I ordered a meatball sub and what I got was disgusting falling apart bread with the insides piled on top. It was totally unidentifiable. I have been going there for years and never experienced anything like this. Never again, I am done. read more

Just a few minute drive from Lake Champlain. This place has a great selection of pizzas. Their specialty seafood pizza and St Albans were by far the favorite for our party. This is the first time we had green apples on a pizza but it worked well. read more

Pie In The Sky - Seafood specialty pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

On our way to Burlington, VT, on Friday, Pooh and I stopped here for supper. The atmosphere was very relaxed and the aroma from the kitchen was mouth-watering. We ordered the T-Rex pizza and it didn't disappoint! There was plenty of toppings and the perfect amount of cheese and sauce. The crust was moist and a joy to eat. The desserts are all homemade We will definitely go back on our next trip to VT! read more

Over rated, over priced, quality has dropped off significantly and they beg you for tips when you pick up take out. If you want average food at above average prices his is your place. read more

Great pizza. Definitely would eat here again. We got a large pizza and it was more than enough for 3 adults.

Half the inside was closed. No tables available, just booths. Couldn't find a place to sit, so we left. This was at lunch time on a Saturday. When you don't care enough about your customers to let them sit down, there's a serious problem. We are regular customers, but we won't be very regular anymore. read more

Pizza is really good! I just ordered it and pick it up sometimes. Service is friendly and good attitude.

Delicious pizza, cooked perfectly with dough but crispy crust. The BBQ pizza is my go to take out order.

Pizza! Pizza! Pizza! It's close. It's fast. It's. GOOD! Wish they had wings. We tried one of their take-and-bake pizzas for Super Bowl Sunday and it was great! And somebody recently told me they have Creemees! Does it get any better? read more

Best turkey bacon sub tonight !! They really stepped up to make this sandwich the best in town.

I ordered a medium pizza with ham and pineapple for takeout. When I got home and opened the box, I found that it was a pizza with a white sauce on it (no pizza sauce) with the ham and pineapple. I called and the person answering the phone said, the person who took your order must have thought you wanted the specialty pizza (I think she called it pineapple passion). Definitely not what I wanted. She offered to remake the correct pizza for me, but that would have been another half hour on the road so I said no thank you. Trying to figure out why the order taker interpreted my order for a medium pizza with ham and pineapple to be this other pizza. Am very disappointed in this visit to Pie in the Sky. read more

Honestly? Have been going to this restaurant starting in Stowe, VT since 2001. Started FREQUENTING the St. Albans restaurant in 2015. Have NEVER had an issue here. Last night, we waited for 40 minutes for a medium 3 topping pizza because at the same time we ordered l, a "to go" order for 15 LARGE pizzas was placed just before us........ So..... we waited because we weren't TOLD this had happened until just BEFORE we were about to walk out after paying for our drinks and going somewhere else. We did however notice that most of the staff was in their teens, and after asking, found out our server was underage and serving us our drinks illegally. Both surprised and disappointed! Will be some time before this Restaurant gets another cent of ou money. read more

We have eaten here once before. Their large pizza costs $24.00 for 4-6 toppings. If you order anything that is 1/2, which in my case was 5 1/2 (because my son doesn't eat black olives), they will charge you several dollars extra, for a reason that the manager and the person at the register cannot explain. Apparently that is just the way it is. Last time I checked math, 5.5 fell clearly between 4 and 6. I didn't see anything on the menu about a surcharge. A pizza that should have cost $25.50 actually costs $28.06. So, I won't get pizzas from here anymore. Too bad. Their food seems good. read more

Staff was nice and friendly. Lots of children in the restaurant definitely family friendly. The pizza was average but I think they are better known for other items. read more

Pie In The Sky - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

Hot and fresh. Friendly service as always. Thank you again and again. I don't know if the fresh bread, attention to detail, or the excellent service keeps us coming back, but it's nice to not have to choose. read more

Pie In The Sky - a sandwich on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

