We've been coming to Old Town Pizza in Auburn every Wednesday night for trivia for quite some time now, and this review is definitely overdue. Every single week, the staff is incredibly friendly and on top of everything. Service is always quick, even when it's busy, and they consistently make the experience feel easy and welcoming. Trivia night is such a highlight for us. It's genuinely fun, well-run, and something we look forward to all week. David and Asia are amazing hosts. They keep the energy up, make it engaging, and you can tell they really care about creating a great experience. One thing that really stood out to me was how responsive management is. I mentioned that the changing table in the women's restroom was broken, and by the time we came back the following week, it had already been replaced. That level of follow-through is rare and really appreciated. We actually drive in from Wheatland every week just to come here, which probably says it all. We love this place and plan to keep coming back. read more

Old Town Pizza - Trivia on the patio Wednesday nights - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

This is for a delivery order to Two Ass Brewing Company (lol), which lets you order in Old Town Pizza. The pizza was really solid (and I say this coming from Oakland / SF, which have really great pizza). Good crust, tasty toppings. We got a Lean Green Pesto Flatbread (minus the chicken), Reset Veggie Flatbread, Pickle Flatbread, spinach salad, and green salad. The Pickle Flatbread was a bit sweeter than I'd like, but tasty with beer. Everything else was great. Spinach salad was solid, green salad was eh but did the job of balancing out all the pizza. read more

Really, really good pizza! We got the meat one and it had pepperoni, sausage, and we substituted bacon for salami. The sauce is really good and they don't put a ton. Their crust is amazing!! We split a small Caesar salad that was tasty as well. Our waiter was amazing as well. Highly recommend! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Our group of seven arrived at noon and sat upstairs by the bar in the outside patio. It is a spacious area and covered from direct sun. Parking was easy in the private lot. Service was immediate and friendly. We had two large "Caboose " pizzas. The check was handled professionally with no issues. We will return. read more

Great service from Austin, fast, great pizza and beer...and not expensive. The rooftop bar is nice also read more

Old Town Pizza - Veggie w/sausage - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Amazing pizza and staff! As always, this establishment knows how to please! Seated right away with a cone off inside or outside on a busy Friday night. Sergio is outstanding as always- my husband and I haven't been here for a while but when waited on by Sergio, he is so personable and kind- this is why people return- when service is outstanding. Food came out quickly- asked many times how is everything?" Menu pizza name changed but we had The large caboose- same as the old mother lode pizza. Screaming good! So much toppings and the crust is outstanding! Thin, crispy and so damn delicious! Can't go wrong with this pizza place. I've had Pizza in SF Toni's and also Grimaldi Pizza in Sparks, Nevada. Both are great pizza too but OTP I think OSS a bit better.... read more

I can't say enough about this place! The service was great and friendly. The environment is awesome slightly modern but still very much that old Auburn country feel! Which I love coming back home. Came in town to visit and go for one of my favorite hikes and stopped in for a post workout meal and football! I will be coming here every time I'm in town going forward :-) what more can you ask for great food, great brew selection, and tons of screens with multiple games for the sports fans:) Also big for me is that they had gluten-free pizza dough and for anyone who is more on the health conscious side I found this to be one of the freshest non-greasy pizzas I've ever had in town. The onions, the artichokes and the mushrooms. Literally, you could tell we're not drenched in Greece and still had crunch and tons of their natural juices left so so good! I'll be back read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

See all

Whether you're passing through or staying to visit Auburn, this is a must stop! Pizza is fresh, the toppings are cut in large pieces, the crust is crisp on the outside, soft in the middle. I go to is the build your own pizza with pepperoni, jalapeño, and pineapple. Pineapple will be cut in circles, not cut into tiny pieces. A family favorite is the Docs Chicken it has a white sauce. We also usually order the spinach salad, but the Caesar is good too! They have a wide variety of beer and you can ask for a beer flight too! Once in a while they have Sangria. This pizzeria was once in the lower level of a building, a small cozy spot, but very well known. So well known that lines were always out the door; so they made the decision to move locations and now it is a two-story restaurant with a rooftop area. On hot days the misters up stairs are on and vibes are niiiceeeee! read more

See all

Busy place on a Friday evening. Lots of groups in a place that can accommodate large numbers of diners. Takeout pizza orders are separate from the main deck. (If you order a pizza here and tell the brewery half a block away, they'll give you a discount on your pint of beer.) I got the 16" cheese and linguisa pizza. Delicious. Went fabulously with the Marzen beer down the street. read more

See all

Came here with a friend after completing a hike near by. It was really slow for a Sunday, we were seated quickly, and checked in quickly. Service was fine, pizza was definitely the star on the show. Extra toppings aside from one was $1.75 which seemed like a lot in my opinion. Pizza was delicious, greasy but good. We were in and out within 25 minutes. read more

See all

Great pizza and great building. Fun to party here with lots of TV's and great bar areas. always a good time here! Great PIZZA!!

