Have been curious what a deep dish pizza tasted like...I'm more of a thin crust person. After watching some cooking channel, I became curious, the deep dish pizza was calling my name...at least for a single try. I'll try any kind of dish once, right? How else does one expand the eating spectrum of delight? This place, Pie Trap Pizza, offers three different versions of a deep dish pizza. You can get a whole pie or a single slice of whatever they have ready. I ordered a 6-slice rectangle one. Three different deep dish to choose from... 1. Pepperoni 2. Lodi Dodi...the one I ordered 3. One other that I can't remember.... But go there...they serve the traditional round thin crust pizza and have other great menu items. My deep dish has pesto and rich pizza sauce, and other great spices. No meat. I highly recommend fulfilling your deep dish cravings here...do what I did and at least try it once. It was wonderful. I can see why folks in Chicago and Illinois love this style of pizza pie. Check out my pictures of the Lodi Dodi. 1. The whole pizza 2. One slice on my plate 3. What it looks like half way through...lol. This is a well run pizza joint with great people taking care of you. Cheers! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Lodi Dodi. - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Loved this place!! We got the hot honey pepperoni with jalapeños and it was SO good. Perfect combo of sweet, spicy, and savory. They also have a great lunch special--2 pizzas and a drink for $11! Such a good deal, especially for how good the pizza was. Definitely a spot I'd come back to. 5/5 for me! read more

From the very first bite, it was clear that this pizza was made with high quality ingredients. The sauce was incredibly fresh and reminded me of the authentic pizza sauce I've enjoyed in Italy. The toppings were fresh and thoughtfully portioned, creating a pizza where every ingredient complemented the others without overpowering them. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing the ideal texture and crunch in every bite. Honestly, each bite was pure bliss. We also ordered the wings, which were absolutely delicious and packed with flavor. One surprise standout was the salad. Fresh, flavorful, and well-prepared, it's definitely an item I'll be coming back for. Overall, I truly enjoyed every bite of the meal and can't wait to return. Highly recommended! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Great ambiance loved that the brewery is attached or shared space! The service was amazing, ordering pizza was easy and very friendly and helpful! The food however was very disappointing. Ordered a large pie and it was completely burnt. We waited 15 to 20 minutes for the pizza. We were starving so we at the toppings and left the crust. Overall I was not impressed at all. read more

See all

Such a bad pizza. This would be great for a bunch of guys drinking beer but for a dinner pizza...its super thin, oily, and the crust is tough. THE LARGE size should NOT fool you read more

Attended a small gathering at Arrowlodge and decided we needed to eat something. Ease of ordering and location within Arrowlodge makes this an easy spot to grab food. Pizzas were good. Thin crust pizzas were good, a bit greasy with the pepperoni, but flavorful. The pizza with the sausage and hot honey was good. Again, nice crisp pizza crust on the two we ordered. Large enough to be shared amongst 10+ adults. Service was great. Seriously, beyond the a-typical pizza joint. All seemed to be runners by young staffers, that seemed to actually care about the customer. Great communication and eager to greet you when you approached the pick-up window. Seriously at levels of in-n-out or chick-fil-a. The areas within this small storefront was clean and tidy. Staff took time to Make sure old receipts were picked up and thrown away and counters wiped down. read more

Whoa Boy!!!!!! I happen to catch a random YouTuber doing an extensive Pizza Centric interview of this Lil Beast of a Shop right here. Kinda late to the Party as usual but I'm here, ok! This spot is DOPE!!!!! No Nonsense Dope. Like the pizza is Super Good Dope. I gotta go back!!! Great Nextdoor Spot to boot. Really good pizza, phenomenal crust, super thin, well made. Really nice crew taking care of business. Great Dodger and World Cup Spot! Super impressed with the Pizza. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pie Trap Spicy Pepperoni Pizza with Light Jalapeños. So F'ing Good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

My BFF brought his home for us for dinner... And I was really happy because I've been wanting to try Pie Trap Pizza for a while. He ordered the supreme pizza and buffalo wings. I love their NY style pizza... the flavor was great. I did like the buffalo wings, but they were a little on the salty side. I definitely wanna try their Detroit style Pizza next. Make sure to put this on your bookmark and stop by next time you're in Covina. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

BEST PIZZA I've had in a while!!! I love the xxxplosive one with hot honey and pepperoni! I will definitely be back to have it with beer

