so I watched some more...The smell of this place is worth $5 extra by itself! When he took my large Supreme pizza out of the oven the edges were well browned and the pizza looked COOKED.. GOOD!! He took down a large box and actually had to fold a little bit of the pizza to get it into the box! Large pizza BIGGER than a standard large pizza box!! When he handed me the box..this pizza has some weight to it! HOT too! Magnificent!
I could go on about how good the pizza tasted and how liberal they were with the ingredients but let me just say if I'd known how delicious this pizza was going to taste I would have bought TWO!
I WILL BE BACK!! read more