My husband and I went for an early New Years dinner yesterday. Our server Gabe was outstanding !…read more He navigated us through the menu as we had not eaten there before. Gabe helped my husband with beer choices and had great suggestions for my cocktails. The food was delicious and the atmosphere very pleasant. We even had a visit to our table from the general manager. She was friendly and engaging. It was an enjoyable time all the way. We will definitely be going back My husband also found a whiskey he liked and purchased that too. It was a very positive way to end 2025. And no one paid me for this review . I'm writing this on behalf of my husband and me because having super food and super service needs to be recognized

Great brunch! Our server, Savanna was outstanding. Attentive and personable! Nice laid back…read moreatmosphere.

Great for takeout Or grab food at the table but I suggest…read moreyou call ahead and get the order started before you arrive

I like this little place. The bread they use for the sandwiches is really good. I got a special A…read more I do think it would be better to buy the bigger balls of mozzarella though and slice it. The flavor comes out better than in using the ciliegine mozz. Meatballs and marinara sauce were good. Mini cannoli was fine. Really nice owners. I thought about that bread all week and had to return. The chicken parm sandwich is really good. The tiramisu tastes like a nice cream cake but is light on the coffee flavor, fyi. I have also tried the #12 sub, the chicken alfredo, the brownie, the bread, and the salad. Salad is fresh and I love the homemade ranch and balsamic dressings. I came here once not too long ago and have not stopped thinking about it since, so I keep coming back.

Michelle wasn't our server today but we were able to catch up. She's an awesome lady…read more Of course we had the baked goat cheese and cheese pizza. Both on point. The Sugar Cookie Martini was delicious. Solid tavern style pizza and always good service.

I stopped in recently for pizza, a Hawaiin and Margherita. It was good, thin crust. Not my favorite…read moretype of pizza, but it was different. The pasta was just ok. My friend did not like it at all. Meatballs were not good. Vodka sauce was ok but thin. The side of marinara was just ok for me. Ranch was good. Service is friendly. They carry Sprecher's root beer. I stopped in a while ago for dessert but did not care for it. Tiramisu was off tasting. Cannoli had cold shell and cream was not anything special. Would skip dessert next time.

Stop 50 is a cute little family-owned and operated pizza within the neighborhood. It's tucked away…read moreon a residential side street, and with that comes a much calmer and chill atmosphere than Michigan City or New Buffalo. There is patio seating outside on the deck, and plenty of seats inside that can accommodate small groups. Everything is hand made and cooked within a wood-fired oven, so have some patience if you place a large order (or one is ahead of yours). They also do carry out as seen from the bustling pick up counter. They also carry a limited selection of craft beers and wine. Food was delicious and our server was awesome and helpful with the menu as first timers. Will certainly be back to this hidden little gem!

Pizzas are great. Love the wood fire My wife had a salad…read moreand it was on point. Will be back

Wowww wow wow! I…read morewasnt sure what to expect when my friend suggested this place but I was thoroughly and pleasantly surprised. The "Detroit style" pizza really reminds me more of focaccia bread. It is SO fluffy and delightful. Unpopular opinion here but I typically don't consider pizza to be a "meal." It's something you eat when you don't have it in you to cook, and even if you get it in Chicago it's like...a last ditch effort at feeding yourself. BUT this feels like a meal. Like a treat. Like a schmancy lil indulgence you deserve. My friend is gluten free and I never in a million years would guess this is gluten free. I almost hope they didn't mistakenly put it on regular dough, for my friends sake. But if this is legitimately gluten free, I would gladly get it again even if I wasn't with a gluten intolerant friend. The artichoke pieces are massive, tender and tangy. The sausage is a bit strange, ground sausage instead of little lumps. And the mushrooms really top the "artesenal" feel. There's a cute little market with interesting delicacies and they have an incredibly diverse assortment of non-alcoholic beverages. The clerk did an amazing job of describing many of the options, took a lot of time making sure we knew what we were looking at. Definitely a connoisseur. Fabulous. A little pricey but, again, this is an indulgence. A meal. A quaint opportunity to relax and engulf yourself in fluffy, delectable fare that feels authentic and real. Not just ingredients tossed on a piece of dough for convenience sake. I look for to my next visit here!

