Those who "Know me", they know 2 things. One, is I've been a Chef for many years. Two, is that I'm a big time "Pizza Snob". So, this place went "Viral" when they first opened. Talk about innovation, these guys harnessed a rotating bread oven, into a magic pizza making machine. And it was good. Real, real good! And then the dreaded "Staten Island" rumor mill started. Saying," they changed". And that the pizza just was not the same? Well I'm a big believer in second chances! One thing I can say is this pizza travels extremely well! And does not lose as much in the dreaded "Cardboard box" as does most "Great Pizzas" so I literally just ordered from them, and you can "Burn The Staten Island Rumor Mill to the ground" nothing has changed! For starters, this is still the best pizza"Traveling Pizza Around" and the quality is well above average on all levels! It's not on that "Mega-Pizza Plane" but it's real close! This is probably The best traveling pizza on Staten Island! And that's a BIG compliment! HIGHLY RECOMMEND read more

Pizza is thin and delicious. Delicious sauce and cheese. Very friendly staff, BUT, there are no tables & the place is very small. Four uncomfortable stools with a tiny counter. No air conditioning. Unless you're going to eat it in the car or take it home, forget it. Again, the pizza is fabulous. read more

Full disclosure...We ordered a traditional cheese pizza for pickup and live roughly 10 minutes away. This pizza was truly outstanding for what it offers. The crust was the deciding factor for me...I haven't had a beautiful crust like that since New Haven, Connecticut. The sauce was on the sweet side and the cheese was fairly light. I am so happy I tried this pizzeria & I cannot wait to come back. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

4.50 for a half burned slice. Mentioned it to the staff and they could not care. Unless you order pies steer clear.

Best pizza on Staten Island. Unique variety. Perfect crisp. Quality toppings. Also tried the vodka chicken parm on their giant homemade garlic knot. Was absolutely amazing. Can't wait to get back there. Joe JM. read more

Great pizza, great price and fast delivery to the surrounding area. What more can one ask for. If you need good Italian delivered fast for a price that doesn't empty you out, then Nonna is a treasure you need to keep in mind. read more

This has to be some of the worst pizza I've ever eaten. The pizza was so thin and hard, it doesn't even resemble Pizza. That's not how you make it. There's no taste. Needless to say I will never be going back there. read more

They don't answer their phones for reservations or answer e-mails for reservations. We came all the way from Chicago, took the Staten Island ferry to say sorry we are booked until the middle of August. When we told them what we tried they said well sometimes Joe answers the phone, how rude!! Terrible way to run a business! Waste of my time!!! Will never go back! read more

I loved the pizza crust and the sauce. The service is quick and the staff is very friendly. Is a comfortable environment.

My family decided to try this pizzeria and happy that we did. The sauce was too sweet for me but the crust was outstanding. Service and ambience were good. Will definitely be there again. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great service and the pizza was great definitely going back again service was really nice

Excellent food and service , the kitchen is kept completely spotless , you'll never find a cleaner kept kitchen . a family owned and run business that treats all its customers like family . From Big Fran down to little Frannie as well as all of the workers , including the delivery drivers , they treat everyone with the utmost respect . All Good People , will remind you of the good ole days . Every employee treats all the customers the way you wish to be treated . Love everything about this business , I'm sure they will be around for generations to come . read more

Where do we begin .... Long over due 5 start review ... My brother Artie introduced us to Nonna's years ago when having all his kids birthday parties .... On the average my brother would order at least 8 to 10 pies for our family & friends to enjoy .... From the dough that makes an awesome crust to the quality of cheese & unbelievable sauces they make are all their different pies are just off the chain delicious ... Me & the wife had a party on the island & we were early so we had to go have a few slices to tie us over .... Their Philly slice & their Alfredo & spinach artichoke & their vodka slice & eggplant parm ....., Need I say more ... we love this place & dining in is way better then waiting on delivery... order one slice at a time & go take a look on their counter to see what pies just came out .... Luckily we met the owner Franny who came into the dining room to ask my wife & I if the room was warm enough ... it was a cold day ... Franny is a great guy, friendly and very proud of the pizza & food that he creates .... Wish he had another Pizza shop In Brooklyn .... Just saying ... lol Thanks to the entire staff who were polite & gave us great service ... Greg D & family read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Bacon & Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Great pizza. Fantastic service. Owner Frankie is friendly and personable. 3 counter stool seats. Mostly takeout or delivery. Garlic knots looked great and other customer said they tasted same. We ate and shared three slices. 1. Jalapeño pepperoni and hot honey. Flavors complemented one another. 2. Eggplant also very good. Has tomato sauce ricotta and eggplant and Romano. Very very good. 3. Burrata pizza. Excellent. Got a Burrata pie to go too. 4. Stuffed eggplant pizza pie. Excellent. Nice crust of pizza shells sandwiching the eggplant ricotta mozzarella etc and they gave us a container of tomato sauce for dipping. Delicious. We will definitely be back and try some other types. Really like the burrata and stuffed eggplant pies. The owner was even eating his own pizza. That's how good it is. Can't wait to go back and try clam pizza and even the plain pies look great. So many choices. We will be back. Everything tasted fresh Yum! Delish. read more

