I rarely order food from a restaurant without doing some research first, but this time I was in a hurry and my kids were craving pizza. I also remembered I had a $5 birthday coupon on Toast, and the place was conveniently located on my way home, so I ordered a large Mexico Combo without checking any reviews. When I arrived, the map showed that I had reached the destination, but I couldn't find the restaurant anywhere. After driving around the block one more time, I finally discovered that the pizza shop was actually operating inside a liquor store. The moment I walked in, I had a bad feeling. The overall cleanliness and hygiene standards seemed questionable. I honestly wanted to cancel my order right then, but since I had already paid, I decided to wait for my pizza. Unfortunately, my concerns turned out to be justified. The pizza was not good at all. Even my kids, who usually love pizza, each ate only one slice. To make matters worse, my son found a mosquito on top of his slice. At that point, we decided not to risk eating anything else and threw away more than half of the pizza. Lesson learned: always check reviews and do some research before ordering food, and don't let a coupon convince you to try a place you wouldn't otherwise consider. read more

See all

The pizza used to be better, but lately each slice they only put 2 pepperoni and 2 ground beef and mostly cheese! jeez read more

New York Pizza - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

Rotten meat. This is supposed to be a linguiça and pineapple pizza. I am Portuguese so I know what linguiça is supposed to look like and smell like as soon as I open the box to this pizza it smelled rotten. I'm not sure how they even put the pizza in the box and thought it was OK to deliver. We often order from this pizza place, but I will not be returning ever again. Bro, the linguica is BROWN! We tossed the entire pizza. I'm so appalled. read more

New York Pizza - Brown rotten meat, supposed to be Linguica and pineapple pizza. - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

No complaints here the lady that helped me was really nice. The price for the X-Large pizza and a soda was pretty decent. My order was ready pretty fast and the pizza was really good not too saucy extra cheesy with pepperoni. read more

BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE! This place just went to $#!+. I ordered a pizza with EXTRA SAUSAGE & EXTRA MUSHROOMS & this is the crap I get! I see more cheese on this damn thing. There is extra cheese though! When I pull I slice off, the f*ckin' whole thing of cheese just slides off. There are parts of the pizza were you can see the bottom layer. It doesn't stay on the pizza!! WTF?! They got cheap! They're Rude! BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE!! I was a loyal customer with this place, but they just lost a customer, because they couldn't even offer to fix this issue. SMH! I didn't want to give this place any stars BTW.... read more

Fast service. Fantastic food very fresh. The pizza was delicious and very hot. Door person polite and nice.

The worst experience at a pizza place EVER! The person answering the phone had a thick accent and I thought they were going to screw up my order, and they did. I ordered half pineapple and half mushroom. They put all the toppings on one side. I asked for a salad with ranch, they only brought ranch. The driver called from the street asking me to come down and get it, but someone from the pizza joint left a coupon on my door so they know how to get it. Forgot my salad. And the pizza tasted bad. I'm back charging it and never will go back, hopefully this review will save ppl from a horrible experience read more

New York Pizza - Asked for half and half. They put all toppings on 1 side ;( - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

The pizza was k but I think u should go somewhere else cuz there is way more better stuff than this .

Bay Area, listen up!!!!! Stop playing with me.... The best New York Pizza you're ever going to get, period point blank, is in my HOMETOWN HAYWARD! A st New York pizza has been putting it down since I was 19 yrs old, lol. 21 years later and they are still putting it down. The original New York Pizza aside from NY! I know I know, some will argue and say Tennyson New York pizza was the original but to me these guys are the original bc they have the best tasting toppings and they've been consistent for decades. You get what you pay for no doubt. While everyone else is being cheap with their toppings super skimpy, This place gives you exactly what you ask for. I drove literally an hour from the South Bay just to pick up a pizza from Hayward. Shame on the rest of you pizza parlors! None of you guys are even competing with these guys. Even funnier, they're under new ownership. Paul's family sold it, but guess what? The new owners didn't change a thing. The pizza is still amazing. Especially their ground beef and beef pepperoni. My fiance and I are Muslim, I don't eat pork, so this place has everything beef, which is so nice since everyone else always has pork. They have great customer service, and the people running it are sweethearts. I'm going to post close-up pictures of the pizza. I'm never going to go anywhere else when craving pizza. I guess I'm going to have to drive an hour to get to my old school pizza joint. Thanks, guys, for keeping it original. See you guys again. read more

