The food is so fresh and delicious! The fish was fresh battered, the French fries were hand cut…read moreand the hot dogs and chili were amazing! The only miss was the soup! So thick and cold.

Best burger in the area maybe even New York lol, dead serious. Benny burger combo for $10?!?! you…read morecan't beat it.

We were looking for a place to stop and grab a quick lunch but except for fast food places, it was…read morea challenge finding something. We stopped in Port Jervis and found this café. We were greeted with a smile and a polite and attentive server . They offer artisan sandwiches , burgers , salads , they have a small bakery and they even sell gelato . They also have a bar . Something for everyone! Although some of the reviews were harsh we found our lunch choices to be delicious and very well-made. I ordered a very simple sandwich of freshly sliced turkey, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese on their artisan bread , served with a side of pasta salad. The sandwich was very good and filled with a nice amount of turkey and bacon . The pasta salad was average , simply made with a vinaigrette dressing. The turkey was moist and flavorful, the bacon was nice and crispy and the bread was thick and freshly sliced. Give it a try if you are in the area .

Breakfast/Lunch spot. They stop serving breakfast at 11:00 am, every day except Sundays. Food was…read moregood, service was good, even though the waitress tried to serve me old decaf coffee instead of asking me to wait one minute for a fresh pot. ( I could see into the service area) Nice selection of baked goods. Panini's were good. Pasta salad tasted sour. The menu says they serve dinner, but they close at 8:00 pm.

The food is excellent. They have a friendly staff and care about your service/food. I would…read morerecommend them to anyone.

My boyfriend and I went for lunch on Saturday. He was excited to try the French onion soup, and I…read morejust wanted a simple soup and sandwich. I ordered a turkey panini with corn chowder, and he got the beef shaved sandwich with the French onion soup. The soups arrived first. Mine was lukewarm, and his French onion soup was decent. However, when our sandwiches arrived, his beef sandwich was extremely hot, so hot he couldn't even pick it up. When he finally took a bite, he burned the inside and top of his mouth because the center of the sandwich was much hotter than the outside. It was obvious that the sandwich had been microwaved. Unfortunately, he ended up with a wound on the roof of his mouth, and it was painful. We even considered going to urgent care to document it. My review is based solely on his experience with a dish that was dangerously hotter than it should have been.

One of my toxic traits is that I judge books by their covers; I also do that with restaurants, and…read moreit burned me here. I stopped by on Saturday afternoon with one of my top-tier chums for a post-Port Jervis exploration/walk nip, deciding that out of all of the places we'd walked and/or driven by, this looked the most intriguing and certainly the most historic. One brief moment of validation occurred before we even entered - after walking through the downtown area and encountering pretty much a ghost town, we found a ton of locals in the outdoor patio/seating area here having a rollicking good time. Pretty decent endorsement, but it was quickly downhill from there. As soon as you walk in, you can tell that the majority of ye olde charm has been replaced; for instance, there's some wood paneling over the bar area that's relatively new - I was expecting something that looked pretty historic inside but in my opinion that wasn't the case. I'm not sure how much of a negative that necessarily is, but if you're walking into an establishment like this expecting to be transported to the 1890s, you're going to be disappointed. There's definitely some history, but it's not going to conjure up handlebar mustaches and victrolas. I ordered the Port Old-Fashioned off the cocktail menu; I was a little leery because it cited mulled oranges, but beyond that the description was dictionary definition. The drink itself was not. As you can see from the accompanying picture, the cocktail was practically red; I can't say for sure because I didn't witness the preparation, but it certainly looked and tasted as if it had Fireball in it rather than straight-up Bourbon. Really strange, and made it morph into a kegger drink for me. And the mulled oranges were definitely a mistake; I knew what I was getting into in that regard, so that part of the experience is certainly on me, but there's a reason this drink is supposed to have an orange peel essentially as a garnish and not a full-on part of the beverage. Really odd and I hate to say it, but probably the worst Old-Fashioned I've ever had. We had a young female bartender who was very nice/hospitable, which is the only reason this isn't a dumpster fire one-star review. She was the only one behind the bar, which was decently packed, and held her own. Our visit was relatively brief - we stopped for just the one drink before heading home across the border - but had no issues service-wise. We were able to order promptly, and received our beverages shortly thereafter. Unfortunately as mentioned, the actual drink was pretty bad, and I'd strongly recommend additional training in that capacity. Some of the intangibles are there, so I think this could be rectified. The Port Jervis residents clearly like this place a lot, so I have to assume they're staying away from the cocktail I had and enjoying either other drinks or the food (which neither of us sampled). And the price point is reasonable as well - I think my drink was $12 - but you ARE getting what you pay for. My recommendation? Head over to Jersey and drive the 29 minutes to the Walpack Inn, which is literally never on the way to anything except in this instance, and has much better menu options and legit rustic ambience.

I rented one of the spaces for a baby shower, and altho it was a tight space, I have to give all…read morethe credit to our server, Cody?Colby? Who was super on top of things, friendly, I'm so glad he was assigned to us, it made things go very smooth. The prefixed menu was good, everything came with fries. I can't complain. I have dined here before & have never had a complaint, so I would definitely recommend stopping in.

