Wife and I went this week. Tuesdays they have a special $32 which includes 2 drinks, house salad (which was fantastic and they give plenty), and a traditional pie. First, the salad, enough and then some for two. Not sure what dress they use on the house salad, but it was awesome. Today (Thursday), I was drooling on the way home from errands about the leftover salad which I had for lunch. Second, the pizza, cracker thin crust but surprisingly filling. Sauce was delicious and fresh, you could see tomato seeds in the sauce. Still have leftovers in the fridge and curious how it reheats. Fantastic pie overall. Finally, the staff, as good as the food was, the staff was exponentially better, friendly and helpful. We will definitely be going again (and again). read more

Holy Tomato Pies - House salad - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

See all

we loved it!!! amazing thin, crunch that doesn't flop over. we couldn't believe when they said each pizza be made in half so we did half a pizza with half a pepperoni. So that was great. Their salad is delicious and fed 4 people! And sadly, we did not have room for dessert! But we will be back! Met the owner and her husband greeted us several times our table to make sure everything was satisfactory!. Boy was it!!!! atmosphere is eclectic!! outside seating has Mosaic surfboards!! read more

Order the boardwalk pizza! Very thin crust which I prefer. The taste was delicious, they hand make their own sauce. I called to order and it was delivered to the car read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

I wish I could give more than 5 stars honestly. I moved down from North Jersey and was unable to find a good pie. Today, my husband and I went here. I can't rave enough about it. I will start with the atmosphere. It has a really cool vibe and there are different themes to the rooms. The staff was incredible. So friendly and helpful and patient. Now the food. I can't say enough. If you over look the salad (yes I said salad), you are missing out. It was top 2 best salads I ever had. It was simple but delicious. The pizza, is the best I have had in South Jersey. The crust is thin and the flavors of the sauce is amazing. I highly recommend the original pie as well as the buffalo chicken. Don't forget the homemade ranch and Bleu cheese. Desert is made in house and was just as incredible as everything else. Only thing to be mindful of, parking is a little tricky and they only take cash or venmo. You guys have gained customers for life. We will absolutely be back soon! read more

See all

This pizza is thinner than a cracker and absolutely delicious. I'm someone who prefers thicker crust but i was pleasantly surprised to love the thin crispiness of this pizza along with the homemade sauce. I was able to eat the whole pie with one other friend snd feel so satisfied. its also amazing that you can customize your pie with two different flavors. definitely a hidden gem read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Margarita Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

Holy Tomato is the cutest hidden gem! We drove by a few times thinking it was just a house! But inside is the coziest, most welcoming spot. Service was excellent! So friendly and attentive from start to finish. We had the Famous House Salad to start and then shared the Original Pie with Italian sausage. The crust was crisp and perfect. The staff recommended the Good Karma local wine, which paired perfectly with our meal. Can't wait to come back. This place is a treasure! Thank you from Texas! read more

See all

Holy Tomato is really something special. It is that place. The pizza is insane--like you'll be thinking about it the next day. And the salad is addictive--even if you don't like salad you'll love it. The whole space is a vibe--eclectic, a little whimsical, not try-hard, just cool. And the staff? Genuinely amazing. Warm, real, and you can tell they actually care (which is rare). You can feel the love in this place and it shows through in everything. Go. Just go. read more

This little place packs so much flavor into their food!! The Caesar salad with the pecans was amazing, next level. The chicken Alfredo pizza and boardwalk pizza were outstanding!! The pies are cut into (more like) long squares but amazing flavors! The gentleman who walked us to our seats and checked in on was top notch in customer service and care. We cannot wait to go back bug eill be spreading the word in the meantime!! They have a list of wine to purchase on site but it is also a BYOB. Super cute decor inside and patio seating available. Our server was outstanding as well. 10 stars!! read more

