Petrillo&#x27;s Pizza

It's been a tradition for us to come back every year because the food is so good! We loved the…read moregrilled corn, steamers, and roast clam special. We tried the mussels for the first time and that was really good too. The mussels are garlicky and just melt in your mouth. The staff are always so welcoming. It is easy to find a parking spot. There are two restrooms on site and a sink outside for washing hands.

Outstanding and Unique Great seafood !…read moreThe wife and I love this place and highly recommend

Flowers

Clam special - cooked with cocktail sauce

See all

Muscles with wine and garlic

M & J Beach Grille and Seafood

3.6(29 reviews)

1.6 mi

We called in advance--on a Saturday night--to double check their hours and we were told they were…read moreopen until 8. We arrived at 7:53 and were rudely told that they were closing early and we could not get ice cream. When I mentioned to the owner that we had called in advance, he rudely told me that he didn't care and wouldn't be serving us. I suppose it's his prerogative to close early, but he was unnecessarily nasty and completely unaccommodating. I won't be returning, there's no need to treat customers with disrespect.

Service was good. Seafood was gross. Disgusting everything was either undercooked or overcooked.read more

See all

Guilford Lobster Pound

4.4(189 reviews)

1.6 mi

Now I see why this place won first place for their lobster roll!!…read more So delicious. The lobster bisque was so tasty. The service was kind and knowledgeable The outside overlooking the water is such a vibe

I really enjoyed this lobster roll!! It was a medium sized roll and a good amount of lobster…read moreinside. Keep in mind it's cash only but there's an ATM inside. The patio area is very cute to sit on outside and the views are so nice. They told us our rolls would come out in 30 minutes but they came out in 10. Would come again!

The Lobster Pound - Guilford,CT (actual pieces from a lobster)

See all

View from dining area

The Wharf Restaurant

3.3(220 reviews)

The manager, Anthony, is a classy, gracious, gentleman who takes time from his busy schedule to…read moremeet with many customers for feedback. Matt the bartender - a great guy and talented bartender. He is very personable and can make you laugh. Our server, Nichole, was a sweetheart and very attentive. A great place to dine, and what a view. I highly recommend it.

My wife and I ordered two dishes: Fish and Chips and Steak Frites. The prices were certainly not…read morecheap, and we found the portions rather small, especially for a place that presents itself as a luxury, high-quality establishment. The Fish and Chips was good. Unfortunately, the Steak Frites was a completely different experience, and it was the most expensive course in the menu. I ordered the steak rare, but when it arrived, it was immediately obvious that something was not right. The texture and appearance of the meat made it seem as though it had either been reheated or had been sitting out for some time. The juices appeared cooked onto and into the meat, which is certainly not what you expect from a freshly prepared steak ordered rare. I explained the problem to the cook and mentioned that I have worked as a chef, so I know what properly prepared meat should look and taste like. I was told that they would prepare a new steak for me. I then waited approximately 40 minutes. By that point, my wife had completely finished her meal, and I was actually about to cancel my order when the replacement finally arrived. Unfortunately, the second steak was overcooked. At that point, I told the waitress that I no longer wanted it. She was polite, apologized, and seemed to completely understand my decision, which I appreciated. My complaint is not simply that one dish was prepared incorrectly. Mistakes happen in every kitchen. The real issue is how a restaurant responds when something goes wrong. Waiting around 40 minutes for a replacement steak while the other person at the table has already finished eating, only for the replacement to arrive incorrectly cooked as well, is far below the standard of service I would expect from an establishment in this price range. Quality is not simply about charging premium prices or presenting yourself as a luxury establishment. Quality has to be demonstrated through the food, the kitchen, the service, and especially through the ability to correct a problem when one occurs. Unfortunately, based on our experience, the prices and the image this establishment tries to project were well above the actual quality we received.

Beautiful views

ZACAPA FALL PUNCH Zacapa Dark Rum, Apple Cider, Maple Syrup, St. George Pear, Grenadine

See all

SALTY DINGHY Belle de Brillet, Cointreau, Fresh Lime

Guilford Bistro & Grille Cafe

4.0(184 reviews)

Started with the Beet Salad which we started. It contained goat cheese, baby arugula, candied…read morewalnuts and apples. With a thick balsamic dressing. It was very good. The main entree was Chicken Cristin. I ordered it over pappardelle. It had two pieces of white chicken meat in a sherry wine sauce. It was covered with spinach, mozzarella, artichoke hearts and roasted peppers. It was delicious. For dessert I ordered the Gelato. The said 3 scoops of gelato, however it was 3 small spoonfuls. Order 3 different flavors. Except for the espresso, they all tasted the same. Not worth the money. The meal was very good, disappointed in the dessert I ordered. Service was good and they had off street parking. Would have given it 5 stars except for my dessert .

