It was a moment of weakness. We had sworn off this place two or three years ago. Should have stayed with that. Ordered the pizza well done. It was barely done. So we had to put it in the oven. Wanted jalapeños on one half and sausage on the other half. Got sausage on the whole thing and no jalapeños. The other ingredients -- pepperoni, onions and mushrooms -- were kind of there. Not especially plentiful or noticeable. Waste if money. Did not complain because they would have wanted to send us another pizza. We never want that again. I'll burn a $20 bill and feel better about it than having to try and eat that crap again. But if raw pizza with some of the toppings you ordered and very few of the ones they got right, then this is the place for you. read more

Horrible customer service refused to honor the papa pairing price after the online order didn't go through correctly. Ended up with a cheese stick and med pizza for $23 instead of two medium and a cheese stick. very rude. wouldn't even try and fix my issue. read more

They believed their diver instead of the customer...... long story short we went to Marcos because they just didn't show up with our pizza. We tried to get a refund they didn't give it to us because "there's nothing we can do". I called corporate customer service rep to put in a complaint and got my refund. read more

I ordered A cheese pizza and breadsticks and they gave me 2 orders of breadsticks and we tried talking to them about it but all they kept doing was making up excuses and hanging up on me, and being really disrespectful. Instead of them remaking the food they wanted to argue about it and make it seem like i was trying to get a free pizza. And the manager and staff was VERY rude and nasty. read more

Apparently Papa John's in Fairborn, Ohio doesn't value their customers, like the recording says. I received a 2-liter with a sticker that says; "We are a pizza store, not your grocery shoppers." I called the store in hopes of finding decent customer service and got hung up on by the Manager in charge, who also would not give me their name. read more

Ordered at 4:56. Called to check on order at 6:23. Two minutes later, driver knocked on our door with an order that had the wrong name and address on it so we refused delivery. Doordash called at 6:28 to blame us and Papa Johns for the incorrect order. (Clearly not the case since the delivery didn't even have our name or address on it.) We attempted to call PapaJohns and got placed on hold for over 30 minutes. We were in the car ready to drive to the store at almost 7pm when our call was finally answered. Manager offered to either refund our order or remake it - which would take another 2 hours. . . . . 4 hours for a pizza, no customer service, no food. I'll order from Dominos next time! read more

horrible service!! they said are pizza would be ready in 10-15 minutes. we came in to get our pizza and they then acted like "it's coming out right now" meanwhile they hadn't even made the pizza. an they acted like they were busy but there was nobody there but us. they served all the people who came after us even though we were there first. an then when they finally gave us our pizza, and the people in the back were snickering and laughing, like they had made us wait on purpose for no reason. their was 2 guys a chubby white male with glasses and a hat on. an another white skinny male. we got there at 8:20pm and they didn't end up giving us our pizza till 9pm. didn't even apologize for making us wait. instead they smiled and laughed. An everyone working there was white and we were black so might've also been racist. first time coming to this papa John's location will never be coming back to this location ever again!! horrible service defiantly would not recommend this location to anyone else! read more

Our food was fine. Fresh and hot but the store needed some cleaning. The lobby area looked like it needed swept and mopped. There also must be someone there feeding stray cats because there was 4 empty cans of friskies wet cat food sitting a couple feet from the front entrance. Kind of gross! read more

I don't know what it is about their bread sticks but I am absolutely in love with them. In my opinion the best pizza chain bread sticks hands down. With that being said, the pizza is pretty decent too. Not spectacular by any means but just plain good. They usually have decent coupons and promotions (if you sign up for e-mail you get a 20% off coupon). This particular has a fast and friendly staff, they always have their pizza ready for pick up when they say it will be. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairborn, Ohio

Inconsistent at best. Of five pickup orders recently two were not correct. This afternoon, after being notified on the app and by email my order was ready I went inside to pay and pick it up. I was informed it would be a few minutes. I asked why if I received notice it was ready. He replied the emails meant nothing and it would be a few minutes. After 15 minutes I asked how much longer and was told another few minutes. I asked for a refund as my order hadn't even been started yet. With the current COVID 19 pandemic I was very alarmed to see NO ONE wearing gloves. I will not be back. read more

Ordered online. When I got the email stating my order was in the works I noticed it was wrong. Called the store. Was told they couldn't change my order and give me the discounts that I got online. Was also told that my order was further screwed up at the store, the sizes were switched. Decided fine I will just deal with it. Got the pizza 25 minutes after the phone call and the vege pizza was under cooked. Considering the lack of effort on the managers part when I called in the initial mistake, I decided that I wouldn't waste my time calling them back to complain. read more