See all

I have a tip for you. The phone number appears to be 510-5 82-3333. The one on the wall on the side of the building does not answer. You can order pizza by the slice and they have a veggie pizza for $5.99. Basically, they make it fresh. So, order ahead of time even for a slice. Then go over to the dollar store. Grab a 16 fluid ounce Coca-Cola including 0 cal for $1.25. Put in for a super lotto quick pick because you just saved yourself over a dollar in soda price at the liquor store. The crust was exceptional. I'd come here again. It's a shame that the outdoor seating in the back is not used for café seating as a restaurant. We could use an outdoor seating spot like this as a restaurant café with this good parking. All these new developments happening and this outdoor seating café is underutilized as a liquor store and a pizza place in the back. No seating all pick up and delivery. Hayward city, see if you can talk him into making this a café. Offer them a great deal on grants for upgrading this brick building into something that's more earthquake. Friendly if that's the problem. It's a great addition to the urban scene downtown. Lots of potential! Higher return than the little café at the library. And turn the Lucky into a Trader Joe's! read more

We love the pizza here! Consistently solid. And everyone who works here is really nice!

Call ahead or order online to get a quick bite.Not too bad.Not a dine in pizza joint it's in a liquor store so if you want beer with your pizza to go than this is the spot. read more

Amazingg Pizza place, loved it!! Just the way I like it! Great staff and great customer service. Take away service and delivery available. Inside a liquor store, great bright inside. read more

Non pizza related. But if you're a fan of Sand One a Los Angeles Chicana Artist. Her only Bay Area mural is on the wall of this place. If you are a fan of her work. You can visit here. There is parking at the front of and next to the pizza place for free. read more

1st time at this location, I grew up eating at the Tennyson location. Not sure if they're the same owners. Here's a breakdown of my review. Location: The are on a Main Street (A St), but they're somewhat hidden and there's lots of ghetto people in their parking lot. Ambiance: It's inside a liquor store. So this is NOT A SIT DOWN spot. Service: They were nice and were quick. Food: We ordered a XL Pizza (BBQ Chicken & Pepperoni) & an order of buffalo wings (10 pieces). The wing were cooked good and I liked the flavor, however they had a unclean taste. Like they're fresh wings not washed or cleaned properly before cooking. The pizza was just alright. Nothing to rave about in a good or bad way, it was just...meh. I will say, they were generous with the ingredients, because at other places they're skimpy with the toppings. read more

See all

Pizza is really good. I love how they offer beef pepperoni since I don't eat pork. Everyone's really nice here and there and always consistent. read more

This is excellent pizza for when you need it delivered. I recently wanted to order some pizza for a few friends but did not want to order from a chain. I ordered a 20-inch "party size" pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and sun-dried tomatoes online via Yelp. The pizza itself was very good--the sauce and crust were awesome. The delivery came on time and the pizza was hot. Price was a good value; when you order via yelp the charge is around 2 bucks btw. As a funny side note, the box was huge (because the pizza was over 20 inches across) and luckily I had it because I couldn't find an umbrella on a recent rainy day; well, the box was a great shelter lol. I'm almost tempted to order the larger 'King Kong' size pizza just to see what type of box that is--luckily, I have wide doors. I believe this establishment lives up to its name as far as NY style pizza and we will be ordering from here again! read more

See all

I order a pizza from them all the time. There customers service is very bad. The clerk will be on the phone all the time and makes you wait unnecessarily long. Then the quality of the food isn't that good. We usually get sausage, basil, and spinach. The quality of their sausage and vegetables were terrible. I highly recommend going somewhere else with your time. read more