We stopped into Holy Tomato for our first time last night. It's an unassuming converted street-front house on the outside, but an eclectic cozy atmosphere inside. Once we sat down our server made us feel like we were one of the regulars. She made sure we knew everything we needed to make the visit all it could be. The menu is a bit sparse, but what's there (mainly pizza) sounded delicious. My wife and I ordered two half pizza's a house salad (which served two to three people) and a bottle of wine from Auburn Road (an excellent local vineyard with very much the same eclectic vibe). The food was as good as Google made it sound and it showed up quickly. The owner (I believe) named Tom also stopped by to make sure everything was to our liking and we were more than happy to tell him it was. We ended up having a nice conversation with him about the history of the business. I don't know how we overlooked it for so long. Live and learn. Everyone there was incredibly nice and very customer service oriented and it felt like they all loved being there. We look forward to getting back there soon. Do take note that you should park in the library lot a few doors down. The township doesn't allow street parking out front and the lot across the street runs the risk of getting towed. read more

Wow. Good pizza. Got the honey buffalo chicken and the original. Thin like I love and tasted so damn good. Cooked to perfection. Crispy crust. Bottom was on point. Ordered...got there...they run it out to you at the curb. Cash and Venmo only. Cool little joint and they quick were nice when we got there. Did I say it was GOOD!!! read more

Our first night out after arriving in South Jersey for our visit was absolutely delicious! We went to Holy Tomato Pies (9 S Black Horse Pike, Gloucester Township) and had a salad and "margarita" pizza. We added mushrooms to the pie and got a side of anchovies for my husband (lovely presentation of the anchovies, but forgot to take a picture since I was already digging into the pizza when they arrived). Holy Pies is BYOB (which we didn't take advantage of since we had just gotten off a 10-day cruise and our livers needed a break) and only accepts cash or venmo. The decor in there is fun and eclectic. We arrived at just the right time, I think it was shortly after six, and there was only one other table occupied inside, but within 15 minutes or so the place was packed and every table was full. I don't know how we managed to time it so well, but yay for us! Loved the friendly and welcoming staff who made us feel right at home. Holy Tomato says that their salads (you can get a nice house salad with lettuce, tomato, and olive assortment, pepperoncini, and toasted sesame seeds, or a Caesar salad) feed two as a side salad, but they're huge and will easily feed four. The delicious pie was also huge, so we're happy to be staying in a hotel with a refrigerator and microwave and are looking forward to the leftovers. It was perfect, with generous helpings of mozzerella, fresh tomato slices and basil. Couldn't even think about dessert since we were so stuffed, but I did enjoy their housemade raspberry lemonade (a LOT!) that pretty much served as a non-alcoholic sangria with its assortment of fruit chunks and berries. Our server said some customers add alcohol to it, which I imagine would be darn good. Note that the prices shown on Yelp are outdated and so you're better off going to their website for current pricing. Everything we had was well worth the price. It was a fun and delicious evening! read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

See all

Great pub-style thin crust pizza with a unique vibe. Really cute spot - the decor is quirky and fun. We went on a ridiculously hot day and it was comfortable in the dining room. The entire staff was sweet, friendly, and considerate and checked on us numerous times. I'd definitely go back. read more

We celebrated my son's birthday there. We had such a warm hospitality experience from all the staff . They are the best! We ordered 3 pizzas, salad, and few other choices. Everything was delicious! We love this place and it is always nice to go back! Thank you for your beautiful place and your staff are wonderful. read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

The pickle pizza is to die for. I had that, their chicken Alfredo, and the margarita. All were great but the pickle one was beyond great.

