Ok, it's a gas station convenience store, not a restaurant. But damn! I had a hot Reuben that…read moreknocked my socks off! The bread was fresh, the meat and cheese were piled on, and it was good quality cold cuts. Had some curly fries and a fountain drink with it as a combo. Best kept secret sandwich place in Starkville.

In the middle of an old gas station at the counter. When I was there, they had 4 meats and the…read moreperson making the food did not look particularly sanitary so we moved on. Underwhelming at best.

-- One of the best Reubens I've ever had! Those who know me…read moreknow I've been taking pictures of my food and leaving reviews in one app or another for almost 20 years. In that time, I've developed a soft spot for Reuben sandwiches and have enjoyed them in more than 10 states. It took me two tries and three trips around the block to finally find The Older Brother, but the effort was absolutely worth it. I think I've found one of the finest Reubens I've ever eaten. A beautiful, fresh marbled rye held finely shredded corned beef, juicy sauerkraut, and their special dressing. It was one of the juiciest--and yes, messiest--Reubens I've ever had, and my mouth is watering just thinking about it. I even sent my compliments to the chef. The trendy little café, with its wide-open windows and bright, airy feel, made it seem like outdoor dining on a beautiful day. Service was friendly, attentive, and right on time. I can't wait to return with my wife. Kudos to The Older Brother!

We ordered the croque monsieur and though it took a while,it was worth the wait. Our server was…read moreSierra and she was wonderful.

I don't know how long Jersey Mike's has been in Starkville, but I didn't start going until this…read moresemester. Never noticed it. Then it popped up when I was looking for fast food places around here one night last week, so I went then and had a good experience. Today was my second time going to this location (third time EVER going to any Jersey Mike's), and I again had a good experience that I think is worth noting. Yes, Jersey Mike's is a little pricey, but the food is amazing with even better service. I walked in there wanting to get something different from what I got last week, and the girl who took my order was so helpful and offered a specific sandwich that fit my mood. While they were making my sandwich, the staff was eager to answer questions and was prepared to give suggestions concerning, in this case, the pepper relish (which was great!). "Oh yeah that's really good and would go well with mayonnaise." She was right! Again, I don't know if Jersey Mike's is new to Starkville, but this place is amazing and my new favorite place to get a sandwich (former fave was Jimmy John's). Their customer service is impressive and the reason for this review. I'll be stopping by consistently this semester in hopes that they maintain their high standards.

We made a visit here today (9/5/26) because they advertise that they carry gluten free buns. We…read morehave two family members with celiacs disease, who cannot consume gluten without being put in the hospital. As soon as we asked for gluten free buns the man taking our order immediately started groaning and complaining about having to do an allergen free order. This already made us feel uncomfortable, but we continued on. Then the same man asked another employee to make the meal and they agreed until he told them it was an order with an allergy. This employee complained and groaned too. It was extremely disrespectful. Especially when I know my family members would LOVE to be able to eat gluten and not have to be selective about restaurants they eat at. We find a place that is SUPPOSED TO BE accommodating, but instead left ashamed. They also proceeded to tell us after all the moaning and groaning that they only had one gluten free bun available.... So after we were made to feel bad then we were disappointed because it was all for nothing. They knew we had two gluten free orders when they started complaining... go and complain in the back all you want, but do not sit there and make someone feel small because they cant eat bread and you have to clean the equipment. Also just to add, the tables were covered in crumbs and food particles. Someone's personal Tostitos chips and salsa were left out open on one of the tables. Mind you it's 3 pm. This isn't a lunch rush time. The whole experience was awful. We love Jersey mikes, just not this one....

