Here is the short synopsis of my review:
1) the food was amazing, and this is the most important point. It's the kind of place you want to make sure you have several hours to enjoy (unless you get carry out). The ONLY thing giving us pause to return soon was the amount of time we sat there with nothing. Service was very kind and informative, but very very very slow.
2) do NOT go if you are in any kind of hurry whatsoever (i.e. if you have concert or movie tickets, this is not the place you want to go and be on time).
***************************************
THE LOOOOOOOONG AND DETAILED REVIEW: and no, I'm not someone that has 10 great meals, then one bad and goes blasting the business. Food was super amazing, just a slow experience overall. Arrived at 6:30pm on the dot for a dinner with friends. At 6:35(ish) our server passed by and said "be back in a minute". At 6:45pm(ish), we ordered a round of drinks and some apps. At 7:00pm, we all got a round of waters and downed them IMMEDIATELY, as it was rather hot inside. At 7:20ish, we were all a little irritated but reeeeally trying to keep it together as she came around with our first round. So 50 minutes into the experience and we haven't even put in our dinner orders yet, just our appetizers which we also haven't seen yet.
So drinks are down at 7:20 PM and we ordered another round QUICKLY (if it's going to take another 45min was our thought process!), and then sat for close to 7:30pm when our appetizers came out. It was clear they sat in the window for a while, but they were all still delicious.
fried: these have been recommended by several and they were awesome!
(couldn't find a clam emoji) strips: super tasty. Not a huge cocktail sauce fan, those that are said their cocktail sauce was very good. I just tried it plain and it was great.
calamari strips were SO GOOD: not overly-cooked and not chewy, these were lightly battered and so tender; a table favorite. Again served with a side of marinara, these we would definitely reorder.
: 1 diner ordered clam chowder, which I tried and would easily say that's one of the better ones I've tasted around. I have to bring my grandma back here to have their clam chowder (and table rolls), she would love that.
He finished his chowder and there we sat with no waters, empty drinks and no dinner salads...for a while. Woof...but ok, not the end of the world; nobody died, so we patiently waited.
house salads came at exactly 8pm: DAMN am I glad these were worth the wait. Hands down thee best creamy Italian dressing I've had. Yes, I promptly ordered a quart to go and yes...I intend to eat it ALL! In fact, it was so good that those who didn't get the creamy Italian were tasting it, and regretting their salad dressing choices. We all agreed; better than Orlando's, better than any place we've all tried. I would go back just for a house salad and that glass of wine brought back from Italy
12oz ribeye: very tender, I only had one bite but it was delicious. Made for great leftovers, cooked perfectly medium rare, and their Colbert sauce that comes over all steaks (similar to an au jus) was great.
broiled gulf prawns: large, plump, juicy, light seasoning on them with clarified butter. Yummmmm. Yes, I ordered 2 dinners because I couldn't decide. Their menu is HUGE!
9oz filet: my friend says hers was super tender.
walleye special: a SOLID piece of walleye, super tender, encrusted with seasoning that didn't take over the walleye taste.
combo Italian dinner: a tasting of several things: 1 Italian sausage, 1 meatball, 1 stuffed green pepper, all over spaghetti and topped with marinara, then served with a side of spaghetti
Parm: was SUPERB. 1/2 alfredo, 1/2 marinara, plenty to share and PLENTY for amazing leftovers!
: one fail here. Frozen vegetables on the side of such an amazing steak? None of us ate one bite of the frozen, cafeteria vegetables.
: given the time of evening, at this point, we all got our desserts to go. Pictured (and labeled) is the array of different desserts, and they were all very tasty.
I will say that the food was completely worth it, and we do plan to go back, BUT...I would only go back if I knew I had ample time to spend and didn't have anywhere pressing to go afterwards. read more