We went there Saturday and took a friend from of town. I thought she would enjoy interior decoration and I knew she was a fan of thin crust pizza. I read several negative reviews about the owners husband but thought they might have been a personal opinion. It was 91 degrees outside and we were seated in a back dining room that was probably about a comfortable 75 degrees. We ordered our food and were off to a great start. The wait staff was very friendly. The owner was seated next to us entertaining some friends. Suddenly an obviously angry man came into the dining room and opened the door to the "patio". Within minutes the dining room was the temperature of the outside. He came back later and opened the door even wider and blocked it with a chair to make sure it couldn't be closed. My friend has blood sugar issues so eating on schedule is very important to her. The heat only exacerbated the situation. Our salad came out first which was mushy and not crisp like I had remembered in the past. By this point my friend is feeling ill and starting to cry. I thought if she got some food she would stabilize but when I asked about our pizza I was told repeatedly we were next. The pizza finally came out. It tasted ok but the crust was matzo thin and crispy. Like eating a pizza on a cracker. By this point my friend is sick. We had them pack the food for takeout. No one in the restaurant seemed to notice that we were packing up our food nor that my friend was crying. Back in the car we got some air conditioning and my friend came back to life. We had concert tickets for that night that we missed due to my friend health. I will never go back here again. Look at my reviews. I think I left one bad review ever but this was my worst nightmare. read more

WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT! We hadn't been in years for some reason. Now we won't be for good reason! Terrible pizza AND salad !!! They HAD to have changed owners or the cooks! We're talking night and day difference! You can tell from "jump," just by the looks of it. Tomatoes didn't taste good, plus very acidic! Before my dad THREW IT OUT, he dropped off a slice to my sister to confirm our thoughts. WHAT A SHAME! (my mom called to complain, and the person wanted to give a credit (a big no thanks) or a refund.) read more

Holy Tomato Pies - just totally unappealing - getting tossed out! (8/9/22) - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

I've heard great things about this place and couldn't wait to try it. My daughter had a game in the area and we planned this for dinner after. We had already decided what we wanted. I made sure to check their business hours before we went and saw that they were open until 9. We arrived at a couple of minutes before 8 only to find a closed sign on the door. At least 3 other sets of people approached to enter as well. I get that sometimes things happen unexpectedly but in the day of social media there's no reason to not make a quick post stating you need to close early. read more

I really like this restaurant and the food. Their menu prices are reasonable, however, their specials threw me. They had Mexican street corn for a side that came in 5 half ears. $16.00??? A family size pizza was only $14.00. How is that? I can only say I'm shocked. Very! read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

This place is phenominal!!! From the minute you walk in, you're greeted like family. The staff are the Best. They cater all your needs and the Food!!! OMG!!! The pizza is to die for but so is everything else, including the desserts! It's an absolute must!!! It will surely be your new favorite!!! RL read more

Greeted by Tom and some staff immediately. Super friendly and welcoming. Hadn't been there before despite living nearby so Tom told me about the place and the food. Inside is super cozy - also great outside deck. Can't say enough about people and pizza was FANTASTIC. Also had Pepper Shooters - so good thanks guys! I'll be back! read more

Service was excellent and super friendly! My wife and I are traveling and friend suggested the pickle pie. Our waitress confirmed so we split a house salad and a pizza, half pickle and half margarita! The salad was crisp romaine with a wonderful dressing and toasted sesame seeds which really set this salad apart. Giant portion for us both to split. Then came the pizza and it was, well, delicious! The homemade pickles and cream dill sauce was great, but the crispy onion straws with the hot honey were perfect! I would definitely go back and enjoy this quaint very cool friendly atmosphere with great pizza! read more

Great food, excellent flavor. Service was excellent. The best pizza I've had in South Jersey. I also love love love the atmosphere and the outdoor porch. read more

I generally do not like tomato pies. This is the first tomato pie is really enjoyed and would eat again. The Parma was excellent! read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Left is Parma and right is original - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

Great food and service. My kids loved the pizza and they can be extremely picky, so its a win in my book.

I don't know who would ever rate this a 1 star. You might if you have absolutely no taste buds. Their salad, pizzas, and desserts are so good. I go here all the time even if I move to williamstown. I would rate this place higher if i could i recommend this place with everything in me read more

Love their pizza. Thin, crispy, and yummy tomato sauce. Easily can see a big eater or man polish off a whole pie themselves.

