I had to add Nick's since they're a "given" restaurant for any type of group pizza order at my workplace. I love this restaurant; the people who work there are great and while they're constantly busy they've never made a mistake on any of my orders, they're friendly and willingly go out of their way to help you. Their pizza is traditional Greek style, and they have won some sort of local award for it; it's my favorite for the area. However, my real needed "fix" to go here is their gyros and chicken kebab salads. All three mouthwatering, and a more than welcome pick-me-up in the middle of a long workday. They've also delivered multiple pizzas for my whole department, and they're still hot upon arrival. Nick's is equipped for large orders and if you call ahead you can just pick it up when you walk in. They also deliver for orders 8$ or more. read more

Nick's Pizza, Roast Beef and Subs - Nick's Pizza, Roast Beef and Subs - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

I had a favorite take out place, but not anymore. Nicks is the best. I don't stray from my favorites like the turkey club and steak fries so I kind of know. its excellent. also, which you never find is a gorgonzola, apple and candied walnut salad, excellent too. delivery driver came to my apartment door; I will be ordering again! read more

2 hours late. Pizza was destroyed with gross cheese all over the boxes. Called for a refund. Lady was so rude. Been a loyal customer for years. Never going back. This management sucks read more

Excellent food, with a large portion at a reasonable price, staff very friendly. I highly recommend Nick's to everyone.

Great food, very affordable, and the best service you can get! My favorite little sub shop by far. Thanks guys!

Great Place, food is excellent and stay very accommodation thanks for a positive experience! Love the Roast Beef and other food !

Ordered a chicken kabob calzone for delivery. Did not realize they close at 9pm and I put in an order online. So I called and told the girl who answered the phone and was awesome that they could cancel cause I know now that they close at 9. My mistake. But the girl talked to the kitchen and we made a change and got a bbq chicken calzone. Got my order real quick. The delivery driver was so polite and just a cool dude and the woman who answered the phone is a great customer service oriented front of house worker. And the calzone was so good. I'll be ordering again and again!! read more

Be Aware - They Don't Accept Their Own Online Coupons! I wanted to try Nick's because it was close to work. I ordered a small cheese pizza and printed off their online coupon ($3.75 for Mon/Tues). I was told they are no longer accepting the coupons from their own website. REALLLY? I ended up paying full price for the pizza. The pizza itself was just OK - maybe a 5 or 6 out of 10. The thing is - if they took some off the full price I would have been reasonably happy, but now I won't go back there because of the way I was treated. read more

Second time ordering from nicks, good food fast delivery. So far not disappointed. Highly recommended good food good service super fast delivery read more

We've ordered from here a bunch of times through GrubHub and they always deliver ahead of schedule, the order is correct and the food is tasty. Definitely a go to! read more

Good deals on pizza. I love the option to add toppings of my own and their pizza never a disappointment. Although I have yet to order other things. I was disappointed with the buffalo chicken wings, too soggy. read more

AVOID! Placed a simple online order of a pizza, chicken fingers and salad. Chicken and salad were delivered, with no pizza. The frazzled driver assured me that, for some reason, the pizza was coming with another driver, who was right around the corner. 15 minutes later, with no sign of the pizza, I called the place and they had NO idea what I was talking about. After explaining three times that they owed me a pizza, the girl asked me, "Sooooo... Do you still want it?" Considering that I had already been charged for it, this was a pretty stupid question. An hour later, the pizza finally arrived, with no apology. We could've had Mandee's deliver three separate, delicious pizzas in the time it took us get Nick's nothing-special, bland offering. What a joke. Get your sh*t together, Nick's. read more

I called for a delivery order and I was RUDELY told that they don't deliver by a young man with a slight accent who answered the phone. They should change their status to NO DELIVERY on Yelp. And they should treat people who call, thinking that they do deliver because Yelp says they do, like human beings. Try... "Sorry, we don't deliver but I would still be happy to take your order if you wish to come here". Just a thought, maybe I am too old fashioned for today's accepted behaviors. Service business should not be RUDE! I only wish I could give them ZERO STARS. read more

Rude unprofessional ordered for delivery pizza came cold called back they didn't offer anything or apologize never calling or placing an order from this place first time an the pizza is horrible frozen pizza is better than this dump .... read more

Rude staff. Extremely slow delivery. Put on hold 2 times during one phone call. Stay Away.

Best steak & cheese ever so good , and their pizza crust amazing service great.... Love this place read more

Nick's Pizza, Roast Beef and Subs - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

[Note: We came here for the gyros, so this review will only be about them, and not Nick's pizza as I have not tried that yet.] We were hungry and about to leave for Thanksgiving break. I've been wanting to try the gyros here for a while after reading Kat H.'s review of them being the "fix" she needs from time to time. They weren't great. They weren't good. There was lettuce. Who puts lettuce in a gyro? The tomato was an unripe color, thinly sliced and kind of limp. There was an absence of tzatziki. The ground lamb was in strips and my boyfriend actually thought that they were just breakfast sausage patties in a weird shape. Twenty minutes after, we were not feeling very well. Maybe this was an off day for Nick's as far as the gyros go? The staff was really nice and friendly. They were chatty amongst themselves and would often speak in a language other than english from time to time (Greek?). I'll definitely go back to try their pizza when I have a couple of friends over next time, but I won't be coming back for a gyro. read more

I live in Lynn and ordered through Slice not realizing they were in Peabody, I am soooo impressed!!! My food was here in 1/2 hr , it was fresh and hot!! Thank you for your awesome service!! read more

