Having read all of the glowing reviews on Urbanspoon, I was really excited to try Piefection. Alas, it was a bit of a downer. Perhaps they were having an off day because few of the truly interesting pies were on offer. We did have a butter chicken pie and the jack daniels bbq, both of which were good in concept with good pastry, but the filling was dry...definitely more sauce required. The sausage roll (bratwurst version) was pretty awful - grisly, livery, dry. My child who normally eats anything sausage related declared "ick" after a few bites, and we scoffed. We then tasted it and couldn't help but agree.
The chicken and vegetable mornay pie and chicken and wild mushroom pies were good but nearly indiscernible. I was hoping for some lovely variety of local mushrooms in the mix and there was maybe one visible button mushroom piece in the entire pie.
Next, what on earth did they do to their mushy peas?? I suspect they put too much baking soda in the boil (a trick to get things mushier quicker) as they had a really bitter, unpleasant aftertaste. The mashed potatoes were excellent, but the peas really just were horrible.
This hasn't factored into my review, but the pie shop temperature was also well over 100 degrees (it was a hot day outside, but still - who wants to eat or serve hot pies inside an oven??). No fan, no air and the poor folks working there looked like they might keel over from the heat. I know it's typical for a pie shop but this was too much. I can't imagine it's legal to allow your employees to suffer like that.
And finally, we drove the distance to this place from our Eastern Suburbs location, only to discover upon arrival that the shop has an unadvertised second location in Coorparoo. Not on their website, not on Urbanspoon...we remembered passing a sign at some point in our journeys around town and were dismayed when it seemed to take far longer than expected. PUT A NOTE WITH THE NEW ADDRESS ON YOUR WEBSITE, FOLKS!
So, the search for the best pie in Queensland will have to continue. Piefection was not perfection for us. read more