I would have loved to rate this local business higher, but these cookies were not good. I hate to say it, but there's a reason that they're "not as famous". They're very expensive and hard and not great flavor-wise. Tbh the cookies were better on Day 2 or 3 than on the first night we got them. Thats what took this rating from a 1-star to a 2-star rating read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bag of cookies: 4 different flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

Craving something sweet and realized not only did I have Not As Famous cookie in my bookmarks, it was pretty close to my house. Ambiance: Store was clean and service was quick, menu is large on the wall and the open concept allows you to see the workers doing everything. Cookies: 3 cookies for $10 I believe. I got the Christmas Sugar, Apple Pie and Oatmeal. Christmas sugar was for sure my favorite, the shape made for crispy edges with a soft center. The apple pie cookie was not it. My boyfriend and I both rated it as "meh". If I was in desperate need for a cookie I would maybe go back otherwise I'm ok with just trying it once. read more

See all

What a treat -- literally! I stopped in after a friend recommended it and I'm so glad I did. The young lady behind the counter was kind, helpful and super patient with all the questions I had since it was my first time there. It's Black-owned, which I love, and everything about it was such a vibe. I ordered the deep dish cookie with pumpkin spice cookie base and cookie dough ice cream on top -- heaven. They have several ways to mix and match your cookie + ice cream combo, which makes it even more fun. A must-try dessert spot -- I'll definitely be back to try more combos. read more

See all

Although it wasn't my first time trying a cookie from Not As Famous Cookie, it was my first visit to their storefront. My husband and I stopped by on Friday night after dinner. The place wasn't overly crowded, but there was a steady flow of customers. We ordered our favorite, the red velvet skillet cookie topped with ice cream and drizzled with caramel. During our last visit, we had selected the cookies and cream ice cream. Since we were at the store, we decided to try a few new flavors, including the bourbon truffle and the strawberry cheesecake. The bourbon truffle was our favorite out of the two, so we settled on that one. While our dessert was being prepared, we opted to sit outside to enjoy the nice weather. There is seating both indoors and outdoors, but we preferred the outdoor atmosphere. When our skillet cookie was ready, it looked fantastic. The taste was even better! However, the edges were a bit too crispy and hard to cut through. Aside from the crispy edges, the flavors were delicious, and we thoroughly enjoyed our dessert. We look forward to visiting again and trying something different. If you're in the area, be sure to check them out! read more

See all

Millions of people quicker, friendly enough, decent selection of cookies nothing too gourmet so a lot of basic cookie flavors just elevated their ice cream flavors surpass their cookie flavors they do serve good cookies, five out of 10 read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Assorted Variety Grab Bag of Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

Visited the truck they had at an event, service was good and I feel like the prices were fair. However, the cookies just.. aren't good. They just have no flavor and feel undercooked and are kind of reminiscent of playdough. We tried multiple flavors and none of them were impressive. We'll continue to support the Publix bakery. read more

One word, AMAZING! My husband and I found this place via an app and I'm glad we did! Will definitely go back! Parking: Plentiful! It's located in The Shops at Belmont shopping center, so even if you can't park directly in front of the establishment, you'll never be far from it. Food: AMAZING! I got the banana pudding ice cream. It's soft & just the right amount of sweet. My husband got a cookies & cream milkshake which was made using an actual cookie. It was so good that he finished it before we got home. I did get one sip but that was it, lol. Customer service: Veronica assisted us and she was really nice, kind, and patient and she provided excellent customer service. She explained how they change their menu once a month, allowed samples, and made great recommendations. Overall: Excited to see what October menu will be and will definitely go back. Glad we discovered this place. read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

TLDR: 3/5 - For some reason still slightly too hard around the edges specifically, some overly sweet but at least the price was fair considering other competition. Ordered: Chocolate Chip: 2/5 - Where art thou the chocolate chips?? I had one in every 3 bites. Needed more salt. Red Velvet: 3/5 - not actually overly sweet but there wasn't much going on otherwise Christmas Sugar: 2/5 - White chocolate just aren't ever the move. I think I would've liked it a little more without it but with it it just makes it too sweet. Service: Great! The girl at the counter seemed sweet. Cute storefront as well. I can't say if I would go back but if times are desperate... read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

We had a Kyri's cookie in our neighborhood and we loved it but it closed. I've been looking for another gourmet cookie to match that and came across this place. I got a variety. It's good! It's not great, but good enough to satisfy a gourmet cookie fix. Of note, My son liked the sugar cookie but none of us liked the red velvet. read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