Ordered through app and it connected us with DoorDash. The order status was unclear on the app and the pizza was never delivered. DoorDash told me to contact the restaurant directly to get a refund. The manager I spoke to complained about the situation instead of helping us, and then he finally did say he would refund... except I haven't received a refund and it's been a month or so. read more

I called and placed an order for delivery. They thought it was for pick up. After an hour I called them and they said it was a mix up, they said I needed to talk to the manager. I told the manager I would like a fresh pizza instead of the one that had been sitting there. The manager got mad at me for asking politely for a fresh pizza and hung up the phone. I called back and ever who answered hung the phone on me also. I called back a third time and we finally got my reorder. Frankly, I was not rude to anyone. This was an awful experience. I am going to try to order from another pizza place from now on. The pizza was for my grandkids. I am elderly and this made me very sad, very sad to the point of crying. No one, should ever be treated that way, I don't care how bad your day has been. read more

I have ordered here for months I get free pizza pies all the time means nothing here the money u spend takes to next week to come always burnt and cold never the right order half the time this store fairborn oh should be closed down asap do not trust them with any of your food read more

Think twice. The pizza is overpriced and the service is mediocre considering they charge for sauces I never receive. It's too bad too because I am legitimately fearful of not receiving what I pay for, so I'm reluctant to purchase from here. The super bready crust is nothing without the cheese sauce but you'll be lucky to receive it if you order it. read more

I have had the worst service from this location. I ordered two pizzas a few weeks ago and the staff had no idea where my order went. After 45 minutes waiting in the lobby, I showed up 20 minutes after ordering, (I was quoted 20 minutes). I chalked it up to being busy and short staffed. I was given a free pizza coupon for my wait. Today I ordered two pizzas, one to used coupon. I arrived after 20 minutes (no quote this time) and waited 45 more minutes for my order. I counted 26 pizzas made along with sides that stayed in the warmer and never left the store. At least 10 other customers came and left with their orders while I waited. When I finally got my order I was offered a "free soda" as I left. The staff didn't didn't know what they were doing and continued to ask each other where food was supposed to go. Needless to say I will never return to this location. Beware when ordering! read more

my boyfriend and i thought ordering papa johns for college football night was a good idea. we thought wrong :/ we ordered a large pepperoni light cheese w extra pepperochinis, 10 piece chicken w buffalo and ranch sauce and cheese sticks. they forgot our pepperochinis... he put 1 extra and usually other papa johns give us hand fulls of pepperochinis but we only got 1, the standard. and we never got our buffalo sauce for the chicken. very disappointed. especially when you specifically wish for these extra items to have a good experience (the experience you wanted). guaranteed, I called back and asked for a refund because i really didn't want to wait for them to be delivered and our other food to be cold by the time it got here. they said they would do that for us so we thanked them and proceeded to try to enjoy our food. my boyfriend then complains that the light cheese is too light cheese and i agreed. it's very inconsistent between papa johns and i will not be ordering from this location ever again. read more

We order from here often and usually get good service, but not today. I placed an order to be delivered at 4:30 today, at 4:45 no food or phone call to say they would be late. I called the store only thing they said was it should be out for delivery, no reason why it was late. Food finally arrived at 4:50, why offer an option to have your food delivery at a certain time if you are not going to do it. read more

service was good but when we got the pizza we started to notice there was burnt cardboard on the pizza read more

Papa Johns Pizza - burnt cardboard??? - Pizza Near Me - Fairborn, Ohio

Love this place. But I am a bit biased since used to work here But really, it is my favorite pizza chain out there!

we waited 50 minutes for a carry out pizza...it was not with the wait. they wanted to charge us $7.00 to add a topping to the $10.00 price of the new pan pizza. I suggest Domino's. read more

This location has great customer service. We placed an order for delivery yesterday. It wasn't until my delivery driver left that I realized one of our pizzas was completely wrong. I called the store and the employee was very friendly and said they would send me out a new pizza. Within a half hour, the delivery driver was back with the replacement. Obviously, it's never fun to have to call about an issue but they handled it very well. On top of that, the quality of the food was delicious and fresh, and our delivery driver was very nice. Considering we've had some bad experiences with other pizza chains in Fairborn, this was a refreshing experience. read more