Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Mill Cafe

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open 8:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Old Mill Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Old Mill Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Edgar A.
    54
    33
    30

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Food is really good, fresh and quality ingredients. Good variety of snacks and drinks. New management and staff are very nice and welcoming.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Old Mill Cafe

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 4,148 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Feldmans Deli

    Feldmans Deli

    4.5
    (890 reviews)
    5.5 mi
    $$

    Feldman Deli is a carefully curated dining experience. It seems care was taken with each ingredient…read moreand how they come together. The bread with just the right amount of rye and moisture, preventing the dryness often present in other delicatessens. This is just the beginning. The meats, the matzo ball soup, the slaw, dressing, and the best dang potato salad we've ever had (seriously, except my wife's, which is killer but is a different kind all together). We loved the staff, who were all genuine, funny, and personal. Great Feldmands reps. And the whole atmosphere with food quotes that explained the attitude of this deli that makes you are part of the building up this experience. We loved the touches from the murals, light fixtures, and decor. It is a distance for us, but one we are willing to travel many more times. .

    Overall a great stop if you're in the mood for a large sandwich! I was passing through SLC and came…read moreacross a recommendation for this place, and it definitely did not disappoint. They do full-service sit-down and to-go orders and have a wide selection of hot and cold sandwiches, bagels, dessert, other New York/Jewish style deli foods, and beer! Sloppy Joe - 5/5 - A large (1/2 lb) double decker sandwich with pastrami and corned beef. There are 3 layers of bread. The meats are tender and flavorful and blend nicely together with the thousand island dressing and slaw between the layers. It also comes with a side, I picked the potato salad which was good too. Not too much mayo but it was still nice and creamy. I just wish I got a little more potato salad to match the portion size of the sandwich! Potato Latke Pancakes - 4.5/5 - They were nice, hot, and crispy. You get 2 pancakes which have a nice thickness to them too. The flavor was good, I just think you should get more sour cream and apple sauce. It comes with a small cup of each, but its not quite enough for the 2 pancakes and its 50c each to get extra! Matzo Ball Soup - 3/5 - The matzo ball and soup broth both had a good flavor. The proportions were just off however, a huge matzo ball but not enough broth. And the broth didn't have enough of chicken meat and veggies (carrot/celery). I basically had 1/2 the matzo ball left over at the end Attempted Murder Imperial Stout Beer - 5/5 - Its a vanilla cinnamon stout. The flavor is subtle but in a good way! Its not sweet, but has a smooth bitterness and mouthfeel with a slight fragrance of the vanilla cinnamon. If you like stout, def give this a try. Its a strong one too, 10.5% ABV! The restaurant was clean, service was good, and there is a good amount of seating and its decorated nicely inside. Def give this place a try!

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Cold slaw with vinegar
    Cold slaw with vinegar
    Feldmans Deli

    See all

    Caputo's Market & Deli

    Caputo's Market & Deli

    4.5
    (181 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    Grabbed lunch on our way to the airport at the recommendation of a friend who lives in the area and…read moreare so glad we did. It's a cute Italian-style market with a variety of cheese, meat, and dry goods selections in addition so a wonderful Italian deli. It seems old school authentic - which who doesn't love in a deli! We each got a half sandwich which was perfect without being overly filling. I had the Old school and my husband had the caputo - we loved them both. They were the perfect epitome Italian deli. It was decently busy during a lunch rush but our sandwiches came out quick and there was ample indoor and outdoor seating. The breakfast sandwiches looked incredible as well!

    Caputo's Holladay location is warm, welcoming, and really fits the Holladay vibe. We don't make it…read moreto Holladay as much as we'd like, but we stop by Caputo's when we do. (I should have written this review years ago, to be honest!) The sandwiches are consistently phenomenal... premium meats & delicious cheeses layered perfectly on fresh, flavorful bread. I'm a fan of "The Old School," but honestly you can't go wrong with any of the options. And no surprise, just like the downtown SLC location, the staff are friendly, patient, and genuinely helpful. They keep things moving smoothly yet never make you feel rushed. This location is a bit calmer and more relaxed than their downtown SLC location. We all know Holladay is...affluent, and their village is such a cute area that invites you to slow down and enjoy your meal. And, of course, the market is half the fun. Imported Italian specialties, incredible chocolates, and loads of pantry items...We always leave with something we didn't plan to get. Amazing food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps you coming back. A true favorite of ours and easily one of the best lunch spots in the area.

