Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Mill Cafe

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Old Mill Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Old Mill Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    27 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Edgar A.
    54
    33
    30

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Food is really good, fresh and quality ingredients. Good variety of snacks and drinks. New management and staff are very nice and welcoming.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Old Mill Cafe

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 3,665 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Feldmans Deli - Sloppy Joe

    Feldmans Deli

    4.5(893 reviews)
    5.5 miSugar House
    $$

    Feldmans is the Katz of SLC but less commercial. If you enjoy a hot pastrami sami then the sandwich…read moreof your dreams if awaiting. We tried both the Rueben combo and the Rachel combo. Both scrumptious for different reasons - the Rueben offers that tangy crunchy sauerkraut while the Rachel offers a fresh crunchy slaw compliment to the juicy hot meat. The potato salad was very creamy, it has so much delightful crunch and there's very potent garlic. The fries tasted a bit like burnt oil but im hoping was just a one off experience? Next time I think I'd like to share a sami to save space and try the Latkes, matzo ball soup, and chocolate babka. WE WILL BE BACK

    Overall a great stop if you're in the mood for a large sandwich! I was passing through SLC and came…read moreacross a recommendation for this place, and it definitely did not disappoint. They do full-service sit-down and to-go orders and have a wide selection of hot and cold sandwiches, bagels, dessert, other New York/Jewish style deli foods, and beer! Sloppy Joe - 5/5 - A large (1/2 lb) double decker sandwich with pastrami and corned beef. There are 3 layers of bread. The meats are tender and flavorful and blend nicely together with the thousand island dressing and slaw between the layers. It also comes with a side, I picked the potato salad which was good too. Not too much mayo but it was still nice and creamy. I just wish I got a little more potato salad to match the portion size of the sandwich! Potato Latke Pancakes - 4.5/5 - They were nice, hot, and crispy. You get 2 pancakes which have a nice thickness to them too. The flavor was good, I just think you should get more sour cream and apple sauce. It comes with a small cup of each, but its not quite enough for the 2 pancakes and its 50c each to get extra! Matzo Ball Soup - 3/5 - The matzo ball and soup broth both had a good flavor. The proportions were just off however, a huge matzo ball but not enough broth. And the broth didn't have enough of chicken meat and veggies (carrot/celery). I basically had 1/2 the matzo ball left over at the end Attempted Murder Imperial Stout Beer - 5/5 - Its a vanilla cinnamon stout. The flavor is subtle but in a good way! Its not sweet, but has a smooth bitterness and mouthfeel with a slight fragrance of the vanilla cinnamon. If you like stout, def give this a try. Its a strong one too, 10.5% ABV! The restaurant was clean, service was good, and there is a good amount of seating and its decorated nicely inside. Def give this place a try!

    Photos
    Feldmans Deli - Inside

    Inside

    Feldmans Deli - The Rachel Combo + Fries

    The Rachel Combo + Fries

    Feldmans Deli

    See all

    Mediterranean Market & Deli - Reuben

    Mediterranean Market & Deli

    4.6(131 reviews)
    5.7 mi
    $

    From the moment you walk in, it feels like you've stepped into an old-school Italian market and…read moredeli. The atmosphere is authentic, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Since it was my first visit, I wasn't sure how ordering worked, but they were happy to point me in the right direction. They have separate counters for phone order pickups and for dine-in/takeout orders, which made everything easy once I knew the process. I ordered the half Italian sandwich, and they definitely don't skimp on the ingredients. It was so packed that I had a hard time keeping it closed! The tomatoes absolutely stole the show--they were some of the best I've ever had on a sandwich and added incredible freshness. The bread was perfectly fresh, and every bite was loaded with flavor. The portions are generous, I only managed to eat half of my half before I was full. Considering the quality and portion size, the value is outstanding. This has definitely earned a spot on my list of must-visit places whenever I'm in Salt Lake City.

    This is such a great deli that is usually very busy, where you are served quickly, and has a large…read moreseating area that is always filled with patrons enjoying the sandwiches, pastas and other specialties they offer. Everyone who works here is very friendly and the clientele is diverse. Upbeat and local, casual. They have freshly baked cookies, that are homemade and the perfect compliment to your lunch, dinner, or snack from the deli. While you are waiting for your order, there is a small market next to the deli area where there is always something new to bring home to try. I crave their sandwiches and cookies and hope to visit again soon!

    Photos
    Mediterranean Market & Deli
    Mediterranean Market & Deli - Greek Pasta Salad

    Greek Pasta Salad

    Mediterranean Market & Deli - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Toasters - Roast Beef Sandwich

    Toasters

    4.7(78 reviews)
    4.9 miEast Millcreek

    What a tasty little find!! Was just looking for a sandwich and had a spot of time to kill so…read morethought I'd drive a ways and check this spot out. Impressive! A warm welcome upon entering. Ordered a 1/2 turkey avocado sandwich on toasted ciabatta bread (my choice) with chips and iced dark mocha. All under $20.00. Absolutely delicious! Am going to try and get back here for another tomorrow or Tuesday it was so good. Tried the beef stew and I swore my mother was behind the counter cooking it!!! Exactly like hers with those tasty flavors! I'll be back for that too! Yum! That little trip to look for a sandwich really paid off! Sweet little spot with exceptional customer service! Hard to find these little gems and here this one is!! I'd be here regularly if I wasn't just visiting.

    I tried the pastrami sandwich and overall thought it was good. The pastrami had good flavor,…read moreespecially with the Dijon mustard and balsamic vinegar, which added a nice tang and brought everything together. I got it on white bread with fries, and the fries came out crispy and paired nicely with the sandwich. Between the sandwich and the fries, it was a filling meal and I left satisfied. Where it fell a little short for me was the value. My total came out to around $21 with the fries, which felt a bit expensive for a sandwich meal, especially considering the amount of pastrami was fairly modest. It was enough to make the sandwich filling, but at that price point, I would have expected a little more meat to help justify the cost. That being said, I enjoyed the food and would come back to try some of the other sandwiches on the menu. With prices going up everywhere, I understand that eating out has gotten more expensive, but this still felt a little high for what you get. Overall, it was a good and satisfying sandwich--I'd just be more inclined to come back regularly if the portion felt a little more in line with the price.

    Photos
    Toasters - Inside seating area

    Inside seating area

    Toasters - I got the spicy chicken Breakfast Burrito.

    I got the spicy chicken Breakfast Burrito.

    Toasters - Interior

    See all

    Interior

    Old Mill Cafe - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...