See all

Hey guys me and my son travel the tri state areas in tasting the best Pizza around I have to say if your in Staten Island Nonnas old fashion pizza makes the best and we have tried many pizzerias before this one is the perfect Pie and Slice they make pizza too perfection from the crust sauce and cheese and the freshness one of my favorites in Staten Island go try it. read more

See all

I'm still not sure if a had a slice of pizza or a slice of tasteless cardboard yesterday. Gross.

Pizza had no taste was so thin isn't fell apart and rice ball was as horrible. Much better pizza places out there

This was already on my bucket list of places to try so when my friend suggested a pizza outing and mentioned Nonna's I said "yeah" So glad we tried this place. Had dining room to ourselves and ordered 3 different types of special slices including pepperoni, buffalo chicken and lasagna. They were all delicious and got devoured. The staff was friendly and I'll definitely be back with more people next time! read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Best everyday pizzeria in Great Kills. My favorite is the upside down round pie. It's a little packed of an area but I always find a parking spot. read more

Absolutely delicious Pizza. The perfect pie. A+++ This pizza has all the crunch, flavor, etc... You know it's good when you can reheat it the next day and it tastes like it was just made. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Nonnas Perfect Pie - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Thin slice cheese slice saucy slice everything slice! One of the best pizza on the island! Its interesting where you drive by and might think it is closed due to its cage exterior, but if you take a step in you'll find the amazing different choices of pizza. Everything looked so appetizing. Ordered the upside down slice and buffalo chicken slice. Upside down had extra sauce on top of the slice. Both slices were sooooooo yummy ! read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken slicr - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

You're really out of your mind if you think Nonnas is second to any pizzeria on Staten Island or NYC for that matter. I've traveled the country and nothing compares, the quality of the sauce and cheese is unmatched. I see these "Best Pizza" lists and never see any that can even match Nonnas taste. Plus Franny is just a stand up, good guy and always treats me like family when I come. I'll alway stop by when I'm in town, Love this place! read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice, Cheese & 2 Vodka slices. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Delicious and Great Staff! Their Pizza is Thin and Just Great! Their Heros are so huge, they go along with the Price I am quite sure everything is awesome at Nonna's. Don't take my word for it, try them! read more

Love their pizza. Their crust and sauce is on point. The little pepperoni pieces they use are very good.

I think this may be my favorite pizza in NYC. I live in Williamsburg, but visit my mother in Staten Island often. Nonna's is a must for each visit. Pick-up is easy. Staff are friendly and efficient. Highly recommend. read more

Terrible experience...floors were dirty and the attitudes of the staff was unacceptable. Ordered two different pies and they were basic...nothing at all to make me go back....don't waste your time or money. read more

Good NY Pizza. I ordered a couple different types of pie. The crust was a bit more firm and crunchy than I prefer. There was very little cheese on the specialty pies, which is a choice I don't prefer but is common amongst pizza shops. The proteins were well executed. Cheese was decent, thought not super stringy or oily and savoury as I consider ideal. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Chicken Specialty Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Very misleading( see photographs).. Besides the receipt in the pizza Pamphlet they really whacked me over the head with the tortellini soup.. I feel like a tourist in my own town paying this much money and It didn't even have any chicken... The only reason I kept it was because my daughter was sick & she needed the soup being she was sick Shame on these people as I thought this was a mom and pop Pizzeria as they will never get my business again..I didn't even bother to complain about the cold pizza and threw it away as the next time I am in the area I will go in and voice my opinion to the right of the right individual...The least they could've done was sent KY read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Price of soup in menu - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I absolutely love this place would recommend it with a 10. You can try their chicken Parm point. It's amazing. They are prompt and cook with love. read more

