Cancel

Open app

Search

Papa Johns Pizza

2.0 (2 reviews)
Closed • 10:00 am - 8:40 pm

Order Papa Johns Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Papa Johns Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Papa Johns Pizza

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 774 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Heath Springs Pizzeria

Heath Springs Pizzeria

4.6(50 reviews)
15.0 mi
•$$

Everything was good down too the servers. I would definitely recommend this place if you are…read morelooking for something quick, hot and affordable.

First time for us at this new, within a year, business for Lancaster. Good to see growth like…read morethis. The present owner is the founder of Heath Springs Pizza in Heath Springs, SC. He did very well so he expanded into the main street of Lancaster to repeat his pizza operation. It was crowded when we went in at around 7pm. Interesting menu with usual appetizers and salads but with a few new items. The Wedge is basically half of a 9" pizza folded over all sorts of fillings and then cut into three slices or "wedges". Cute idea...different. Wife and I split a small chef salad ($7.99) which was more than enough for two of us. Had Italian dressing and it was a packet of creamy Italian, which was OK. Ordering pizza is either pick from their suggestions, of which there are plenty, or create your own, or...any combination that works for you. They have Chicago pizza, and for those of you that are not familiar, this is a deep dish pie, thick with crust and cheese. It is almost 2 inches high. Crust Types: Hand-tossed, Thin' N Crispy, The Edge, Gluten Free Cauliflower, crustless (!), or create your own. This includes a base pizza, pizza sauce, cheese and your first topping. Each additional topping is charged based on pizza size. Sizes are: 9" Personal $8.99, 12" Medium $10.99, 14" Large $12.99. 16" X-Large $14.99. We ordered a thin crust, crispy crust, medium size Little Italian pie ($14.99). It did not jibe with their pricing, but we were not to quibble about it. It took almost 30 minutes to arrive, but then again, it was crowded. It was OK...not like you would expect. Our specifications with thin and crispy came out appearing like a frozen pizza from the grocery store. But it was flavorful and had a nice mix of the various ingredients. Next time we will go with a hand-tossed. Not fancy, with wood bench booths on both sides and small or large table combos in the center. And you are there with what appear to be very nice Americans, working class, with their children. Every one was having a good time and it was comforting be with a regular folks kinda place. On the south end of main street. You can even park in front on the street.

Photos
Heath Springs Pizzeria - Red Riding Hood small pizza

Red Riding Hood small pizza

Heath Springs Pizzeria
Heath Springs Pizzeria - Large pizza with half pepperoni and half mushroom

See all

Large pizza with half pepperoni and half mushroom

Off The Tracks Brewing

Off The Tracks Brewing

4.1(54 reviews)
13.7 mi
•$$

I really wanted to like this place because the atmosphere, decor, and overall look of the…read moreestablishment are great. Unfortunately, after several visits, the service and consistency have continued to be disappointing. The biggest issue is the customer service. At times, it feels like some of the bartenders are more interested in socializing with certain patrons than paying attention to everyone at the bar. Getting a refill or placing an additional order can be unnecessarily difficult. In my experience, Carly has been the most frustrating in this regard. Brandy often seems distracted and disconnected from what is happening around her, while Sara can come across as uninterested in engaging with customers. You may place an order, receive your beer, and then barely be acknowledged afterward. The food is also inconsistent, especially the pizza. We have ordered it multiple times and rarely know what to expect. One visit it may be overly greasy, another time overcooked or burnt. Consistency should be one of the basics of running a restaurant. I also believe personal political opinions should be kept separate from the workplace. Customers come in to relax, have something to eat or drink, and enjoy themselves--not to feel like they are being pulled into an employee's political views, regardless of which side those views fall on. What makes this especially disappointing is that the place itself has a lot of potential. The atmosphere is appealing, and with stronger management, more consistent food preparation, and employees who genuinely make every customer feel welcome and valued, this could be a great establishment. I hope the owner takes constructive criticism seriously and focuses on hiring, training, and retaining staff who understand that hospitality is about making every paying customer feel acknowledged and appreciated. Unfortunately, we have experienced similar issues at the other location nearby as well. There is a lot to like about the concept, but the service needs significant improvement.

At a brewery, EVERYTHING starts with the beer. We had the Cloudy Days hazy IPA and it did not…read moredisappoint! Swift, friendly service and an excellent atmosphere between this business and its neighbor Hobo's. Very kid and dog friendly with great outdoor space.

Photos
Off The Tracks Brewing
Off The Tracks Brewing - Hawaiian Pizza... can't see in the picture, but it was SATURATED with Balsamic Vinegar (WAY too much!)

Hawaiian Pizza... can't see in the picture, but it was SATURATED with Balsamic Vinegar (WAY too much!)

Off The Tracks Brewing

See all

Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...