Everything is very good. I love Pizza Boy! My favoritee are the calzones and pepperoni pizza.

This is pretty much our go to local spot for pizza that isn't a chain. They run specials occasionally and post them on their social media page (Facebook). Depending on who you get at the cashier service is hit or miss, but they're never rude. Their style of pizza is New York Style and is very thin. I prefer to get a little extra sauce on my pizza when it's thin. They have awesome garlic rolls/knots and cinnamon knots. Overall this is a great local establishment to get pizza. read more

Excellent pizza. I can't wait to try the Stromboli. Very nice staff. Going back for sure. read more

Pizza Boy Pizza - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake City, Florida

One of my fave local family pizza joints. NY style, so good you even eat the crust. Those garlic knots are not to be missed. read more

Pizza Boy Pizza - Garlicky and buttery, these are KNOT to be missed. Ha, see what I did there. Seriously. Order these. - Pizza Near Me - Lake City, Florida

See all

Order was ready, on time and correct. We ordered a calzone and garlic knots and we're both were pretty good.

My friend picked up a pizza for us this week and the crust was very soggy and had the pizza sauce had no flavor. We were very disappointed especially since it was expensive. They advertise their pizza as NY style. There was nothing NY about it at all. We will not order from there again read more

Door Dash ordered Supreme pizza, received bacon and best I could taste, hamburger. Mediocre like a frozen pizza is Mediocre. Right away my first slice had a medium length black hair attached to the cheese. The wings were swimming in a pond of greasy hot sauce. Disgusting and vile. I knew by experience if I called to complain there'd be no satisfaction. Done. P.S.: 8 pc wings, all drumettes, not one flat. read more

I ordered a delivery supreme pizza with extra jalapenos and everything was done great the pizza was very good. I am a traveling nurse and I'm glad. I found this little spot right next do a grocery store. read more

Pizza Boy Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Lake City, Florida

Fast service but for 16.00 food was okay not much flavor it tasted like spaghetti in a can. I know sounds weird but that's the flavor I got. The meatballs were also plain not much flavor read more

Pizza Boy Pizza - Spaghetti with meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Lake City, Florida

Been eating here for years and they still have the absolute best garlic knots. Family run businesses. Eat local, support small business. read more

See all

Average pizza with a long wait time. Not as good as locals made it sound to be. Very greasy pizza.

Awesome pizza for takeout only. We stopped here on our way back from Florida and the pizza was delicious! We had two 14 inch pizzas, one pizza chicken and jalapeño, the other pizza was half pepperoni and bacon, and just cheese. We also had a side salad and garlic dough knots. The total bill was $52, so not cheap but again, it was all delicious. I'd. recommend not eating here, the entire place was filthy, old dirty worn out tables and lawn furniture chairs. No bathroom, floors, walls, windows, doors, counter, all filthy. We ate outside, moved two tables together and sat on stationary benches and lawn furniture. A man approached to get takeout and we exchanged words and said they had the best pizza in town...... but he refused to eat there, only take out because it "wasn't up to his standards but they've got the best pie in town". read more

QUICKIE REVIEW Never had pizza from New York but I can say this was good. FOOD This is what I tried: -2 slices of pizza Pizza was simple, thin, and generous portion. I think the best part of it was I didn't expect it to be so big. Definitely worth the wait as it filled me for lunch. PARKING Yes. Location is in a strip mall and next to a Winn Dixie. SERVICE Order at the front and pick up at the front. Pretty straight forward. Cashier who took my order was nice. PRICE 2 slices and a drink less than $10, lunch special. TIP/OTHER THOUGHTS If you are going during lunch, call in, call in, call in. Did I mention to call in? Took roughly 15-20 minutes to get my pizza. While I was waiting, I was seeing people that called in, come in, grab and go. Smart. read more

See all

Great pizza in Lake City, Florida. First time here. Located next to the Winn Dixie in a small space. We called in an order for a large meat pizza. They said 20 minutes and were right on the money. I showed up early and went through the drive thru pickup. There was no indoor seating last week. Cute little outdoor seating was open. People were there waiting for orders. Pizza was very good. Lots of meats!! Great crust. Overall great food and service. I will definitely be back. read more

Pizza Boy Pizza - Really good pizza in Lake City. - Pizza Near Me - Lake City, Florida

Just try it, that's all I can say. You will not be disappointed! Costs no more than Pizza Hut and the pizza is amazing, every - single - time! We ordered the 24" pizzas for our daughters birthday party, and I'd recommend you not do that, unless you're feeding a small Army. They are HUGE! I always order the chef salad, and it's large enough that our family of four can split it, to have as a side with pizza. I haven't tried the lasagna yet - but I definitely will! It's everything you want from pizza - cheesy, foldable, delicious! The one topping we didn't like was the sausage, but you might! read more

I tried the rest, Pizza Boy is the best! The dough is fresh and delicious. Unbeatable taste!

Best crust and toppings in Lake City. Always a great pizza every time we've ordered there.

