Do not judge a book by its cover...who said that anyway? The Pizza Pitt makes wicked good pies...for sure. Rustic and simple, but quality food and staff are inside. Female owned and managed, a plus for sure. We ordered our pizzas from the counter and chose a corner table on the upper deck...inside. Two locals pensively played chess while waiting for their take out pizza. A 10" Vegetarian for my wife, and a 10" Hawaiian for me. The toppings came deliciously steaming. And the crust was crisp, light, with just the right amount of singe to my liking. I finished off my pie, and we grabbed a box for the veggie leftovers. This is our first visit to Vinalhaven (we are total "Aways") and we will definitely be back. For pizza. At the Pitt. read more