    Photos
    Drinking chocolate and more
    Drinking chocolate and more
    The Caputo (Half)
    The Caputo (Half)
    Caputo's Market & Deli

    See all

    Grove Market and Deli

    Grove Market and Deli

    4.6
    (281 reviews)
    7.9 mi
    $$

    PSA: come here to cure your lunch hunger!…read more With massive sandwiches churning out of this deli / market duo, it is the perfect spot to swing by during the work day. Head to the back deli upon walking in and you will be asked for your order at the counter. I recommend your first order be a half sandwich - don't be macho like me and think you can handle a whole because you'll be wrestling with it all afternoon and possibly skip dinner. While you wait for the sando, browse the Asian themed market for a unique find, such as a flavor of Lays you've never tried (or seen!) or even a hot sauce from the many they carry. Orders can be taken to go, or eaten outside on one of their many tables. I'll definitely be back soon, they are open for business no doubt about that!

    Wowwww! Want an awesome sandwich? I'd say they know how to make it right at this spot. First time…read morecoming here, and I have been to many sandwich spots around UT. This was #1 on my list thus far. We ordered the Big John Sandwich (half portion) think of this like the ultimate club on a roll. I would add onions next time. Deluxe Sandwich - Ham Turkey and Avocado. Full size. If you're hungry, this is the spot to be. They offered prepacked salads, housemade and international fun flavors of drinks and chips. Coming back from Japan we were craving good ol american deli and this hits the craving! Every box checked. Fast friendly no frills service. They had outdoor sitting as well. Check em out!

    Photos
    Grove Market and Deli
    Grove Market and Deli
    In business since 1947! Same family, I'm told.

    See all

    In business since 1947! Same family, I'm told.
    Toasters

    Toasters

    4.7
    (75 reviews)
    4.9 mi

    What a tasty little find!! Was just looking for a sandwich and had a spot of time to kill so…read morethought I'd drive a ways and check this spot out. Impressive! A warm welcome upon entering. Ordered a 1/2 turkey avocado sandwich on toasted ciabatta bread (my choice) with chips and iced dark mocha. All under $20.00. Absolutely delicious! Am going to try and get back here for another tomorrow or Tuesday it was so good. Tried the beef stew and I swore my mother was behind the counter cooking it!!! Exactly like hers with those tasty flavors! I'll be back for that too! Yum! That little trip to look for a sandwich really paid off! Sweet little spot with exceptional customer service! Hard to find these little gems and here this one is!! I'd be here regularly if I wasn't just visiting.

    The one on 3300s was much bigger than it looked from the street. Staff was super friendly and…read morehelpful when it came to picking something from their menu. The 1/2 sandwich and soup combo was perfect for lunch. It also came with a drink and bag of chips. The roast beef wasn't dry and had flavor to it. They didn't skimp out on the portion for the protein either. The chicken noodle soup was good, nothing crazy. I believe I saw the owners talk to a group next to my table. Super friendly wife and husband. Happy I stopped by instead of driving past it like usual. Glad there's another sandwich shop in the rotation.

    Photos
    Inside seating area
    Inside seating area
    I got the spicy chicken Breakfast Burrito.
    I got the spicy chicken Breakfast Burrito.
    Interior

    See all

    Interior
    East Coast Subs

    East Coast Subs

    4.5
    (146 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $

    I've been here a few times and this place does not disappoint. Before I review the food, I have to…read moretalk about the incredible service. The owner, Korbyn, was working the front, taking orders, ringing up customers, wiping down tables, checking on customers dining in, and that level of attention and care was evident with the entire staff. Now on to the food. These sandwiches are so good. We know the bread makes the sandwich and their bread is perfect for a good sando. I got the Italian cold cut combo with everything and omg. The giardiniera they top on the sandwiches really round it out. Add a side of fries that come with fry sauce and that's a damn good meal. Casual environment, counter service, went at 2pm and it was still packed. They're always busy and for good reason. But they like moves fast and the food comes out quick.

    We came in the last hour of this spot being open, and it was wildly busy. They made our food pretty…read morequickly though they were sold out of onion rings. Seating is pretty limited in this small space, but we still got a table. I thought my sandwich was fine, not great. My husband did not enjoy his at all. We also got fries, which were just OK. Service was decent--didn't stand out in either direction. I think I'd come back to give something else a try, but it would be without my husband since he was not a fan.

    Photos
    Best Subs, anywhere, period!!! The fries are pretty amazing as well!!
    Best Subs, anywhere, period!!! The fries are pretty amazing as well!!
    Italian meat is my go to sandwich at ECS. So delicious!
    Italian meat is my go to sandwich at ECS. So delicious!
    Italian Meats

    See all

    Italian Meats

    Old Mill Cafe - tradamerican - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...