We were in town for a concert and, as one does, decided to order some pizza for the night. I don't know why we chose NY Pie, but I am glad we did. I only ate one of the two pizzas we got (although, I was told the 2nd was very yummy as well) .... my pick was an 18" with Ricotta and meatballs (pie cut). and .... I have to be absolutely honest with this. I use to go to NYC a lot. I would spend a week there, every year, for over a decade. And when I am out of town, I typically get pizza. I am a sucker for any place that claims its NY-style. But let's be honest. They NEVER are. They wish they were. NY Pie is the closest I have ever had to actually NY style pie. I mean, it was spot on. The only thing missing was - I didn't let it sit for a couple hours, then re-heat it. (Some of my friends did, however, and said it held up like a true NYC pizza). .... I know that's a weird flex. But if you know, you know. I would recommend this place to anyone going to Nashville. In fact, I am leaving this review to assure I can reference it at a later date, for myself. read more

Pretty good pizza joint. It's in the Nashville Burbs away from all of the Honky Tonk's and Bridal Shower Parties! If you have any idea what I am talking about, you get it. It is good to see the real world at last! I stopped by only because there is a Tesla Supercharger in the parking lot. Elon helping the community once again. Yay The Supercharger station has recently been upgraded so I may be back soon for some pizza. I come in and out of Nashville a bit in spurts. The crew was nice. They took care of me quite well. Counter service inside is all good. I forget if I got up or not. I just ordered a couple of slices on my visit. They reheated them well and they arrived all toasty. I got the meat junt along with a grandma slice. Both were really solid choices. I dig both styles so it's almost always a shoe in, bet. Those did perform well. I liked the crust, the sauces, the meats, the cheese, the spice was just right, and it was cooked perfectly, even on the reheat. I love pizza!! I bet a whole pie would be great. I will do that next. '26 - 27 read more

See all

We went here on our last night in Nashville because it was close to our hotel & it was really good. We got the BBQ Chicken pizza and a Greek Salad and it hit the spot. Being from Philly/NJ it is hard to find good pizza when down south but this was a hit. The restaurant was cute & the service was good. I would recommend this place if you need good pizza in your life! read more

NY Pie - 14" BBQ Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

We didn't know what to eat while in Nashville, but my wife found this place on Yelp. We gave it a try and it did not disappoint! The flavor was amazing and the customer service was top-notch. read more

See all

OMG I'm so glad I found this place!! 1. I am from NJ, NY pizza is supreme, all other kinds are trash. This actually tastes like NY pizza. 2. Ordering online was easy, I did pickup and it only took 20 min. 3. Pizza was fresh and hot, tasted great 4. Plenty of parking out front. I didn't stay to eat in but there was some seating. No complaints! See you again soon. read more

See all

This New Jersey native finally found a great slice of pizza in Nashville! NY Pie feels like a slice shop from up north, it's exactly what I've been waiting for. Plenty of options, heated up in minutes, served with no frills. I love this place. read more

NY Pie - Grandma slice and Hawaiian slice - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I went inside to pick up 2 slices of pizza because I was originally given them wrong item! I walk in and start getting yelled at by two employees saying you were here last Friday and that they already replaced my meal?? I was so confused and shocked and didn't know what to say. They were super rude and disrespectful to me. The guy (Caleb) said it must've been a different guy. So they both attacked me and was yelling at me for no reason! I was simply picking up my replacement meal that the manger Travis told me to come get !!! I will never spend a dime there again. And several other of people I know will not come back. read more

I'm from New Jersey....the pizza is legit !!! Fantastic undercarriage. I also appreciate these people are serious about pizza...also obvious that lots of regulars frequent this place read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

This small pizza shop has the real deal New York pizza. Some of the best NY style pie I've had in Nashville. The cheese, hawaiian, and buffalo chicken slices were all great. I also got the chicken salad with Italian dressing, and they loaded me UP on the chicken. Got my protein in. Also, my cashier Sam was super friendly and gave me all the good recommendations. read more

NY Pie - Chicken Salad - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Great food and awesome service John was super nice and helpful! Will definitely be coming back! read more

NY Pie - 10" Meatball Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I've been too over 1000 pizza places in my life at least and not one not one fucking place has ever delivered or gave me a pie that was not cut. Are you fucking out out of your mind who the fuck delivers a pizza on fucking cut and who the fuck on your app Wood put square cut double cut or no cut no cut would obviously mean it was a regular cut into eight slices not uncut whatsoever be fucking specific and use your fucking common sense. Has anyone ever the fuck ordered a pie uncut! Totally completely fucking unbelievably insanely unacceptable are you guys seriously fucking morons? Why would you even offer an uncut and why wouldn't you be specific! Fucking ridiculous absolutely fucking ridiculous. read more

Very good pizza, incredible cannoli and tiramisu. The service was amazingly quick and thoughtful. The staff here are excellent and look to be enjoying their work and it shows. Not quite true New Yorker pizza, but it's probably the closest I've had outside the NE. read more

Nope not worth the price it taste like sir pizza sorry just not for and I had lots of pizza in my life and this one don't cut it.