I try to give businesses the benefit of the doubt even when rated so low but this business makes sense why they have such bad reviews. If you want longer wait times than given, greasy wings, a chicken ceaser with more croutons than chicken, and a half and half that looks more like a 60/40 pizza than this is your place! And to top it off, the manager, Mr. Singh has the worst customer service ever. We were quoted 45 minutes to an hour. As time passed, being that it was a Friday, we gave them some time before I called in to inquire. It seemed as if they couldn't find my order and then suddenly the worker stated the driver was on the way. 20 minutes later we finally receive our order. We pay and then come to realize how horrible the order is. We ordered a half Hawaiian half combo and it was definitely more Hawaiian, not a 50/50 as we requested. Also the peppers and cheese seemed to have been thrown in the pizza box and spilled all over. The chicken ceaser, which is hard to mess up had more croutons than chicken. The wings, sat in a pool of oil and were very bland for being barbecue. When we called in to speak to a manager we were place on hold twice and finally spoke with Mr. Singh. I explained the situation and I felt a refund for a horrible order and a long wait time with no communication from the business was more than called for. Well after arguing with Mr. Singh, he stated if we wanted a refund he would do so but he would instruct the driver to come back and pick up the order. This is where I lost it ... As a business if you make a mistake, your job is to correct the situation not to aggravate the customer even more. So not only did we get a horrible order but we were threatened in having the food taken. TRUST ME, NEVER ORDER FROM THIS BUISNESS!!! You would be better off with Little Ceasers or a Costco $10 pizza or hell even a Digiorno ..... read more

See all

The food was pretty good, and reasonable prices. This time I had the chicken Tika masala which I recommended along with the vegetarian pizza and a side of garlic breadstick. read more

New York Pizza - Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

I get sometimes we're all busy, but when you commit to 50 mins but show up after 1hr 40mins it's inexcusable. Commit to a time you can actually make, and let me decide if I'd still like to order from your place! read more

UPS sent me my package here, so I came to pick it up and decided to order pizza since, I'm here. Well the pizza was super overly cooked. As u can see in the pic. Soo over cooked the sauce was dry and the crust super crunchy and rough. The cheese was like one piece. You know cheese usually stretches when u bite into it? This one didn't! I don't know if I just happen to have bad luck and they forgot to take the pizza out or if this is usually how the pizza turns out? I just know that I will not be coming here for pizza again. I need more sauce and less time cooking. My jaw literally hurt after eating it.. so tough. Are used to live in New York for seven years and I'm disappointed that they call themselves New York pizza. No way!!! read more

New York Pizza - Here is the super dry over cooked pizza w burnt edges - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

This is my go to pizza place in Hayward. Their prices are reasonable and they have nice greasy pies. I love getting the garlic cheese bread with ranch. For like $6, it really is a great deal. I've had their lasagna as well which was satisfying. It is an odd setup though, with them in the rear of a ghetto liquor store. Usually 2 people working and they always seem to be busy. I think they deliver too, but I always pickup because they are so close to my house. Hats off to the dope artwork mural on the front of the building. read more

See all

Crust was too thin and like cardboard, toppings were tasty but wasted on a miserable crust

Pretty damn good. We got the pesto pizza with chicken and the works. Large was about $17 and the do delivery for $1 if you call in. The pesto is awesome, first time doing that and not the basic tomato. You can pay credit on the phone or cash. read more

New York Pizza - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Horrible experience, WILL NEVER ORDER HERE AGAIN. Save yourself the time and the headache and do not order from these clowns... Just ordered a pizza and it came with all the toppings slid off too the side... contacted the OWNER who asked for pictures and then had the audacity to ask if I wanted store credit.... Did not offer to remake the pizza and was very rude. Now waiting for the driver to come up this JUNK. read more

New York Pizza - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

First customers to order their Super King Kong 32" pizza! Great size pizza if feeding a LARGE GROUP! Highly recommend. Forsure ordering from here again. read more

New York Pizza - Super King Kong Combination - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

Simple pizza place with vegetarian options situated in a convenience store. I got the large Hawaiian and a salad. All in all, pretty good. Usually I pick up an energy drink and snacks from the grocery aisle while I'm here. I'm all about the convenience these days. I usually get decent service here as well read more

Omfg i found my new pizza place!!! Affordable and super nice staff and oh yes.... Excellent pizza

They are not honorable. I ordered a King Kong Pizza Deal with a coupon and they didn't honor it! I had a coupon for 25.99 and they Charged me 34.99. They said my coupon was old and the price is higher now. 1. I believe this is illegal as the coupon doesn't have and expiration date, and 2, I wont be ordering from them again! read more

