Cancel

Open app

Search

Old Mill Cafe

5.0 (2 reviews)
Closed • 8:00 am - 8:00 pm
Updated 2 months ago

Old Mill Cafe Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Old Mill Cafe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Edgar A.
54
33
30

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Food is really good, fresh and quality ingredients. Good variety of snacks and drinks. New management and staff are very nice and welcoming.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Old Mill Cafe

You might also consider

Feldmans Deli - Sloppy Joe

Feldmans Deli

(885 reviews)

$$

Sugar House

Feldman Deli is a carefully curated dining experience. It seems care was taken with each ingredient…read moreand how they come together. The bread with just the right amount of rye and moisture, preventing the dryness often present in other delicatessens. This is just the beginning. The meats, the matzo ball soup, the slaw, dressing, and the best dang potato salad we've ever had (seriously, except my wife's, which is killer but is a different kind all together). We loved the staff, who were all genuine, funny, and personal. Great Feldmands reps. And the whole atmosphere with food quotes that explained the attitude of this deli that makes you are part of the building up this experience. We loved the touches from the murals, light fixtures, and decor. It is a distance for us, but one we are willing to travel many more times. .

Overall a great stop if you're in the mood for a large sandwich! I was passing through SLC and came…read moreacross a recommendation for this place, and it definitely did not disappoint. They do full-service sit-down and to-go orders and have a wide selection of hot and cold sandwiches, bagels, dessert, other New York/Jewish style deli foods, and beer! Sloppy Joe - 5/5 - A large (1/2 lb) double decker sandwich with pastrami and corned beef. There are 3 layers of bread. The meats are tender and flavorful and blend nicely together with the thousand island dressing and slaw between the layers. It also comes with a side, I picked the potato salad which was good too. Not too much mayo but it was still nice and creamy. I just wish I got a little more potato salad to match the portion size of the sandwich! Potato Latke Pancakes - 4.5/5 - They were nice, hot, and crispy. You get 2 pancakes which have a nice thickness to them too. The flavor was good, I just think you should get more sour cream and apple sauce. It comes with a small cup of each, but its not quite enough for the 2 pancakes and its 50c each to get extra! Matzo Ball Soup - 3/5 - The matzo ball and soup broth both had a good flavor. The proportions were just off however, a huge matzo ball but not enough broth. And the broth didn't have enough of chicken meat and veggies (carrot/celery). I basically had 1/2 the matzo ball left over at the end Attempted Murder Imperial Stout Beer - 5/5 - Its a vanilla cinnamon stout. The flavor is subtle but in a good way! Its not sweet, but has a smooth bitterness and mouthfeel with a slight fragrance of the vanilla cinnamon. If you like stout, def give this a try. Its a strong one too, 10.5% ABV! The restaurant was clean, service was good, and there is a good amount of seating and its decorated nicely inside. Def give this place a try!

Caputo's Market & Deli - "Old School" Sandwich

Caputo's Market & Deli

(178 reviews)

$$

Caputo's Holladay location is warm, welcoming, and really fits the Holladay vibe. We don't make it…read moreto Holladay as much as we'd like, but we stop by Caputo's when we do. (I should have written this review years ago, to be honest!) The sandwiches are consistently phenomenal... premium meats & delicious cheeses layered perfectly on fresh, flavorful bread. I'm a fan of "The Old School," but honestly you can't go wrong with any of the options. And no surprise, just like the downtown SLC location, the staff are friendly, patient, and genuinely helpful. They keep things moving smoothly yet never make you feel rushed. This location is a bit calmer and more relaxed than their downtown SLC location. We all know Holladay is...affluent, and their village is such a cute area that invites you to slow down and enjoy your meal. And, of course, the market is half the fun. Imported Italian specialties, incredible chocolates, and loads of pantry items...We always leave with something we didn't plan to get. Amazing food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps you coming back. A true favorite of ours and easily one of the best lunch spots in the area.

Caputo's in Holladay instantly gives old-world vibes -- the kind of spot that feels like it's been…read moredoing things right for generations. It actually reminded me of the markets I visited in the Czech Republic when I was a kid -- that same warmth, authenticity, and attention to detail. I ordered the Whole size "Old School" and took it to-go. This sandwich was delicious: The Italian cold cuts, Cacio de Roma cheese, lettuce, tomato, olive oil, balsamic, and a roasted red pepper spread that tied it all together beautifully. No heat, just a touch of sweetness -- and I was into it. The bread held up perfectly without overpowering the fillings. Every bite was balanced and satisfying. And then... the tiramisu. Silky, rich, heavy on the espresso, not too sweet, and just enough cocoa to finish it off right. Easily one of the best I've had in Salt Lake. Service was friendly, fast, and genuine. Whether you're wanting to grab lunch or treating yourself to a little dessert moment, Caputo's delivers quality without trying too hard. Beyond the food, definitely check out their awesome inventory too -- the shelves are full of unique, high-quality imports, snacks, and specialty goods you won't find just anywhere. A little up there in price but SO worth it! I'll definitely be back!

Old Mill Cafe - tradamerican - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...