So after our last day in NYC on our lustrous DC/NJ/NY trip, we knew nothing could make the day more complete than some original pizza. I didn't want us to be lured in, unfulfilled, by this or that promise of "world's best pizza", and there were so many choices!! As a student of history, I decided to read up on some of the origins of the craft--why not take it to these heights right? And in the spirit of 1) heading south toward our NJ hotel, 2) looking for a place that celebrated the history of the pie whether overtly or subconsciously, and 3) being extremely hungry and needing--no demanding--we get full, we landed in...Staten Island? Yes my friends, the journey began. We walked up to the window and ordered our huge Nonna to go. The plan was to eat that baby down by the ocean, and everything was going according to that plan... All we had to do was convince the wife that she liked pizza a lot and would be pumped. Fast-forward ahead two huge slices per person later, and we were all lying on our backs at the park wondering how we dreamed of being able to eat three slices each. Those were good dreams; they were Nonna dreams. We even got a non-negative pizza reaction from the wife--perhaps it was the food-coma talking, but we'll take it! Could it get better? So mission accomplished, and we will return once we run those carbs off. Okay you all can return to arguing which is the best pizza anywhere of all time in this and other universes. We will just lie here full. read more

Ordered a calzone asked for light ricotta paid $11 with topping was the size of my hand I call them because there is no mozzarella in it they tell me they dont make calzone with mozzarella in it ... very strange never seen that before the calzone wasnt even closed it was put together like a sandwich. How do you not know how to make a calzone and have the guts to charge that for something maybe 5 inches. Never will order there again. read more

Ordered here for the first time and asked for my order total before hanging up the phone. Upon the delivery man coming, asked him for the price and he says $2 more than what was told over the phone. I figured maybe there was an extra charge for delivery (?) so promptly called the store and they said the original price. The girl on the phone couldn't be bothered and the phone disconnected. I called back again and she offered for the guy to come back to give me back my money but at this point I was already turned off by the "disconnected" call. Do a better job of making sure your delivery drivers are giving accurate prices and you really should be giving them a receipt with the order that they are delivering. read more

This was a great experience. Extremely friendly staff, delicious pizza. We came by Staten Island to try some Italian-American pizza and they did not disappoint. Definitely check this place out if you're in Great Kills. read more

Need price on menu pizza was good ''xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

This place is waaaaaaay overpriced. I was driving by and decided to try it. This was my first and last time. I ordered a half pepperoni pie, knots, mozz stix and 20 oz soda. $46. WHAT??? My brother owns and pizzeria. His price wouldn't been around $33. The pie alone was $22.50. I could get the same pie elsewhere for $18-19. 6 garlic knots for $5 - again what? They only gave me 4, they were TINY and had way too much garlic and not much else for seasoning. The mozz stix were your run of the mill frozen mozzarella sticks. Nothing to rave about. I think they were $13.95. Some people may say well if the food is good then it's worth the price. It was just decent. The crust on the pie had good flavor but the sauce was overly sweet. And the pie was small. It was def not a standard size large pie. I would def never go back and wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. Village Maria is a block away. Their pizza is much better and definitely priced better. read more

Food is always great. New menu has no prices, hard to believe. How do you order if you don't know prices.

Love this!! Vodka pie was the best thing i have ever eaten. The delivery was fast and theh were polite at the door.

Every time I drive by Nonna's, I am never sure if they are open because they have their outside cage down by the dining room closest to the train. However, I stopped by on a Monday and success, they were open! Nonna's has a wide variety of specialty slices. There were so many to choose from and my eyes were bigger than my stomach. I ordered the following : - white slice with roasted garlic - I thought this was going to be a heavier slice as white slices usually are but there wasn't too much ricotta where the crust got soggy. The roasted garlic added some texture and some crunch to the slice. - margarita slice - the pizza here is thin crust and the sauce was delicious. This is classic slice to go with if you're unsure. - vodka slice - this was a heavier slice than the others. A bit of flop to this slice. But the vodka sauce was made perfectly - it reminds me of the sauce my mother makes. If you find yourself in Staten Island - this is a solid pizza choice. read more

See all

Decent tasting pizza and food at reasonable prices. Delivery is usually right in time, which is unusual lately for most pizzerias.

I am so disgusted I order from this place all the time very good customer girl who answered the phone tonight and so nasty hung up on me twice they forgot my order twice. Had to go back and come back and deliver two things twice. Got on the phone with the manager so nasty With me being that, I'm the customer wouldn't even have any consideration about the food that I ordered making me nervous and I'm seven months pregnant with my family. Here we couldn't even eat together. Terrible terrible Don't ever order from this place again nasty people. read more