Pick N Save

Locally owned & operated

Established in 1919

Woodman's Market...may be the first grocery store that had me contemplating relocation across…read morestates just to be able to shop there. Woodman's Market is a local Wisconsin brand of markets that puts every other market I have shopped at to shame. They are community focused and worker owned, which is really cool in today's corporate driven retail environment. In addition to their mission, they are solely grocery driven, meaning they focus on food, and lots of it...you will not find a wide variety of clothing, toys, seasonal items, etc...here, just food, lots and lots of food, and drinks. The store itself is MASSIVE, overwhelmingly so. However it is so thoughtfully laid out and spaced very well. Aisles are wide, sections are very clear and well defined and again, the selection is unreal. This is repeated throughout the store with every section from produce, veggies, snacks, frozen, meats, drinks, etc... In addition to the impressive variety of goods, Woodman's also has a gas station, service/lube station (oil changes), car wash and of course a well-stocked and good sized liquor store! Legit, everything. The store is well maintained conditionally and was very clean, inside and out. Service was top notch as well. From the cart attendance to the stock associate to the cashier...all were great! Overall, Woodman's Market is currently my favorite grocery store in the country. And I am honestly willing to throw hands over it. In addition to restaurants and other spaces I visit when in WI, Woodman's is always considered a priority stop!

went to shop today and there were 2 employes at the self check out needed help and they said just…read moreuse the scanner and continue to talk to each other and the lady behind me needed help to and told her want to do from the self checker register to instead going over to help her so they could continue to talk to each other so there getting to get paid to talk

See all

Hy-Vee

3.3(133 reviews)

8.5 mi•Mayfair Park

This location is not the best in town. Shelves are frequently empty, especially on sale items,…read moreresulting in several rain check slips stacked in my car. The cashier's rarely get my two coupons entered properly which is another challenge to get customer service to fix the mistake. Overall for the few items I choose to buy here it frequently results in a stop at customer service to deal with their faults.

My son and his wife had their Christmas holiday dinner catered from here. It wax beyond fabulous…read more They had a prime rib and a spiral ham. The rib was cooked to perfection and the ham was moist , which isn't usually the case with spiral sliced hams. They had Mac and cheese and mashed potato. I'm sure it wasn't cheap but it was worth it! I would highly recommend.

Spooky cookie cakes

Flowers

See all

Gilbertson C B Store

5.0(3 reviews)

0.4 mi

About a four stool country bar and general store, a 130 year old blast from the past! You can spend…read morea long time just looking around at all the old stuff. There was a table of patrons playing cards in the center of the store. Ambiance was slow and relaxed. Go check it out now because it will be closing the end of this month. Very nice owner and Outhouses out back!

This place is like going back in time. Love it and love the owner. Best BACON I've ever tasted…read more(sliced to order)

Nice dive bar!

November 2016

See all

November 2016

ALDI

3.1(13 reviews)

6.3 mi

Great place to shop! Friendly staff well organized & clean. Super tasty deli pizza!read more

I gave up hope on this place because the people that work here are unpleasant and rude. In…read moreaddition, this place is poorly stocked and has limited selection in food items. Please improve your customer service team and restock your items.

See all

Festival Foods

4.7(7 reviews)

33.2 mi

Staff was helpful in my hurry and rush in and out. They showed me where the item I needed was. And…read morethey answered a few other questions. Clean and accessible for all items. The produce was fresh and nice looking. Has a lot of different and interesting ingredients.

So my wife and I were tired, we both at worked, didn't feel like cooking. So I go to festival…read morefoods. I was really excited to get a roasted chicken at five fifteen p m.In the evening. And there were none and when I asked if there'd be any more, I was told no. You lost a sale I went to pick and save and bought one. I have been in there a couple more days and notice there is no rotisserie chicken out and recently you just said it was on sale. You're missing your mark.

See all

Festival Foods

3.8(4 reviews)

23.5 mi

Hello, We have a…read moreFestival card and I have been trying to use it at Kwick Trip on fuel for my truck. Today I tried again and they told me that Festival cards are not used on diesel. I asked why and they quickly said that it was a Festival decision to only have it for gasoline. Based on the quickness of their response I would say that they are asked this fairly often. The Festival card is nice but not being able to utilize it on fuel is unfortunate. Please reconsider this as it impacts my family and our needs. Thank you - matt

I like the store and people that work there. Produce is always good and the stuff they make in…read morehouse rules. Love the hot bar as well the fried chicken is good even better later if you heat it up in the air fryer. Just got some of their fajitas and they are super tasty. All in all better than Walmart and Aldis if you ask me I will be a lifelong customer for sure!

Piggly Wiggly

2.9(20 reviews)

7.0 mi

Well organized and clean. All the items in produce looked nice and fresh…read more Checkout was awesome . The clerk was young but was really good at checking patrons out. It might be a bit more expensive but for general shopping and a close location. The bakery carries some decent products.