It looks like they rotate their menu monthly but probably keep a couple of the classics, like chocolate chip. I tried the honey bun and the lemon blueberry. The edges were crispy while the middle was super soft, almost like an uncooked texture and taste. The overall flavor of the cookies were just ok. 2 cookies came to $9.01. So it's pricey and wasn't really worth it to me due to taste and texture. read more

See all

This was a nice place to stop for a treat, and a paradise for people in search of a cookie ice cream sandwich. I had a Cookie Monster cookie with cookies and cream ice cream, and it was very tasty. I don't think I made the right selections for me because the cookie was a little too sugary-sweet to me - I probably would have preferred some dark chocolate in there somewhere. But the service was good, and there was a little area to sit in the front. We'll be back! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Cookie bowl! - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

So my kids told me this place has THE BEST cookies ever, so I had to see for myself. Let me say this, I am cookie conneseiur, and I have enjoyed cookies all over this fine city! That being said, I was skeptical until... I bit into the Chocolate Chip cookie . Now, I am a believer! The cookies were OUTSTANDING! Brian and Amari waited on me, and they were the absolute best. The service was superb. I am a chocolate chip cookie girl, but they have lots of other flavors. Check this place out and tell them you saw Lynn's review on YELP! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Front of "Not So Famous" Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

I have been wanting to try Not As Famous Cookie for so long. I love desserts and I love trying new sweet spots. The staff that we're working were awesome and super helpful. They have a ton of different cookie flavors and ice cream flavors, and I knew I wanted to try an ice cream sandwich. I ended up ordering a red velvet cookie and a birthday sugar cookie with birthday ice cream. The red velvet cookie was warm and soft and really good and doughy, the ice cream was OK, and the sugar cookie on the bottom was hard. So it was kind of hard to eat because I couldn't use my spoon to cut through to the bottom hard cookie. It was just kind of disappointing for $8.50. I was pretty overwhelmed with the number of choices, so I would definitely be willing to try it again, and maybe go a little simpler with what I order! read more

See all

Best cookies in the Atl area! Seriously. And black owned! Always receive friendly service.

Better thank Crumble!!! If you are looking for a cookie, this is a dang on cookie-lol! Thick and huge! I was really impressed with the quality and richness and it took me 2 days to eat 1 cookie and I had 3. The 3 for $10 is probably the best value, but this is the cutest little cookie shop. I like! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

Today (2-26-2022), I visited Not As Famous Cookie Company in Smyrna. The store has easy access, located in a shopping center at a stop light, and with plenty of free parking. The store is bright, modern, and very clean. The staff was friendly. They asked if it was our first time and explained their cookies, ice cream, and combo options. The aroma in the store was intoxicating. They are baked fresh and there is plenty of variety. The cookies are great! Gooey, soft, and a good size.... definitely worth the price. My complaint (and reason for my rating of 4) is the packaging. Our M&M cookie had just come out of the oven and was warm. That's fantastic if I was eating the cookie immediately, but we took ours home. Our six cookies were stacked 3 high. They molded together. Our Fruity Pebbles, M&M, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip with Pretzels are stuck together so we can't enjoy half of the cookies we purchased. I think it's a great cookie spot and recommend you check them out, but don't let them stack your cookies, especially if they are warm. I doubt the same thing would happen if they have cooled. I think a box or some other packaging would eliminate this issue. Nothing is more frustrating than not being able to enjoy something that smells and looks delectable. read more

See all

I happened to be reading a blog post from What Now Atlanta months ago and made a mental note to visit. I remember reading the article and heading straight to the website to see what all this cute little shop offered and was immediately excited about this place. Oooooooo how I've been thinking about stopping by for some cookies...and finally...on a whim....I made it. Located in The Shops at Belmont shopping area, there's plenty of free parking so just park and head right in. When we arrived, I loved that there was a board outside the door listing all the different types of cookies so I kinda had an idea of what it wanted before I stepped inside. As I walked in, a young man greeted me and guided me to the menu on the wall with alllll the sweet treats offered (cookies, ice cream). There was also a cute little display with a bunch of cookies and I was just overwhelmed with joy starting at them. My husband and I decided to get half a dozen - 2 sugar, 2 chocolate chip, and 2 cranberry white chocolate macadamia nut. When I got that cute little paper bag with a little window in it showing me the yummy cookies, I just couldn't contain myself...anddddd they were warm! I ate one of the cranberry white chocolate macadamia nut cookies on the way home and my goooodnesssss. It was so warm and soft and just amazing and heavenly. Just the kind of sweet treat I needed on a cool night. I will definitely be back because the service was outstanding and I'm excited to try the other flavors!!! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