Great reviews with this place. I stayed traditional and I got the traditional tomato pie. It was very thin and crispy and the sauce tasted fresh but I wouldn't recommend taking it to go. Eating it fresh makes all the difference so if you can dine in. The one thing that was weird is that they cut the pizza differently which I wasn't a fan of. For takeout they bring it to your car which is a nice touch. In my opinion, this is a top 5 tomato pies in nj. I will be back and probably eat the whole pizza myself! read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

See all

Mediocre pizza, terrible service. Went for my second time (first time pizza took over an hour and owner blamed on "new chef"). This time, we were told 30 mins for a pizza and it took 1hr 20 mins - must have been another new chef. Small place but has been in business for a long time and should be better about making pizzas on time and/or communicating better expectations to customers. Pizza is thin crust but floppy. Decent flavor but nothing special. I hope they decide the quality of the customer experience is more of a priority moving forward. read more

The pizza is amazing, the atmosphere is enjoyable. The salads are also amazing and the staff very friendly

Pizza was great thin crust. Caesar salad was huge and tasty. Sat outside on the back deck. Didn't know it was bring your own though read more

Where to start...this place is amazing. From the ambiance, to the excellent customer service, and of course the high quality food. The pizza is great, the salads are delicious, and the homemade desserts are a must try. Don't forget, it's also byob...can't wait to go back! read more

Love everything !! The atmosphere the food the service !! Great family place ... byob to a plus !! read more

Holy pies, friendly service and a lovely artistic dinning room! We only had the pizza it was very good thin crust with a great savory sauce not sweet and good quality cheese and pepperoni cups on half of the pizza was delicious. There homemade Raspberry lemonade was delicious with fresh fruit inside the drink. Definitely worth a try! read more

The best customer service I've ever had. Hands down. The place was very cozy and welcoming. And the owner and servers I spoke to were all very polite and friendly. I mentioned it was my first time there, and they were very eager for me to experience the place. And what an experience it was! To put it in simpler terms, pizza was amazing, staff were amazing, and the restaurant itself was amazing! 10/10 read more

Great Pizza! Me and My wild loved the Buffalo Chicken Pie. Our service was great, the workers very very nice. The chicken was great, and one of the best I've had. Id definitely recommend anyone to try them out. Only downside was that it took a little while, but it was worth the wait. read more

This was my first time eating here, it's one of my friend's favorite places. It was a cold snowy night and they have signs up out front, that day No Parking, curbside pick up only. It really doesn't seem legal and it was crappy so we parked there anyway. A man came out of the restaurant telling everyone not to park there and questioning us about parking there. We went in and were seated, only to have the same man come back and tell us there were 2 other parties in front of us. I guess if he wasn't out front hollering about the parking he could have communicated that to the server that sat us. He took our name and phone number, then told us to go back to our car and wait! He was so rude, I didn't want to eat there anymore. Since we were back in the car, I decided to move it to a different spot, as I didn't want the ride man to come back out again. My friend talked me into staying and eating there. If I had not been with her, I would have left. The pizza we got was half white and half The flip. We also ordered the Cesare salad. Thankfully the food was really good, so I will probably go back. However, if the same man is there, and ride again, I won't hesitate to leave. It's no way to treat your customers read more

Holy Tomato Pies - Half White, half the Flip - Pizza Near Me - Gloucester Township, New Jersey

Great pizza and salads. Love the atmosphere we had a party there everyone loved the pizza and salads.

My family of 5 loves this destination. The pizzas are unique and delicious. The wait staff is familiar & fantastic. We feel VIP every visit and reccomend to all of our friends. Tom is the host with the most and we look forward to our next visit. read more

Best thin crust, brick oven style pizza around! BYOB eat in available and great for takeout. Want a pizza that is more than the norm...check them out! read more

Great pizza, wonderful service, kind owners. My friends and I have designated this our Mom's night out spot. It is BYOB, cozy and very affordable. Its also decorated nicely inside. We love their salads and the Super Veggie pie. They also regularly have specialty salads and apps which are always good. We've never been disappointed by anything we've ordered. Friday and Saturday nights can be busy -- but this is also a gem for a weeknight dinner. read more