Nice looking produce & deli area . Overpriced in everything, variety is fair , cashiers won't give…read moreyou change ? I'm used to having more options in a town of 16,000 people. Maybe city officials will approve the Hy-VEE ...oh wait, they botched that up

Where I hang in the 'Kee

Who among us can resist the allure of a a Piggly Wiggly umbrella?

See all

Fresh salad without the work

Maurer's Market IGA

3.0(35 reviews)

34.3 mi

Great little grocery store in the heart of Wisconsin Dells. Excellent selection of fresh foods,…read moreethnic specialties, and basic staples. For those fretting about the higher prices - the store is in a tourist town, it is to be expected.

First time coming here, wanted a place to check out since I was in the Wisconsin Dells area and…read morewanted to see what the grocery store had so maybe I could take back a few things to my hotel room. There wasn't anything eye catching about this grocery store. It was just a typical grocery store, featured plenty of food, groceries, household goods, Etc. The store was clean and it had very clean restrooms as well for its guests. Parking was pretty easy, some items were a bit overpriced as well like the water. Overall it was an average grocery store experience

Beautiful dog left while mom shops

See all

GHOST PEPPERS for sale here!

Miller & Sons Supermarket

4.6(65 reviews)

19.8 mi

I was there on a weekday afternoon mostly to take out lunch. Lunch prices were reasonable, but…read morestill food was good. I loved the sloppy joes the most. Salisbury steak dinner was a good one as well. Pinapple upside down cake was probably my favorite.

I have ordered cakes from Miller's for two special occasions. I anticipated they would be great,…read moreand they always exceeded expectations. Miller's bakery has great staff and service, and the cakes are artfully done and delicious. If you want a cake for your special occasion, I highly recommend them.

Menu

See all

Lunch

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rodney D.

0

1

0

4 years ago

IF I spend 100's on a cell-phone and sine up for phone service and go git perks points. I have a perks card , NO THAT IS NOT GO!!!!! Case in point today pop $3.99 BUT WITH ON LINE POINTS $.99 TELL ME HOW CAN THEY DO THAT????? This is shame full to elders looking to save on fixed INCOME. read more

Pick N Save - grocery - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Restaurants near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Things to Do near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Coffee near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Pizza near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Desserts near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Parking near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Breakfast near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Liquor Store near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Pharmacy near Pick N Save

BEST of DeForest, Wisconsin Shopping near Pick N Save

Best of DeForest

Things to do in DeForest

Browse Brands

Pick'n Save

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pick N Save also viewed

Hy-Vee

3.3

(133 reviews)

This location is not the best in town. Shelves are frequently empty, especially on sale items,…read moreresulting in several rain check slips stacked in my car. The cashier's rarely get my two coupons entered properly which is another challenge to get customer service to fix the mistake. Overall for the few items I choose to buy here it frequently results in a stop at customer service to deal with their faults.

My son and his wife had their Christmas holiday dinner catered from here. It wax beyond fabulous…read more They had a prime rib and a spiral ham. The rib was cooked to perfection and the ham was moist , which isn't usually the case with spiral sliced hams. They had Mac and cheese and mashed potato. I'm sure it wasn't cheap but it was worth it! I would highly recommend.

Trader Joe's

4.0

(115 reviews)

We made the mistake of going to Trader Joe's on a Sunday, and it was absolutely packed. The parking…read moregarage was full, so we had to park on the street--which should've been our first clue to turn around, but we didn't. Inside, it was shoulder-to-shoulder with shoppers. That said, we managed to grab a few items we wanted, and the checkout line moved surprisingly fast. We picked up the Pad See Ew, Paneer Masala with Rice, and a couple of ice creams. Everything we tried was tasty, and I was pleasantly surprised by how good the frozen Pad See Ew was. The portion size is on the smaller side, but at $4-5, it's a solid value. Note to self: avoid Trader Joe's on weekends; weekday trips are much better.

Trader Joe's is a national grocery chain that still manages to feel like a neighborhood store. Most…read moreproducts are their own private label, and you'll find a strong selection of organic produce, vegan options, and even fresh flowers and succulents right at the entrance. The back of the store has a nice beer and wine section--think Whole Foods-style offerings but at lower prices. For example, a six-pack of beer for just $4.99 isn't the best tasting, but at that price, it's hard to complain. Here's my biggest tip: avoid this store on weekends. I made the mistake of visiting on a Sunday around noon, and it was chaos. The underground parking garage holds maybe 20 cars, and the line to get in stretched onto the street. I ended up parking on the street in the neighborhood two blocks away, which wasn't terrible, but once inside, it was a different story. Every register line had 20-30 people, stretching all the way to the back of the store. Overall, Trader Joe's offers great prices and unique finds, but unless you enjoy battling crowds, I'd recommend going on a weekday.