These were the WORST cookies I've ever had. They look great in photos but had the strangest texture and were sickening. They were completely stale and flavorless! read more

My husband and I love this place. The owner and the workers are always so pleasant and can give recommendations. We love how they change flavors each month, which keeps things interesting and fun for different flavor choices. I haven't had a cookie I haven't liked from here. So good! read more

I've seen the Not as Famous Cookie Truck scooting around town, so it is really cool to see the brick and mortar finally open up, especially because it is not too far from my house! So, fresh new spot for some of the freshest cookies in Cobb County!! Located inside of the shopping plaza that is anchored by Creatwood Tavern at the corner of Atlanta Road and Windy Hill sits Not As Famous Cookie Company's spot! They sit on the Windy Hill side of the shopping center in the building where Cielo sits. Given the shopping center, parking is a breeze and should never be an issue! The place isn't large, but it is purposeful and perfect in size for what they do! The place is 70% kitchen, so get ya cookies or ice cream and keep it moving! This definitely needs to be the case as it gets a little cramped when the crowd/line starts to build...which I imagine is going to be often! Menu boards are all over. They have a chalk sign outside stating the current flavors of the week, same sign on the counter for cookies, as well as ice cream flavors. On the wall is the pricing and product board. It details out the cost and all the offerings from cookies, to ice cream scoops and sandwiches to floats. Pricing starts at $3 for cookies and are served in 1, 3, 6 or 12 counts. We got a sample of 3 cookies. Chocolate Chip, Red Velvet Chocolate Chip and Cinnamon Toast Crunch. That Red Velvet Chocolate Chip cookie was fantastic! It was light, yet sturdy, soft yet firm with the perfect balance of sweetness! Looking at their menu, it appears they have a lot of really great flavors to offer. I hope they get to the place where they dont have to rotate their full cookie menu and can offer more of their specialty flavors more consistently! But for right now, as long as they keep those chocolate chip cookies on the rack... Overall, really awesome to see this place open up! Very happy to support these phenomenal folks and I mean, having a cookie store nearby ain't the worst thing that can happen! read more

See all

They were a sponsor for the resent yelpies and provided their delicious goodies for all the attendees. I'm not sure the name of the cookie i got but it was delicious! These cookies are larger than your standard cookies and full off flavor and sugary goodness! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Box - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

A friend of mine attended the Grand Opening and after seeing all the pictures they posted of their cookies I had to come and try this new spot out myself. My husband and I visited on a Saturday around 3:00pm. Their operating days and hours are limited so make sure you visit the website before coming, their hours are listed and which cookies they are offering is also listed. There were 6 flavors of cookies being offered and we decided to order 1 of each cookie so that we could taste them all. The cookies were all thick and very large. The flavors were rich and tasted homemade. My favorites amongst the 6 we had was the Cookies and Cream and Butter Cookie. My husband enjoyed the Red Velvet and the Chocolate chip the most. My diet does not typically allow cookies but I made an exception and I am glad I did. If you are a fan of cookies I would suggest adding Not As Famous Cookie Company to your list of must try establishments. read more

See all

I was looking for to a cookie but the chocolate chip at Not as Famous was definitely not as good. The outside edges were cooked but the middle of the cookie was gummy. And didn't have a good flavor. I couldn't tell if it was the fat/ shortening they used, it just had a funny taste. The chocolate chips had no taste except sweet. And I hate counter service that expects a tip. read more

Not as Famous is a cute cookie & ice cream shop in Smyrna! They offer different cookie flavors weekly and serve a variety of different ice cream flavors! I ordered the Red Velvet, Chocolate Chip Pecan & the St. Patricks Day sugar cookie! They have 1/2/3 scoop ice cream options, but you can't mix the flavors (example: 2 scoops, 1 vanilla, 1 chocolate) it had to be 2/3 scoops of one flavor. Which womps when you want to enjoy more than one flavor. My Fiancé said the ice cream was really good, he had the cookies and cream! Overall the establishment was very clean, the staff was very nice and patient with us, the cookies were delicious , soft and great portion sizes! The only down fall was not being able to try two different ice cream options, otherwise, I'd definitely return for more delicious cookies @ Not as Famous Cookies! read more