I don't know how anyone could give nothing but 5 stars for Nicks in Peabody. They are the best take out and kind people. You know they are clean, the food is great, I love them. read more

Hands down my favorite pizza shop in Peabody. Been coming here for the past 5 years since I moved here and it is great. Staff is so friendly and food is always consistent and perfect! Definitely recommend 10/10. read more

We have gotten Nicks several times before for takeout but I was not sure how it would be during the whole pandemic. We had it delivered tonight and took advantage of a great special offer on the pizzas. Being the pessimist that I am - I expected that with that great of a deal, their pizza covering would not be as generous. I could not have been more wrong! The food was as good as always - with the recommendation that we reheat the food when it's takeout during the pandemic, pizza was the easiest food that I could think of to reheat after delivery. In a time where there are so many unknowns it was a great comfort to have great comforting food the first time we decide to treat ourselves during this craziness. read more

not overly impressive. chili was odd, way too spicy with a strong vinegar taste, maybe tabasco Im not sure lots of meat some beans onions green peppers but that flavor overpowered the whole thing. Lemon chicken soup was very bland oddly enough. read more

I love this place! The menu selection isn't as big as other delivery places. But the food is good and they're extremely quick. I typically get my food within 20-30 mins of delivering. read more

It was very good. Th e grilled chicken salad unbelievable great fair price I shall return.. read more

I got a roast beef and fries here. The fries weren't bad but the roast beef was over cooked and very chewy. Don't recommend the beef ‍

Been going to Nick's for years. Love the food,! The people are always very nice . Never had a bad meal from there. L.p.

The fries weren't curly. I had to give the driver directions my food was cold and she didn't have any change on her. Most unprepared delivery ever! read more

Its a great place! Pizza is great! And subs awesome! Very fast delivery without extra price read more

John Johnson does not approve. I am very dissatisfied at the service and food of this place. Hope you like waiting hours for food that is trash, because that's all you get from this place... would not recommend read more

So, I'm feeling a little depressed because my once-reliable Nick's suddenly morphed into a stranger that I don't even recognize. The OLD Nick's had the tastiest, cheesiest pizza with a sauce that was just sweet enough. And their kabob salad was second to none. Tonight, we ordered and what we received didn't even resemble the "old faith" pizza place I've grown to love. I'm not sure if they have new owners, but everything about our dinner was different-the sauce, dough, salad dressing, etc. Blech! It was a greasy disc of pizza sadness. Time to explore other neighborhood spots, I suppose. Old Nick's, R.I.P. read more

Very friendly. Great roast beef sandwiches (I alway get at least one Jr with every order ). Chicken kabab salad and steak tip salads have plenty of meat. The "wild west side" pizza is AMAZING. I am very impressed with the pastrami sub, it is top shelf pastrami. Also, the "chicken breast club" sandwich is amazing and comes with your choice of fries. This has been my go-to place for 6 or 7 years now. read more

Ordered and paid on Grubhub while at work. The delivery driver stood in the lobby for 45 minutes (I wasn't able to just walk away from what I was doing and thought they would leave it at the front desk like every other place I've used on Grubhub) claiming I didn't pay him even though the money was already taken off my credit card, his tip included. read more

Always friendly service when you go there. Phone orders are tough with the thick accent but never had an issue. The Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza is always my go to. Decent cheesesteak subs as well. My wife loves their chicken Cesar salad read more

I ended up getting food poisoning after ordering a fish and chips. I spent a week in the hospital throwing up and diarrhea.

Very tasty food, although I did have a bad experience. My coworkers and I have been there many times. The last, and I do mean last time, two of us had hair in our chicken, broccoli and ziti. When I went over to ask for a new plate, the man was rude and said,"I don't know how there could be hair on the chicken....it's cooked on the grill." Really?! So burnt hair is ok? When my coworker went over, a female staff member told her,"Thats not hair, it's part if the broccoli." Not sure about anybody else, but I've never seen hairy broccoli!! Had the attitude been different and an apology offered, I might reconsider revisiting. I will NOT return to Nick's. read more

New owners. Prices have gone way up and quality has gone way down. Too bad. We have gone here for years.

I work down the street from Nick's and it is one of my favorite lunch take out spots. The chicken kebab salad is my favorite item on the menu although I absolutely love their chicken & garlic pizza as well. This place is always busy, and it should be the food is YUM! read more

I have been here multiple times because my family lives close by in south Peabody. I would have to agree with other reviews about the chicken kabob salad it is the best around. Pizza is ok, but I'm not a huge fan of Greek pizza either. The roast beef is comparable to land and sea but in my opinion not as good. I had a turkey club there tonight and it was great, it comes with steak fries and coleslaw, but they were very accommodating when I asked for a side salad instead of coleslaw. Never had a problem with customer service, staff seems nice enough. read more

By far the best chicken kabob salad on the northshore. Their dressing is outstanding!

The worst experience ever! These people definitely do not know how to run a business. My first time ever writing a negative review... Even if there's a problem, I always give restaurants a second chance. Everyone can have an off night. This however was the third time we had an issue! Tonight we were promised a 30 minute delivery window, after 45 minutes we called to check on our order, we were told it would be sent out soon! I told the woman on the phone that this was not acceptable and that food was going to be cold. She assured me that it would be hot. She told me that if we lived nearby we would be best off picking it up because they were very busy. When my husband got there to pick up the pizza, it was definitely very cold. When he complained about this, the response he got was that he should try being on their side of the counter! Nice customer service! I definitely do not recommend this place and will not go back again! read more