Our experience with PennyMac during a loan assumption and home sale was nothing short of a disaster. The official closing date was July 14, 2025, yet over 60 days later, the loan had still not been finalized. Both we--the sellers--and the buyers had submitted all necessary documentation, but PennyMac repeatedly requested irrelevant or redundant information, such as monthly HOA statements (which did not apply) and the name of our realtor, which was clearly listed in the contract.
They insisted a checkbox be marked regarding agricultural property, despite the prior question already confirming the property was not agricultural. Their refusal to accommodate an earlier closing date added further unnecessary delays and stress.
On the official closing day, July 14 at 10:00 a.m., matters deteriorated further. The buyer was mistakenly charged our full July mortgage payment, when they should have only been charged for 17 days. We were unable to reach anyone at PennyMac by phone to correct the error in the closing documents. Eventually, we spoke with the processor, Nicole Mingle, who escalated the issue to her manager and submitted the correct prorations (14 days for the seller, 17 days for the buyer). Nevertheless, the underwriting/closing department still processed the information incorrectly.
As a result, no funds were disbursed on closing day, leaving two families--including one with small children--caught in limbo. Even on July 15, although the closing attorney received updated documents at 7:15 a.m., PennyMac had still not provided approval by mid-afternoon.
By July 17, a new mortgage statement was issued showing we owed two months of payments--even though the July payment had already been accounted for in the Final Closing Disclosure. Our loan remained unpaid, the agents had not received their commissions, and the buyer's refund had not been released.
My husband and I are both veterans, and we are extremely disappointed by the way this loan assumption has been mishandled. On July 22, I spoke with a representative named Frank and explained the situation again. Despite his efforts to escalate the issue, PennyMac still had not released the final Closing Disclosure. Frank attempted to contact a manager in the closing department but received no response. I asked to speak directly with a manager, as this situation is urgent and serious--this assumption loan has yet to close, and our original mortgage remains unpaid as the end of the month approaches. Frank told me the assumption supervisor, Brittany Blankenship, would call me back once she was off another call. So now, once again, we wait.
This entire ordeal has caused undue stress and disruption to our family, and it is unacceptable. The level of mismanagement, delay, and lack of communication we've experienced is unacceptable for any mortgage company--especially one responsible for legal financial transactions that directly impact families' housing and financial stability.
If I could give this company loan processing side negative stars I would.We strongly caution anyone considering PennyMac for loan servicing or assumption processing. read more