Amazing, friendly staff. I came in expecting a casual lunch with my cousin and left questioning why I hadn't eaten there sooner. First--the hot wings. By gawd, the flavor. Crispy outside, juicy inside, and that sauce? Pure perfection. One bite had me sweating like I was at a court date--but in the best way. Then the garlic knots. Calling them "knots" feels disrespectful--they were little clouds of buttery, garlicky joy. Soft, rich, and that garlic oil at the bottom... I definitely blacked out for a second and came back to an empty basket with zero regrets. The pizza? I'm from Long Island, so I'm picky--but it held its own. Crispy yet chewy crust, solid flavor. By the end, I was full, happy, and low-key considering proposing to the chef. This place isn't just a restaurant--it's an experience... and proof that carbs are always worth it. Go get you sum! read more

Pizza and boneless wings are excellent got 2 pieces of carrot cake a little to high on piece and the cashier was unsure of my question when asked bring home the pieces of carrot cake very dry and little taste don't recommended that cake but usually one of my favorite places read more

The service was quick and food was delicious!! Definitely will be back, we enjoyed everything we got read more

See all

Ordered veal parm tonight takeout. There was no cheese on the veal parm. Very little spaghetti tonight. Won't order again.

OIP was great! The staff was friendly and the restaurant was nice and clean. We got the chicken almonds salad which was large and had lots of toppings (almonds, fruit, chicken, etc). It was only about $12 and definitely enough for 2-4 people. We ordered the large pie with meatball topping. I was so pleasantly surprised at how delicious it was! Perfect amount of sauce and toppings. We will definitely return soon! read more

Original Italian Pizza - a salad in a styrofoam container - Italian Near Me - Sayre, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered wings from this place. They're sorta pricey for the amount of wings you get. The wings were okay. There was a bit of flavour in them but the blue cheese dip that they gave with it was more flavourful than the actual chicken wings. But it was decent tasting and I was full at the end. I am interested in trying out their other menu items or other flavours of chicken wings to see if it's the same results. read more

Original Italian Pizza - chicken wings and celery - Italian Near Me - Sayre, Pennsylvania

The pizza here was awesome and there was such a variety to choose from. Definitely one of my favorite pizza stops !!

Good food. Good service. $2.99 for a fountain drink with no free refills? Seriously? Unheard of. It's the little things that kill.

Well they charge a 3.00 delivery fee and they have high prices and when the delivery guy shows up they don't give you your change back. I got taken for a ride today I paid 30.00 for a large pizza. Just be warned the pizza takes over an hour to get deliverd 5min from the restaurant its bairly warm when you get it and you have to tip a generous amount and the delivery driver isn't even the one who cooked the pizza. read more

Have bought a lot of meals but just got a Chef Salad and some of the meat is spoiled called them up and they would not replace the salad after we spent 60.00 will not be going back again. read more

Sayre PA Original Italian Pizza location, dine in. I've consistently received good food, generally stuck to pizza, salad, bread and something with red sauce. The kitchen and waitstaff have been there a long time. Service is quick and there is a huge menu. Recently, like every other restaurant, prices have gone up. Plus cash is preferred but they accept most cards. Despite that, it continues to be my favorite local pizza place. read more

I figured I would get the nurses a nice treat for everything that they do, and this is what I received. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. It had an inch of liquid on top of it with everything running off one side of the pizza. The Cannolis were absolutely runny . This business should be absolutely embarrassed by what they serve . The place was closed by the time I realized this so I took the food that was not eaten the next day and the man at the counter wanted to be argumentative about me returning the disgusting food that they served the next day. He kept running his mouth about how he wasn't going to give my money back because it was the next day. I don't know how this place has been in business . Save yourself and your money. This place serves the worst pizza I have ever seen . They should be so embarrassed read more

See all

the bread was amazing but the service was really slow my waiter was not paying attention but it's good for the location

Gotta tell you guys; I'm not at all impressed. I'm staying at a hotel that Google maps is telling me is five minutes away from OIP . Girl at hotel desk recommended OIP so I gave them a call at 6:46 to order a salad and order of chicken wings from a mono-toned woman who didn't seem at all interested in dealing with me. 59 minutes later I got a call from a guy apologizing for the delay but the restaurant had gotten slammed on this Wednesday night, and that the driver was on his way.. 41 minutes later at 8:36, I got a call indicating that my food was in the lobby. While the food was good, apparently, whoever packed it (even though it was going to a hotel room) didn't see the need to include a fork or a napkin for the now room temperature food.. As a frequent business traveler who spends a lot of time here, I have to relay that there's really decent restaurants in this part of the world. Unfortunately, this doesn't seem to be one of them. Girl at desk watched this and tried to apologize for recommending them. Wasn't her fault. I felt bad that she felt that she had to assume responsibility. Not impressed. Chat Conversation End Type a message... read more

