The Pine Street Inn has changed very little over the years for the "guests" that are forced to turn to the shelter for a variety of reasons, not all of them drug or alcohol related. The Inn remains immune to advancements made by other shelters around the nation and its staff are split between a minority that are truly helpful and a majority that are abusive and uneducated.
After a long hospital stay that caused me to lose everything, I was forced to start all over with my career and life. My girlfriend and I came to Boston as the only city in which I had even a hope of getting an IT job. DC and Richmond, VA were depressed, economically, and after 6 months of looking, I hadn't even been able to secure an interview.
The Pine Street Inn was the only viable option: We came to the city, figured out the food, figured out the bed and started immediately to pound the pavements looking for jobs. I got 5 job offers in 14 days flat. It took my girlfriend 21 days. We both begin work next week... no help to Pine Street's Women's Shelter where my girlfriend was forced to stay. Their supervisors and staff staff did everything in its power to keep us from getting jobs. The mantra, there, is "rules are rules" and the rules are designed, Joseph Heller style, to provide a choice for its guests between bed and job. One cannot have both.
The abuse on both sides is easy to see: Dress casually, walk in and, as politely as one can, ask simple questions. One is immediately yelled at, cursed at, derided and threatened with expulsion. If one is actively searching for a job, then one must find a job that allows you to leave every day at 2:30 pm so that you can get back for the bed lottery. Or, you can humiliate yourself by asking your employer for a letter proving that you have a job ("why do you need it? Is this for a probation officer, or something? Are you a felon?").
If there is no 'rule' saying you must or must not do something, a staff member will be quick to make one up: You MUST turn in your coat, you must turn in your bag, you can ask for it back if you need to go outside, you will be yelled at if you DO ask for it. If you open your locker before 4:30 to retrieve a brush or book or something to do besides sit in a lobby and wait, you will be kicked out into the cold. If you start to ask "how do I...?" you will be yelled at. If you try to ask for the simplest thing, which you MUST ask for, you will be yelled at.
This is not an exaggeration and one only has to spend a day there, themselves, to see this in action.
Yes, there is an appeal process. You appeal and word comes down the line that you're a trouble maker. You're never seen again. If you think you can go against Paulette, who has been there for years and years, you'll learn what "immovable object" means.
If you're homeless through foreclosure, losing your job, sickness, fire or any other reasons, your chances of getting on your feet are much higher if you brave the cold and stay away from Pine Street Inn. By sleeping in the car with a pile of blankets, we were able to make it despite 20 degree weather and worse.
If you're reading this as a Pine Street Administrator with a 6-figure salary and $15M in assets, I defy you to spend a single day and night in one of your own shelters (without the staff knowing who you are... maybe hire someone to go in with a video camera?) and not have the desire to fire every single person. By the end of a day, you'll be wondering how best to file a lawsuit.
This is the first of several posts I'll be making on the subject. I fully intend to make the Pine Street Inn the poster child for abusive environments... and, yes, we're compiling video and audio. read more