I stopped by today and had two different slices with a soda, and I really enjoyed both of them. The pizza maker, who I believe may also be the owner, was very nice, welcoming, and courteous. The place was clean, and most importantly, the pizza tasted fresh and made with good-quality ingredients. I also felt perfectly fine afterward, which for me says a lot about the quality of the food. I don't live close to this area, but I can definitely say that if I'm ever around here again, I'll stop by for another slice. I'm actually surprised the reviews here aren't better. I'm not someone who gives five stars easily, but based on my experience today, this was genuinely five-star pizza. If you live in the area, give this place a try. Enough said. read more

Pleasant experience. Has a bar seating style. Ample of tables for dine in. Highchair seen but no koalakare. Clean and smelling good restroom. Accepts debit/credit card. See images for referenc read more

Pizza Brothers - Restroom - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

I wanted to try Pizza Brothers for a long time and finally I was able to make time and try a slice. Maybe I should have rethought the effort because there are better slices available just up the road in Peapack. Sorry. I just didn't care for the Brothers effort. The crust was flavorless and any cheese was identifiable by color. Certainly the package said cheese, but that's what was missing. The tangy flavor. This example was devoid of that classic flavor that says mozzarella. But my opinion is just that and I'm sure they have many fans. Just not my favorite pizza around. read more

This pizza is by far the best pizza, the freshest pizza, and the most satisfying pizza in Jersey!

Had their BLT pizza! It was great! Sorry I didn't take a pic but I will next time. read more

Pizza Brothers - Cheese slid a little. Sausage and mushroom. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

I came to Visit my Mom who is staying with my sister She said she was going to order a pie with the works with a bottle of soda!! When the pie arrived she said it was 25.00 plus the tip She gave the driver $30.00 And brought the pie in When I opened the box it was a plain pie!!!!! I called the restaurant and spoke to a man! I advised them that they made a mistake on the order it was supposed to be a pie with the works and it was a plain pie !! I asked what a pie costs he replied $16.00 plus the bottle of soda and then the delivery Charge of $4.00 total 25.00 What I'm upset is that the pie was plain and that the delivery fee was $4.00 And the pizza wasn't tasty and they were robbing people without a gun Just unbelievable they lost our business!!!! read more

Good pizza all around. Have been in for slices and found them pretty good. Decently crispy crust and good sauce and cheese. Also good experience with whole pies. The grandmas was even better when heated up the next day. The proprietor/workers are super nice as well. It bugs me when people whine about a delivery experience during COVID. Times were challenging. What is important is the pizza and in that regard, it is pretty darn good. Nice to have something close by that is reliable and good. read more

Food order was wrong. This is the second time that order was wrong in the last three visits. Order was repeated a number of times and still wrong. One was ordered while at the shop and one was ordered over the phone. Of course you don't know that the order is wrong until you get home. Food is good when they get it right. This is the Bedminster store. read more

We had the pizza for the first time at a party. It was so good that we decided to order from them for dinner. The cheese pizza is excellent. The crust is perfect, and the sauce and cheese are heavenly. The garlic knots are so good!! Tons of garlic!! The penne vodka is very good. The bacon pieces made the penne so tasty. The mild chicken wings are finger licking good! Service was fast and very friendly. I will definitely come back again! read more

We stopped by here for a few slices when we were around the area. Not sure what happened but I paid for 5 different slices and were only given 3 slices in the box. By the time I realized this we were already far away from the restaurant. When I called them, they offered us to come back for the two slices or to get the refund on store credit. We were already too far to return. I was surprised that they couldn't just refund the amount back to my credit card. Not sure if this was done intentionally. Other than that the pizza was okay. read more

Ordered takeout, quick, still hot after getting home, delicious and reheated the leftovers which were great the next day. We shall return.

