Cancel

Open app

Search

Pickett House

1.0 (1 review)

Services - Pickett House

Hotels

Pickett House Hotels Photos

More like Pickett House

Recommended Reviews - Pickett House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hotels 434 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Outermost Inn Aquinnah - Outside upper deck and bar

Outermost Inn Aquinnah

(81 reviews)

Enjoyed a lovely dinner at Outermost Inn. The drive is about 30 minutes from Vineyard Haven and…read morereservations are a must. You need to call at least a week in advance. We snagged an 8p on Saturday night. The restaurant serves a tasting menu ~$140/pp before tips and drinks. They serve cocktails and wine/beer, but they don't have a full liquor license(no martinis here). I saw duck on a recent menu but it wasn't available when we went so double check if you have dietary preferences. We decide to share among 4 which worked well. I enjoyed the kimchi oysters, seared tuna, and matcha cake the most. The cheese plate looked nice. Great views if you make it before sunset. Service was slow, we had to flag down a different waiter to get our dessert. Overall nice experience but won't beat out other favorites.

I was hesitant to drop a bundle for dinner after reading a scathing review of Outermost on Yelp!…read moreMy brother Bif ( some musical connection with the Taylor clan) said that I must go there. So I made a reservation for dinner. The night I arrived the Inn was hosting a full on wedding. I was seated promptly. Living on a sailboat sine July Fourth I was ready to rumble! Starting with coffee, Saratoga and ceviche. This came in a bowl 7-10 ounces of fish. It had a perfect balance of lemon/lime juice, There was no distractions to compete with delicious fresh fish Next I choose from an amazing prix menu. Being TypeII, I had to choose carefully. My fish arrived cooked to perfection. The flavors in the yogurt sauce took my fish to another level. At this point I drank a glass of red Italian wine ,to honor my mother while eating a cheese plate dessert. Personally this was a very satisfying outing at Outermost. Tazbro47

Duck Inn - Deck room East Q

Duck Inn

(8 reviews)

$$$

This reminds me of going to my grandmas 100+ year old farmhouse if it were on an island. Up island,…read moreAquinnah (formerly Gay Head area) is nice and quiet in comparison to the rest of the island and Oak Bluffs where the ferry drops off. Elise is just a wonderful person and made the trip special. She makes a breakfast out of this world and the inn has some great animal life. A few bobcats and she has nursed some wildlife back to health. Walk to the rural more private beach is less than ten minutes. We will most certainly be back!

This is my sanctuary from the world; quiet, serene, listening to the crickets & ocean waves at…read morenight. The breakfasts! OMG carry me though to dinner. Aquinnah is far from the other towns (30 min drive) so plan accordingly. The liquor stores do deliver with enough advance notice, and there are a few restaurants not so far away, but you are out in the country. Love sitting in the hot tub at night watching the stars. This is an old house so you might hear noise from other rooms or when breakfast gets going, but I travel with earplugs & a mask so not a thing for me. Elise is welcoming & has tips for everything you can think of. Free wifi, amazing water & sunset views (except from the downstairs stone-wall room) and blissful calm. There is no AC but mostly it's not needed, and mini fridges in many rooms, bring a small cooler for a day at the beach, a beach towel, good walking shoes, and de-com-press.

Pickett House - hotels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...