If I would've read the reviews first I wouldn't have tried this place. The ONLY reason I have it 2 stars is because once I re-cooked my wings they were better. My original order was a cheese steak. It wasn't cooked the way I ordered it, the mushrooms didn't look real and they smelled sour. The meat was just thrown together and slapped on some bread. It didn't even look desirable! I tasted it anyway but I knew it wasn't going to be good and I was right. It was nasty and they were called immediately to get it rectified. The customer service was good though. So my replacement order was garlic parm wings. They didn't say they cook them in red sauce (with hot sauce) and sprinkle parm cheese on them so of course I was not happy when we picked up the order. Like I said they were ok but I really only tried them out of curiosity because who makes garlic parm wings as if it's garlic parm chicken! Go at your own risk. read more

See all

Walking into Nick's Pizza (Sicklerville) brought me back to the 90's and I loved every bit of it. The tables and chairs and smell reminds me of an old school pizza shop! We ordered the Philly Cheesesteak, garlic knots and the hot dog kids meal with fries. Total came to $25. Cheesesteak was good, comparable to a cheesesteak you buy from the corner store in Philly. The garlic knots were ok. And my daughter loved her hot dog - nothing special about it but they did use a hoagie type roll instead of a hotdog roll, which she said was very delicious. read more

Nick's Pizza - Philly Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

See all

They have they cheesesteak meat pre maid when I ask the guy about it it told me don't come back I guess that's how they treat there customers if u don't like what they say or have a problem then they treat u like u don't matter read more

Every single time, legit EVERY SINGLE TIME, I select an extra side of sauce; I don't get it. I pay for it every time and never get it. Honestly you probably owe me a car by this point. How hard is it to double check a ticket?! A one off I get. But every time?! Is there a sauce shortage? Is it a creative way to gain extra income?! read more

Mediocre food. Also was allowed to purchase dough once and now today not allowed to with no explanation? Now I have my husband running around to another better pizza place to get the dough for our pizza night. Won't be purchasing anything else from here. read more

Customer server is horrible. My pizza was undercooked. Then they had a attitude when I called them out in it. Don't recommend. And they charge an extra fee if you use a credit/debit card. read more

Been going here since a kid I love their pizza, their pizza is very nostalgic to me and they will always have my business.

This was last nights dinner; we decided to do pick up but delivery is an option. We have never eaten inside but we have ordered from this location on several occasions. We had a large pepperoni and sausage pizza. The slices and toppings are big (compared to other pizza locations nearby). I like that the pizza is not overly greasy and is well seasoned. The sauce, cheese and crust are tasty. We also had an order of Buffalo wings (hot sauce). The wings are a decent size, the sauce is not overly spicy and they are fried well (not soggy). Overall good food, reasonably priced and conveniently located. read more

After going through the menu and ordering over $50.00 of items, during Checkout was notified Nick's does not deliver to my area. Knowing the pizza is eww from recent review, its all Good for me. Not for Nick... read more

Ordered a few sandwiches tonight, they tasted good however, there was a long curly black hair embedded in my sandwich. (Side note I have short blonde hair) I called to let them know what I experienced and I was told "well no one in our kitchen has black curly hair". Regardless of how it got there and who's working in the kitchen, it's not my hair. Not only is this disgusting but this is a time where extra precautions should be taken, which obviously were not. Gross, gross, gross! read more

See all

I ordered a pizza half pepperoni at 1:22 and it arrived at 2:40 after 2 phone calls. The pizza wasn't hot nor was it tasty. There are a dozen pizza places around my home and this is unacceptable. They will never see me again! read more

I order hot wings the meat was not cooked all the way through. It seem like my order was rushed and half ass. I give a good rating for there customer service but the food nasty. 2/10 read more

Ordered for pickup & the whole process was super convenient! You call once in the parking lot & you pay over the phone. They bring it out immediately. Over the phone and in person they were so nice! The pizza was so delicious and cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend if you want a yummy cheesy pizza. read more

Nick's Pizza - Small pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

The food is very good. I think that they have the best meat balls and fried shrimp around.

Every time I order from Nicks in Sicklerville, my order is messed up. They don't give me what I ordered, but instead give me something completely different. I guess if I ever order from there again, I will have to open up every item and make sure it is what I ordered before I leave. If this was an isolated incident, I wouldn't be upset, but it happens EVERY SINGLE TIME!!!! I haven't ordered from them in so long, I guess I hoped they would have improved. Nope! They still suck! Don't order from here unless you want to be surprised with what they actually give you because it won't be what you ordered!!!! read more

Does it taste like authentic NY pizza? No but I thought it was pretty decent and my husband really liked it! Probably will go back!