The pizza just slaps. Don't even get me started on the garlic knots... a must try. Located next to Arrow Lodge, you can have a fresh slice and wash it down with a brew. The service is great, and the food is served piping hot! A must try! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Tried this place via takeout a few days ago, from placing the order to picking up the order took about 20-25 minutes. Pie trap serves NY thin crust style pizzas and at first I was skeptical because not a lot of places in SoCal can develop the crust. After having it, I'm completely blown away! The crunchiness of the thin crust was just like the ones I had in NY. We got half xxplosive and half spillmatic. The xxplosive side had good toppings but was missing the hot honey and not enough sauce. The spillmatic side was definitely 10/10 in flavor and the vodka sauce is amazing. read more

Best pizza in the area for sure. Nice thin crust and great toppings. Ordered cheese, xxplosive and pep. I reviewed the buffalo chicken instead of cheese by accident, but decided to give it a try. Didn't love the buffalo chicken and regretted not bringing up the mistake because we liked the cheese best the last time. Anyway, there is really no bad pizza, just degrees better so all good. Happy to keep trying their slices and hope to order a full pie at some point so we can try one fresh. I guess cheese will have to the one we get next time! read more

See all

Great pizza and great service. The pizza and garlic knots are a favorite for my family. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza absolutely deserves all the hype. The pizza is next-level -- perfectly crispy crust, balanced flavors, and toppings that taste fresh and intentional. You can tell they actually care about the craft. But what really sets this place apart is the owner -- seriously one of the coolest, most down-to-earth people I've met in a long time. He makes you feel like you're part of the neighborhood the second you walk in, and it's clear he's built a place that's about good vibes just as much as good pizza. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or hanging out with friends and grabbing a brew next door, Pie Trap feels like the kind of spot you'll keep coming back to -- for the food and the experience. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Had a friend hangout and needed a food option that could satisfy 5 people. I called in around noon to place a takeout order for two pizzas. I was advised that it would take about 30 minutes for both to be ready. However, it took another 10 minutes before it was ready. As I arrive, Pie Trap Pizza is located in a plaza with plenty of parking. There were also plenty of indoor seating and a patio outside as well. Unexpectedly there were a lot of pinball machines inside and beer on tap. Atmosphere wise, this place was already a 5/5. For the actual order, I got the Xxplosive and the Lodi Dodi. The Xxplosive came with jalapeños, but I asked them to leave on the side for folks that couldn't Handle spicy. This meant we did ate raw jalapeño. This was definitely a fan favorite. Highly recommend if you like a sweet and spicy flavor profile. For the Lodi Dodi, it was good. A few of my friends like it but not something in my flavor preference. It was definitely a more calorically dense pizza! They do accept American Express. Until next time! read more

See all

My family and I felt very underwhelmed with Pie Trap Pizza (Covina). We were recommended the Detroit Style "White Square" ($35 - 6 square slices), and it tastes like fancy cheese bread sticks. Many of these expensive slices were left half-eaten. I arrived at Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) on Friday (around 7:20PM). The location's main lobby is cramped; it fits about four customers. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) shares dining space with a connected sports bar. It's extremely loud and cramped with sport fans and pinball enthusiasts. There's also outdoor tables but expect inconsistent cleanliness. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is better for to-go unless you're searching for booming, pounding, hyped energy. Staff is busy and frantic. Staff is helpful, but there's a constant nervous energy as staff rushes away from the register to prepare the next order. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is definitely popular. I empathize with its novelty. I was recommended the Detroit Style "White Square" ($35 - 6 square slices). It was ready in 26 minutes and 52 seconds. The "White Square" includes mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, and Romano. My family and I absolutely adored its unique & crunchy pan-seared crust; however, its fluffy body tasted dry and muted. This "White Square's" flavor resembled those rubbery cheese sticks we'd eat in a school cafeteria. As my family and I ate this, we pondered how this "White Square" would taste great with spaghetti or... pizza. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is unique, pricey, and somewhat small. Similar to an expensive glowing pen you'd purchase at a theme park, Pie Trap Pizza is a "fun" moment. 3.4 out of 5 read more

See all

This restaurant exceeded my expectations. The menu had plenty of options, and everything tasted homemade. The staff was courteous, and the entire dining area was spotless. A fantastic place for a family meal. read more

First time here and definitely one of the best pizzas i've had, and maybe the best in a 20 mile radius? I tried their "the d" slice. Which is Detroit style pizza with pepperoni and a sprinkle of basil. They used the cupped pepperonis which is crucial because these tastes much better. The only downside is that this place is pretty expensive. The 3 slices I got were $20. The whole pizzas are near $40 which is kinda crazy. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

They actually answered an early phone call even tho they weren't open yet. I put in an order for pickup and although they had me wait couple more minutes at my pickup time, I think it was worth it. Their sausage pizza was amazing but a little pricey though the pizza is gigantic. They might be slightly greasy but I find it flavorful. Sometimes they have limited time pizza flavors but it's not advertised that well. I would come again to try other flavors and square pizza pies. Their garlic knotts are awesome, but they charge for extra sauce. read more