We don't get down here too often as it isn't in our normal area of activity. The wings bone in were…read morefantastic. I really enjoyed their red sangria which I wasn't highly hopeful of but I'll take a good surprise any day. The coconut shrimp with strawberry coconut dip was excellent as well. We got the sampler of ribs, pork and brisket which was also really nice but couldn't finish as for two people it was too much to eat. Other menu items of the past I have really enjoy are the Mac and Cheese and the Duck Dumplings or pot stickers... name escapes but the memory of enjoyment never did. Great server. Great staff. For the sports fans if you are worried about missing the game when nature calls they have audio in the men's room as well. Watch your excitement please for the obvious reasons. lol

Had dinner there tonight. It was our first visit. Restaurant is cozy and comfortable. Our server…read morewas a great young man but it did take a while for our food to come out. Drinks were good. We had a Peach Cosmo and White Sangria. For dinner we ordered the Cajun Pasta dish which was fettuccine with chicken, andouille sausage and shrimp. The dish was plentiful but didn't contain a lot of protein. The other dish was Fish & Chips. One very large piece of fish and fries. Meal was average. Dessert was the Italian Lemon Cake and a Tiramisu. Both desserts were good, coffee could have been hotter and fresher. Overall it was a lovely dinner and we will be returning as there are many other items on the menu we would like to try.

Great bagel. French toast bagel with Oreo cream cheese ! Will definitely return to support this…read morebusiness.

Great food, but a slight mix-up with my order. The breakfast…read morebagels were absolutely delicious, but there was a small issue with my order. I had ordered two hobo everything bagels with slight variations: one with mayo, the other with ketchup, salt, and pepper. Unfortunately, one of the bagles ended up with mayo and ketchup--just a bit of miscommunication over the phone when placing the order. That said, the sandwich itself was still tasty, and I would definitely order again. Just hope the little details are sorted out next time!

The food is always incredible. Hearty, healthy, delicious, and served by such kind people! If you…read moreneed a carry-out meal that's home-cooked but better, this is your place!

We have an opportunity for this wonderful business to cater our wedding. The food was so delicious!…read moreKate the owner was very hands on in everything. The owner was very polite and professional all throughout our planning process. It was indeed a terrific experience with her and the food service. I highly recommend her business to everyone as our experience was indeed great. Thank you and more power. Penny and Casey Morgenroth​

Went here for a birthday dinner. My Daughter ordered 3 traditional tacos. She got 3 Gringo tacos…read moreinstead. Another order that we got was completely wrong. Waiter disappeared and couldn't even find anyone to tell. By the time they came back the food was cold. Language barrier and management was really no help. Will not be back.

The food was amazing. The wait took a bit, but it was well worth it. I wish I had a better picture…read morebut I didn't decided to review the restaurant until after I had tasted how good the food was. The mole sauce was incredible. If I could change one thing about that dish, it would be to ask for them without cheese because I just wanted the mole and chicken. The cheese itself is tasty, it's just my preference!

Now I know why the burgers are 2/$6.00. Got them home 5 min…read moredrive. Cold , dry and tasteless. Should be a crime to sell these.

Never ever ever ever ever will give me sauce 4th time in a…read morerow. Please I just want some sauce.

Meandered in on a Saturday - right when they opened (4pm) with the intention of some cocktails and…read moresnacks. This bar is gorgeous - beautifully renovated with perfect nods to what once was. The staff is super helpful and attentive and the food/cocktails are delish! We will definitely be back!

What a beautiful building and that's all. The potential is limitless…read more My experience today is what should never happen at any restaurant. From the servers lack of knowledge of anything on the menu to the cold food we waited 45 minutes for, this place ranked "the worst place ever" to have a meal at. Even the drinks fell short with lack of flavor and ingredients. The tables are low and the chairs are comfortable, but not the greatest to eat from. Great for drinks and maybe finger food? When the food came we changed seats to a table, which they have a few of. From the moment they served our food cold I could no longer hold my tongue. I asked to speak with the manager and began to tell her my concerns. Her response was unbelievable. "this is my third day here", we don't have a Chef today and all of the staff are new". I said why open then. I really need to preface that. There were four people dining. We all had burgers and fries. One of us had a veggie burger. If you can't serve burgers, hot and fries hot that's a real low bar that you can't seem to get under. I really hope the Owner reads this review and straightens out what's gone wrong here. They removed three burgers from the order as one of our friends was so hungry. He decided to eat his burnt on both sides, veggie burger and he showed this to the manager and she didn't even make a suggestion like let me just take it all off the bill. My wife is not a person that would send stuff back however I am and the couple we were with the wife is the person who would send things back and the husband's more of a I won't come back here kind of guy. Both me and my friends wife post reviews, me in yelp and her on google. Look for her review. This was a truly disappointing experience. we wound up going right down the block to a place that we always dine at and had great burgers and some fish n chips. PS I took the menu pictures before all of this took place and I'm gonna post them anyway.