Always while traveling - i try to support local businesses. Why not a pie place. :) Will say... when i walked through the door everyone stopped talking and all eyes on me. It was a weird feeling i will say but waitress was super friendly and did greet when she arrived at the front, so that helped. Did i want to sit and eat there - nope! Maybe it was just RBF on everyone faces; not sure and very close sitting on top of that. Honestly i can't remember if there was table top sitting; definitely a local hotspot. Anyway - were the pies good; YES! I ordered 4 pies (pie flight) to go and took it back to my place. I was not disappointed with the tasty treats. Happy Eating!!! read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Yummy - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

I always stop here on my way up north. I have had both the food and the pies, both great. The pies are a MUST. They have lots of flavors and every single kind I've tried is amazing. I believe the owner makes them fresh each morning. My absolute favorite is the chocolate raspberry cream pie! I think about it often. The food is small town American and always hits. It is a popular spot with the locals so they can tell when you're from out of town lol. read more

See all

Great food and great service! We love this place for breakfast, lunch, or pies/coffee anytime. My breakfast favorite is 'one of each' and my lunch favorite is the French dip sandwich. As for pies, I love the coconut creme off the longest pie list I have ever seen. read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Main dining at OJ's! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

The staff was friendly and the food was AWESOME Drove 30mi from Mountain Springs and was definitely worth the drive!!

Food was very tasteful and light on the wallet. Staff was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. We will definitely be back! I ordered the Cali Burger with sautéd onions then coconut cream pie for dessert. read more

See all

OJ's has been famous for decades as being home of the best pie in Wisconsin. They have so many choices and you can get a slice or a whole pie, all at good prices. They also have "Pie of the Month ", which is always a favorite and also discounted! I live out of state, in San Francisco now, but follow them on Facebook. When I heard they were doing Apple Dumplings during October again this year, with a goal of selling over 3000, I made plans to take a vacation and get a couple! Flew to Green Bay, met with a friend, and did a 3 day trip looking at Fall colors then 2 days in Gillett. Ate at OJ's a couple times and it was just as good as I remembered! I had breakfast, lunch and my favorite pie; coconut cream. And of course bought apple dumplings to take back home on the plane! I got 5, and they ended their season passing their goals with a final count of 3508!!! read more

See all

I can't stress enough how awesome this place is. Prices are super responsible. Food is excellent. Pies........OMG. read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

See all

Quality food with daily entre at lunch. A GREAT Breakfast is served till 11:00. Thé homemade Pies and desserts are a must.Caramel Topped Apple Pies Gillett Burger Door County Cherry Pie no one can resist. read more

Food was good and cute atmosphere. The serving staff was friendly and never stopped moving.

Family-owned for two generations, passing the recipes for great food and even better pies. I grew up on OJ's pizza after school before basketball games and continue to go back whenever I'm in the area for the pizza burger and pie...always the pie. My favorites in no particular order: raspberry chocolate cream, red velvet cheesecake, triple berry, caramel apple streusel. read more

OJ's has been a family favorite for years. From the Friday fish fry's to the homemade pies. I never leave disappointed.

Great diner food. Fast service with a smile. Very clean. Crazy good bakery. This property is a throwback from days gone by!

The way cafes should still be. Local, homemade, neighborly, and priced right. Don't forget to buy some of the best pies ever!

OMG - the Pie is so delicious here! We missed the opportunity to eat at the restaurant due to our schedule, but were able to buy a pie - and what a pie it was. We also bought a slice of another pie as the options were so delicious looking. We bought strawberry-rhubarb pie and caramel topped apple pie. Both were very delicious! Thank you OJ's Midtown Restaurant for creating such delicious deserts! read more

Go for a diner meal and stay for the pie. The pie hear is the reason I'll drive out of the way. They always have a special and they are delicious. read more

Awesome food, awesome pies. Everyone in our group liked the food and service. They let us have breakfast even though breakfast had just ended. And the pies... I just heard someone at another table say that it is the best lemon meringue pie he's ever had. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the area. Awesome place! read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Awesome pies! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

See all

I had dinner here on a snowy night. The restaurant was warm and welcoming. I had a very good cajun salmon and, of course, finished with a slice of pie, raspberry in this case. I will be visiting them again! read more

Always 5 stars on all their pies! I especially enjoy their traditional sour cream raisin and mincemeat pies, when they have them. My husband loves their chipotle bacon cheeseburger. read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Caramel Apple Streusel pie - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

They list a ton of pies and they were all very good. The personal favorite was the blueberry blizzard. The pricing is great. You can expect a great dinner with drink and desert for about $10. read more

See all

what a great restaurant! Quaint, homey, friendly and quick service. The waitress really hustled! My husband had the special ( spaghetti ) I had the pizza burger (made with Italian sausage and stuffed with mozzarella cheese). We shared lemon meringue pie for dessert and the entire bill was only $15! read more

OJ's Midtown Restaurant - Lemon meringue pie! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Gillett, Wisconsin

See all

What a gem. I was driving through that area and looked on Yelp for a good place to eat, this one came up 5 stars and I was not disappointed! I had the liver and onions. This was the best liver I had in years, not overcooked, tender and fresh tasting. It came with a big portion of real home made mashed potatoes and gravy topped with delicious, crisp bacon. The bacon was cooked to perfection, very crisp but not half-burned as most places do it. One of my sides was a large portion of coleslaw which was much better than you'd expect in a diner. The sides are huge by the way. I was stuffed after all that so I took home a slice of chocolate cream pie and door county cherry pie which were to die for! I wish we lived closer to this place, we'd be there a LOT! You can't go wrong with this place. read more

Wonderful tasting food! OJ burgers, chipotle bacon cheese burgers, chicken tenders & cranapple wslnit salad. Service was excellent - we had a group of 6. We will be back! read more

See all

Great food. Friendly staff. And of course the home made pies. This is how cafes should be.

Best pie ever. Apple dumpling was great. I also love the breakfast. You will get your money worth

Awesome pie. They claim to have the best pie in the state and thus far I have to agree. Also the Gillett burger is awesome.

This place was voted best pie in Wisconsin for a reason! We sampled Triple berry, rhubarb, pecan, and banana cream, all delicious! The service was friendly, the food was yummy, and the pie completed a great lunch! If you happen to be in Gillett, stop here for lunch and pie! read more

This is our favorite place for breakfast. We go every Friday! Also has the best pie/dessert around!!! Great service and clean place owned by a wonderful family too. read more