*** UPDATE / WARNING!!! *** We received a fraud notification shortly after entering card information on the website to order pizza, when someone tried to charge our card for $40K. DO NOT USE THE WEBSITE TO ORDER!
-----
We read a positive review somewhere by a real live New Jersian, so despite our misgivings, we stopped in. Take this review with a grain of salt since it's such a particular matter of preference -- but this pizza definitely was not for us as lovers of NYC-style pizza. Pan Pan is very, er, cheese forward -- as it in has a very thick layer of cheese, which was not in balance with the amount of tomato sauce or crust. The crust style was also not for us. Pan Pan has a very tender, low-gluten, thin crust, crackery at the edges, similar to the Elio's frozen pizza brand or the kind o school pizza I grew up eating. Although the thickness of the crust was fine, our family goes for a higher gluten, chewier texture.
Don't order on the website. It doesn't work. The restaurant claims its web developers added a feature for online orders that they didn't ask for and told us the amount would be refunded in a month or two (!!!!). Hopefully that happens!! In the end, we just placed another order in person, waited around for about half an hour for the pizza to be ready, and brought it home. read more