Pizza burger, chicken fingers and fries...average food , somewhat on the greasy side. This was delivered & I specifically requested catsup but did not receive. read more

I have had New York City Pizza. If you can't get to New York, you have to try this pizza. I love the thin crust, with x-tra cheese and tomatoes. Even their original pizza is amazing. By far the best pizza in the Valley. I visit once a week to take out 2 pieces of pizza. Keep up the great work!!!! read more

Great New York style pizza! Nothing fancy but delivery was quick and they also deliver beer.

The food here is consistently very good! The menu is mostly Italian, and the pizza is of course outstanding. It's also the cleanest restaurant I have ever been in, by far. read more

In town visiting my family, after a little league games with grandchildren came to celebrate. Seated 4 adults 4 very hungry children garlic knots are a super starter, had grilled chic salad, pizza, chic parm and meat ball sub. All food served timely and prepared great. Wait time for paying tab was a bit dragged but did little to spoil evening read more

This restaurant is great for always having great service and great food. Today they were out of what I wanted. The waitress was wanted with no problems while I chose something else. I highly recommend OIP. read more

A busy place in an old railway station. A good assortment of Italian dishes, salads and sandwiches. I've been in for lunch a few times and while the food doesn't blow me away, it's a welcome change from my bagged lunch on occaision. The atmosphere is nice-attractive yet simple, service is efficient and the food is decent. read more

This company lies! They advertise that they have char broiled grilled chicken wings, and they do not. I ordered these wings expecting them to be grilled and not fried because I have heart disease and I did not want to eat fried wings. They told me they were char grilled. When they arrived they were clearly fried. When I called to complain and ask for the manager he told me that they deep fry them then put them on the grill. I made it clear to him that that is deceptive advertising, and he said he didn't really care because that's what the owners want. Would not give me even a partial refund. What a scam! See their menu pictures and description. Clearly deceptive and sad! read more

Original Italian Pizza - the price of the menu - Italian Near Me - Sayre, Pennsylvania

See all

This place is more than just pizza. Has beer and wine, and really good pasta. Great service, clean and friendly staff, can't wait to come again!! read more

OIP is one of our family's go-to places for dinner. They have an extensive menu, reasonable prices, and good service. We are always satisfied when we go there. My favorite sandwich is the Garden Chicken Steak! read more

I just got charged 50 cents to have mayonnaise on my sub. I know it's not a lot, but 50 cents for mayonnaise. Come on! Parrish's Deli is a block away and never been charged for mayonnaise. I knew I should've went there instead. Better food. OIP just lost a customer. And I'm in sales at a local dealership. Lots of people ask me where is a good place to eat in the Valley. I'll give you one guess who I won't be suggesting. read more

I work nearby, in a busy department. We place huge orders often. Sometimes multiple times a day, and that's just one department in an enormous building with many big departments. Everything is always great, on time, always there, not usually short. If anything's not in order, we just let them know. Good tasting food, good pricing, good delivery times and personnel. Would Absolutely recommend to anyone looking for pizza in the Sayre Athens area! read more

This is a good place to eat money well spent if you want to eat good food go to oips. So stop and eat fill them bellys

My husband and I were in town shopping and stopped by. Everything was excellent . The waitress was attentive, the food hot and fresh and the prices were reasonable. We will definiately stop by again when in the area. read more

Excellent food, not so great service! I don't know what happened to the older sweet waitresses that were so attentive and kind, but these younger waitresses seem to have no idea what they're doing. We love getting their food when we visit town, but service will have us ordering out from now on. This has been several visits now that the service is not good. read more