The place is lovely, I was so looking forward to having a sandwich there. It was a ballgame day and…read morehoped they may have had the game on, but they did not. I asked for the wifi password so we could check the score, but was informed that they do not share their wifi password. I told the waitress I was having a hard time deciding because I was quite particular about roast beef, I almost went with the turkey, but I felt reassured and ordered the French dip. The bread was amazing, the beef was pink and cold and I bit into a piece of fat I couldn't chew and had to spit it in my napkin. My lunch mate had the same sandwich but was pleased with hers. I told the waitress I didn't like it and she offered to cook it longer, I said no thank you, that I was just ready to get out of there, (we had quite a drive ahead of us and we couldn't keep up with the game.) The waitress mocked me out loud, "Oh she's just ready to get out of here". At that point I REALLY couldn't wait to get out of there. It is really sad when a restaurant has everything going for it, and a rude waitress ruins everything. She could have maybe offered the turkey since I didn't like the beef or discounted the ticket, but no just a childish smart remark.

I may be the only Jewish person to have ever been here, what a delight…read more July - 96 degrees, feels like 109. Until you get here.. opens at 5pm.. arrived with a smile and by myself I have been baptized and converted to proffits religion. I am a profiteer now. THE CAM. THE GUMBO. THE RED BEANS & RICE CINDY THE SERVER I SEE YOU GIRL! INCREDIBLE SERVICE! Coursed out the meal for me. What a treat. My wife is about to receive a better man now leaving this place THEN THE DESSERT!!! The chocolate chest pie!! GET OFF OF ME YOU ARE ON FIRE. It may be one of the best things I've ever had.. simple but so rich and decadent

Never had a bad choice for many lunches with friends at Cater - soup, salad, quiche, sandwiches…read more Also had some quiches made for a family gathering that were a big hit with all ages. The casserole options are good too. My favorite is the sweet potato with pecan topping. Just pop in the oven and the meal is done.

Customer service: spot on great experience…read more Food: it was ok. The Mexican salad was watery and a strange consistency. Presentation/delivery: this was ordered several weeks in advance as a catering order to be picked up. I chose the specific salads, sweet treats, and crackers and chips. I understood that everything would be on a platter ready to lay out on the table for the meeting I was hosting. Sweet treats would be cut and arranged on a platter. I selected all of the specific items I wanted abd prepaid. Fast forward to pick up day. The order wasnt ready. When i showed up, staff was scrambling to put the order together. They pulled the salads that I ordered from the refrigerator, cut the sweet treats bars (although they didn't have any of the bars I ordered), and threw everything in bags. Not only I didn't get what i ordered, but it wasn't presented as expected. There was no point in ordering ahead--I still had to wait. Then I had to go to the office and arrange everything on serving platters. So completely frustrating. Outcome: will not return.

We stopped in for lunch while in town for MSU orientation for our son. While this restaurant is a…read morechain, this particular location is awesome! We were greeted as soon as we walked in and the friendliest staff on the planet was eager to help us with each and every request. The manager even stopped at the table to see if our meal was ok and to check to make sure we had everything we needed! The food was excellent as well. Delectable sandwiches were had by all. My husband and I split the French dip grilled cheese with au jus and it was fabulous! We wish we had a sweet peppers near our home so that we could eat it again! My son had the bbq chicken with white sauce. He got extra white sauce for dipping because he liked the sauce so much! Fabulous sandwich shop in Starkville. Give them a try if you are ever in the area.

We love sweet peppers! Always clean! Staff is always friendly. We don't have one near us but…read morewe usually visit when in Starkville.

Great food and excellent service! We were in town for a baseball camp, heard this was a place we…read moreneeded to check out. I am glad we did, cool place and location, and the food, service and atmosphere are all great.

Used to be our go-to spot when we attended MSU! Came back for a game-day weekend and it NEVER…read moredisappoints. Whether you want a gameday brunch/lunch/dinner or late night cocktail with the college kids it's an amazing time. Friendly staff and food comes out quickly. I recommend a mimosa tower to start the day! Ordered: The smoked wings are the best wings I've ever had, large juicy and perfect w their signature sauces. I always get the pulled pork grilled cheese - amazing flavor, pork is always tender. They have a variety of tacos you can mix and match with your choice of side. Excellent. Fries were crispy and addictive. Can't wait to come back to Starkvegas for another delicious meal.

