My first visit today- and I think I'll be back. Overall very positive experience.
I ordered a decaf long black and rye bagel with cream cheese and plum jam. Both were A+. My decaf long black came out with a rich and creamy crema- which is a treat in itself as most cafes do not make a decent decaf. The bagel was beautiful with lashings of cream cheese and a the most delicious plum jam. Service was quick and efficient.
Being off the main street of West End, NYC Bagel Deli may have a tough time with competition. It was quiet while I was there, and didn't have the relaxed cool vibe as other places in the local area, but could easily be fixed with better music, more customers and a more open and friendly approach from staff. It was air-conditioned too, which is a plus during summer, but may have contributed to the closed-off feel. Would be hard to sit here for longer than 30 minutes with small seating area and lack of other customers around. read more