TERRIBLE. Stayed at a hotel in Sayre, PA for Labor Day weekend 2014. Not many places to choose from when it came to food, but were given a menu for this place at our hotel. Ordered a Stromboli and chicken cheese steak for delivery to hotel. We were told it would be a 45 minute wait, which was ok considering it was a Saturday night. Food arrived over an hour later. Once we got back to our room with the food, we were disappointed there were no napkins, or silver wear in the bag.. Once we opened up our food, I was surprised to see beef instead of chicken on my sub. The food was wrapped it foil, but it was ice cold. So obviously it had to of been sitting for quite some time. Called the restaurant asked to speak with manager. Explained our order took longer than usual, given wrong food, and that we were unhappy about not having napkins or silver wear... especially because we had the order delivered to a hotel. Wasn't like we were at home and easily had these things. I asked for a side of mayo and had to use my finger to put it on my cold sub. Manager was some what helpful over the phone, offered for us to come in the next day and have lunch on him. I was hoping for some type of discount off of my bill, but it was a kind gesture. Told him we were not from the area and would be leaving early, but we would stop by. He informed us he would not be there the next day, but assured us he would let the other staff members know we were coming... Stopped by the next day, explained the manager told us to stop by. We were looked at as if we were crazy.. Manager on duty was rude, said he knew nothing about this. All in all a very poor experience. I left my name and phone number for the manager whom we spoke to, and requested he call when he returned to work. Never called. HORRIBLE SERVICE. read more

It has been many years since I have had a stromboli from OIP. Tonight was a real let down! 1) the sauce taste nothing like it did in the past. 2) they down sized the the product. 3) people behind the counter should not be eating. That is a health department violation. 4) I should have to pay your paper cost because you have those God awful look boxes and flyers. The food was so much better back in the day when the kitchen was ran by an Italian family with their hair nets and white tee shirts. Use the K.I.S.S method and you will save money. ( Keep- It- Simple- Stupid) read more

The bruschetta appetizer and eggplant parmesan were delicious! Glad there were vegetarian options to eat. Definitely be coming back!

Eaten in the totally renovated OIP three times now and food and service were all excellent each time. The Penne Vodka with grilled chicken is best I've had. Only drawback is no liquor license so no beer or wine and you are not allowed to bring your own. read more

My business travels take me to Sayre several times a month. OIP has been my favorite lunch spot for over 25 years. Recently they remodeled a couple years ago and it's clean, friendly and the food is excellent. The staff is very good to me and I enjoy the experience. Pizza excellent and the subs on fresh baked bread are amazing. Price is excellent. Where can you get lunch for under 7 bucks anywhere else? read more

Standard pizza/sub shop fair. Had Italian sub... Building is old and could use some tlc, but everyone working was very professional and courteous...solid bet if in area read more

An ok Italian pizzeria with an updated dining area. Portions have been cut down since the remodeling a couple of years ago. Pizza good. Lasagna very mushy as if they used "oven ready" noodles. They really don't know how to prepare veal. Don't know if it was a formed breaded patty out of the freezer or just badly prepared. read more

Their pizza is great! Best pizza in the valley! They prices are good and the service and people are amazing

This is one of the most reliable places in the area. Their subs, pizza and calzones are all great every time I get them. The bread they put their subs on is amazing. This is the go-to in our family when we eat out or to grab pizza. We always know it'll be good! read more

So now I have to find a new pizza place in the valley bc this establishment is trash. I ordered two pizzas, a half dozen honey garlic wings, and cheesy bread for me and my family tonight. The first time my wife picked it up the pizzas were right but they gave us somebody's sub and fries, which we didn't realize until we got home and opened it up. So we called them to tell them we were bringing the sub and fries back and they said they would give us our honey garlic wings and cheesy bread. When we went back again we could see them behind the counter trying to make sure everything was good with our order so when they brought it out to us and apologized for messing up we assumed it would be good. When we got back home they didn't put any blue cheese in my box with the wings and they put absolutely no sauce on the wings, no honey garlic, no garlic, just plain wings. These guys are clowns, thanks for nothing. read more

I am giving 1 star only cause ZERO isn't an option. My family has always loved the food here, however, lately, when I call the greeting is "OIP please hold" then click, I find that very rude. Also, I have ordered my side salad with no tomatoes or onions but add croutons and cucumber and PAY extra for some mozzarella to be on top. They have it right on the receipt when it comes, however, the last 3 times they have yet to make the damn salad correctly then tell me I have to wait 1 hr for a new one...WHAT? Not my error! This last time the cucumbers were spoiled. Last time I checked it in front of the delivery driver and it was completely wrong, had tomato and onion no cucumber or croutons or the cheese they charge extra for was not on it. He said he would bring a new one and never came then they were closed. The take over an hour to deliver, when I call to tell them its incorrect the several previous times they tell me they can being a new salad but it will be an hour!!! As if its my fault they can't follow simple instructions on the ticket. Between the extremely rude staff and the consistant incorrect orders, I think we will take our business elsewhere. We order at least weekly and spend about $50 each time. They said they are very busy since Covid and I understand that, however, you won't be busy for long treating customers rudely because you are "busy". I would much rather give our business to a business that appreciates their customers and treats them well and also can get the orders correct. We will be helping out the smaller businesses from now on. read more