Pie in the Sky has long been a staple in my book of restaurants to visit. Their pomodoro sauce is amazing and their staff are always super helpful & happy. So let's get down to the review business. 3 years ago I would have given this place 5-stars but let's take a look at why they've been dropped down 1 star. Their atmosphere is wonderful, the wall art is very on par with their brand and feel, their staff are very friendly and welcoming. The cleanliness of this place is what you'd expect from a very busy pizza venue; clean i the AM, crumbs in the PM, but never really "dirty". The food quality of their non-pizza options is on par & amazing. And I would say the same for their pizza, except a few years back they made a change to their Mozzarella and I have been greatly disappointed. Every time my partner and I dine on their pizza or mozzarella based food options we feel crumby afterwards. We've found that cheaper mozzarellas tend to have more oil leading to more tummy upsets. But I have to say the rest of their foods, the non-mozz options, are on par with an Italian pizzeria, wonderful, tasty, presented beautifully. Overall their food is wonderful, their staff are very friendly, and the business is clean & presentable. I'd recommend giving them a try yourself next time you're in St Albans. read more

My favorite pizza in st albans hands down! Subs and salads great also. Been eating here for 20+ years and it's consistently good. Fair prices. Casual atmosphere, good service. read more

The restaurant is always booming and it's for good reason, the food is excellent every time my wife and I get the opportunity to dine here. Highly recommend Pie in the Sky's Calzones, you won't leave hungry. read more

Absolutely love this place! I have never had a bad experience here, staff is friendly even when it is extremely busy, and food is always delicious. Pizza, calzone or Stromboli you can't go wrong! Heros are delicious as well. read more

Outer sprout you spin me right round, baby right round, like a salad baby...in a roll that's round round. Whatever, Pie in the Sky kicks some major Italmerican food booty. Mostly, though, I go here for the outer sprout...and I may have developed a slight addiction. Imagine all the wonders of health that is your traditional salad....heat up your ingredients, add some flavored olive oil and a few cheeses, then stuff it into a toasted bread roll. I'm sure my description of this little bit of glory is somewhere between WTF and Huh-ville, but trust me, it is a good time on a plate. Consumption of the outer sprout is known to cause happiness, dancing, and evil jealous glances from your co-workers. Also, the pizza here is good by the slice even though the sauce could use a little more punch. Um, I'll finish this later. read more

Pie In The Sky - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

See all

All time favorite pizza place. Their garlic white sauce is amazing. They have an order ahead option so that your pizza is ready when ypu arrive. On a cold winter day this was an amazing service. We were cold and hungry, ordered ahead, came in, sat down and out came our pizza. It was a total hit with our hungry kids. I LOVE their pizza. read more

I'm pretty critical about my pizza joints. Pie in the Sky was a total sleeper. Everything they make is fresh but more importantly it's flavorful. It was the Maple Festival in St Albans and they were offering a maple pulled pork white pizza. I'm a Dave Portnoy pizza review fan so I live and die by, "One bite, everyone knows the rules." My pizza had little flop, big flavor, and soft buttery crust. Not too thick but not too thin. If you're in St Albans, check this place out. I promise you won't be disappointed. read more

Favorite pizza place. Love their crust and sauce and it's never super greasy! Would recommend

Great pizza and calzones. I am sure the other food on the menu is great, but I go for pizza or calzones. Never disappointed.

Best pizza!!! Miss this place. Not sure what they do to the dough but it is perfect! I like whatever is on special and the white pizzas!! Service could be a little better though. There is this young blonde girl that is a monster. One time she yelled at my grandmother. Snotty brat. Everyone else is nice though. I do also wish the served some kind of hard lemonade or something. I don't do beer and that's all they have. read more

Pie In The Sky - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

Ordered take of spaghetti. There was a lb of spaghetti and very little sauce. I needed to extract a lot of the spaghetti. It was a busy night so I blamed the good on that. A few weeks later, different night, different time, different food order. I ordered a large tuna sub. No frills, nothing special, didn't even ask for it to be heated. When I got home I couldn't believe it. Very little tuna, two tomatoes little lettuce and no extra onions like I asked. I'm not sure I'm giving this place another try read more

