Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Ny Pizza

    5.0 (1 review)

    Ny Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Ny Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    We absolutely love this place! Best pizza ever, fantastic wings, great service and a a full bar. It's our new Saturday go to.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 18,454 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Pizza Twist

    Pizza Twist

    4.7(10 reviews)
    3.4 mi

    Interesting fast casual/counter order restaurant. They had a lot of traditional pizzas, but also…read moresome very unique options as well. The man at the counter was friendly and patient as we perused the menu a bit! We ordered 2 pizzas between the 3 of us: 1) Large hand tossed Hawaiian pizza 2) medium thin crust tikka masala pizza We had about 4 small slices of leftover pizza after our meal. The pizzas were good, and my favorite between the two would be the tikka masala pizzas. I loved the spicy chicken and fresh cut cilantro! I couldn't tell the difference between the thin crust and hand tossed pizza. They both looked and tasted the same, tbh. -1 star because the restaurant itself was hot, and smelled unpleasant.

    The pizzas here are unique for sure. The flavors are good. The problem is the prices you pay in…read morestore do not match the prices on their site if you order online. I'm not talking about online-only deals. Just the normal prices. I did not realize this until today. I WFH and this place is on the way home from my wife's job. Due to issues in the past with me ordering online and places giving her a hard time for not being me when she goes to pick the item up, she prefers to just ask me what to get, call in the order and pay in the store. Today we ordered one of the new naan lamb pizzas. When she got home she mentioned the naan pizza was pretty small (about 8 inches across or so) for the $17 she was charged. I was like.. $17? That was supposed to be $12. Showed her the prices online and compared to the receipt and it seems a mystery $5 was added to the base price. We looked back at the last time we got a medium detroit style pan that should have been $19 and it was $25. Not sure what's going on here other than maybe they're just adding the bs doordash/grubhub tax to all pickup orders but that seems kinda crappy.

    Photos
    Pizza Twist
    Pizza Twist
    Pizza Twist

    See all

    MrJims.Pizza - Pepperoni Deluxe with roasted garlic

    MrJims.Pizza

    3.9(31 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    So, the missus and I haven't been to Mr. Jims since the early 2000s when they were still on…read moreBallard. Not really because we didn't like them, it just never crossed our mind at the right time. Oh, we've driven by on lots of occasions and said to each other how we should give them a try, but we have always been just a little wary since there are never many cars outside. But I guessed that maybe there's no indoor seating at this location, and that part is right. Sure, there are some benches outside on a cute little deck if you want to weather the heat, but that's not something I care to do, generally speaking. Fast forward a bit and we saw a few of the ads talking about their new Detroit style with the narrow pans and all the yummy garlic-buttery deliciousness that you would get with all those edges. Curiosity got the better of us. We thought, why not give it a try? We like Detroit-style crust, and then there was that curiosity. Have we been cutting ourselves out of something we would really enjoy? I've seen them on the Slice app when we order take-out from Napoli's, so I tried that first. Detriot style you say? Not on that app. No worries, this is something new. I'm sure they just haven't got the menu update pushed out. Over to their actual web site and voila, Detroit-style is there! I pick their version of supreme, place the order and get a confirmation that would lead you to believe 15-20 minutes until hot, fresh pizza is ready to pick up. Well, if you read the bold print, that's all you would see, they do say "If time is of the essence, please call the store ... for a more specific pick up time." Totally get it. it's an estimate and it can be off. Drive to the store and walk in around the 15 minute mark. Honestly not too worried about it being done at that point, but wanted to be there when it was fresh out of the oven. I really wanted to enjoy this experience! Here's where the interesting kicks in. Mr. HighSchool-I'm-TooCoolForThisJobOrReallyForAnything "greets" me at the counter. I let him know I have an order for pickup and he asks me for my name. I give him my last name and since that didn't seem to garner a reaction of any recognition, I then give my first name too. "It's not ready". Totally fair, I really didn't expect it to be ready yet. The lady working back by the ovens speaks up and lets me know that it'll be about 10-15 minutes, it's the next one she's working on. "Sure, no worries." I stand by the window as I wait, I could've walked out to the truck, but remember I wanted the fresh experience and have the best chance to really like this? Well, Mr. TooCoolForYou just sort of disappears into the back. Ms. ITakeMyJobSuperSerious is clearly frustrated by his total lack of ... well... anything. Honestly, the lumps of dough in that place have more personality than he does. She calls for him, he ignores her, literally walks right by her while she's trying to talk to him and he doesn't give her the time of day. He's got one of those lumps of dough and is clearly not helping out with the fact that they are clearly behind on the orders coming in. You can tell she bears the weight of all of it and takes it very personally. Like, I'm a little worried she's going to break down and cry, have a stroke, or I'll be reading about how a pizza worker was stabbed multiple times in the local news. I'm just there watching this unfold and realizing how much all of this is stressing me out too. Then she calls the boss/owner? She's almost too upset to form sentences. She finishes the call and gets back to the boulder she's been pushing up the hill. I'm sure it has taken a lot for her to get to the point that she can't hold back even though she's got customers there to watch it all unfold. Someone else comes in to get an order. She calls for Mr. TooCoolForYou (my name for him, not hers), he looks out, sees there's a new customer and wanders away. She loses it a little with a blurted out "Seriously???!!!", then trys to regain her composure with not nearly the success she would probably have hoped for. Gets the customer name gets their order, the extra dressing they ask for and gets back to work on orders. Mr. TooCoolForYou is MIA right up until the customer is just about to head out the door. At this point I realize that the 10-15 was not an overestimate like I hoped, but rather more like what she hoped for, but was not going to get near. 25 minutes after getting there the "pizza" (more on that in moment) comes out. Mr. TooCoolForYou pulls it from the oven, boxes, slices and checks if my name is still Brian. I assure him it is and he hands me the box. I'm elated to be walking out of that stress box. The pizza. Is. Underwhelming. Those buttery, garlic-y edges? Crisp, sure, flavorful...no. and the toppings - I get it, she was the only one really working there - were strewn about with glops of sauce in some spots and half the other with none at all. Little Caesars does this one better. Really, don't bother.

    The online ordering was easy to navigate. The price was…read moregood for what you get. The pizza was ready on time, and the staff at the restaurant were nice. The pizza tasted good and it was hot and fresh. The only issue would be the amount of toppings. The pizza I ordered was supposed to have double beef (See description on photo) If this is double beef, imagine what single beef would look like. It makes me wonder about other "double" quantities. If I ordered double cheese, would I just be paying extra to get regular cheese?

    Photos
    MrJims.Pizza - Meat Eaters

    Meat Eaters

    MrJims.Pizza - Sticky Fingers Pizza

    Sticky Fingers Pizza

    MrJims.Pizza - Cheese Pizza

    See all

    Cheese Pizza

    Ny Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...