Three salads and a pizza and a slice by itself. It was takeout only but it was superb. Because of the times, it was delivered to us at their drive-through and we were extremely pleased with the meal as we ate it on the back patio of the local Hilton. Give it a try. Pizza was good. The order was right. People were friendly. read more

I saw their daily special advertised on FB so decided to try it. I haven't been to Pizza Boy in a while, I forget that they have more than pizza. I got their spaghetti, I think they called it million dollar spaghetti. It's amazing!!! So delicious!! The staff were so friendly and helpful. I didn't call ahead, pulled up to their drive thru and ordered, they brought it to my car within a few minutes. I will definitely be back!!! read more

got pizza 9/7/23 ..been buying here for 16 years ..definitely not the same anymore ..ever since COVID came pizza kept coming with less and less ingredients and thinner and thinner ..but price keeps getting more and more..this last pizza finished me going there ..it was SO thin it was not funny ..CHEESE ???? what cheese ??? no sauce ..no big fluffy crust ..THE WORST PIZZA IN MY LONG ENTIRE LIFE and I love pizza ..managed to get down 2 tasteless slices and threw out the rest of a $16.12 super thin red round limp piece of soggy cardboard ..WHAT A SHAME ..you were good but NOW ..just another pizza place run into the groud by being so cheap and no more pride read more

Best pizza around north Florida, portions are generous, staff is always friendly. Love their lunch special! Clean facility. Love love their garlic knots and cinnamon knots. read more

Great Pizza. Can't go wrong with any of their options, but my favorite (besides just the classic cheese pizza) is their Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Would definitely recommend it to someone looking for something a little different but still delicious. read more

Found this little place by chance and had an absolutely great pizza. Lots of cheese, good toppings and really friendly people. We ordered a "small" but it was more like a medium. We said "we'll have some to take home for later".. that didn't happen! It was so delicious we ate it all! They have a couple tables outside for customers - that was nice. Very reasonable price, great food, quick service. They had a constant flow of people coming in for take out, and that's always a good sign. read more

Please people must be crazy this pizza was horrible. Lady didn't even say hello when I walked in walked past me twice without even saying a word. Then try to give me a dirty cup and then when she noticed that I saw her she washed it out and asked her to change it she seemed upset. I was actually excited because of all the good reviews. I've eaten pizza all over the country definitely in the bottom I can look past Bad customer service for good food but neither one was good at all read more

This is my second visit, the subs are huge and delicious. Haven't tried the pizza but I'm sure it's also as good.

Really great pizza and friendly staff. I got the two slice lunch special with a drink. The price was better than other places in town, the pizza is significantly better. Try them out if you're near by. read more

Driving from Houston Texas to Mount Dora Florida and needed a place for the family to eat. I looked on Yelp and this place had 4.5 stars. Giving 5 stars because it was not only some of the best pizza, but great people. read more

I had the Stromboli and it was amazing! Delicious with lots of filling and huge! It was so big it came in a big pizza box with plenty of marinara on the side. Would definitely eat there again and highly recommend. read more

Has always been my favorite place to eat with my granny. I just has to stop by on my visit. CinnaKnots aand the cheese pizza are

Ate here tonight. Stromboli was off the chain. The marinara sauce is fresh and full of tomato. Hard to find a good italian pizza now a days. Wish they were open later and 7 days a week. They keep me hooked though with great food every time. Nice people too. Also, have a pickup lane that is very convenient and unique for a pizza place. read more

The only reason this place doesn't get 5 stars is that they do not deliver. Their Pizza, Baked Spaghetti, and Cinnamon Knots are Fantastic!!!! read more

THE BEST pizza in Lake City, FL!! All other items are great also. Been going there for 10+ years. If you're having a party, go for the 3XL pizzas! read more

I have lived in Lake City for a year and this is my go to place for local pizza. I am not a pizza guru but I think it is New York style. Thin-ish soft crust with great flavor. read more

I grew up eating at this establishment and have traveled the world and currently reside in California and still haven't had pizza as good as it is here. read more

Food is good....I like the meatball sub. Good portion and they make it when you order. Service is quick. Only issues was small dining area and restroom was out of order. If you don't want to eat from a chain restaurant check them out. The location is centrally located. read more

Pizza Boy Pizza is the best pizza in town. All their other items are also great. They served the best of their baked spaghetti and cinnamon knots. Will be back. read more

By far the best pizza in Lake City! I have ate here several times and have never been disappointed. Nice friendly people, clean facility and good location. Only negative the donor have a dinning area. I recommend the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and cold drink. read more

Just Love this Pizza just like a few others I would give it a *5 if they delivered, they closed sunday an mondays.. Enjoy it..

Best pizza in town! The prices are a bit higher then everywhere else, but definitely worth it- unfortunately my budget doesn't allow for it as often as it's $5 - $7 pizza competitor's nearby. I only have 2 "complaints," but they won't take away from my review/score- 1. Being it's very apparent they need a bigger location that offers dine in as the bar and few tables barely hold the people that are just waiting on their food to rake out, and 2. Being that they're closed Monday's, I have caught myself 3 Times in the last 2 months in route to get food, only to realize they're not open on Monday's. I get the Monday blues bad so by dinner time, I'm not wanting to even climb the stairs on my front porch, rather the less cook dinner, & alas "my hero" aka pizza is yet again having to be settled for cheaper competitor's food. read more

Amazing pizza! They have odd hours because it's not a chain. I believe it's family run. I always see the same people. You get addicted to there pizza and when there closed your so sad!! Only place in lake city you can get New York style pizza and it is so good! Lick your figures good! Needless to say we are regulars here!! read more