Whoever said this place never disappoints should have been at my table today. I've come here many…read moretimes but the last 2-3 times it has been lacking....and I always get the same thing..Bistro Salmon. Today, small, thin piece and the sauce was missing the usual honey sweetness and overly mustardy. Squash barely cooked and a few pieces of asparagus that looked more like string beans. Basically not much on the plate for $33. The service was also bad. The waitress was absent from visiting our table in the beginning , middle and end of our meal, had to ask her for water, she never asked us how our meal was and was, didn't clear our plates etc. it was poor all the way around this trip. Maybe chef was on vacation with the usual servers!!

Gelato

Papardelle Rustica

See all

L&J’s Fish Tale

3.6(331 reviews)

4.6 mi

Let's talk about THIS lobster roll ‍…read more Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale did NOT come to play. That buttered lobster roll is fresh, loaded, and worth the market price--every bite hits. I've had a lot in CT... this one is top tier. So good I finished it and said "yeah, I need another one to go" Friendly staff Indoor/outdoor seating Open year-round Now don't leave without dessert. The ice cream is a MUST Oreo sundae for me, Reese's sundae for the kids... no regrets. Summer = ice cream shack outside Off-season = still inside This place is the whole experience.

Food isn't very tasty…read more This place is great if you have a family and don't care what the food taste like. Lobster roll is bland. $30 for an experience that makes you crave biting into a lemon for flavor. My wife's fish was so dry and flavorless that you would think you are eating a fish sandwich in Arizona. Clam chowder is an insult to New England. It's soupy and not creamy. Only come here if you don't care about spending $$$ for food that genuinely makes you question your life choices. The atmosphere was nice. Service wasn't great but that was understandable given the dinner rush. Owner: i respect that you read feedback and respond. I wanted to love this place but was disappointed. Please include a lemon with your fish dishes. That little of a difference may change a lot of opinions about the food quality here. I'm only writing this because this was my first lobster roll in 2 years and I was heart broken.

Plenty of souvenirs

Westbrook location

See all

Chapter One Food & Drink Guilford

3.4(182 reviews)

I wanted a lobster roll before I flew back home to KC. Unfortunately the place I stopped first was…read morestill closed for the season & I was so hungry I decided to pull over and grab lunch at Chapter One. Hot crisp fries, buttery chunks of lobster on a brioche, my mouth is watering just thinking about it again. More of an upscale place than a lunch counter, it was peaceful to sit and eat by myself. Staff gave me Lemonaide instead of the iced tea I ordered, but it was so delicious I didn't even care.

Came here for dinner and drinks; the restaurant had a fun vibe. The service was friendly; however,…read more they were so busy on a Friday night that our food took forever. The drinks were good and priced reasonably. The truffle fries were good, and the chicken wings were just okay, really small and pricey. BF and friend thought the chicken caprese sandwich was just average. I had the Cajun chicken pasta, and it was incredible! Lindsay, who served us, was really nice and apologetic for the delay in the kitchen.

See all

South Lane Bistro

3.8(142 reviews)

My wife and I had a great meal! The food is always so fresh and the service is always on point! We…read morewill definitely be back!

First time here.last week of August with brother and sister in law,on a Wednesday night. Place was…read morebusy, need to say,I'm not a fan of wooden chairs. My Prostrate agrees. ordered gazpacho for an appetizer,came in a coffee cup and they charge $12 for that. I wasn't impressed , lack luster on vegetables in it,was kind of bland. I ordered a bnls ribeye steak as an entree with side salad,ordered it medium,it was more like medium rare,but I didn't send it back,but should have, it was tasty but a little too raw. I had a taste of my SIL's squash blossoms filled with cheese. That was very good. Probably won't return on my next visit.

Aperol Spritz

Buffalo brussel sprouts and calamari

See all

Rosemary Fried Zucchini

Donahue's Madison Beach Grille

3.9(196 reviews)

4.7 mi

Place hit the spot!…read more Needed a wellness meal and I came across Donahue's during my travels of the coast. Could have eaten a bowl of the chowder, so good. Blacked Swordfish and asparagus were delicious, could have substituted another vegetable for the rice and would have been just as happy. Carrot cake was good. Dense which is how I like it, icing made it too sweet. Cream cheese filling, yummm. Will certainly be back.