Great slice to accompany the terrific beer at the neighboring/attached brewery. Their Detroit slices look amazing and will be what we try next time. The standard pepperoni slice had a tomato sauce with a nice fresh taste. Properly greasy, hot and fast. As it should be. read more

See all

I needed a quick lunch so I decided to revisit this pizza spot. The first thing I noticed was there was quite the variety of pizza and they all looked pretty damn good. The service was friendly and I was in and out within a few minutes. I ordered the Detroit style pie, a cheese and regular pepperoni slice. I'm glad I decided to give this place another chance because the pizza was fire and I love the fresh sliced basil on top. I definitely recommend checking this place out. They are next to a brewery with an arcade and you can enjoy a beer and have some pizza! read more

See all

I finally stopped by Pie Trap Pizza to try their pizza. The Pizzeria is located in Arrow-Grand Business Park, next to Arrow Lodge Brewing Company. There is a nice patio outside with outdoor seating. There is an option to order a slice of pizza of your choice. I ordered supreme Clintel pizza and Deez Knots. -The Supreme Clintel pizza had Mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, red onions & red sauce. The crust was perfect and had a light texture. The toppings were generous and delicious. -The Deez Knots came with marinara. The order included six garlic knots. It was soft, buttery with adequate flavor of garlic. The service was fast. It took around twenty minutes to receive my order. The staff were nice and friendly. It's a great Pizzeria to stop by and try their delicious pizza. I will be back soon. read more

See all

Fav pizza and even better staff. The boys are always so hard working and kind. My kiddo loves coming here ( and so do we) Ps- heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

The noise of the lockdown bar of the pinball machine clicking interspersed with the sound of the Dodger game and chatter in the background is where I found myself this faithful Friday. I was several to many delicious beers in at this gem of a brewery in Covina. Anyone in the area should check out Arrow Lodge Brewery. They're filled with satisfying craft beers. But even better they're literally connected to this whole in the wall of a pizza joint called the Pie Trap. It was as if I was seeing water in the middle of the desert. Pizza was available right next door to where I had just been digesting the heavy barley and reassessing my life decisions, as beer tends to make me do. And even better, the pizza is good, real good. And not just when you're drunk but after the liquid munchies have exited your hospitable liver. The XXplosive pizza is a particular favorite amongst the locals and myself. Pepperoni, jalapeños and Mike's hot honey sauce might just be the new Pedialyte. My fellow beer and cocktail drinkers know what I'm talking about. So on a slow day it might be worth checking out the craft beer and pizza Covina has to offer. And that's Covina not West Covina. Same mother, different father. Stay present and adventurous my friends.... read more

Omg, so good. Had to get a quick bite before a movie and decided to stop by here to get some slices to go. Best choice! Their square slices had just come out of the oven and they were delicious. Got a slice of the Lodi Dodi and it was so flavorful and not floppy. Garlic knots were very good as well. We live in Fullerton and already plan on coming back, even if it's a drive. Worth it! read more

Anthony Bourdain, one of my favorite humans, had a deep distain for Yelp and so, I try to be judicious about reviews. We have two, teen boy, athletes. Given our busy schedules and hosting a ton of boys/ young men, we order a lot of pizza and often, multiple times a week. We order from La Verne, San Dimas, Glendora, & Covina. Well, we've given this place at least 3 opportunities and each time, they've fallen short. On this occasion, we ordered 1/2 supreme clientele add pineapple (yeah, there's a place for it on pizza!) and because in the past, the pepperoni has been so minimal, we ordered and paid for double pepperoni. Well, they did not add the pineapple and you can see from the pictures, they also did NOT double the pepperoni. Caught this at the restaurant, because I knew from previous experiences to check. They did offer to remake the pizza, but we had already been waiting too long, the Mexico FIFA game was about to start, AND I don't want to act as a restaurant's quality control. If you're gonna force me into that role, pay me. So at $56 for ONE poorly made pizza, garlic knots & a few bucks for tip, this place is not getting our business again. Sigh. read more

See all

Bomb. Crispy, light, airy crust. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. The XXXplosion (pepperoni jalapeños & hot honey) is perfection. I'd give it more than 5 stars if I could. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Half bacon & pineapple half XXXplosion - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

We came here for some pizza and they were pretty busy. Our pizza took a while to come out. Luckily, I had ordered some garlic knots and I asked to get those ASAP since we had already waited for 30 minutes for our order. The knots were so yummy - super favorable and delicious. They come in an order of 6. Our pizza finally made it out almost an hour after we ordered it. It was good but not my favorite. My husband comes here all the time for beer at the Arrow lodge and he raves about the pizza. He did say it was not the norm for it to take that long. Thank goodness for the knots because I can tell the pizza dough is excellent. read more