1st Star - For a small in size location with limited seating they have managed to limit wait times to minutes at most. 2nd Star - You are greater at the moment you arrive and always with a smile. The staff run around like crazy but never leave you unattended. 3rd Star - Ambience is nice, the art walls add a local feel with a imaginative approach. The sound is a bit loud with no noise cancelling but still low enough to carry on conversation. 4th Star - The food... I really like to give this star based on creativity and they earned that big time last month with their valentines month pie, my goodness this was perfectly balanced in flavor and presentation. Well done Pie! 5th Star - this one is discretionary because not everyone automatically gets five stars. I'm giving them this one for keeping their menu reasonably priced and having great meatballs in pomodora sauce! read more

Had an amazing dinner tonight at this inconspicuous restaurant. Eight of us showed up at once with four kids and they were happy to accommodate us with fast service, and smiles all around. We had St. Albans pizza (amazing), margarita pizza (very good) and the old sprout hot sub to name a few of the favourites. Definitely an amazing dinner and I am a pizza snob! read more

So very disappointed! I realize that things are more expensive and things are getting smaller but...$25 for 4 pieces of garlic bread (extra) order and a full order of spaghetti with sausage. My six year old granddaughter could of eaten the meal. My husband and I were going to share it. Clearly we were wrong very very wrong! Sadly that will be our last order. read more

lol so this is what you get from pie in the sky when you ask for diced tomatoes... looks like tomato paste and a few pieces of diced tomatoes to me... not impressed tomato's aren't much if you can't take the time to dice some tomatoes up or even by a can of actual diced tomatoes, I get them sometimes they don't look like this... like common won't be getting diced tomatoes on my pizza here again I guess... very disappointed read more

Pie In The Sky - Pizza with diced tomatoes and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

Food is "ok", service is terrible. They are incapable of handling lunch/dinner rushes. 50 minutes for 2 sandwiches, ended up having to take them to go because we had no more time for lunch. And this was during the week. Had a BLT, they "baked" the entire sandwich instead of just toasting the bread and cooking bacon, perhaps some people like cooked lettuce and tomatoes on their BLT, but it's not for me. Was not good. Price is also a bit much. $26.00 for 2 sandwiches...... We love to eat local and support our local economy and fellow citizens. This is one local place we won't ever be going back to, and that's saying a lot for a small town. So if you want a "quick" Bite for lunch, plan on 75-80 minutes for lunch. read more

HOLY SMOKES!!! I've eaten at American Flatbread here in Virginia and we decided to try one while we were up in Vermont. I just don't get it, I guess. This place on the other hand absolutely ROCKS!!! Our server was awesome. Constantly checking on us, offering ideas for the kids, very friendly. The pizza came out quickly and tasted great. I was dubious when we were told one pizza was enough for the 4 of us, so I didn't order a second one. Our server was almost right -- I was pretty hunger so I needed an extra slice. I chose pepperoni, sausage and mushroom. One of the best slices I've had. EVER. The mushrooms were amazing. Piled high on the slice and a little smokey. Really, really good. Then we had the soft serve ice cream. I mean "Creemmee". So much for so little and the candied walnuts on top of the maple/vanilla swirl were off the hook. We loved our trip to Vermont and would be tempted to stay a little further north next time so we could come here a couple times. The place is nothing to look at -- kind of old school booths with a low rent strip mall feel, but probably our favorite meal in Vermont. The only complaint, and not one worth even 1/2 a star is the beer selection wasn't great. Otherwise, perfect. read more