Welcoming atmosphere, my meal was very good and I felt the prices were reasonable…read more My waitress was friendly however my food took a very long time to come out. Then again with the check it took a long time waiting. I will try it again because the food was very tasty.

See all

Prime on Whitfield

3.5(120 reviews)

We're massive fans of Prime! Have visited for brunch, happy hour and dinner and always had…read moreoutstanding experiences. Lots of custom cocktails to choose from as well as a wide variety of beer and wine. The food is always delicious no matter what you order. Steak is their forte and they do it very well. Always cooked to the proper temperature and well seasoned. Our favorite spot to go for family brunches. FYI, the restaurant is relatively small and it is noisy when they're busy. Not the ideal spot if you're hoping for an intimate experience.

We decided to have an anniversary brunch on the Green. Prime has superior location. The ambiance…read moreis definitely upbeat & happy. We had mimosas to toast- they were too sweet from perhaps a bit more orange juice than needed. The classic brunch was generally nicely served, but it came lukewarm. My poached eggs hopefully free range were tasty but small-ish, the bacon was just fine, but the brioche toast was dreadful: so dry that it crumbled. Definitely, real brioche buns or high quality sliced brioche bread should be introduced. The fruit bowl that accompanied my brunch was decent. The server was not too attentive.

Dinning room

Buffalo Cauliflower: EXCELLENT

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Daniel K.

0

4

0

13 years ago

Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like Like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like like read more

Regina C.

1

46

1

12 years ago

Had takeout for my family tonight and everything was great! The wings were perfect, buff chicken pizza my kids ate all of, my salad was huge, and my husband had one of the chicken specials that was delicious! Very friendly staff, made sure I had everything and gave us enough warm bread for all of us to share YUM! we fed a family of 5 for under $45 and have plenty of leftovers, We will be returning soon! read more

John L.

0

1

0

10 years ago

AVOID BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY Absolutely terrible. The pizza is really bad. Frozen pizza has more flavor. The owner is quite rude. He told me he was gonna throw the f***in food in my face! Wow! Check your options in guilford. There are much better choices close by. Disgusting. He shut down his facebook page due to bad reviews. Now his business is listed as a person so you cannot review it. Ha! read more

Samuel L.

0

1

0

8 months ago

This might be the best pizza ive had in a while, the crust was amazing, the cheese was perfect and so was the sauce. The service there was great and was run by the sweetest people. I had to wait no time for my food to come out and to know that the restaurant is run but a family is so sweet to me. If you're looking for good food and good people this is your next stop! 5 stars! read more

Lela D.

0

1

0

9 years ago

've been going here for years. I must say my favorite restaurant. The food is always amazing and the atmosphere is very friendly. I love, love their pizza :) read more

Zachary Z.

0

2

0

3 years ago

when i at dis bro you could say im dead and in heaven. my erection removed all the blood from my brain and i passed out. delicious. :)

Ellen B.

0

9

0

3 years ago

Rude Manager, bar tender and owner. And they store their food in a truck in the back parking lot - health hazard.

Joel R.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Owner and staff are great, so is the food !!! Highly recommend to all.

Perry C.

0

3

0

10 years ago

Not even going to lie. This pizza here sucks. stay awayyyyyy.

Laura Z.

12

9

13 years ago

Horrible nachos. Pizza is nothing spectacular.

Gerard M.

9

120

41

15 years ago

Its a pizza place with a bar. Its fine.

Petrillo's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Petrillo's Pizza also viewed

Grand Apizza Madison

3.8

(137 reviews)

First off, Grand has great pizza service and people. I've eaten there multiple times. This review…read moreis about my mess up. I screwed up a pizza truck reservation for my house and party. Mike was amazing and understanding about it. I probably wouldn't have been if I were in his position. I recommend him and Grand for their food and professionalism.

Awful pizza, poorly made with cheap ingredients and flimsy crafting, a mess really and no flavor…read more Also, rude careless servers, not a nice place, dont bother. Shoreline usually is a good place to dine so this was a shock.

Bufalina

4.2

(188 reviews)

Pizza, desserts and staff never disappoint! It's cozy whether outside or sitting inside, so BE SURE…read moreTO CALL FOR RESERVATIONS. The pizza crust alone is a star. I had the Maine Lump crab last week. Think elevated tuna melt in Heaven.

