This is a great store. I can't believe some absolute jabroni wrote a negative review because of…read moretheir lighting being too good. And, I'm sorry, if you can't figure out parking in this area, you are an absolute idiot. Great store. Great website. Staff is very helpful, but also happy to let you browse on your own. Support small local businesses! Don't be like Matthew C.!

I tried. I shopped at this store several times. I really wanted to like this place so I can…read morecontinue to support local comic book shops. But, alas, I must pass on this establishment for the following reasons: 1-In my over 40 years of collecting, I noticed that successful comic shops on LI have a certain 'jenesequa'....a community-nerd appeal that is hard to define. They are a little dark, in bad areas and rough around the edges (in a good way). They have survived gentrification with just a few scars. They are a place where you can befriend other nerds and talk shop for hours about Mexican foils, Maria Wolf and MCU plot fails. Sayville comics is small, bright and meticulous, like your grandmas high-tea room after she cleaned. If comic book shops are an experience, this store is a brand new bright lime-green neon sign that everyone must stay 15 feet away from. This approach probably works in higher end towns that cater to professional parents buying the latest expensive toy craze on tic tock for their children. I prefer other shops with more room, seasoned staff and less ostentation. Awful parking.

Fantastic store, great prices and merchandise. Had all the cards and sports products I was looking…read morefor. Highly recommended

The bearded hoarder is a great location in the heart of Sayville. 279 Railroad avenue is the new…read morelocation. Here you can find toys from your childhood, pokemon, viral Tik Tok squishy toys, comics, and more! Kevin (The owner) also does trading too. Bring in your treasures and leave with something new or a wad of cash!

Awesome store with an incredible selection or old and new toys, comics, records, and really unique…read moreantiques. The owner Kevin is super helpful and everything is well organized! Definitely check out this hidden gem- myself & my kids absolutely love coming here

If you can't find at least one item at Milo's, it's hard to imagine why. They offer a wide…read moreselection--ranging from toys, cards, and video games to DVDs, VHS, and vinyl--all priced fairly. With frequent restocks and constantly changing inventory, there's always something new and worth checking out. Plus, be sure to talk to Mike--he's the best and always great to deal with.

When I talk about a great toy store only one comes to mind. Mike and Lauren who run Milo's are…read moreamazing people and are super knowledgeable about all toy lines. Whether you collect vintage or modern they probably have it! Milo's also trades as well. I highly recommend them!

My sons favorite place to go to support his card hobby. Knowledgeable staff. Quality cards. Good…read moreprices. Nice people. What more could you ask for?

This place is great! They have a huge selection of sports cards, collectibles and other…read morememorabilia. Everyone there is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. I highly recommend stopping in and checking out their merchandise!

This is the only comic book store in the area that has great prices, the best variety, great…read morequality, and the most chill owner ever with great service

This place was my childhood, bookstore when I went to revisit it in my mid 20s I pretty much bought…read moreevery single thing I didn't have enough money to buy when I was a kid and it was still there. I was so happy I love that place I don't care what people say. I will always go back when I get a chance and I'll buy more stuff so hurry up and get what you can before I come back, pretty chill guy just as I remember him when I was a kid. The value of everything is not so badly priced, but in my opinion, it's worth it. The selection of everything is beyond amazing.

We come here for our smoking needs ad essentials. Vapes…read more Pods. Cigarettes, beer, candy, chips

Costume party, conventions, any type of theme event, this place has you covered! They have ears,…read morewigs, wings, masks, and even a magic section. They also sell really huge and realistic Halloween decorations. They even have a prank section. Now I know where to go for my niche costumes.

This is the type of place you can only find in New York. A smorgasbord of costumes, makeup, horror…read moreprops! Tons of masks, hats, headpieces (think cats, bunnies, demonesses). Tons of prosthetics and fake blood, dyes, wigs, etc. There is a special downstairs section where big time productions like SNL often rent costumes and props. They have entire sections of specialized apparel ranging from zombie to cop to dominatrix and BDSM. Steam punk, cowboys and country, retro 50s, 60s hippies, 70s. Anything you need for Halloween, plays/shows/productions, or events, you can find it here. Tons of people to help at every corner of the store, and all are attentive and kind. Also a lot of photo ops around the store, including a Heath Ledger joker, various Child's Play alum, Art the Clown, Michael Myers, and a ton of other huge animatronics and props.

Love coming here. Employees are always great, friendly and there to help. Get a lot of my Pokemon…read morecards here. Great selection of stuff to check out.

Amazing service, game selection is great, and staff is knowledgeable. If you're looking to offload…read moreyou're retro game collection they will gladly take a look at what you have and give you the fairest price you could possibly get. Love this store and we need more like it on Long Island.