Very nice selection, especially for Utica, but also very expensive. I have always found Peter to be quite rude and condescending. I don't think the staff is all that knowledgeable or helpful either. I wish I could award zero stars. I shop at Peter's when there's a great sale or I can't find what I need elsewhere in Utica. I like to shop local, but the people at Peter's often make it an unpleasant experience. read more

I love this place and the fact that it also serves healthy food, juice, and smoothies. The only downfall is that I wish they have nutritional info. On the smoothies and meals. read more

Peter's Cornucopia - Acai bowl - Health Markets Near Me - New Hartford, New York

Absolutely love this place! Need any kind of supplement, herb, health food .. you can find it here 99% of the time. Taking one star off because it is alittle more expensive then other stores. The staff is usually helpful as well. They have a cafe that has yummy healthy , delicious food made up of mostly soups, salads, sandwiches& smoothies. Usually made up of local ingredients as well. Fresh goodness! -unfortunately the hours are limited from what I've experienced & every time I go there the cafe is closed! :( Their kombucha on tap is my fav& you can bring back your jug to refill. read more

Went there for breakfast. Sat at the counter. Had the BLT. Delicious! Very casual place with an interesting market. Very pleasant staff. Friend had the avocado toast. Nicely done with no skimping. Loved it. read more

They get 5 stars solely based on their seasoned sour cream! It was sooo good!! Stopped in for lunch and it was pretty busy, but we were able to get a table and ordered promptly. I had the cafe quesadilla with chicken. The portion was huge and probably enough to share between two people (I had food coma after...). The quesadilla came with plenty of salsa and seasoned sour cream. It would've been impossible for me to run out! Would definitely come back to have the quesadilla again or try their tomato and mozzarella salad or grilled cheese. Tons of great options - even for the pickiest eaters!! read more

Run-down looking shopping center, but inside this store I found a treasure. Tons of selection & good prices. The restaurant was excellent. Nice people too. read more

A SHINING DIAMOND Peter's Cornucopia saved us while on tour. It's basically the only spot between Boston and Buffalo that is good, fresh, vegan and GF friendly, and soooo good. We had kombucha, BLT, soup, cookies, we really ran the gamut. Would come back here everyday if I could. Love u peteys. read more

Delightful cafe/bistro inside a healthfood store; counter service is fun and excellent, food is fantastic: had Picasso wrap and sala an coffee for only $11 and loved it! You can socialize at the bar or enjoy a quiet table or take your food to go. Everything is fresh and cooked to order, so there may be a small wait but it is well worth it. No heat lamps here! Whole kitchen is in plain view and is immaculate and a delight to observe in action. Oh, I realized that my review is for the cafe only. There is a whole grocer here as well. read more

This place is clean, bright, well-stocked, and the cafe food is fabulous! Had the vegan blt and a chai smoothie which both rocked! I just wish I lived closer. Definitely a vegan's dream! read more

Peter's Cornucopia - Vegan BLT. - Health Markets Near Me - New Hartford, New York

I love Peters Cornucopia. It's a tad expensive but the food is great. At the lunch rush, they can be a little slow but if you are willing to wait, the food is delicious. They make excellent sandwiches, salads, and smoothies. It is also the only place I know in the area that has acai bowls. read more

Peter's Cornucopia - a grilled cheese sandwich and salad - Health Markets Near Me - New Hartford, New York

Bring back the chicken dinner sandwich! It's an amazing mouthwatering creation that I would give 10 stars if I could. Why would you take it off the menu? Cafe here got very boring with menu changes. I'm posting this because I'm actually begging you to bring it back lol. read more

Thank goodness for at least one store in the Utica area like this. I really like this store, however prices can be a bit too high for certain products. They tend not to have what I am looking for, but always offer to order it. Would like it better if they stocked more items/variety. The cafe is great, however I was shocked when I ordered a cup of soup that was WAY to expensive ~$4 for the portion size. It's soup, it shouldn't cost this much or they could be a lot more generous with the portions size - Yikes! I also would love to see them expand the menu or have specials! Other than that I really like the cafe and store! read more

Really amazing natural food selection. The cafe here is also really great. Nice staff. And their almond butter is really amazing!!

I love this place. Whenever I visit family in Utica, NY, Peter's is a must visit for me. I am very health conscious and I can always find what I need here. I go there for health supplements, nuts, cereals, etc. The employees are knowledgeable and friendly. Try it...I guarantee you will love it. read more

Excellent store and cafe but do not order baskets!!!!! Ordered basket for a friend and didn't deliver at said time then blamed the recipient for not being home and left rude messages! Then canceled the order. Great place but do not order a basket to be delivered! read more

This place is AHMAZING!!!! The smoothie, the omelet, the pancakes, the coffee, all excellent! I am so thrilled I found this place! Very accommodating to our dietary needs! read more