Pizza, pizza and more pizza! The problem with NJ is that there are too many pizza joints and not enough days in the week to try them all. Pizza Brothers has a few shops and their pizza is decent. Crust is a little thicker than I like, but the sauce is flavorful and the cheese has just the right oil content. The staff is always very friendly and gets the orders right, which is a huge plus! read more

Pizza Brothers - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

See all

Mediocre pizza, made worse by terrible management. As we were waiting for slices, one of their delivery people returned and informed the manager that they had accidentally given someone the wrong pizza. The manager proceeded to berate the employee for the next several minutes. She did not seem to care that two customers were uncomfortably standing by. There is a way to handle crises at work, and swearing/verbally abusing your staff in front of customers is not it. Also- it ended up not being the delivery person's fault and was a mater of a mis-marked pizza box. read more

Ordered online at 530. Received email that it would be delivered between 615-625. Called to check at 635 - pizza's ready, will be there in 15 min. Reached at 730. Manager first blamed 'slice' for a late order coming through. When I told him I called at 635 and was told the pizza is already ready, it was the "new phone boy's" fault. read more

Second time trying - chicken parm is really low quality. There is one chicken tender in the sandwich. Wings barely has sauce.

This place is sufficient. If you have a need for a filling meal and slice, you can't go wrong with pizza brothers. Many nights I have ordered for a meal fitting and read more

Poor even by generic pizza place standards. I recently purchased for delivery the penne vodka entrée with a side of meatballs and cluck-u wings figuring it was a safe bet order. My goodness. Vodka sauce was too sweet by a mile. Ugh. Meatballs were disappointingly bland and came in a watery red sauce also far too sugary. Ugh x2. I ordered atomic (medium) sauce on the wings and I could see a sauce and feel it and vaguely smell it, but for the life of me I could not taste it. It wasn't even mild it was just tasteless. Cluck-U sauces have never been this transparent to me I don't know if the Pizza Brothers changed the sauce or put on the wrong thing, but it was like I was eating air. The chicken itself was also tasteless. Three strikes and you're out. This was a rough go of it. It was pasta and meatballs guys. I wasn't asking for anything crazy, yet the only flavor was sweetness. Would advise to steer clear. The bill was cheap and I still feel like I got taken. read more

Second best pizza in the Far Hills/Bedminster area. The cheese is very good and cheesy. The sauce is also not overruled with spices (which is a fault I find in many pizzas- the spices in the sauce should never overpower the cheese and breading, but rather it should compliment it). The breading is also good. Nice and thin crust. I cannot comment on any toppings. I only order my pizzas unadulterated. My personal pizza philosophy (aka P-cubed) is that you cannot adequately judge a pizza with toppings on it. Toppings hide the true goodness of a pizza. It's like putting a spoiler and nice rims on a Kia. At the end of the day it is still going to be a Kia. They have a sit down area that I cannot comment on, but when we order over the phone, service is fast! Definitely a place you should try! read more

Been in Bedminster for close to two years now and still trying to explore the best pizza and gave this place a try after receiving multiple ads in the mail plus reading some mixed but promising reviews. We ordered a plain pie thin crust well done, wings and a grilled chicken Cesar salad and it was just awful. The pizza was lightly cook and super chewy I could taste the doughy. That unfortunately was not the end of the disappointment as the salad and wings were just as bad. I'm sorry I hate to do this but it just wasn't good. read more

This place has some of the best pizza around. They have wonderful pizza and the dinners from the back are all delicious. The staff is very friendly and accommodating, and I would recommend this place to everyone. The Chicken Saltimbocca is my favorite dish on the menu. They also serve Cluck-U wings, which is awesome as there are no Cluck-U restaurants near. They even put it on the pizza if you want it! Also, the delivery drivers are awesome and some of the best around! read more

Stopped in for a couple Slices(probably my last) and asked they leave them in the oven so they get hot. I get it's close to closing time but thats no excuse. I am writing this and they aren't even closed yet. I like this place But wtf!! You give me barely Luke warm pizza and then when I turn around both the counter girl and pizza guy back fascinates with Thor cell phones. read more

This is the only pizza place in town where the food and service are consistently great. Usually order take out and the veggie specialty pie is our absolute favorite. This time we brought a large group in for a party (approved ahead of time) and the staff was truly amazing. All the food came out on time and when we needed more they made it super fast. Allowed us to bring in a cake and were very helpful and thoughtful. They will always get our business. read more

Not bad for delivery Fast I ordered large pie with pineapple. Certainly not fresh pineapple. The best pizza in Bedminster for delivery as of today. It would be nice if they went a little gourmet!! Nice people read more

Was driving through decided to stop in. I'm happy I did. Nice size parking area, fast service and the pizza was good.

