Cancel

Open app

Search

Pitmasters Pizzeria

4.7 (3 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 7:30 pm

Order Pitmasters Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

Pitmasters Pizzeria Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pitmasters Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Pitmasters Pizzeria

The Inn at Honey Run - Baa!

The Inn at Honey Run

4.1(75 reviews)
2.8 mi
•$$$

Wow! What a wonderful surprise in a gorgeous forested area on a private understated property…read more Birds, trees, and accommodations built into their natural surroundings and under beautiful full grown trees. So much has already been said, but this is a natural respite from the world with all of the creature comforts. To anyone saying the property is somewhat outdated, I disagree and fully appreciated features like carpet in the honeycomb suites and in the dining areas. It keeps noise down from fellow diners and guests staying in rooms nearby. When can you ever say this in modern stark industrial hotels? This made the experience so cozy. And the place is clean!! It looks and smells fresh. The honeycomb suites are constructed from stone and wood, and it's so refreshing. The food is delicious and well-appointed on the restaurant menus - both brunch and apps and dinners. They change the menus frequently based on what's in season, as a natural property like this should be. Service! Also "outdated" in that it was actually great! Where can you receive personable service anymore? The front desk, hostesses, serving attendants, communication prior to check in, you name it. We were first timers but met many guests who have been returning for decades. We would count ourselves lucky to be able to do the same. Great experience. My only gripe, and it's a legit one, and it can be avoided: room service. It should not be served in plastic in a bag like carry out, at a romantic resort and at this price point. We opted for brunch in our room one morning, and were disappointed to find a bag of food on plastic. No. Beware of this and go the fine dining room to avoid this. I have never ordered room service anywhere in the world and had it delivered in this manner to a $500 per night room. This did not take away from the rest of our experience though, but diners should be warned.

The reason I state maybe is due to the following. A family member has stayed here all throughout…read morethe years. It's nostalgic for them and they rave about the place. She told me about the area of the Honey Comb Rooms, the restaurant etc. We were out at Mt. Hope and coming back from the ride we saw the sign and had to go see the place. It was snowing so we felt we were in a picturesque snow globe. We drove to the area of the Honey Comb rooms and it look so cool. We stopped by the Inn and spoke to this gracious young lady at the restaurant. She said it was open to the public as well. We also spoke to the person at the front desk and picked up pamphlets on what you can do in the area. The rooms looked pricey on the website, I'm not sure if it's a place I would stay. Maybe for a celebration of some sort. It's close to many different Amish Places.

Photos
The Inn at Honey Run
The Inn at Honey Run - Entry

Entry

The Inn at Honey Run - Porch view with borrowed binos

See all

Porch view with borrowed binos

Downtown Diner - Side salad

Downtown Diner

4.1(51 reviews)
6.7 mi

The wife and I visited and ate at the Downtown Diner both Saturday and again today, Monday. We…read morelive an hour away from Berlin but visit the area often. On our visit with friends on Friday three of us selected the buffet that featured burgers grilled on a Green Egg, which we all agreed were some of the best we had ever had! I am normally pretty conservative at a buffet, but the burger was so good I ended up eating 2! We all loved our service, the facility, the fair value and everything we ate that day! We all rated this experience a solid 5! So the wife and I returned to Berlin on Monday to exchange a couple clothing items that did not fit right, and decided to return to the Downtown Diner to give it another try. I had the Barbecue Brisket Burger & Onion Rings, and the wife a Taco Salad with their homemade dressing (she loved the dressing). Our meals were fantastic! We met the new owners of the restaurant, who are young very nice hard working people who have a desire to operate a facility that produces excellent food at a reasonable cost to the customer. The 4 of us that visited the establishment over the past few days believe that are doing exactly what they are desiring to do! I can't wait to visit on Friday or Saturday again to get owner Dave's burgers off the Green Egg! By the way, they have an assortment of great desserts, but we have been so full on these visited to try any of them. Maybe next time, other then when it's Green Egg burger time!

The food was amazing and not a long time to wait. It's a 50s style dinner in the main area. The…read morerest is additional space with long tables and 4 tops along the walls. Don't sit at the first table by the door in back area. There is a post near the table and for some reason everyone tries to go between it and the table. I was bumped into twice. If you see someone sitting there then go around the other side of the pole. High prices for the food, the food we ordered came with fries so I wonder if that's why the price was high.

Photos
Downtown Diner - Main dining area

Main dining area

Downtown Diner - Chili Soup

Chili Soup

Downtown Diner - Main dinner

See all

Main dinner

Millersburg Hotel - Ornate ceiling light in room

Millersburg Hotel

3.2(49 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$$

We traveled to Millersburgh to get away from the lunch crowds in Berlin and were glad we did! The…read morehotel staff was polishing the front doors when we arrived which shows they work hard to care for the hotel. The inside is beautiful and if you like historical places I recommend asking the front desk for a guided tour, which if we would've known about prior to leaving after our meal, we would've done but our schedule didn't permit it. We were seated quickly and requested the outdoors courtyard. WATCH your step there is a small hole in the brick covered with a welcome mat that could cause someone to fall. The courtyard is so quaint but it was slightly windy and the umbrellas aren't anchored so they kept nearly coming out of the tables throughout our meal. We ordered fried alligator tail for an appetizer that was very tasty. The Reubens were delicious and the Mac and cheese was good with a huge prob of bacon if you paid a bit extra. I also got it as a side and was surprised by the option size, much bigger than expected. I wished the sauce was a bit creamier and maybe a different pasta like a cavatappi or fusilli instead of the penne but that's just me being picky. I have to say that of all the places I've been I've never had a more personable waitress. She was fantastic! She had small talk at every stop to the table, was attentive, accommodating and friendly (not forced). I hate that I can't remember her name because she really did a great job. Not only that but we had a fabulous conversation with two of the chefs that were set to be married the next day. They were friendly, comical but really just great people that are passionate about people, cooking and each other. My mom, sister and I wish them well. They sure we're having a great time celebrating for the next day and they brought us along for the ride and because of that we even commented later that that alone would influence a trip back to the restaurant if we ever find ourselves out that way again because you were made to feel like you were apart of the family. I highly recommend this restaurant and a tour of the hotel.

Had a wonderful dinner at the restaurant hotel. I had a filet mignon that was perfectly cooked. My…read morehusband loved the Parmesan crusted salmon. And beware of the courtyard lemonade! You don't taste the alcohol and it will sneak up on you. Delicious! The server was very nice and responsive. We will come back on our next trip.

Photos
Millersburg Hotel - Antique pictures in room

Antique pictures in room

Millersburg Hotel - French Toast

French Toast

Millersburg Hotel - Hallway's decorated with quilts

See all

Hallway's decorated with quilts

Pitmasters Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...