First, the cafe. As others have said, the food is meh. And overpriced. I assumed the food and drinks were organic ( after all, the veggies in the store are) but no it is not. They only tell you its not organic if you Ask. My mistake. Pricey for ordinary shakes and food. Tabuli is way off. Much better in the area. The store. Pretty good selection, but staff are not that knowledgable, and not helpful. I get better selection of produce and refrigerated products at hannaford s, and they seem to be getting more every day. read more

I went in to buy my monthly supply of Bone Meal as I make my own dog food. There wasn't any which has not been a problem in two years. I buy it ever month. It is $4.50 more expensive than buying it online. Okay, but it is buying local and when I go I usually spend a minimum of $40.00 and often much more. I asked the cashier, she looked, and she went and asked Peter and came back and said no one buys it and he wasn't going to order it anymore. There were 5 rows of the other bone supplement (not the same as bone meal). I politely asked if I could speak to Peter. I walked back and he was eating lunch and I politely asked if he would order more. He was petulant and rude and insisted that no one bought it basically telling me I didn't know what I was talking about and that he did the ordering. I told him that I just drove 30 miles one way to buy it and I do so once a month. He then offered to order it but his tone was so disheartening and nasty I told him I would get from Amazon. He said good. I also told him I would no longer shop there. He said good. I suppose he was in a bad mood but I have been shopping in his store for over 20 years. I am very disappointed that he would treat a long time customer like this. read more

This cafe is a tad expensive but you are getting a quality meal. The lunch spot is attached to the best health food store in the area. Everyone who works there is extremely knowledgeable and if they don't know the answer they will find it for you. read more

Great smoothies! Try the strawberry/banana with a shot if whey. Love their balsamic vinaigrette over chicken breast/salad.

Excellent selection of health foods and local goodies. Cafe has great sandwiches, smoothies, fresh baked goods and breakfast. The baked goods especially, are delicious. Mocha chocolate chip muffins and the crumbley cinnamon blueberry muffins are amazing. Decently priced food at the cafe, though some grocery items can be a little pricey. Well worth a regular visit. read more

Peters is awesome! Healthy organic food and product choices. Everything you can imagine. They also have a small cafe inside. I found my favorite organic cold brew coffee there, bottled tazo teas, and Arctic zone lactose free ice cream. read more

The prices are a bit high but this is a good place for organic products. We found some nice unscented products and tried the smoothies. The Chai and Mixed Berry- both were delicious. I thought the cafe area could be a little bit cleaner, there was garbage on the floor and on the tables, probably left over from the lunch crowd. Too bad the plaza is out dated, it might impact ability to draw in customers. Given that there aren't many places like this in the area, we would likely return. read more

Peter's Cornucopia - Gluten free options - Health Markets Near Me - New Hartford, New York

See all

THE CAFE: I come here for lunch, but wish it was open later. The food isn't necessarily amazing, but the selection is good and the cafe's staff is friendly. Try the cafe!!! THE STORE: The staff didn't even make eye contact with me... and weren't knowledgeable about what was on the shelves. Furthermore, the shelves looked bare and the merch needed to be front & faced. I also get some cookies from here, but the last batch of the flax-zucchini-blueberry-granola tasted different and were't as soft as they usually are. read more

I've been to Peter's many times over the years, but today was the first time I've had lunch at the cafe. It was wonderful! Brought my two children, 9 and 12 years old, and the selection of sandwiches and salads was plentiful, and everything sounded delicious. My son got the Greek salad and the tzatziki dressing was amazing (my son said that that alone would make him want to eat there again!). I split a roasted vegetable ciabatta sandwich with my daughter---I wished I had gotten a whole one because it was that good! She also had a cup of the vegetable beef and barley soup---also a big hit! We watched many people order smoothies of all kinds and special coffee drinks that I'd like to try the next time. I highly recommend this cafe for anyone, especially those who enjoy real food! read more

Hugely amazing selection of vegan food! It's great for any kind of herbal pill you are looking for. The owners is extremely knowledgeable and helpful when it comes to herbals. Also, the eat-in restaurant is vegan- and vegetarian-friendly. Everything is a bit pricey, but you can get anything your healthy body desires. read more

Okay let me just sum this place up in one word, AMAZING. So many options to choose from and every single choice is delicious! They even have vegan options. The smoothies here are also so good. Whenever I come here, I choose a new smoothie to try. I have tried a lot of the sandwiches and wraps here and they are all good but my favorite is the tuna sandwich. It is LOADED with tuna, lettuce, onion, and tomato. Every time I eat here, I'm full for days. The side options are great as well, I always get the sliced pineapple. read more

Huge selection of health products and food. Also has a cafe that serves full meals along with coffee, tea and smoothies. Great ambiance and staff. If you like to live heathy (even only a little), this is your place! read more

The food is consistently amazing and fresh! I've never been disappointed! Love this place :)

Best place in the area for healthier options & it's a small business, which makes it all the better! Without runs to Syracuse, I can usually find what I'm looking for at Peter's. Sure, things may be a tad more expensive then, say, Wegman's, but we work with what we have and everyone at Peter's is very knowledgeable, whether you have a question in the store or at the cafe counter. read more