New York Pizza - Honor your coupon! No expiration date on the coupons! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

I usually don't like to give reviews without having tried the food, however, when an establishment refuses to give you what you ordered I guess it has to come to this. So we order a special that comes with an XL pizza and a free medium. I heard the order clearly and out loud, no mention of the availability only the agreement to it. Fast forward an hour or so later when the pizzas have still not showed up and we call getting many apologies from whoever answered. They said are pizza would be there within minutes. Fifteen minutes later are pizzas arrived, but it's not what we ordered. It's two XL pizzas with garlic bread. We mention that this isn't the right order and proceed to say what we did order and how it cost $21.99 because it's the special. They say oh well this order that we have here is $31 so after some back and forth the driver calls his boss. We talked to him on the phone where he doesn't apologize and say, "hey, look we're sorry about this and we'll give you this order for that special price." No. He proceeded to argue with us about it and make a big deal about it. He would rather take the loss of these two pizzas to be wasted than any money whatsoever. All this over $10. He made it seem as though we were trying to get over on him when all we wanted was the right order. Unbelievable. Don't even bother ordering from this place, this is the worst customer service I have ever seen. read more

So fast delivery! The best pizza around! Great prices as well! We come here all the time.

Pizza was average conveyor-belt style pizza, NOT New York style. Value is good for the money, no dine-in offered. Its literally a pizza take-out in the back of a liquor store. That being said, the pizza is big, fun, fast, hot, and you can get about anything else you need while you're there. read more

New York Pizza - Huge 25" pizza! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

I don't get all the negative reviews. This place is our default pizza place, which means we order here quite a bit. We've never had a problem. They are always on time or early and they have yet to mess up an order. The pizza itself is fantastic. I really like my "new england" pizza and this is the closest out here I"ve seen in the bay area. The salads are pretty solid as well. I would not recommend actually eating there though- this is more of a pickup or delivery place than an eat in one. read more

Best pizza in town. Not overly saucy and the crust beats all the other pizza joints. We've been getting pizza here for 10 years and now that we've moved outta town we still drive back for it. read more

This place hits the spot every time. I happen to stop by here today and the crust is still chewy with a good crunch, the cheese is firm and the pepperoni is savory. I ordered two slices but wished I ordered four. read more

New York Pizza?! NOT!!! No seasoning. The dough was mushy. No no no people. I'll have to wait till I am back in New York. Ugh!!! read more

pizza is okay, ordered Hawaiian and got a pepperoni, might have been an accident but overall i think Tennyson road NY pizza is better

This place doesn't even deserve one star, but apparently I have to give them something in order to save people and keep them from going there...lol. First of all, they are a liquor store...so do I really need to even say more? I mean, c'mon a pizzeria in a liquor store is just a recipe for disaster. They have been voted number one on numerous occasions and I have yet to figure out which drunk person was bribed to say that. Between you and me (and the entire internet), I believe that one of their very large extended family members has some pull at the local newspaper. I have found out some very horrible things about what goes on behind the pizza counter things such as saliva and other bodily fluids getting mixed into the sauce. Ok, so I can say all of this because I live right around the corner from them and used to buy my smokes there (and I dated one of the employees....shhh...). Anyway, this place scares me and I don't usually get scared. I refuse to patronize it and I urge the same for all of those in, or visiting, Hayward. Don't get tempted by their 21" KING KONG pizza just because of its size. This place needs to be inspected....unannounced. read more

Was super hungry....coming off of a Mexican feast, I kinda wanted something different, but my tummy & taste buds wouldn't have been mad had another taco came down the shoot. So banking on my memory to remember who sold pizza slices close to the house. NY pizza came first.... so I head over the fattie in me wanted 2 slices, not remembering the slices being very big. 2 slices of pepperoni..... I walk around selecting a beer, Eye of the Hawk...good dark ale, remember this is inside of a liquor store. I come back to pick up my slices I swear I have a 1/4 of a LARGE pizza, my gosh....looking and thinking hell I only need one slice of that. So yup I ate 2 and dumped the rest...it's not as good the next day read more