Really had a good experience here at Old Town Pizza. We just happen to be passing through coming back from Tahoe. Definitely lots of area to sit and watch a game if you wanted to. Didn't have any of the beers, but a pretty good selection. Everyone enjoyed the pizzas, the service was very friendly and helpful. Would definitely come back if we were in the area. read more

See all

Omg I miss Jordyn so much she is the best! :) I enjoyed my very first visit so much, I went back within a week! I only had wings, but they were as good and fresh and hot as I've had in Roseville. read more

5 stars for the ambiance upstairs. It was a really hot day and the upstairs has fans, misters and a nice breeze. There's a second bar, lounge seating and tables. Great drink menu and the bartender made it. The chicken wings were good. The pizza was 2-3 stars, very basic American with a lot of bread. Downstairs is really large, lots of families with kids and bigger parties, very loud. It's not my style of pizza, but I can see why this is an Auburn hangout . read more

Been a fan for years. If you haven't tried their pizza then you're really missing out. The beer is not bad either.

Stopped in on the way home. Jeff our server was awesome and had great suggestions for pizza. Got the Royal Hawaiian and the Caboose.and.the breadsticks were delicious. Pizza toppings were extremely generous. Definitely recommend!! We will be back when traveling through the area. read more

See all

No parking at this place. Pizza is trash as well. Way over hyped. There are so many other better choices.

Delicious pizza! I ordered a small Caboose pizza. It was loaded with toppings: pepperoni, sausage, linguica, salami, mushrooms, yellow onion and black olives. It was cooked well done as requested. Brad was my server and he did a great job! read more

Old Town Pizza - Caboose (Small) - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Love the fact that everything is made from scratch, from the fresh house made mozzarella to the hand-scooped gelato. I love the Gunpowder pizza, which is like an elevated Margherita pizza with a pesto sauce base. OTP is a cute little kick back for all ages, family-friendly, and low-to-average noise which includes rooftop seating overlooking beautiful downtown Auburn. I really want to give kudos to Nan and Cristina. Both times I've been, they were super sweet and helpful when placing our orders and answering questions. Everyone has a smile on their face & seems like they enjoy their job! Dare I say this is one of my favorite pizza shops in NorCal? read more

Dark, no heat, and mid pizza. Would t go back but waitress was sweet. Took a lo mg time to get 2 pizzas out of the kitchen and they were 10 minutes apart. read more

The pizza is still awesome as is the customer service. Old Town Pizza is still one of my fave lunch spots. The building is spacious, clean, modern and comfortable. Family friendly. The upstairs outdoor covered patio and bar area has a cool vibe. They offer lunch specials all week long including the weekends. Luv those tasty bargains. The pizza has never disappointed. Be it by the slice or whole pie. The pulled pork sliders and sando are delicious. They have beer and wine options. But on our last visit both of our side salads, that come with the lunch specials, was mostly if not all the hard core of the iceberg lettuce. I don't find that to be particularly tasty or edible. I believe most folks don't either. The top of each salad was prepped with edible lettuce though,made for a gorgeous looking salad at first glance. read more

See all

Pizza Cake Great locally-owned and operated chain that now has three locations in the Placer County area, with the Auburn location being the OG that's celebrating its 25th year (1999) . While this is the OG city, it is not the OG location as they moved into this bigger space a few years (2022) back. The Good: *Damn good American-style pizza *Great service *Terrific beer selection on-tap, as well as cans and bottles to purchase. *Happy Hour weekdays 2-5 p.m. and every day from 8 p.m. until closing time. *Plenty of TVs with sporting events--and NOT news. *Street and lot parking The Meh: *Not to get too pedantinc, but they're not technically in Old Town; more like Old Town adjacent. :) The Ugly: *I got nothing. Conclusion: Great spot for a beer--or three!--and a slice. read more

Old Town Pizza - Final Thoughts Bourbon Barrel-aged Barleywine 13.9%ABV - Sante Adairius Rustic Ales - Capitola, CA ($12/8oz) - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

See all

I Met family members for a birthday lunch. Never have been there before. NO DOUBT ABOUT IT It is THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. Great atmosphere, for all ages. Great time was had by all. Parking is tough tho ! read more

I haven't tried anything I didn't like here. Place is clean and atmosphere is fun. Stuffed bell pepper with sausage and bbq sauce is where's it at.. my husband likes their take home pizzas. read more

Their salad portions are huge. Spinach salad was fresh. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza well done. Cooked nicely, good flavor, came out quick. Looks cool inside, all the workers were friendly, super clean inside. read more

Old Town Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza, extra pepperoni, well done - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Really good pizza. Service was HORRIBLY slow although. Food came out decently fast. Waited literally 20 minutes for dessert, waited another 15 the check which we legit had to walk up to the bar because our waitress, katie was no where to be seen i understand it was busy. read more