Pizza gets 5 stars, but service gets 1 star. Everyone working here seemed miserable. I felt very unwelcome. However, the pizza was very good. Maybe we'll just get take out next time. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Ordered ahead of time for pick up on a Friday evening. We ended up waiting a long time in the restaurant too, because it was so packed! The pizza was good though, so well deserved busyness! Hope to be back maybe on a weekday with less of a wait time! Limited amount of indoor seating. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

My husband and I both agree. It's the best pizza in town! It's loaded with yummy cheese, amazing sauce, and lots of toppings! I don't know how they do it, but I commend them immensely! read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I've been wanting to try this place & finally in the area so ordered to-go & so happy I did! This place was really good.. I ordered the small meat pizza, 6 slices.. enough for 1-2 people depending on how hungry you both are. It had tons of meat and the sauce was so good & flavorful. The staff were really friendly as well. I will definitely be back! read more

came here for a late lunch with my boyfriend, we ordered a salad and pizza to share and everything tasted amazing!

We had the Margherita and cheese and it was amazing! Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and crust was so perfectly crunchy. 10/10

Solid pizza spot! We got a half and half NY cheese and buffalo chicken and they were so accommodating making only 2 slices w/ blue cheese and 2 without on the buffalo chicken side so my boyfriend and I could both be happy. They were even so kind to point out which ones had the blue cheese when they gave us the order. The garlic knots were pretty good and the greek salad was so fresh (and HUGE). The pizza itself was so fresh, cheesy and had amazing flavor. Will be back soon to try more of the flavors! read more

Pizza was amazing! I love a saucy pie and this was perfect. Crust great with just a little black on the bottom Only negative was I used delivery and the guy just left it outside in 40 degree weather. No call no doorbell. Had to heat it up and still great read more

Pizza is bland....very mechanical ...tried twice don't believe the hype...do they even try there own products

We recently ordered delivery from NY Pie on Charlotte and were pretty impressed with their pizza! We got a half n half pepperoni and cheese NY style and it was loaded with cheese and perfectly foldable. We also got the garlic knots, which were just ok, but the marinara they were served with was fantastic! Will definitely eat here again! read more

One of my favorite places! I make an hour+ round trip drive here twice a week. Best pizza in tennessee

I had a late lunch here and was very hungry. I am not to familiar with New York style pizza, so I technically don't know how it is supposed to be. I wasn't overly impressed. When you walk in, the front counter has individual slices to buy. I ordered a small margarita pizza which took about 10 minutes to prepare. I engulfed it and ordered a slice of cheese pizza because I was still hungry. I compared the Margherita to the cheese pizza and each had their strong points. The margherita had that fresh basil coming through. The cheese pizza was much more savory with the cheese combination. The pizza sauce and dough was fair, but the whole experience was not enough to bring me back. read more

See all

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and it was burned on top and bottom - not really edible at all - the last 2 pizzas I ordered here were like this. I called and spoke to the girl who answered the phone advising that I come in frequently and the last two times the pizza was burned and I wanted to see if something had changed (new ovens. - something to explain) her reply was nothing has changed and asked if that was all - no I'm sorry, no let me get the manager, no offer of compensation- zero anything, she made it clear she didn't care. I said well I guess we have to find a new pizza place - still nothing..... click. read more

Might be my new favorite slice in Nashville (wish it was closer to the city)!) Quality ingredients and quality pizza.

NY Pie makes decent pizzas at a rate that doesn't feel like you'll need to start slinging pies on the side to pay for the meals. All jokes aside, we primarily do pick-up for the variety of pizza options they serve here. I'm partial to more classic varieties like their margarita with buffalo mozzarella, but they have options that are more contemporary like sriracha chicken. Service in terms of a to-go stand point is pretty efficient. We can typically put in an order within an hour and pick it up on the way home. While we haven't dined in, my spouse often comments that it would be a perfect place to do a family dinner with our young one. Parking is ample in a quaint shopping strip, but there are bustling businesses nearby, so just be mindful when you decide to pull into the lot. read more

