(Dined 09/20/2026 SU from 12:00pm-2:00pm): Watermarks were expected along the waterfront!…read more
Friends and I spent an afternoon at Watermark for some Oktoberfest revelry. A stylish open-air event space with panoramic views of the Brooklyn and Williamsburg bridges and Brooklyn skyline overlooking the East River at Pier 15, this spot was currently in the throes of "Oktoberfest NYC's Waterfront Celebration". Throughout the year, seasonal and themed events transformed the area. Additionally, the space was rentable for corporate gatherings, entertainment events, media purposes, and more. Would this place leave a positive mark besides the water from the sky!?
PURCHASE(S)
"Royalty" 2-Hour Open Bar Package ($40.00 + $3.43 Process Fee): My consumption averaged just over $6.00/drink - a decent value.
~Staatliches Hofbraühaus München Hofbraü Oktoberfestbier Märzen Beer 6.3% ABV 8floz Draft: Hazy amber color, malty aroma, light body, malty sweet flavor, effervescent clean smooth finish, malty sweet aftertaste.
~Radeberger Gruppe Radeberger German Pilsner Beer 4.8% ABV 8floz Draft: Hazy amber color, malty aroma, light body, bread malty sweet watery flavor, clean smooth finish, malty sweet aftertaste.
~Samuel Adams Octoberfest Märzen Beer 5.3% ABV 8floz Draft: Caramel red color, malty aroma, light body, biscuit cinnamon malty sweet flavor, clean smooth finish, malty sweet aftertaste.
~Bayerische Staatsbrauerei Weihenstephaner Hefeweissbier Beer 5.4% ABV 8floz Draft: Hazy rich amber color, banana cloves floral wheaty aroma, light body, banana cloves floral flavors, smooth finish, and banana cloves floral wheat aftertaste.
~Radeberger Gruppe Schöfferhofer Grapefruit Radler Shandy 2.5% ABV 8floz Draft: Guava color, fruity grapefruit tropical aroma, light body, grapefruit guava tropical sweet flavor, crisp effervescent finish, grapefruit sweet tropical aftertaste.
~Five Boroughs Brewing Co. Watermark Pierbier IPA Beer 6.0% ABV 8floz Draft: Hazy amber color, hoppy malty aroma, light body, biscuit bready hoppy malty flavor, mouthfeel smooth finish, biscuit malty malty aftertaste.
~Classic Margarita Cocktail 4floz: An odd choice for an Oktoberfest event, more tequila was needed.
Jumbo Soft Pretzel w/3 Types Cheese ($26.00): Larger than my head, everyone loved this and the cheeses!
Watermark Tasting Tower For 2 ($75.00): An assortment of truffle fries, chicken sliders, hot chicken wings, bratwurst, calamari, and a scoop of ice cream (we never received that), this was enough for our party of four. My favorite was the hot bratwurst and the fact that this was the only Oktoberfest-themed food on this sampler.
Pretzel-Crusted Chicken Schnitzel w/Bacon-Roasted Potatoes ($24.00): I loved the large piece of moist chicken with its lightly-crusted exterior, the creamy sauce, and the roasted potatoes nearly melted in your mouth.
Auto-Gratuity 18.00% ($22.50): This seemed excessive for a party of four.
SERVICE
The online ticket purchase was easy. Once we arrived, we were greeted at the front by a jovial tall male dressed in a lederhosen who led us to the check-in table where we showed our respective tickets and given a rundown of how this event worked. Then, he led us to a tall table closest to the bar when a charming female server greeted us, provided water and a menu, and eventually took our food order. As we each gathered our drinks from the bar, all of the food came out about fifteen minutes later. Empty plates were collected and settling the bill was simple. Everything was straightforward - prost!
PARKING
(Varied; N/A this instance): My friend and I took a train from the Journal Square PATH Station to the World Trade Center PATH Station (about 20 minutes) and walked about 15 minutes to the location. I'm sure there were parking options all round.
ATMOSPHERE, DÉCOR, AMBIENCE
A huge open one-floor layout with expansive waterfront views, it had a beer garden feel with artificial turf on the floor, plenty of high tabletop dining spaces, a small covered area, a main bar, and an explosion of Oktoberfest decorations from the moment you entered. Plenty of natural lighting since you were outdoors while strung electric lights filled in the rest. No actual TVs while an interesting mix of German oompah music and Euro dance tracks played in the background.
ATTIRE
Totally casual, so I would normally be in a t-shirt, boardshorts, and flip-flops.
OVERALL
Watermark's Oktoberfest was decent, and I would consider attending another seasonal event. I felt much was lacking and was more a backyard or tailgate party. I've been to other Oktoberfest celebrations that felt more authentic (i.e. ALL German beers, food, music, and entertainment). The food was generally good, the prices were comparable, and the service was fine. I found fairly good value based on the prices, service, and experience noted above (TOTAL paid experience was around $202.00 BEFORE any discounts and/or tip). And, they accepted my credit card of choice... AMEX! 3.5 STARS