We have been making the Olamendi pilgrimage regularly since we moved to Dana Point some 13 years ago. I am addicted to the salsa (homemade and quite spicy.)
I always recommend Olamendi's for the food. It is consistently great. That's why I gave it five stars. Try the carnitas (there is one platter that serves 3-4), the fish tacos (cooked ceviche is the best description), the Mexican chef's salad, any of the homemade soups, the huge burritos or the traditional combo plates. Prices are getting steep - in the $20 range for a salad and entree dinner. If you love mole, this is the place. There are several on the menu. My fav is the Oaxaqueño - served on chunks of pork. Again, it is very spicy but if you like spice this is the one to get. Also try the blanca nieves (a creamy white jalapeno sauce served on chicken, steak or pork). There is mole poblano, mole Esmeralda (lighter, less spicy) and the Oaxaqueño. I have a pal who orders the Pescado al Mojo de Ajo every time he goes. (Lightly fried fish in a garlic and lemon sauce.)
The menu is nothing like the taco/enchilada combo plate special at most Mexican restaurants including the same-named place in Laguna.
However ... the food is always great but the service can be really, really, really spotty. There are times when one thinks there are no servers at all and that can be on a mid-afternoon Sunday in February when it is raining outside. Pack your patience.
The atmosphere is tacky and ever-changing, except for the pictures of Richard Nixon and other GOP luminaries on the walls. Hey, it is South Orange County. It is hard to imagine Nixon, in suit and tie and well-polished oxfords, eating at the plastic tables that used to be the hallmark of the place.
Today, the restaurant is an eclectic collection of wood tables and dining chairs that look like they are from the rummage sale. There are cast-offs from Dia de los Muertos in the dark corners and chain-saw carved depictions of Christ on the Cross. But don't be scared. There are also pinatas and Teletubbies hanging from the ceiling. You really have to see it to believe it.
Parking is not plentiful so be prepared to park across busy PCH and run through traffic to get there. (That's in mid-summer. Those rainy February days keep the tourists away. Then the parking is fine.)
It is closed on Mondays - even when it is a Monday holiday (like Labor Day.)
Finally, the restrooms are outside (one per gender.) The men's room door didn't lock for a while. (Use your imagination, or not.) It is also impossible to think that prissy Richard Nixon would go outside but I guess if one has to go, one has to go outside. At least he had Secret Service protection. I wouldn't send my kid off to the bathroom alone.
Go for the food and pack your patience - and maybe some blinders. You are not at Dennys. read more