Milo Toys & Collectables has to be one of the top toy stores in New York…read more Located in a shopping center in Oakdale, Long Island, this super large store offers a huge selection of both vintage and unique items you might be searching for your collection. They offer a variety of old toys, figurines, tapes, CDs, DVDs, all kinds of sports cards, board games, and many other unique items. It's the largest toy store I've ever visited. As a collector of Batman 1966 memorabilia, I found an amazing array of items to enhance my collection. The also Buy Sell and Trade. This place is definitely worth a visit.

This is a business that hires nasty judgemental workers for some reason. Despite the sections being…read moreunclear in store, they have at least one employee who is actively rude and judgemental towards customers. Go to tri county instead

This is a great store. I can't believe some absolute jabroni wrote a negative review because of…read moretheir lighting being too good. And, I'm sorry, if you can't figure out parking in this area, you are an absolute idiot. Great store. Great website. Staff is very helpful, but also happy to let you browse on your own. Support small local businesses! Don't be like Matthew C.!

Awesome comic store just off of Main Street in Sayerville…read more The store is decent sized and the young lady working there was very pleasant. They have a decent selection of mostly newer comics and toys as well. They did have some vintage Star Wars toys and some other vintage stuff too but they mostly have more recent comics and toys. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the area

My son requested Pokémon cards for his birthday (of course), so we stopped by in Bellport, huge…read moreselection, super friendly staff, and honestly a hidden gem if you're into cards or collectibles. Definitely making this a regular stop. Plus, my daughter even got some Squishmallows and Moana cards!

The shop is incredible. Its vast open floor plan is filled with incredible sports memorabilia and a…read morevariety of other collectibles. Staff were extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Would definitely recommend.

Friendly and nerdy staff - what you would expect. But the selection was a bit overpriced. They…read morepriced games that were heavily damaged the same as games that weren't damaged at all. I think if you're willing to wait for shipping, just buy your retro games on ebay.

Love coming here. Employees are always great, friendly and there to help. Get a lot of my Pokemon…read morecards here. Great selection of stuff to check out.

Such a fun place! True to the name, nostalgia hits hard here for those that grew up in the '80s and…read moreafter. Plenty of records, toys and collectibles to sift through. For a shop of this kind, it's quite organized and even if you are not looking for anything in particular, there's always something that will grab your attention. It was an enjoyable trip down memory lane!

Nostalgia and all kind of good memories hit you from the moment you enter this amazing magical…read moreplace,

This is the only comic book store in the area that has great prices, the best variety, great…read morequality, and the most chill owner ever with great service

This place was my childhood, bookstore when I went to revisit it in my mid 20s I pretty much bought…read moreevery single thing I didn't have enough money to buy when I was a kid and it was still there. I was so happy I love that place I don't care what people say. I will always go back when I get a chance and I'll buy more stuff so hurry up and get what you can before I come back, pretty chill guy just as I remember him when I was a kid. The value of everything is not so badly priced, but in my opinion, it's worth it. The selection of everything is beyond amazing.

Very Nice card store in Patchogue offering a wide variety of Pokémon, sports, and other card…read morecollectible genres. This is a locally owned and run small business and people who work there are very nice and knowledgeable/helpful. Excellent selection in a very large/clean store with tables available for game play. I took my son to several different card stores in Suffolk County and this is his favorite one for Pokémon because of their extensive selection. This is a nice addition to the neighborhood.

7/11/26 market price on chaos rising is $42. Payed $50 plus tax. These guys are just scalpers. I…read morethink if you dont go in there looking like a dweeb they try to play you and upcharge think people can't check prices online

This establishment has been an M family favorite for many years now. The proprietor is a treasure…read more If it's not in stock simply ask and every effort will be made to find the item and to order it! Highly recommended!

I have been going to Jim and his store since my intro to gaming back in 1978. While this is a…read moresmaller store, with a corresponding smaller selection, I have never felt pressured to buy anything. Jim has become a welcoming presence in my life, and I make it a point to buy a few things a year, just to help a friend out.