See all

Had these cookies for the first time! They came in a cute little bag. I tried the Cookie Butter yesterday and the Cookie Monster as well as the Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip today. Decent cookies. For my personal taste, I prefer soft, gooey cookies with a little crunch on the outside, if not completely soft. The outside of the bag says "But better than..." after their name, and I am sad to report that I disagree. For me, Sugar Shane's stuffed cookies give that gooey and melty with a perfect crunch, and Crumbl gives that decadent softness. All three Not As Famous cookies I've tried so far have been over baked for my preference. I tried the cookies at room temperature as well as warmed up to see if it made a difference. Room temperature they're solid and hard in your hand and in your mouth. Heating them up helped soften them, but they still didn't live up to standard for me. If you have to rely on an oven or a microwave to reheat to provide soft cookies, they should at least become exceptionally gooey upon doing so, like Sugar Shane's... not here. The Red Velvet so far has warmed up to be the softest although I preferred the flavor of the Cookie Butter. The Cookie Monster cookie was a good choice for breakfast this morning because of the oatmeal and low amount of sweetness. Over all, the flavors are pretty good and the sweetness level is mild to medium. What makes these cookies stand apart from other cookie companies is the unique shape. I think it's fun, but it also makes me wish that ball was a glob of raw cookie dough on top of the baked cookie. It's not. If you prefer your cookies hard or just a little soft upon warming, where it still completely holds shape, these cookies are for you. I'll be trying the praline pecan later to see how that one ranks. Perhaps I just got a mediocre batch, but it's hard to use that excuse when it's several different flavors of cookies that were most likely not baked together in the same batch. An off day maybe? Despite my disappointment, I am still thankful for the cookies because 1. This is a business doing their thing and 2. my boyfriend got them for me as a surprise while he's out of town. I am grateful. I told him they were so yummy and tried to sound enthusiastic, but I think he caught onto me. The honest review is here on Yelp. I'd be interested in giving them a second chance when he comes back, to see if my opinion changes. read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Cookie butter, red velvet white chocolate chip, cookie monster, praline pecan - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

I am not a cookie person. But I've had cookies from *a very famous cookie place* and I think Not as Famous runs circles around them. I came and got the 3 cookies for $9 deal: -honey bun -chocolate covered strawberry cookie -valentine's cookies and cream (or something like that - it was a cookies and cream cookie with strawberries throughout) The cookies are nice and chewy - with the exception of the valentine one, I think it had maybe sat in the oven too long because the outer portions were just hard so i tore them off. That *very famous cookie place* had cookies so chewy they were borderline doughy and that makes me gag. So they definitely got the soft level correct here. The cookies are also pretty big. So I ate one per day. I thought that by the third day they would be hard like the first one, but I nuked each one in the microwave about 15 seconds, and it was the same great chewyness. It was like it reactivated the butter or something, idk. Still as tasty as the day I bought them. Guy at the counter kinda shoved the bag into my hand because there were people behind me waiting, but before they walked in he was friendly enough. Their menu changes every month so that's at least one time per month I'll be coming back. read more

I come to this area frequently, but the store isn't open some days so I've been excited to try when it was. When I first walked in, the girl working the front was sitting down. She was polite while greeting me, but short and to the point while pointing out what the cookies look like, flavors and pricing. She tried to sit back down before I told her I already knew what I wanted. The cookies don't look appetizing really, they're just scooped from the batter onto a tray but they are a pretty good size. I got 3- chocolate chip, cookie butter and red velvet. I waited until I got home to share with my bf. First, the cookies were hard and I hate hard cookies. I gave him the edges and tried the center which was a bit softer. Chocolate chip- super bitter and had an odd taste. Maybe they used semi sweet chocolate chips. Red velvet- no flavor really, not sweet just meh. Cookie butter- okay, tasted like caramel that's about it. The texture of the cookies is odd, they're hard and kind of grainy. My bf isn't picky and loves sweets, he even said he wouldn't get these again. I hate wasting money but they ended up being thrown away. I really feel sad and contemplated leaving a review because I do want to support a Black owned business, but it just wasn't it for us. read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Chocolate Chip Cookie Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip Cookie Cookie Butter Cheesecake Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