Fresh, delicious pies! Intimate seating (read small) but a homey feel. Definitely worth checking…read moreout!

Amato's Pizza & Pasta

4.6

(54 reviews)

How have I not found this place until now? Absolutely loved their pizza, garlic knots and…read moremeatballs! Super easy online ordering and pick up. I will definitely be back!

4 stars only because its take out only. There is absolutely no where to sit inside. There is a…read morepicnic table outside, which is where we ate. We were pleasantly welcomed. We ordered and waited. And the pizza is amazing! The chicken Chipotle was really good. It could've had a little less Chipotle on top. But other than that, absolutely no complaints!

Grand Apizza Shoreline

3.7

(167 reviews)

My original review was a while back. We love this place and eat from here all the time. When we…read morehave had issues, they seem to want to fix them. The pizza is great, the pastas are great, the salads are great. You can't go wrong really. Keep up the standards and for some of the younger staff maybe keep your eye on service, but all in all. We love it.

Tried Grand Apizza Madison for the first time and ordered a cheese pizza, a plain pizza, and a…read moremeatball pizza. The meatball was my favorite. The meatballs had great flavor and went really well with the crispy crust. The cheese pizza was also really good, and the plain pizza ended up being the favorite for a lot of my family because it lets the crust and sauce shine. Everything tasted fresh, and the pizzas had that classic New Haven-style crunch. We'll definitely be back to try more!

TJ's Restaurant & Pizza

4.0

(139 reviews)

I eat here quite often because it is convenient. The food is nothing special but good enough. I…read morehave always had good service as well. Everyone that works there are always friendly. I have had issues with the take out though. They always give you the incorrect time to arrive. It drives me crazy when I get to a place early to pick up my food and it is already ready and sitting there getting cold. This happens here a lot. So if you are getting take be sure to get there early.

Absolutely the best ever. The food and the staff are top of the line..We have never gotten an…read moreunsatisfactory meal..

Otto

4.0

(195 reviews)

We have been patronizing Ottos Pizza of Chester for at least 10 years regularly different times of…read morethe week or weekend and we've never been disappointed with the food or the atmosphere or the service great place

Dog friendly (outdoors) pizza restaurant right in the heart of Chester!…read more We started off with a rose cider and a spicy margarita. Unfortunately I was not impressed with the drinks We ordered a hot honey pepperoni pizza and the pizza was great! Although it took a bit to come out on a busy Labor Day Monday, it made for a great chat session under the tent

Capotorto's Apizza Center

3.5

(79 reviews)

•$

I absolutely love this little piece of East Haven. It absolutely represents East Haven and…read moreeverything that makes it great. It has amazing Italian food, a sweet dessert section and hot chicken wings. The young employees there fit the culture perfectly. They are young, caring and nice. I have eaten here even though I typically take out. They have three little tables to eat at and a cute outdoor section to eat at.

Last night my kids came in from North Carolina and all they could talk about always when coming to…read moreConnecticut is Capotorto's Pizza. Their flight was delayed and when we went to call Capotorto's. We were four minutes over the 8:40 pm cut off. Speaking with the kind gentlemen, letting him know that all my kids have been asking for is Capotorto's. He said come on in. I was so appreciative that he stayed a little later. Satisfied my children's cravings and let us have a wonderful night together. Thank you. Capotorto's. Your pizza rate BEST!!!

Naples Restaurant & Pizza

3.9

(62 reviews)

Had the pizza truck out for my wife's 50th celebration. JP and Danielle were amazing. They put…read moreout great pies, took requests, delicious desserts and did it all with humor and a smile. Use them for your get together, you won't be disappointed.

They have slices! Delicious sauce, cheese; crust was thin and crunchy, perfect. Order at counter…read more Friendly service. Clean little hole in the wall in a strip center next to the grocery.

Westbrook Pizza

4.2

(71 reviews)

Good pie. Good price m. Good price and location. Did not have a lot of time for lunch. Needed a…read morequick fix.

Last order was good. I questioned the price but the salad was loaded with chicken and cheese and I…read moreordered a steak grinder so it was fair. I still don't like being forced to tip for take out and pay more for using a card, but is what it is. Only thing I'd ask is that if they're gonna start making pepper steak they say so. My steak grinder was very peppery and I like black pepper, but go easy unless customer requests it please!

Moravela's Pizzeria

4.1

(50 reviews)