Woodman's Food Market

3.3

(145 reviews)

While shopping at Woodman's may not be the most glamorous experience, it hard to beat the…read moreincredible selection and rock bottom prices. The store is not as nice as the newer Sun Prairie store and gets insanely busy on weekends, which means long lines to checkout. The liquor department has possibly the best selection of wine, beer and spirits, but the staff is not as knowledgeable as some of the area specialty stores. While this Woodman's offers a large variety of produce items, the quality is really hit or miss. If you are super selective and look at each item closely, you can come away with decent produce, but it takes a lot of effort. I know, no credit cards means lower prices, but it sucks when you are in the check-out line and realize you left your ATM card at home.

It is too giant for me, hike and a half from the exit back to my car, and the rattling carts on the…read morebumpy tiles was maddeningly loud. I thought I'd just grabbed a bum cart, but the tiled flooring really creates that noise. The lay-out is bizarre. Like, you wade through the produce section to get to the rest of the store, and then it's impossible to get out through that same entrance to exit after you check out. Or maybe there's a path, but I had to push my creaky cart downhill in the snow all the way back to my car and almost got hit by several cars zipping along that same route. I'll give this store another try, because I was told by coworkers this is the cheapest option in town for groceries, but it was too massive, crowded and noisy for me. And I don't think the prices were great, even with the app I downloaded.

Bent and Dent

4.3

(4 reviews)

A different type of store to explore in the area. I had fun walking through its aisles. They have…read moreunique products and prices. Check it out!

I've been to the Bent and Dent up in Oxford, and that place rules, so I was excited to come here…read more However, these stores are not at all the same. This location is a bit more well organized; however, that was really the only thing it had going for it. The selection and prices were really not very good. Some items were as much or more expensive than going to a regular grocery store. Along with that, despite the mask mandate, nobody here seemed to care about wearing masks, social distancing, sanitizing, or anything Covid related. The woman working came out without a mask to ring up my items, but did go back for one after she saw me wearing mine. But otherwise she didn't wear one and neither did any of the other customers.

Sauk Prairie Market

3.1

(11 reviews)

Store is clean up to date. New walk in beer cooler is amazing. Most employees are friendly and…read morehelpful. Selection is great, and fresh meats are spectacular and fairly priced. If you have never had the deli's Broasted Chicken is THE BEST!!!! Smelling it as you drive past is brutal to resist. The older women in the deli recognize us, we love them. Meats, cheeses, salads, and fries from deli are delicious too. Local flair and local foods...highly recommend!!!!!!!

As far as small-town grocery stores go, this Sentry is a couple of decades behind the times. Over…read morethe four years that I have worked in Prairie du Sac, I have repeatedly sworn off this Sentry in favor of the nicer and newer Piggly Wiggly in Sauk City. The store manager is surprisingly rude, though I will give the employees credit for having a nice demeanor most of the time. Unfortunately for them, their store is dingy and dated. The layout is in the typical 70's era fashion. I never did any significant grocery shopping at this store, but when I did need to pick up certain items it was always hit-or-miss, since the selection was never all that good. The produce area was not terrible, though I don't recall ever seeing organic. I used to frequent the deli for lunch quite often since it was a quick walk, but the food was generally mediocre and occasionally terrible. Most of the food was either fried or broiled. There were a few instances where I was impressed, but these were unfortunately few and far between. I recall there would be sandwich specials from time to time, including turkey with sun-dried tomato and provelone. These were quite good, but it was only a rare occurrence and most days you would have to settle for the same-old. I sometimes would try the pre-made cold sandwiches and salads, but these were never good. I now make it a point to either bring in my lunch or drive to Sauk City rather than go back to the bad old days at the Sentry.

J&P Fresh Market

4.0

(24 reviews)

This place didn't have any website or recent reviews. I wasn't quiet sure if they were open. I was…read moreopen in a silent area. Blueberry raspberry oreo was a nice twist to oreo. Chocolate ice cream bar was slighly less rich, but still very good. Mango banana drink was a good one. Olive juice was something new to try. They had Melona popsicle. I bought a store made drink and a bun. Both were just ok. They had several products which crossed expiry date in the shelf. Finding the expiry date of a product here is an ordeal. Some products come with expiry date printed. Some products had a date printed, which happen to be the manufacturing date. Then there is additional detail on how to calculate expiry date written somewhere in small letters.

Clean and cozy grocery store with a variety of Asian pantry to produce, meats to beverages, and so…read moremuch more! Rewards activated after swiping card via text. Quick in and out!

Local Source Foods

4.0

(1 review)

Meat. Lots of meat. And I mean lots and lots of meat of every variety. Great prices. Mainstream…read morebrands. Also you could buy small portions or enough to feed a football team. I was pleasantly surprised at how much variety they had and how little we spent for the amount of tasty meat products we left with. The bad? The one staff member there never greeted us, never asked if we needed anything, and didn't even say hello when we got to the register. There were exactly 2 customers in the store at the time, and he wasn't doing anything else either. Grumpy Gus he was I guess. I dinged a star for that.

Madison Food Mart

3.8

(4 reviews)