Service: 5 Placing order/inquiry was pretty easy. She is very responsive and handles short notice orders. I was looking for a cake less than a week from pick up. Sent in order/inquiry via email and she was able to communicate effectively all the details that needed to be addressed in the span of a few days. Cake quality: 4.5/5 I originally chose s'mores and guava but because I wasn't sure if two layers would be too much for 2 people serving, I decided with 1 layer and 1 flavor. S'mores flavor was a marshmallow delight, which included a marshmallows buttercream for frosting, chocolate flavor cake, and marshmallows and graham cracker center. I loved that the frosting and cake were not overly sweet but felt that there could've been a bit more graham cracker. Overall: would highly recommend! If you are looking for a fast turn around time, and solid in quality flavor and design, please consider paperrock fork bakery! Also, Cheers to Elmeisher--She really cares and aims to make every cake wonderful and her best work yet. Can't wait to try her bakery again :) read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - 2 layer 5 inch cake - S'mores Flavor with character design & happy birthday message - Desserts Near Me

See all

I ordered a cupcake pull apart Dinosaur cake for my sons 2nd birthday! I sent a dinosaur image I got from Google and asked if they could add a party had with his age on it. I honestly wasn't expecting it to turn out this good but wow! The artwork with the buttercream nailed the original image. Flavors: I opted for 4 flavors cookies n' cream, funfetti, Vanilla strawberry filling and chocolate! The chocolate cupcake with the chocolate filling were to die for. Super rich! Will surely be ordering from this place again! read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - Dino cupcake pull apart cake - Desserts Near Me

See all

I cannot seem to give Paper Rock Fork enough stars! I am now a 3 time return customer and am so impressed with the cupcake number cake we ordered for my youngest son's third birthday. Elmeisha is incredibly responsive, talented and easy to work with. I highly recommend her for any of your cake/cupcake needs! read more

See all

Brought my girlfriend a chocolate chocolate cupcake or muffin. I can't remember which it was, all I know is that my girlfriend (who loves chocolate) said it was the best one she had ever had. I got literal brownie points for that one! read more

I contacted Elmeisha about 3-4 weeks prior to my son's bday to order a cake. I was worried this was too late since apparently other bakeries are booked up but I emailed a few places and gave paper rock fork a shot. Honestly I was skeptical just because there weren't enough reviews or picture as I'm used to, buuuuut Elmeisha did such a great job I knew I had to contribute to her business in case others thought the same. She was very prompt and thorough in her replies. I always have so many questions and she replies line by line. Let's start with her website, wow so organized, I love that there were so many options and the prices is all there so I don't have to ask her for every little thing. I'm sure that saves her lots of time too. But more importantly, the flavors! So many to choose from I really can't wait to re order to get some new flavors. I sent her a few inspirational photos and told her to decorate as she wish as long as I had my main centerpiece topper. She really came through! I made my own decorations and it matched completely! Everyone loved how it looked and how it tasted. The fact that I had just a small slice to bring home was a sign it was a hit. It was a moist chocolate cake with real strawberry filling. My favorite was that the buttercream wasn't heavy nor sweet. It went really well with the cake. She had eggless and vegan options which I also picked out for the cupcakes (with added fees). I got mini cupcakes because it allowed people to try different flavors without being overwhelming. I am so glad I got them. She went above and beyond with the decorations. I didn't expect it to be so decked out and I loved it! Now the buttercream on here is a bit sweet but it's probably the ratio of cream to cupcake. I couldn't even tell the vegan cupcake was vegan. I got it in pineapple coconut flavor and will definitely re order these. Overall, I am very happy and will be a returning customer. read more

See all

I ordered a Vegan Apple Tart for Thanksgiving. Elmeisha was wonderful to work with...responded so quickly. The tart was as delicious as it was beautiful. So happy to have found her...delicious vegan baked goods are not easy to come by! read more

10/10 Amazing customer service from the owner. She was so kind and understanding and helped me get my dream cake. I havent had a birthday cake in over 10 years and seeing this when she presented it to me brought me to tears. It was so delicious and I enjoyed it with my family and friends. Definitely recommend this business and will be coming back maybe just for fun :) read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - my cake!! - Desserts Near Me

Meisha is a fantastic baker. Reached out for a custom order and she was more than happy to help out. Come to find out she's also a TMNT fan so she did a fantastic job with the cookie cake. It was so delicious and everyone was super impressed. Bonus: she has an awesome personality! read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - Cookie cake - Desserts Near Me

Love the cakes, cookies and all kinds of goodies I've ever ordered from Meisha, the pastry chef/owner of Paper Rock Fork. She made my son's 8th birthday cake, which he absolutely loved! It was so cute, delicious and reasonably priced and planning/ordering was seamless. I've ordered random things like banana chocolate walnut bread and chocolate pecan pie and Meisha always makes it happen! She takes the time to listen to what you want and throws in ideas of her own if you're not sure which route to go. Her seasonal goodie boxes are a must! She makes different desserts/pastries for Halloween, Christmas, etc. I'll remain a repeat customer for sure! read more

Great communication and wonderful to work with. The birthday cake that I ordered for my son's birthday came out beautifully.

