Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    NewCastle Comics and Games

    4.8 (5 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 1 week ago

    NewCastle Comics and Games Photos

    You might also consider

    More like NewCastle Comics and Games

    Recommended Reviews - NewCastle Comics and Games

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Excellent store. Clean, orderly, with well informed staff. This is our favorite local comic book and game shop

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Comic Books 214 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Coffee Cat Comics - Funko Pops
 Trading Cards
 One Piece

    Coffee Cat Comics

    3.5(4 reviews)
    30.2 mi

    Tight!! Not much…read morespace, but a cool shop. Lots of comic books to choose from. I saw some live game play too, in the back. Pretty fun.

    The joys of discovering a comic shop in the mall. Where geek culture thrives, and new adventures…read moreawait. Or at least, that's what we thought. What we actually found was a frustrating barrier to entry, not just into the store's event, but into the hobby itself. Let's talk about the Gundam TCG beta event. You'd think being physically present, cash in hand, eager to participate would be enough. Nope. The real gatekeeper? A smartphone. No phone, no game. It doesn't matter if you're a dedicated player or a teen excited to get into the hobby--if you don't have the app, you're out. And let's not forget, to even use the app, you have to hand over your personal data and jump through digital hoops. When I called ahead to confirm, I was given a workaround: "Just emulate the app on a computer." Sounds simple, right? Except, if you actually read the terms of service, that's a violation of the rules. So, the store's solution? Encourage rule-breaking just to participate in an event they're hosting. Yikes. This is exactly how you alienate an audience. Five eager teens, $70 per player, all turned away because they didn't meet a completely unnecessary tech requirement. And that's just us. We have a group of dads and teens always wanting to dabble in new games to see if they hold their weight. There were plenty of other potential players in the same boat. Imagine the revenue lost. Imagine the enthusiasm squashed. All because we agree smart phones dont belong in our teens hands. Now we got this store trying to tell us our kids need smart phones. This store, like its now-closed predecessor in the Mills, seems to have forgotten a key business principle: know your customer. Not every hobbyist is glued to a smartphone, and forcing a tech barrier on a physical card game is absurd. We play these games because we would rather play these than sit on a phone. The whole situation is ironic. 1/10--because at the end of the day, a comic shop should bring people into the hobby, not shut them out. Good luck--you're going to need it.

    Photos
    Coffee Cat Comics
    Coffee Cat Comics
    Coffee Cat Comics

    See all

    Heroes and Horrors Games - Pokémon card...it was Misty's, but now it's mine!!

    Heroes and Horrors Games

    4.6(9 reviews)
    23.6 mi

    I've been coming here regularly for the last ten years and will miss it when I move. Nick is the…read moreabsolute nicest and their selection is absolutely unbeatable. This place is really a gem of Windsor, and honestly probably the best place to stock up for MtG in all of NoCo.

    Felt like writing a well deserved good review today because frankly I have been going to this card…read moreshop since I was 16 and I am currently 28 years old and it's long overdue! This shop means a lot to me and has created great memories for me growing up and even today as an adult. Bringing my kids here is kinda surreal because it feels like I've gone full circle haha anyways. The owners are awesome people and have always treated me with great respect and helped me with anything I was looking for and they rarely don't have MTG singles I'm looking for, ide say they generally have what I'm looking for 85% of the time. And if they don't have it they are always willing to order cards in for me! Their prices are very fair and I love coming here for events I always feel welcomed and never excluded from anything. I also love that they always make sure the kids are included and treat my daughters kindly even sometimes giving gifts like little penny cost Pokemon cards which might not seem like a lot but it's so big to them and that's those kind of things that leave good memories in little children's heads. Thank you Heroes and Horrors for bringing such fun into my life and may it continue to bring joy to my children :)

    Photos
    Heroes and Horrors Games - Our collectible card games and  accessories.  We have one of the largest Magic: The Gathering singles collections in Northern Colorado.

    Our collectible card games and accessories. We have one of the largest Magic: The Gathering singles collections in Northern Colorado.

    Heroes and Horrors Games
    Heroes and Horrors Games - Come play Warhammer 40k or Age of Sigmar on our felted table.  We have terrain available for use.

    See all

    Come play Warhammer 40k or Age of Sigmar on our felted table. We have terrain available for use.

    JNJ Comic books and games - Board games!

    JNJ Comic books and games

    4.9(14 reviews)
    19.4 mi

    There hasn't been a Comic or Games shop in this corner of town for about 20 years. Maybe longer. I…read morewas very excited to see a big new sign for "Comics & Games". My kids were also excited. Met James and Jamie and got to talk with them about their journey to opening this store. It's more than a business... it's them taking a leap and sharing a passion that their family has with others looking for a place to call "their local shop / hangout". Something I loved was that there wasn't just a big pile of unorganized back issues. Instead, there were complete series of back issues bundled together at reasonable prices so you didn't have to hunt and peck to find them all. Also, there are weekly/monthly episodes available for people of all ages and interests. A good collection of trades as well. Also, they make it very easy to order anything you might not see on the shelves. They've also dedicated a nice chunk of the back of the store to a game area where people can come and hang out and have a place to play and meet. Not my thing, but still really cool for people that need that type of local community spot. Above all, I love that I can take my teenager, and my very small children into this shop and not see near-pornographic fantasy art on the walls. It's a safe place for people of all ages and for parents like me that don't want to expose my small children to adult themes until they're old enough to understand what they're seeing. It's really rare to find a place like this. Owners that take the time to talk to every visitor. People not trying to be an "empire" but to still have a personal touch. It's really a cool little shop and I suggest people give it a shot. At first it may not seem like there's a ton in the store, but just talk to one of the owners and you'll find out that there's more than you can handle nicely organized right in front of you. Give this place a shot. Take a risk and try giving them your business. You won't be disappointed. Obviously I wasn't, becasue I HATE writing online reviews but just HAD to for this place. Keep it up J&J! Happy to have you in the neighborhood!

    Really small tucked away comic shop with some interesting and tiny selections. The lady who works…read morethere is nice, but not very knowledgeable of the things they sell. When presented with information they are charging 70%-100% more than other retailers, she (what seemed like) BS'd about why that is the case. I'm all for supporting local businesses, but when they charge so much more than anyone else, it's hard to find value in buying from this place.

    Photos
    JNJ Comic books and games - Some of our featured local art

    Some of our featured local art

    JNJ Comic books and games - Some of our featured local art

    Some of our featured local art

    JNJ Comic books and games - Some of our featured local art

    See all

    Some of our featured local art

    NewCastle Comics and Games - comicbooks - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...