OMG ... my experience tonight 3/5/21 was exquisite! You the young lady who took my call. I have never had a more present person take my order before! She seemed eager to take my order verses in the past feeling like I was a nuisance. Thank you to her. I know the job is not easy but I felt like I could hear her smile. To the delivery... delivery was quoted hour to hour fifteen. This was ok for my family and expected for a Friday night and the size of our order. Our order showed up in about 45-50 min! And the man who delivered it awesome! Kudos to him absolutely pleasant and just a wonderful experience! Now I write this well before I eat my food and I have had the food before and it is good. But tonight's experience has me compelled to give the 5 stars. For me it's all about the experience and atmosphere before the food. But don't get me wrong I will write if the food is not worthy. Nicks has been around well before I moved here 14 years ago they have to know what they are doing with food. read more

We placed an order for 1 small pizza, 1 medium pizza and some waffle fries. It took almost 2 hour for them to deliver the 1plan pizza and waffle fries. They didn't bring the pepperoni pizza. I asked nicely if they could simply credit us for the pizza they forgot but still deliver the other since we have already waiting 2 and a half hour at this point. The guys Reggie who took our order was not professional he said he wouldn't do it even though we order from nicks almost one a week... hopefully Reggie learns how to talk to people and fix their mistakes!! read more

This place is normally ok. I have ordered from there and the food has been good. Tonight I ordered for take out and the host was horrible she had a nasty attitude from the time I ordered my food till the time I picked it up. I saw her interacting with other customers and her interaction was different. She even had the nerve to look at me and shake her head. She was a white lady that looked like white trash and the nerve of her to have an attitude to a black women that is patronizing the company that pays here. I usually would give an 5 stars but because of the lady that I encountered tonight she is a horrible representation of this brand. The funny this is I'm a business owner and I'm big on customer service!!!!! read more

The make a really good salad and Stromboli. Pizza was ok, the dough didn't seem homemade. Very friendly staff and they have a great curbside pickup going instead of going inside. read more

I think they have some of the best salads around to be honest, they have amazing cheese steaks too. One night we ordered the cheesesteaks weren't good but sometimes things happen. Don't really care for their pizza since it's dish but it's not terrible. If you are looking for a good salad or steak definitely check this place out. I also love how they put their cheesesteaks in boxes instead of wrapping and smushing it. read more

Nick's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

Pizzas were delivered and at least one of them was put back into the oven. The crust is burnt to the taste and rock hard. It was the worst pizza I've ever had. My jaw hurts from attempting to eat it but I couldn't get past the burnt taste. I've honestly never experienced a MANAGER and the original employee we spoke with around 8pm on 7/25 argue with a customer the way this manager just argued with us. We ordered 4 pizzas and French fries via DoorDash. Apparently our doordasher wasn't paying attention and ONLY brought us the French fries, ok. That's on DoorDash. So we call to see what the best way to get the pizzas we're, not knowing if they would drop it off or if we go directly through DoorDash. I pull up DoorDash to process it as a "reorder at no charge" while we're on the phone with the manager who's arguing that the order was never closed out or picked up. We're trying to explain to them that we know the pizzas are still there, we know that much. But if we're replacing the order, by the time another driver comes and gets it and drops it off those pizzas will no longer be fresh if they've already been sitting there at least 20 minutes. We spent $80 (yes our total through DoorDash) and he continued to yell about how it's only $65 to them. Okay? That had nothing to do with the situation at hand. We understand that the original error was not nicks fault, but the absolute disrespect that both the original employee (who obviously can get away with it if management is the same) and the manager completely disrespected us when all we wanted to do was make sure that we were going about it the correct way and we're going to be delivered fresh pizzas. We'll definitely never order from here again read more

Placed an order for a "chicken parm dinner" with the spaghetti on the side w/ diced tomatoes which is pretty simple. I get home, open the bag and it's pasta, sauce, cheese and tomatoes with no chicken. There's a bag of chicken tenders on the side in a fry bag. Return to Nicks to tell them about the mistake. Manager comes out to the car and "fixes" it for me. Thinking I'd get a real piece of chicken In the dinner I come to find out the tenders were just mixed into the pasta. I wasn't offered my money back, discount or coupon after the ride home and then the wait for a new order to be made. Disappointed. read more

Nick's Pizza - Chicken tender parm - Pizza Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

Pizza was delicious and I got about three servings of chicken parm for less than ten dollars...awesome! Four stars instead of five because my dine in experience was less than desirable. They had about six too many people working but the dining room was still somehow dirty. Crust and fries on the floor, tables with crumbs everywhere, etc. I'm not usually picky about that kind of stuff but the dirty dining room + surplus of people working screams they need better management. read more

My friend usually orders stuff from here. He told me about a really good cheese steak which i'm a sucker for. I'll probably be banned for saying this, but i'll say it anyway...i think pizza shops in NJ have better cheese steaks than Philly. YUP...you read that right. And Nick's Pizza is one of them. The Rustic Cheese Steak is so bomb, so overwhelmingly delicious! I've had it once, and i'm a big fan of it. Even craving one now that i'm writing a review for it. We also ordered some fries and two pies, one plain and one pepperoni. The fries they have are pretty good too. They are the extra crispy type and not overly salty. The pizza i thought was good, but the sauce/cheese combo was slightly salty. The pizza dough was nice and the pizza itself was evenly baked. We did pickup, so we had little interaction with customer service. The cashier that took care of us was pleasant. Till next time, rustic cheese steak! read more