There is no pizza in the area that tops Pie in the Sky. I've been a customer since the 1990s. My three-year-old son used to take great pleasure in going to the counter and ordering a cheese pizza with "murmurs" and "gingerado" and have the kitchen staff know exactly what he wanted. (Mushrooms and gingerale). We stuck with them when they moved from the crowded little shop they were in to the much dual-room establishment they're in now. Quality has never diminished. For the most part, the menu's stayed the same. They're very good at what they do and don't feel the need to change with the trends. I highly recommend the St. Albans pie. Sausage, Granny Smith apples, and cheddar. Also, don't overlook the pie of the month. Of all of them, the seafood is a family favorite with the harvest veggie taking a close second. Also, if you have room, which is tough, their minestrone is the best I've ever had. read more

So far our favorite pizza place in St. Albans for multiple reasons. The staff is consistently awesome. My daughter always gets a black olive and cheese pizza. When we order it by the slice they cut it up in kid sized bites which is awesome!! The gluten free pizza is the best I have tried in town...not the best I have tried...but the best available in St. Albans that I didn't have to make myself. Back when I was eating gluten I loved the outer sprout sandwich. I am happy that they have a gluten free option...no complaints...but I miss the outer sprout! Pie in the Sky is also my husband's favorite pizza spot in town. No complaints from him EVER about eating here! My daughter is thrilled when she is allowed to go up to the counter and pay. Makes her day! Creemees are decent too!! read more

This place is great ! I dare you to walk into the complex where this is and smell the pizza cooking and not want to go grab some chow ! The restaurant is small and unimpressive but the food speaks volumes - everything is great and it is super convenient when you are going to the grocery store or doing some other errands in this "strip mall" type of complex and need / want to grab a quick bite - check it out you won't be disappointed...Hope this helps! read more

Pie In The Sky - Pizza Near Me - Saint Albans, Vermont

Usually I enjoy eating or there delivery. But the last few times have not been very good at all. I Ordered a calzone that was undercooked,raw dough And when I cut into it liquid poured out. Okay anyone can have a bad day. I ordered from there delivery service a few days after that a large cold sub with the works extra meat a cold drink and tip $18.63. That was fine. Two days later I had delivery again. And I ordered the same thing as before except not a whole sub instead half a sub. The price was the same as a whole. $18.06. I called them after I had finished lunch just to bring it to there attention. I had both of my receipts. I explained it to the person speaking with me and gave her the info from both of my recites I was given to a person in charge. I was told there was no mistake and I should be happy with it. Rather than argued I said thank you and left it that. But I won't be going back or ordering delivery anytime soon. read more

Stopped in for test-bite (as I always need to find a good source of pizza where ever I may be). Asked for two slices and a Switchback. I would judge it as average-tasting. I had two plain slices, to test the flavor and texture of the crust. The establishment was busy and appeared clean. Waitress was friendly and attentive. Men's room was clean and functional. Need to try some other pizza places around here... read more

I have had several random times where I had had pie in the sky: Only twice have I sat down and stayed for a meal here. The first time it was with my mom and we both got sandwiches. We both thought it was good. The other time before work my SO, a friend and I came for lunch before work and I got a ham and cheese sandwich, my SO got a calzone; he liked it but it wasn't as good as mimmo's or zachery's calzones. My friend got a chef salad and was happy with that. Had some of the pizza here when my job ordered a ton of pizza for everyone. It was really good and in my opinion, it was on par with mimmos. I got a salad once here also, I had a huge craving for a chef salad. It really hit the spot, everything was fresh and good. A little on the small size (for the price) but that was probably because I got it to go and they filled up the container as much as it could possible be filled. No points off for that, just a little disappointed. Next time i go with a salad in mind and sit in maybe I'll have a better idea on size vs pricing. All and all I'm looking forwards to the next time I go! read more

Love their "Outer Sprout" veggie sub and my son loves the pizza.

Was in town for a doctors appointment and hadn't eaten all day. Stopped in to do some shopping and thought I would check this place out. Glad I did. I had half an Italian sub which was more like a whole sub. The rolls they use are the right sub rolls....chewy exterior with a fluffy interior to hold all the goodies. I had mine loaded and it was with everything. Tasted so fresh. Yum....It is hard to find a good sub nowadays. I will be back to check out the pizza. read more