This is a pretty good to almost great pizza carryout spot. We were doing a monthly Costco run with the intent of grabbing a pepperoni pie from there to go only to discover their food court (as of January 2024) was out of commission (horrors!). So thanks to Yelp, I quickly discover we're 2 minutes away from NY Pie. I call them and order a large meat pizza and an order of garlic knots. Picked it up and it was ready right when they said it would be, got it home and feasted. There was enough left over for us to get another entire meal out of it and everything heated up perfectly in the oven. The slices are HUGE, NY style. Great crust, great toppings. Everything cooked well. The garlic knots are like giant rolls, and pretty good as well. Pricewise, we definitely spent more than we would have with the prices stuck 40 years ago menu from Costco, but the pizza is of much better quality. With tip, $40+ for all of the above. A loyalty program via your phone that seems cool. Friendly, funny service at the counter by folks who seem to like what they do. Not a top 5 Nashville pizza joint, but a better than solid one and I'll be back. read more

Their pizza always tastes delicious, they are very accurate with their time if you are ordering out, and the service is one of the best in the area. This is my go to pizza spot (if you like traditional NY pizza). read more

I've been to this location (west) 1 time before and felt myself starting to get hangry so I needed something quick. The first time, I didn't care for the food. The second time, I can say I had a much better experience. I ordered 2 slices of pep, and they came out fresh just a few minutes after I ordered. I can only speak this truth: I will return to get pizza here again, but only for the cheese and pep slice. I don't trust a lot of pizzerias with anything but the basic slice. But this slice was great. My suggestion: dress it up with seasoning, parm, and crushed red pep. Bonus: customer service is 10/10. I walked in wearing a buffalo bills hat and the guy behind the counter wearing a 49ers hat put on the Bills shout song (IYKYK). A great guy, good experience, good food. read more

NY Pie - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Great correct proportioned Pizza Pies. Some places add too much sauce or cheese because they don't know any better, NY Pie does! This is the closest to my NY Bronx Pizza I grew up with. read more

NY Pie - Large pizza pie!! NY Style. - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

NY Pie was the absolute best pizza. It was good hot and cold. If you are looking for a pizza that will make you want to come back, it's here! read more

The best pizza in town just go ahead and try it and you will see why everything is so delicious and service is amazing, thank you keep up the golden work read more

See all

NY Pie is awesome with a smallish shop with wonderful well deserving five star pizza place. My dad loves it there from the employees to the quickness to the taste of the actual pizza. This is why we have been going there for more than five years. Thank you for everything you do and we will keep on coming. read more

Don't get me wrong, the pizza is GREAT! I ordered through Uber and the box is not secured to deter tampering. In the age of food delivery, ensuring the food packaging is tamper resistant is quite important. This is easily accomplished by stickers securing the box that a customer can tell if it's been tampered with. Very uneasy with my food being easily accessible to the delivery driver (who I have NO issues with). The concern is around your customers' safety. I'll try again and hopefully this feedback will be taken into consideration. read more

Every time I come in here, the managers seem so mean to the staff. But the staff is so sweet! I hope it's not always like this! As always my slices were divine! read more

NY Pie and Joey's House of Pizza were my go-to's for the best pizza in Nashville. Now that Joey's has closed, NY Pie is Absolutely the BEST NY-style pie I've in Nashville. I live in East Nashville and travel to NY Pie in West Nashville at least twice a month to get my fix. There's not another shop that can beat their sauce or just the right amount of crunch on that crust for the perfect fold. And, you gotta fold pizza for it to be truly a NY pie. read more

Second time here. When we are in Nashville (and then we bring it home to Clarksville). Had every intention of trying a new place this time, you know, give someone else a try. Nope, hubby (lived in NY) says let's not bother, this pizza is fire. It was. Again. Yum. Period. read more

Can't remember the last time I had pizza and legit NY Pizza ... it's been years. I saw someone try this pizza joint on Tik Tok and it looked like the real think so I was like I gotta try this. So while running errands I ventured over to #nypienashville @nypienashville First off like the NY Pizzerias they sell #slices they had 10 different #pizzas to chose from I figured I would try 4 to go for today and tomorrow. #pepperoni and #sausage the sausage is very tasty. Also one they call #grandmas I believe it is #margarita plain pepperoni and #pizzabianca white pizza. The #sauce is good. Pepperoni not too spicy. The #crust #thin #crispy. They had other varieties which I will need to try. I was told the #sarachi #chicken is a must try. Also they have #cannolis and #tiramisu and of course #nycheesecake Service was polite and helpful. The restaurant is inviting, clean but I could see it filling up very quickly. Looks like I got a new go to pizza parlor. Yum read more

See all