For someone that doesn't like sandwiches, this is beyond excellent. What makes them different from…read moreother joints is the sauce. The portions are huge, even the salads if you order a full size it feeds 2-3. Newk's Q is my favorite sandwich, and the lobster crab bisque my favorite soup. There are free pickles and hard breadsticks for appetizer. Plenty of parking, and great service!

Friendly staff, clean environment, and delicious food. This is my favorite lunch spot.read more

They need to quiz their drivers on places around Starkville. I can understand not knowing where my…read moreapartment is once, maybe twice if it's not the same driver, but three times in a short amount of time is kind of crazy. But the food is delicious and when the delivery knows where you live, it's blazing fast as always. Recommended for sure.

Yeah - do NOT do a delivery order from them. I ordered food on 2/5 at 1pm and I was told on the…read morewebsite the order was delivered. I checked - nothing. I called the store and was told that the order may have accidentally been delivered to my neighbor. I checked - nothing. Three hours later (while I was at work) someone from the store called to inform me that my order was delivered to South Montgomery (on the other side of town - no where near my house). In their defense, they did ask if I wanted the order redone (by now I was no where near my house) and... nothing. I filed a complaint online and... nothing. No refund, no apology, nothing. And it was over $50.00 worth of food - just gone. I might as well start sending my business Jersey Mike's way, since they seem to at least care.

I got the creole burger, which is in August special I would rate that at 7.8 out of 10 it was a…read morelittle greasy. I got the side of chips and queso and the queso is absolutely amazing and would rate 10 out of 10. They should make it an appetizer because we had to order two things of cheese. The Cajun fries were also a 10 out of 10. Our server was Ashley and was amazing and very attentive, not too much and not too little and had a great personality. Would love to come back.

We arrived at lunch (1PM) on a busy Saturday and were greeted by a somewhat frazzled server who…read moreoffered to seat us at the bar or we could wait for a table. We opted for bar seating and had water brought to us while we scanned the expansive drink menu. In addition to the signature cocktails, there is a variety of hard liquor, an amazing amount of whiskey, wine, (both red and white) as well as an impressive draft beer menu. It should be noted that there's a whiskey flight for $20 and you get a 1 ounce pour of each whiskey. It looks like there are seven on offer for this special. We didn't try it so cannot offer any more insights on that. We ordered the January gumbo special"Baby Duck Gumbo" - mine as is with chicken and sausage for $9 ( interestingly with okra which is only ever found in seafood gumbo ... at least in Louisiana) and the other with the addition of shrimp for $5 more. We asked for the saltines to be left off as we don't like to waste food and aren't fans of these old school standards. We split the brisket melt on marbled rye instead of Texas toast and left off the American cheese too... yeah we're *those* people... the sandwich comes with a choice of house seasoned fries or potato chips and we ordered the fries. The order arrived together (sigh). I would have preferred the gumbo to come first, then the sandwich, but hey, my mistake I guess I *should've* said something. Of course, I thought it was common sense that it should come in two courses instead of altogether. ... On a brighter not the order came just as we had requested and was a nice presentation. The gumbo was hearty and had plenty of protein albeit more rice than I would've liked. NOTE: if you are not an okra fan, beware. Both of us are good with okra so it was not a problem, but they do have plenty of okra in this gumbo. My dining partner said to skip the $5 add on of shrimp because although they are plentiful, they lack flavor. The sandwich is a decent size and was very tasty too and we both gave it a thumbs up. The fries were still hot and had a nice subtle flavor. Overall we'd give this roadhouse feeling, zany atmosphered little joint on the corner of Old West Point Rd and University a recommendation. The servers could use a refresher on how to greet guests and checking on them at least once during the meal :/ (1 star deduction) Oh, hey, they also have ample outdoor seating which is pet friendly for well behaved dogs.