Order New York Pizza and Pints Takeout or Delivery
New York Pizza and Pints Photos
NEW YORK PIZZA AND PINTS ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like New York Pizza and Pints
Recommended Reviews - New York Pizza and Pints
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Stopped in the for first time for lunch while I was in the neighborhood on business. Ordered a slice of their Margherita pizza. It was huge, hot and the best Margherita pizza I have ever had!!! And I'm almost 75 yrs old and I've had pizzas in NY, Philly, Chicago, Rome & Florence...well, a lot of places. Fresh big slices of tomato, perfect seasoning, a decent amount of sauce (I hate pizza that looks like a sauce drought!) and the edge crust was just as soft and tasty as the rest of the pizza. What else can I say? Perfect! Glad I didn't read these reviews before I came or I might have missed it. Maybe people don't bother to review good pizza, only if it's not good or perhaps this place had some one-off days. I don't know, but if I'm within 20-30 minutes of this place at lunch or dinner, I'm coming back! Or I'll pick up a to-go order and make sure my family enjoys it. I hope you give it a chance and surely if you live or work around the Addison circle area, give it a try.
If i could give it zero stars i would. It's 11:52am. We walked in stood in line for 10 minutes before anyone came out. We had to yell so someone can hear us in the back. Then as we looked we saw the pizzas stacked on each on a cart. Obviously from the night before which i hoped they would not serve to us. Welp they sure did. It was the worse service and worse food I've had in a long time. Everyone in this establishment should be ashamed of themselves.
Been eyeballing this place for a minute. Here's all I can say....to-go, slices for delivery are a biiiig no go. I placed my order about 30min after opening. So you'd think that this would be....fresh-ish pizza, right? Soooo....why did my slices look like the pizza you pull out of the fridge 2 days after ordering it and contemplating the scale of how desperately hungry you are ...to see if you'll eat it or toss it. I got a cheese, a BYO 3 topping and a sausage. But...but...y'all....it just wasn't good. The crust was chewy ... You know the kind you sort of have to gnaw at a little to get it to rip off when you bite? The cheese was sporadic and seemed to miss the edges....the cheese pizza was thrown out bc it was deemed on that scale of 1-10 of leftover pizza, a -1. It was just sad. Now, the slices are GINORMOUS. but a GINORMOUS slice of underwhelmingly bad pizza is just...a whole lotta bad. Now....would my experience have been vastly different if I'd dined in? Perhaps? Are their whole pizzas hugely better than their slices? Quite possibly yes. Was I persuaded by my delivery results to give that a shot. Absolutely not. Definitely dissuaded. So...my rec is...of you're gonna give it a go...perhaps dine in? And avoid the slices like the plague.
You know it must not be good if you are feeding 6 teenagers (including teen boys) who are hungry and there is pizza left over. We ordered three medium pizzas on a Saturday night with garlic knots. A whole pizza and a half is still left afterwords. Yes, despite ordering an hour earlier saying that they were hungry for pizza. If teenagers don't want to finish pizzas after they are hungry, you know there must be a problem. And that problem would be "dry, flavorless, overcooked and crusty." We even had to send back the first batch of garlic knots because they were black on the bottom. The second batch wasn't that much better. Almost hockey puck-like. To add to the frustration, the lady that work there was upset that she had to redo the garlic knots. Quality control must be bad. Or finding good workers is hard right now. Good luck.
Food was not good. Pizza: very little cheese and then they added a sprinkle of extra cheese (not my request) on top as seen in picture. It was dry and not much sauce. Shaved ribeye focaccia grinder: Menu calls it shaved rib eye but it's actually just deli meat (looked like roast beef) thin sliced on bread. Two slices of deli meat in whole sandwich. Very little cheese and bell pepper wasn't cooked. Fountain soda: tasted flat "stubborn brand is name of it" soda not like regular coke and root beer branded.
Pizza was delicious! Easy ordering and service. A nice chill atmosphere, would for sure come again.
Not sure if this place is new or not but definitely a new find for me! I was out and about and got a call from my fiancé to go pick up a pizza from this location. It's in Addison circle and has about two to three parks out front. There's a parking garage near by but not ideal if you are alone and it's late. Especially if it's just for pickup. I walked in and there was no line and I let them know I had an order to pick up. I gave them the name and they turned around and placed the LARGEST pizza I've seen on the corner! I was in total shock. This pizza was 24"! Warning: THIS WILL NOT FIT IN YOUR FRONT SEAT! Lol! I had to put this bad boy in my trunk. Any who, I love the cheese they use and the pizza had a good taste to it. Wasn't crazy about the sausage they had, so I'd stick to pepperoni with mushrooms in the future. Oh they're also an authentic New York style pizza, I haven't been to New York so have nothing to compare it to but I thought it was decent. Great for when you have company and have people to feed.