This place is a real gem! I was shocked to find somewhere this good in small-town Michigan. I made…read moremy parents come here from Indiana and we're so glad we did. They've got a great selection of pizzas in several styles. We tried both the thin-crust Roman style and the thicker al taglio. Both were good but the al taglio was fantastic! The crust was the best part, for sure. We got vegan pizzas (with really good vegan cheese!), but they've got a ton of dairy/meat options as well. It's nice to go somewhere that can serve everyone! There's also a really good little market of Italian products and wines, so you can do a little shopping too while you're here. I didn't have a sandwich but they've looked really good too. There's a nice dog-friendly outdoor patio as well for warm days. Emma Hearth and Market is a must-visit if you're in the area and worth a drive too!

Food is OK, but service and attitude from staff and management are horrible. Seems to have a…read moreclientele that is part of some kind of a clique or cult.

We tried this for the first time last night. Exceptionally friendly staff makes you feel welcome…read more And the service was perfect. Being a vegetarian, I opted for Eggplant Parmesan and my husband had manicotti. All dishes appear to be homemade and the gravy (sauce) is very tasty. I also enjoyed a cannoli for dessert. My husband had the cheesecake but it was a small slice. The restaurant interior gives a homey feel and is able to accommodate large families. Great value for the price. We will be back.

Love the updated reno at Brewsters! The ambiance is much brighter in the atrium and the new…read morefurniture is comfy. The food is always delicious and the homemade sauces, dressings and baked goods are greatly appreciated! Although we noticed the portion sizes are slightly smaller, our meals were outstanding and the service was great. Parking can be challenging; however, they do have a small parking lot and there is street parking in the neighborhood. A beautiful outdoor patio with vines and flowers is a perfect spot for lovely weather days and Brewster's is great for families, lunch/dinner with friends or date night!

This was just about as perfect an experience as it gets…read more We were in town for a Paul McCartney concert in Chicago and had opted to stay in new Buffalo to have a slightly less expensive room for the night as well as avoiding Chicagoland traffic in the morning. We had not counted on finding such a wonderful restaurant as part of the experience. To begin with the restaurant space is gorgeous. We arrived to find beautiful lighting, and various rooms dressed up with Christmas trees. This space was clearly something else in its former life, perhaps a home? Our waitress Melissa was an absolute sweetheart. She made a point of checking with us several times throughout the meal, and was Delightful to talk to. Our meal was magnificent. I went with their signature Bolognese, and it was absolutely perfect. Heaping amounts of sauce with generous amounts of meat, and perfectly cooked pasta. I was so pleased I almost licked the bowl. Dessert was a must and I went with their sticky toffee pudding. This was another triumph, wonderful toffee bits and soft finish. Frankly I'm a little sad that this place is so far away from where I live, or I would be inclined to come back just to have dinner.

Romas Pizza nailed it. Fresh ingredients, amazing homemade meatballs, and super friendly staff…read more Can't wait to come back!

Man its been a couple years since I've been there, but what happened???????? No servers, ordering…read moreat a counter, getting your own drinks...paper plates and silverware?? Now let's talk about the pizza....it used to have flavor...and you can definitely tell they have downgraded ingredients...no wonder why it wad completely empty and the phones werent ringing anymore. This place went from great to the ghetto.

Pizza was recommended by a patron at the Blue Chip Casino. They deliver right to your room. Arrived…read moreluke warm. We had gotten thin crust with sausage, pepperoni, bacon and mushrooms. The crust was not thin and crisp. Half of the pizza was overcooked. There was plenty of sauce. Plenty of pepperoni. Lots of mushroom. Very little sausage and bacon. Not a bad pizza, but not great either. Wouldn't bother ordering again. Maybe would try a pasta or something different.

I have been a long time resident in Michigan City but had never ordered from them before. I was…read morepleasantly surprised by an excellent, vegetarian pizza. Their phone service was good and delivery on time with an elderly, sweet man. The only complaint I have is their french fries. I got a decent amount, but it was tasteless. They need to put some kind of seasoning on it. I still think Rally's has the best, but have stopped eating theirs, because it has way too much salt and grease. I have to watch blood pressure.