Nicks is ok great ways to order delivery or pick-up. Foods ok not great but not Bobo either. Fast delivery read more

See all

Nicks Pizza is a south jersey pizza chain with locations in Clayton, Williamstown, Glassboro, Voorhees, Northfield and Sicklerville. I first heard about Nicks from a couple of my degenerate friends leaving The Landmark in Glassboro after watching the Phillies (this is before they were the heap of donkey excrement that they are today) when my boy Hook said we should go get a slice from Nicks and our other friend Blackout Bob aka B.O.B. agreed. So having no idea what or who the hell Nicks is I naturally asked them about it and they both started ranting and raving how it's the best especially for a local chain. Welp fast forward a smooth 10 years and I can confirm...they weren't lying and it's not just the pizza that's phenomenal, all the food is fucking delicious. It's my go to on a NFL Sunday when I have a bunch of people over to binge watch Americas game....now since everything is made with love, delivery can take a hot minute but I can never stay hangry at them after I take that first bite. My main suggestions off the menu besides the basics are the buffalo chicken pizza (add broccoli and bacon...sets that shit of RIGHT), the mozz sticks, the breaded chicken pita/any of the wraps, and any of the rustic sandwiches....they are soooooooo good, my stomach started beat boxing just now while typing this. Basically what I'm saying is if your ever near one of the Nick establishments and your hungry, you should strongly consider stopping in and grabbing a slice. read more

Nick's Pizza - buffalo chicken pizza with bacon and broccoli - Pizza Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a cheesesteak and buffalo chicken cheesesteak and was very disappointed! First all, for the cheesesteak I asked for extra meat and by the looks of it didn't seem to have extra meat at all and it's not cheap either - still skimpy af. And as far as the buffalo chicken steak I would've liked REAL BUFFALO SAUCE mixed in, not HOT SAUCE just poured on the damn bottom of the bread ! Y'all need to do better ! read more

Ordered a chicken cheesesteak & fries.. it was delicious! Both were huge & very filling. Delivery was also fast & efficient - Definitely ordering again! read more

If I could give less than a one star review I would. Food is always cold or late, orders are screwed up and the staff is unprofessional but today took the cake. I place an order for a lunch delivery for my sons school, to treat him for a good grade. I scheduled the order for 12:15p and the order didn't arrive until 12:45p and my son was distraught because he had no lunch. I called the store to inquire and the person who answered yelled, told me basically its not their problem because they can only get the orders to the destination when they can, and I should have sent my son to school with food and called me a Jackass!!! This might be the worse business for customer service and food quality in this area. I hope the ownership understand the type of low caliber staff that is representing their company because this business NEVER had this type of pathetic service and with all the other Pizza shops and competition, they need to fix it before they start to lose more business. Ridiculous. read more

This has happened TWICE now. I ordered a sausage Stromboli and they gave me a vegetarian Stromboli one time and something complete different the other time. I called them to tell them they gave me the wrong thing. They made ME drive back to THEM both times. No apology and no offer to comp me for it or no free fries or anything. I am never ordering a Stromboli from there again which is upsetting cause it's actually pretty good. read more

Ordered a Ham and Cheese hoagie with a lot of extras on it Would of been good if they remembered to put the ham on it ! read more

This pizza is underwhelming. I've had frozen pizza that taste better. The dough nor the sauce stand out in taste. We've had them deliver to the house a few time and each time the pizza has been ok at best. read more

Food used to be good. Now it's basically one step above dumpster diving. Deliveries are never on time and our order is never right. If they tell you 40 minutes, plan for 2 hours. If they forget half of your order, plan on another 2 hours, if it even comes. read more

Very disappointing! They were OK when they first opened but now it's hit or miss. We get cold pizza almost everytime! The wings are either undercooked or cooked too hard. Girl answering the phone is rude and cocky, needs training. I'm done with them. Will go out of my way to Nick's in Williamstown, better quality and consistency of food. Glassboro is even better! read more

I'd have given zero if I could have. Delivery order placed 90 minutes ago. We were told 45 minutes. When we called to inquire about the order we were blown-off and told "they'd get to it". After 95 minutes it arrived. Cold They've lost our business for good and should never get yours. read more

My favorite pizza place and especially, this is my favorite Nicks location. I have literally never had a thing here I do not like. My usual orders (which basically rotate) are: chicken cheesesteak wrap, pizza, broccoli bites, chef salad with grilled chicken. I have tasted a good portion of the menu, and can say with confidence, EVERYTHING IS GOOD. It's hard to say that about a pizza place, but Nicks is the real deal. Service is always friendly and they always make sure you are satisfied! read more

Pizza is horrible, conveyor belt style which was exactly like carnival pizza without the rides..Not A good place for a pizza.

If I could give a rating less than a star I would! We ordered pizza and three panzarottis, The pizza was no better than some frozen crap I could get from the supermarket . The panzarottis were tough, chewy and tasted like they were in the freezer for months. I will never ever visit this establishment again and I suggest you steer clear as well. read more

The food isn't too bad but the pizza is really greasy. The wings are good but sometimes they're overcooked. Also, the wait is really long and the delivery takes forever. read more