I love the pizza here. Rarely do we have a bad experience. They must be short staffed because today, service is slow, table is dirty. I asked for a cloth to clean it myself but was told there wasn't one and it took a while for someone to come clean otherwise it would be 5 star just like most days. read more

Old Town Pizza - Half his favorite half mine! - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Pizza was good but employees were terrible and it felt like me and my family were ignored and rushed out of there. We just had a long day snowboarding with my fiancé and two sons and we came in around 6pm there was plenty of open booths and seats but they sat us upstairs not a terrible experience but they said they had no seating down stairs. I asked for the guest wifi password which was displayed that they have and was told they didn't have it and knew nothing of Wi-Fi when I was looking right at it on my phone then anytime I asked for a refill or just cheese, peppers , and some ranch for some pizza it seemed like the biggest chore. I don't know if it was a we are brown thing but it kind of felt like that all and all I left no tip and wouldn't go back. read more

ve been going to Old Town Pizza for most of my life, and I've always enjoyed it. The pizza is consistently great -- the cheese, the crust, everything -- and the in-house dining experience is top-notch. The service is friendly, the atmosphere is great, and the upstairs bar is an awesome addition. However, my biggest frustration has been with takeout orders. Despite ordering sauces and extras like plates through the online system, they're often missing when I pick up my food. And when I mention it, some staff have made me feel like I'm being a bother for asking. If your online ordering form includes options for sauces and extras, those items should be provided without needing a reminder. It's a small detail, but it makes a big difference. read more

I didn't realize OTP was a full service restaurant and our whole team descended on the Auburn location after a Saturday afternoon game. I thought it was a fast casual, seat yourself and hang. None the less, the whole crew were welcoming, warm and super happy to have us. This was my first time to any OTP location and I was so impressed! Food was superb and the customer service was top tier. I live closer to the Roseville location, so I'll definitely be visiting them soon! read more

See all

Food: I was not expecting it to be that great! I was pleasantly surprised with the taste of the pizza ! The pizza is flavorful and crust was just the right baking time . Service: 15 minutes before closing time and they still allow my family to dine in instead of other pizza place that they would ask for the pizza "to go" because it's almost closing time. I would definitively come back! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

See all

My boyfriend and I ate here last night, delicious watermelon Margarita and craft beers. I got the choo choo chicken pizza and had it drizzled with pesto, delicious! The rooftop is also a really pleasant area to hangout and have drinks. Highly recommend read more

Old Town Pizza - Rooftop bar - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

See all

We just love this pizza parlor!!! So much so that we celebrated our nieces bday!! Food was great as usual and the customer service was a 10!! read more

See all

This is the best pizza I have ever had. My family and I moved to Arizona and I cannot find any pizza over here that even comes close to Old Town Pizza. So every time we come back to Northern California to visit family and friends, Old Town Pizza is a must. The service was really good and our waitress took care of our big group of friends and family. The inside is really clean and cool looking. read more

Old Town Pizza has become our regular stop after a day on the boat and for good reason! We always grab our pizza to go, so I can't speak to the dine-in experience, but the food itself is consistently excellent. The pizza is always delicious, with a perfectly cooked crust and generous, flavorful toppings. It's a great value, especially when you're feeding a big group. Easy, reliable, and tasty--what more could you want after a lake day? read more

Loved the Margherita pizza. It was reasonably priced and the people were very nice. Beautiful area around Old Town Auburn, and we enjoyed the river. read more

Kudos to Austin. He was manager on duty when I had a delivery and order problem. He expertly solved my issues. Austin deserves recognition. He's the kind of employee that makes me a OTP fan for years. I recommend everyone to OTP! Ps. I do wish the free delivery boundary was made to 5 miles. Thanks read more

Food is great but customer service is definitely lacking these days and over the past few month. I used to be quite the regular but tapered off due to servers and bartenders visiting with friends vs checking in on guests. Came in today and the bartender was definitely not in a good mood. Will take another break away from here and hope things improve next year. read more

I miss the old location and atmosphere, which felt like an extended family member hosting Thanksgiving -- you know you're related somehow, but it doesn't really matter so long as the pizza's consistent and the tap rotation stays relevant. But after moving locations, cousin Jimmy and the boys get a little too excited over IPAs and college football, and turns out you're not related to these people at all. Jimmy, you're 40 years old and haven't been to the dentist in years. Take a walk. read more

I was the owner of the arcade in the FIRST Old Town Pizza and when Reese bought it he kept it perfect and made excellent changes as well .. then he opened one in old town Roseville and Lincoln.. then changed location in Auburn, with better parking beautiful area to eat and drink the pizza is still amazing and they are all fantastic.. props to Mason and Lara .. best pizza around .. great for family's! read more