So good!!! You have to check it out if you're in the Glendora and Azusa area. The pizza has so much flavor and thin crispy crust read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

There is no better pizza place within a 10 mile radius. It's next to a brewery. They play sports. The service is great. There is no reason not to go here. read more

Notorious pep was lacking on the pep, the D was definitely delicious, wing taste like they were straight out the freezer read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Notorious pep, the D and frozen winds - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Covina has a surprisingly high number of pizza spots and Pie Trap Pizza is one of the best. Spillmatic is one of my faves, vodka sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni and basil, what's not to love? The pizzas are on the pricey side, but worth it. Their pizzas are pretty big and their pizza dough is top notch. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Spillmatic - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Really great service. Came in and was greeted by the guy working the register. Really great vibe. I ordered the Lodi Dodi for pick up and just had to wait a couple minutes. First time trying this type of pizza and it was really good. A little heavy on oil, but what can you expect from pizza. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Lodi Dodi - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

best pizza!! i swear!! tried the D, the Xxplosive and the white gurl!! everything was incredibly delicious and really served NY sytle.. glad I finally tried to order to pie trap as I will only order pizza to this place from now on.. and best customer service! read more

Came here for daughter's school fundraiser and really didn't expect much but this place is actually pretty good. We ordered the 20 inch what's beef whole pizza, garlic knots, and buffalo wings. The pizza are of New York style, thin and crispy crusts even tho it's huge slice but still to have that NY fold. The meat toppings are not over salty, great with beer. The garlic knots are solid but could be a bit more garlicky and the wings are nice. Overall, really enjoyed it, tho it took a bit longer for the food to come out but maybe it's because the crowds for the fundraiser. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Great pizza and cool atmosphere. I played pinball and had a drink from the bar while I waited for my pizza

#1 Pizza & Best Customer Service! In the words of Bonquiqui (Anjelah Johnson), we had a "cOmPLicAtED oRDer". We ordered a pizza for my daughter which was a pepperoni pizza with NO CHEESE! That's right, no cheese! I'm sure they questioned who was raising the little girl to have a pizza with no cheese... but hey, that's her preference. Well, they were able to execute this order as requested. My little girl chowed down that slice in record time, I couldn't even get a photo. It was so delicious that we had to order her a full complicated pizza, because one slice wasn't enough. Sure enough, they made her pizza and she got to bring some home. Pie trap customer service is impeccable! Definitely recommended!! They deserve 20 stars because 5 isn't enough. A 'must go to' place for good pizza. read more

My wife and I got the New York style Pizza with pepperoni. Their pizza dough was perfect. It was cooked just right. Pepperoni was a little salty but went good with pizza dough and cheese. We also ordered the Garlic knots that were probably the best I ever had. The pizza is kinda expensive but I don't feel ripped off because it was so good. The service was good especially that it was packed with people . The brewery inside was super good too . The lighting wasn't overly to bright and not to dark although, I like a dark bar.The overall experience was awesome. The ambiance was really good. The vibe was good . And that's all I got to say about that. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

The pizza is delish at Pie Trap! Be warned, these MASSIVE pies are addictive. My family loves the Notorious P.E.P. which is red sauce mozzarella and pepperoni. They also have pizza by the slice for $4-$6 which I feel like is a pretty good deal. I have only done take out here, the inside is pretty small. However, the brewery next door let's you take pizza in there! read more

Ain't nothing but a pizza party. Ain't nothing but a pizza party going down all day & all night at The Pie Trap! Wu Tangy slices are not nothing to mess with. Better get yourself a whole pie, or maybe just a single slice to grease the gullet for later. I am a smooth criminal of cheese, pepperoni, and crust, so I must order a slice of OG pepperoni at any pie pusher that is fresh to me. The Pie Trap got me good. A bang, bang, bang of meat, cheese, crust, and last but not least: grease. The oils are on the loose here, and the police have bigger fish to fry. This level of flavor should be a misdemeanor though. The service here is as organized as any bona fide & lucrative racket. The staff sets & serves a delish pizza trap. My order did not take long to make, to pick up from the counter, or consume. That type of efficiency frees up more time for first rate compulsive gluttony. Speaking of decadence, the interior of The Pie Trap is a real feast for the eyeballs. Cartoons, punny order names, and a staff with a disciplined demeanor reinforce the perception that this place is a speedy pizza oven that cooks. Stay for the Pie Trap pizza, and crawl away when you're too pizza sauced to walk. 5 stars baby. read more

See all