I hired them to prepare a dessert bar for my daughter's recent wedding. Elmeisha, the owner, was wonderful to work with. She made it clear from the beginning that her goal was to give the couple just what they wanted. She prepared samples for us and tweaked the recipes to our specific requests. About 6 weeks before the wedding, the bride and groom decided to add a cake. Elmeisha was so accommodating. The day of, she came to the venue and set up everything. It looked beautiful and it was all delicious! We had brownies, lemon bars, raspberry bars, rice krispy treats, and chocolate chip and snickerdoodle cookies. The cake was amazing, as well. Prices were extremely reasonable and Elmeisha was a delight to work with. I highly recommend her to anyone planning an event and will definitely use her in the future! read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - a three tiered wedding cake - Desserts Near Me

See all

I'm so glad to have found Paper Rock Fork Bakery. I contacted Elmeisha with only 1 week notice as the usually cake vendor I go to had a big wedding event and wasn't able to do my order. Elmeisha was able to accommodate my request. My kid has an egg allergy so it's usually quite hard for us to get cake that's eggless, but not necessarily vegan (we still want the butter, lol). She also delivered on the design aspect. I let her know my kid is into Roblox or Minecraft and she sent me pictures of samples and had me choose. It turned out great and all the kids at the birthday party were ogling at the cake design. Paper Rock Fork Bakery will definitely be my new go to cake vendor! read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - Square cake. Minecraft design. Triple chocolate flavor. - Desserts Near Me

Meisha was great to work with. She was very accommodating and patient to all my requests for my daughter's Red Egg and Ginger cake - Meyer Lemon Buttermilk flavor. read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - Red Egg and Ginger Cake - Meyer Lemon Buttermilk Flavor - Desserts Near Me

See all

I had a last-minute need for a custom cake and so glad I contacted Meisha. She was wonderful from the beginning of our conversation. Meisha was willing to accommodate me and gave me some great options/ideas to make my cake vision come to life. She provided excellent customer service and made a very delicious and beautiful cake. I highly recommend Meisha / Paper Rock Fork! read more

Paper Rock Fork Bakery - decorated cake - Desserts Near Me

Elmeisha is amazing! She accommodated my custom cookies request with less than a week's notice and was very responsive and easy to work with. The cookies came out better than I could have imagined! And the size of the cookies are much bigger than I expected. She also made the pick up very convenient. I will definitely order from her again and again! read more

Meisha is amazing to work with! She was preparing the dessert bar for my daughter and son-in-law's wedding. They had planning on having a variety of baked items, and decided to add a wedding cake just a few weeks before the wedding. Meisha was so accommodating. She baked, decorated and delivered a beautiful cake, along with custom desserts that were delicious. All were set up in a stunning display. She made sure that every item was exactly as the bridge and groom liked it. I would HIGHLY recommend her for any occasion! read more

See all

I just had the most amazing Pecan Pie that Meisha made for her Thanksgiving customers. I've tried pecan pie before at other places and they were always too sweet and sticky.... so I gave up on it. Then I was presented with a pecan pie from Paper Rock Fork Bakery and wowza..... it's buttery, soft, nutty, just enough sweet but not too sweet, melt-in-your mouth goodness. I'm sold!! Now I'm waiting for what she has up her sleeve for Christmas goodies! I'll definitely be back for Thanksgiving next year. read more

There was never a question of who was going to do my child's graduation cake. Elmeisha took my undeveloped idea of a half and half high school college cake and elevated it. This looks better than any inspiration photos I found online. And she really cares about making something unique and wonderful that the honored person will love. This time we chose chocolate and it was PHENOMENAL - she's not just a talented decorator, she's an equally talented baker. It was moist and rich without being overly sweet. Everyone was incredibly impressed. I wish I knew about Paper Rock years ago - I cannot rave about her enough. read more

See all

Yes to the cupcakes, cookies, and marshmallows. I was grateful for Elmeisha for making these yummy treats for my baby's 1st birthday. Will be back again. read more

I've used Paper Rock Fork several times over the years for my boys birthdays and it's always been amazing! Meisha goes above and beyond to decorate the cake to what the boys would like. We got a Spider-Man birthday cake for my son this past weekend and he absolutely loved it! She also included cupcakes (which wouldn't get the birthday boys breath on) due to covid- which I didn't even think about! Can't say enough good things! Wish I would have taken a picture! read more

Reached out with a one week notice for a custom two layer, 6 inch cake. Not only was she able to get it done with a short notice, but she was also able to accommodate with a specific flavor request and custom decoration. Additionally she even provided feedback on suggestions for decorations and color to bring my cake idea to life. Would 100% recommend! read more

I ordered holiday cookie boxes from Meisha last year and they were gorgeous and delicious! So impressed and they made fabulous gifts. I can't wait to order more treats for family celebrations. read more

Absolutely incredible! I reached out on short notice and not only was Elmeisha willing to do it, she went above and beyond to make it perfect! i asked for a cat cake for my feline-loving 2yo's birthday and she DELIVERED! Even put his name on and age on the collar- such a cute touch! Also, the cake was delicious! Thank you so much!!!! 10/10 will use again read more

If your ever looking for an amazing cake.. look no further. Meisha was wonderful she took the time to make sure our cake was exactly what we wanted. The cake was beautiful and more importantly it was delicious. Can't wait to place my next order! read more