I celebrated my birthday here with a party of 18 and I'm so glad Ofena exceeded all my expectations! From what I could see online, it seemed like a pretty small space, but they actually have a room in the back that was able to comfortably seat my party. They had us at 2 tables, one table of 8 and one table of 10. Parking was easy to find on the street, so we all arrived and were seated around 6:15pm.
Our server for the night is usually a bartender, but he did a great job with such a large party. My table ordered family style so we were able to try more items on the menu. We started with the focaccia, one with the garlic, balsamic, and olive oil and another with the whipped ricotta and mortadella. The focaccia was out of this world delicious, it was so light and fluffy with a sprinkling of salt on top. Both of the dips were really good as well, but I liked the ricotta and mortadella since it was a unique thing to see on a menu.
For apps, we got the chilled artichokes, house greens, mushroom arancini, and the lamb skewers. I liked the artichokes and salad, everything tasted high quality and fresh. The lamb skewers were just okay, the meat was quite tough and chewy though the flavors were good. I didn't get to try the arancini but everyone that had it really liked it.
For mains, we ordered the steak tagliata, 2 orders of the gnocchi carbonara, the seafood risotto, and the cannelloni for the vegetarian in our group. The steak was cooked perfectly, and topped with balsamic and flaky salt. The side of grilled broccolini was cooked nicely, with flavors of lemon and garlic coming through. The gnocchi were pillowy and not too thick, with a nice creamy sauce peppered with salty pockets of duck prosciutto. The seafood risotto was definitely my favorite main - it had such a depth in the seafood stock and the saffron risotto was cooked to creamy perfection and topped with snappy shrimp and calamari. The bite of the cannelloni I had was really good, pasta was cooked to perfection and the filling was creamy and flavorful topped with a bright tomato sauce.
Off their drink menu, I highly recommend the Lost Boy and the C is for Cookie cocktails. The Lost Boy was a whiskey drink perfectly balanced with bitters, absinthe, prosecco, and a touch of tobacco. The C is for Cookie is Ofena's version of an espresso martini, and it was really good with the cookie butter whip. Our server also told us his salt and pepper martini was voted best in SF, so if you're a martini fan be sure to check this one out.
The service was really good the entire night, attentive and thoughtful and I appreciated the team clearing plates and bringing out new cutlery after each course. The only strange thing was there was no comped dessert, even though they knew it was my birthday - if my group spends $1k at your restaurant, I would assume that a $10 dessert would be included for a celebration. There were no candles or anything on the dessert we did order, so that was the only thing that could have made the dinner perfect. The panna cotta was really delicious, some of the best I've ever had - with lemon curd, mandarin slices, and crunchy bits of meringue that added the best texture to the silky custard. Overall, it was a memorable dinner and I look forward to coming back again! read more