Came in last weekend to pick up some cookies. They weren't crowded when we went in around 2pm on Sunday. They have new flavors monthly. We decided to get the chocolate chip and chocolate chip walnut to keep it classic. They were served warm but we ate them a bit later in the day. They were very pricey for that sized cookie too. When we got home, we warmed them up, but they didn't get gooey like cookies usually do when you warm them up. They had a slightly off flavor about them too. Maybe we got a bad batch? Seems like a cool business with some unique flavors so might be worth to check them out. Maybe we got unlucky read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Chocolate chip and chocolate chip walnut - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

If you love crunchy cookies like myself, this is a great place. I order three cookies from the menu and they all turned out fantastic. Each cookie had a nice crunch to them without being hard. Highly recommend this over crumbl! read more

I had a good first experience. I ordered lemon blueberry (my fav), red velvet, and birthday cake. All were soft and delicious. The staff was helpful in helping me with my decision-making. I like how the menu changes monthly. If I lived closer, I'd def frequent more often! But I'll be back! See on... IG/TikTok: @ChrissyEatsAtl read more

OMGGGGGGG these cookies are seriously delicious. I ordered some to Phoenix and they arrived two days later soft and fresh. These are the best cookies ever. I ordered a dozen mixed with chocolate chip and snicker doodle. I was planning on sending half to work with my husband but changed my mind after my first bite. Lol The cookies came wrapped in groups of three, very easy for sharing. Presentation is everything and they did an awesome job. I'll definitely be ordering again soon!!!! read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Presentation is everything - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

I wish liked these cookies more because I live close by. I had a red velvet, July 4th, and pb cookie. The texture is a little too sticky and hard for my liking. It's very different from Sugar Shane's and Crumbl. Overall, just not my type of cookie but everyone should experience at least once to see if they like it. Best wishes. read more

Totally recommend. Delicious and portions are worth the price. You will not be disappointed

This place has come a long ways since I first visited them in 2021. Their cookies are the absolute best. I love how creative this shop is for creating cookies that no one else has. I only wish them the best for years to come. read more

So I ordered 3 cookies on Sunday. Let's just say I didn't even leave my parking spot before devouring my first one. Finger licking good. Ordered the chocolate chip, red velvet and M&M one. Chocolate chip was gooey and meaty and soft and warm and so so good. Red velvet was delicious and so was the M&M one. They were served in a nice little brown bag. I ordered online ahead of time and walked in to pick them up with NO wait on a Sunday afternoon. You could tell the cookies were freshly made. And they did not disappoint me one bit. They're kind of tucked away in the shopping center but plenty of parking. I'll be a frequent customer for sure. Glad to have found this hidden gem! read more

When you wanna satisfy that sweet tooth craving, you need to try this spot. I'm sure they have something you'll love, whether you simply desire a few cookies or a crazy milkshake. They also offer deep dish cookies with some delicious ice cream along side it. You can't go wrong with a stop here. I first discovered them at their food truck when it came through my neighborhood and I fell in lobe with their cookie ice cream sandwich. I'm telling y'all, you'll be addicted‼ read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Deep Dish Cookie with Ice Cream on the Side - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

These cookies are so good and the flavors are so creative! The service is amazing and everyone is so friendly. I love this place and their cookies :) read more

All three were great! The thicker two (chocolate chip and oreo cheesecake) were crispy on the outside but chewy and soft inside. It was not just sugary overload flavor but actually tasted good and like their flavor. The lemon blueberry was a nice balance of the two, not too overwhelming. Also, this place is black owned! Will be back. read more

See all

My husband and I were in town visiting from Rhode Island and I saw this place while I was heading to another store. We decided to stop in and I'm so happy we did , the staff there was Amazing. The service was above and beyond , I wanted to try the Banana pudding ice cream and they were out . I mention to the one of the employees that we had come from RI and he went the extra mile to make sure I was happy. The ice cream was delicious I almost went back inside to get a bigger one but after his fight to get me one scoop I didn't want to put him thru that again Next time we're in town we will definitely be returning after thie service we received from your staff. Keep up the good work guys... read more

My GOODNESS! THAT was REAL Large moist decadent cookies... Real rich creamy ice cream?!? Whateva they ask you to pay, jus PAY it and smile all the way back to the car. Thank me later read more

Not As Famous Cookie - Yaaassss....come thru BOB!! - Bakeries Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia