The mac and cheese was lacking some flavor but the prime rib was absolutely delicious!

Popped into Greeley to visit my godson and we dined at Pinocchios Prime. What an amazing dinner! We had steaks which were incredible, amazing service, and a wonderful time eating, chatting and enjoying great food with great company. The atmosphere was "happy energetic" which was evident at every table I saw. Our party of 4 had the shrimp cocktail and bread appetizers, salads, the filet, the ribeye, the huge ribeye (split for two), 4 sides and 4 desserts. Everything was perfectly prepared and delicious. While we loved each dessert (tiramisu, carrot cake, lemon cake and German chocolate cake) the German chocolate cake impressed me with its sweetness and subtle coconut frosting. The staff were attentive without imposition, the food was outstanding, and the company was divine. My experience was one of those rare "meal nirvanas" where everything was perfect and I left with a huge smile. Best meal experience I have had in a long time. I hope that everyone has the opportunity to enjoy Pinocchios Prime. read more

Food was delicious, but the service was even better!!!! Perfect place for a date night. We will definitely be coming back. read more

Pinocchios Prime - Chicken Alfredo & Prime Rib - Steakhouses Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Had my dinner here after my engagement and it was absolutely lovely. As a fairly new restaurant, Tamra(our server) who wasn't even aware of our occasion still made it an even more incredible evening. The prime rib was hot and had amazing flavor. The fries were crispy and the potato was steaming and buttery. And dessert.. oh my lanta the mother f****g German chocolate cake will be the death of me. EAT HERE PEOPLE. And save room for dessert!! read more

Pinocchios Prime - THE Homemade German Chocolate Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Stumbled upon this gem in Greeley. The woodwork of the tables and bar to the brick inside this amazing restaurant. The food did not disappoint. Just like the ambiance, the prime rib was delicious. Medium rare and a baked potato with bacon pieces served on the side and extra butter if you need. The salad wheel was also a neat concept. Then the cheese cake was out of this world. Will be going back to try other menu options. The service was terrific as well. read more

See all

We really enjoy the food here. Loved the French dip and salads! Good service! Has the feeling of back when restaurants were special.

We went here before a show so our reservation was a little early. The restaurant decor is bright and modern. The hostess and our waiter Benj were both attentive and charming. The food was very good and brought quickly without rushing us. We had mussels and prime rib and enjoyed them. A good dinner and great service. We will be back I am sure. read more

Food was served cold. There was a large party at the same time so our server did her best but all in all very substandard. Too bad.

Do not sleep on this restaurant. We've been several times and it's outstanding! These folk care about great food, great service and great ambiance. We've had anniversary dinners as well as regular evening meals. read more

Great food and great service. This is what white tablecloth service should be. Our food was on point and the service from Harvey was great. Attentive, never in the way. Conversation was enough, but not too much...and never pretentious!! Wine service was appropriate, even accommodating the new screw top bottles. I would highly recommend Pinocchios Prime the single legit white tablecloth location in all of Greeley. read more

Awesome service and great food!! Everything was hot and anything extra I needed I received quickly.

The food was very good, had their prime rib and it was done perfectly. The service was excellent.

Not that impressive Prime rib very good, not impressed with wait staff, would not recommend or return, sorry was really looking forward to a great dinner read more

Food was delicious, ambiance was nice and cozy for a dinner date. Service was exceptional with great attention to detail. Highly recommend.

The prime rib had great flavor but it was pretty dry and tough. The service was great, but the food was marginal

Finally got a white tablecloth restaurant in Greeley!! But not stuffy or snooty!! The service matched the exceptional food. We had prime rib, brussels and German Chocolate Cake for dessert. Best we have ever had!! read more

Speedy service, delicious breakfast and a romantic ambiance. This is there new 8th street location due to construction on 16th. Street. Can't wait to come back and try their pasta!! read more

Prime rib is amazing! Service is too notch! Was impressed with prime rib best I have had in Colorado. Ambiance was nice