Do not bother asking the prices to items not on their menu. They will get snappy and give you a range of prices. Not the exact price. Great for a ride service though. read more

Always know I can get a nice quality pizza without any hassle here. They are friendly and make a good pie for the price. I have only purchased pizza here. read more

Shame on me for not writing a review sooner! Since we moved into the neighborhood (5 years ago) we have ordered pizza here AT LEAST once a week! We have had most (if not all) the different types of pizzas and have never been disappointed! We have ordered a variety of hot sandwiches, entrees, strombolis, and chicken wings and have always enjoyed our meals. The other night I ordered the tortellini alfredo with chicken- it was tasty! We've also tried other local pizza places and feel like Pizza Brothers still makes the best pizza! We know that's pizza is a personal taste preference, but we have eaten a LOT of pizza in the tri-state area, and still prefer theirs! We are always greeted with a smile, even even they are super busy! Definitely stop in if you haven't tried their pizza yet! They also Jace a small dining area on the side, if you're looking for a casual BYO option! Bon appetit! read more

It's like a fast food pizza place. Food is all ok, prices are about on par. I've only ever used them for delivery, and that is a mixed bag. There are times they are very prompt and there are times they are anything but. Once, they completely forgot my order. Said that they put it in as a pick-up when I, obviously, asked specifically for delivery (they even confirmed my address on the phone call). Also, I'm not sure if this is a habit for them, but recently they changed some of the portions on the menu. I usually order the chicken tenders (on the menu it is 6 tenders for $X). When I ordered them last time, I was told it's actually 5 tenders. I pointed out that it says 6 on the menu and was greeted by silence. read more

Ordered 3 large pies for delivery Saturday night and it took 1hr and 50mins......Called the pizza shop 3 x's and on the 3rd call I was told the delivery guy had a flat tire. So finally the pizza's arrived and no apologies or anything from the delivery guy or even a call from the pizza shop. I didn't bother asking if the guy really had a flat tire b/c I was pretty annoyed at that point but really??? No apology, no discount nothing...... I rather drive and pick up my own pies, Basking Ridge needs more places that deliver. read more

Order a plain pie for delivery, come a little early and was still fresh, the crust and sauce was perfect they just put to much cheese on it. overall will order agian. just ask for light cheese. read more

It is horrible. The sandwiches are soggy and salty. Their salads are horrible, salads are supposed to be healthy not fatty.

Worse delivery ever Used to consistently wait 1 hour for a single pizza which is long enough considering I'm only 3 miles away The past 3 times it took 90 minutes! They never apologize or give you a break on the price Never order from here read more

Got large cheese pizza for the family...nice portions and great ingredients. Probably my favorite pizzeria in town. Wish they had some more options on the menu but generally very happy whenever I order anything here read more

Best Pizza and Best Cheesesteak I have ever had. Not greasy, just perfect. Our server was super sweet too, too bad she doesn't work there anymore. read more

The Cluck U is especially delicious. The pizza is not great, probably the worst in town. However, the service is pretty good, the deliveries are usually prompt and without mistake. read more

One of the better pies in the area. Glad they deliver to bernardsville. We have now used them 4 times. Looks like we still will.

"This pizza is amazing" was a quote I heard several times as my family devoured 3 large pizzas. Service was amazingly fast, the staff very friendly and anticipated our needs before we could voice them. They have a small eat-in area but it was the perfect place for a tired family returning from a day at the shore. read more