Once again had a delicious meal at the bagelry, the staff are attentive and know exactly what their…read morecustomers want - after only visiting a couple times they knew my order by heart (and my wife's!) - never had a bad bite here and sure I never will.

I came here for a morning bagel while visiting the area after hearing great things. Found parking…read moreoutside easily on the Sunday morning and walked right in. Definitely a popular place, there were folks sitting inside and plenty for people taking food to go. There were a lot of great bagel options and homemade cream cheeses as well. Highly recommend the bacon horseradish cream cheese or the vegetable. Both well made with good flavor and ingredients. Reasonably priced and super friendly folks. Dustin took our order and was great to chat with. Highly recommend a stop in!

I had the egg, bacon, and cheese sandwich on a bacon cheese bagel and it was soo good. First off…read morethe amount of bacon on this bagel is very generous to say the least. "There's too much bacon on this" said nobody ever, lol. I wish I took a picture of the sandwiches middle because it really would've shown how much bacon was on there, was thick. They also cut the bagel sandwich in half and which makes it easy to eat. I also had half of my mother in laws cream cheese garlic bagel and absolutely delicious. Very garlicky but not over powerful. If they say it has garlic or bacon they mean it. Great job guys! Also staff was very friendly, I can't wait to try their pizza place next door.

I stopped here to get some bagels for my team, definitely glad I stopped. The team loved the…read morebagels and I bought a breakfast sandwich too. the shop is small but done well and kept spotless. The server was great and she was helpful too. Great place right on the riverwalk. Try them out!

Updated review - I'm glad to say they seem to resolved the issues with picking up food - you can…read moreagain pick up by name on the shelving by the door. Orders are promptly ready, and the food is consistent and good. Also, while other downtown restaurants seem to be raising prices willy and/or nilly, the prices here remain very reasonable. I can't speak to the speed of ordering in person, but this now is a quick and affordable spot with tasty bagels and sandwiches.

We usually pick Water Street Bagel as our go-to bagel spot just in relativity of its proximity to…read moreour home. We've had a few mixed experiences in the past but we do keep going back. The staff always seem to be hard at work as they are clearly in high demand. We were lucky this visit because all of the bagels were super fresh as it was peak busy hours. We also were lucky because we actually found parking quite quickly & didn't have to circle the block. I appreciate they offer sandwich options but I usually stick with a bagel & some form of cream cheese for myself because that's just usually my preference. This visit I got a rosemary salt bagel with salmon cream cheese. It was simple & perfectly what I was looking for that day. It's a beautiful space that is well lit & well decorated. It's easy to find them with their sign out front. It can get a bit crowded inside if they're busy but that's nothing to complain about it's just the reality of the space they are working with. Last note- it does always smell really amazing when you walk in there.

Quick and easy breakfast and lunch options. No fuss, modern cafe. Nice drink selections. Great…read moredesserts

I loved the look of this place, they were incredibly friendly and the drinks were delicious on a…read morerainy day. I would recommend the cherry cheesecake! It was so yummy! Definitely recommend the hot chocolate. It was delicious

Another great breakfast! Everyone was friendly, ordering is simple at the register....then just…read morewait for your name to be called. I had the bagel of the week - Quattro Formaggio ( 4 cheeses)... with bacon, egg and fried egg it was a very tasty sandwich. (My only disappointment was the very small amount of thin bacon and it was all on one side as you can see in the picture). I love that you can order the egg scrambled or fried. Excellent bagel, delivered warm and quite quickly considering how busy they were.

Auburn bagel Company is the best bagels in Auburn, New York! This place is a must have when…read morevisiting Auburn, New York. The inside is very clean they have tables and a dining room area to sit and enjoy your food, and they recently opened up their outdoor patio to enjoy some fresh air while enjoying your food. The bathrooms are clean and the kitchen area is clean too. The service was excellent . I've been here three times since visiting Auburn, New York and every time the service has been amazing. The staff was quick to take our orders. They were quick with preparing the food, and they all worked as a team communicating, and helping each other. I saved the best for last, let's talk about the food! I got an everything bagel, toasted with scallion cream cheese, red raw onions, and fresh tomatoes. I also purchased a cinnamon scone for the road. All their pastries are made fresh as well as the bagels. They have a regular menu of the most popular bagels and they always do a bagel of the week. This week was a chocolate bagel. They also have gluten-free bagels. You can do breakfast sandwiches, they have specialty sandwiches. They have a large variety of flavorful cream cheese spreads. In addition to serving pastries and bagels, soups, salads they also serve a variety of beverages. In conclusion, Auburn bagel Company, as they say "A Schmear above the rest!" if you're visiting in the finger lakes area then you must try Auburn bagel Company, I promise, you will not be disappointed! Cheers

Smash burgers are amazing! Next level burgers and French fries with gravy make the trip…read moreworthwhile!! Don't sleep on this place!

The best diner around. The staff are all so amazing,…read morefriendly and fast but also attentive and personable. Food comes out quick and is so fresh and delicious!

Outstanding! The bagels are perfect NY style. I tried the whitefish salad today & it was excellent!…read moreThe service was fast and friendly. This place is a true gem. Do yourself a favor and get a cookie. Worth every calorie!

Just had a fire on 9/9 and are unsure of damage. They aren't sure when/if they will be open again…read more Their website is up to date. So sad--they have the best bagels in town and are incredibly nice.

I've long been a fan of their buffalo cream cheese and occasionally swing by for a bagel…read more However, last week I ordered takeout, and was so pleasantly surprised that I felt like I needed to update my review. My bagels came to me warm and straight from the oven, and were delightfully fluffy. There was a smiley face drawn onto my takeout bag. Honestly, little touches like that just made my whole day. Of course, the flavored cream cheeses were decadent. It was the perfect pick me up I didn't even know I needed, and I feel even more fondly about this little gem now.

This place was a master class in fumbling the ball, we went there got 4 bagels and it took 20…read moreminutes. The place was busy, but toasted bagels don't taje 20 minutes. For bagels that are closer to rubber. The coffee was a sorry sight too.

We recently ordered Bagicious for breakfast for our team at work and everyone had rave reviews…read more They loved the breakfast platters that were put together, one with savory bagels and one with sweet. The different flavors of cream cheese were also a hit. The French toast bagel was a fav!!

This probably isn't fair since I grew up close to NYC/NJ. This might be good for CNY, but sheesh I…read morewas underwhelmed. Given the hype this place gets, I was expecting what I used to get. Like I said, good for here but would SOL downstate. Nice staff though and very clean!