Cool place. Cool location. 2 out of 10 pizza. Dry pizza with hardly any sauce or cheese on it. Skimped on toppings. Crust was burnt. Took four bites & walked out. Large portion was a plus but expensive for an underwhelming slice of pizza. Won't be back.
I've been to the Carrollton location with my family and have had their giant pie, good stuff. Decided to order a pie for a co-worker and myself. After delivery & a service fee I paid over 20 bucks - I have no problem with that if I'm getting what I'm told. 14" pie - no. Off by at least 2". Enough for 2 adults - barely. Not a plate, napkin, cheese or red pepper flakes either. Certainly you guys can do better.
We just finished a photoshoot in Addison and my wife looks at me and says babe, I'm in the mood for some pizza... I then look at her and say not Skinny Pizza, and she goes on to say it's not there anymore it's a new place NY Pizza. I rolled my eyes, me being from NY said, come on another pizza joint trying to be NY PizZa in Dallas. Well we called in and ordered a cheese and pepperoni pie. We then drive back to pick it up, and decide to try a slice while they made the made the pies. WOW I was blown away. The dough is perfection, the ratio marinera to cheese is a formula! These people got it right!!! Warning 1 slice is equivalent to 2 slices just so you are aware before ordering. Definitely ordering from here when I'm craving pizza. Welcome to the neighborhood!
Something has changed in their pizza, the cheese is different. Lower grade. Thanks it was good while it lasted.
My wife and I must have hit them on a good day because our Saturday lunch was quite good! I had a 1/2 Caesar salad with ranch dressing and the chef also included a container of Caesar dressing. Both were phenomenal! And the croutons were crispy and well seasoned. Our server also gave each of us plastic flatware and salt and pepper packets sealed in a plastic bag. Very hygienic! Both of us ordered a slice of cheese and burger pizza. It was pretty good but I could have used more cheese and less of the overly seasoned tomato sauce. My wife could not get enough of their iced tea and must have refilled her cup at least 3 times; I liked the ability to customize my tea with the awesome lemonade dispenser nearby! Other than the overly seasoned pizza sauce my only other gripe is that they charge a 3% fee for processing your payment if using a credit card. Nobody said anything about that when we paid; l just happened to request a receipt.
This new pizza joint is walking distance from our apartment and we couldn't be more excited!! Great food, friendly service, and good vibes! Come hungry! I ordered the chef's special which is a GIANT slice, Caesar salad, pickle, and a drink. Then I went back and got the tiramisu which was also very good. The prices were very reasonable. They're currently waiting on a liquor license which I hope comes soon, because I saw they also had some fun bar games (cornhole, Jenga, and a NY themed chess set).
I visited my friend house in the Addison area. I was all the time pass though this place when I was walked with my dog. Smells make me to eat there. And I had chance to tried this place. We ordered slice pizza. Combination pizza(1/5)- too salty for me and difficult cut with knife. Buffalo chicken pizza(1/5)- too salty too much sauce for me. I eaten better place for eating pizza. Definitely I really disappointed this place. Just experienced and will not try this place again. We wished this pizza for Togo to home and use scissor for easy cut. waiter seems friendly. read more
This pizza is HUGE! Like a slice is gigantic and worthy of a photo. It's also really, REALLY GOOD! Their dough, sauce and cheese are always delicious. I know TX is not known for pizza but you should definitely try a slice here read more
2 years ago
NY Pizza and Pints III....... Absolutely awful! Ordered thru Grubhub. Came dried out, old and burnt. We usually go to the one in Carrollton which is outstanding! #3 is horrific. I wouldn't even feed it to my dog! When we called they said it was not old, but trust me.... It was. See photos. read more
4 years ago
Stopped in the for first time for lunch while I was in the neighborhood on business. Ordered a slice of their Margherita pizza. It was huge, hot and the best Margherita pizza I have ever had!!! And I'm almost 75 yrs old and I've had pizzas in NY, Philly, Chicago, Rome & Florence...well, a lot of places. Fresh big slices of tomato, perfect seasoning, a decent amount of sauce (I hate pizza that looks like a sauce drought!) and the edge crust was just as soft and tasty as the rest of the pizza. What else can I say? Perfect! Glad I didn't read these reviews before I came or I might have missed it. Maybe people don't bother to review good pizza, only if it's not good or perhaps this place had some one-off days. I don't know, but if I'm within 20-30 minutes of this place at lunch or dinner, I'm coming back! Or I'll pick up a to-go order and make sure my family enjoys it. I hope you give it a chance and surely if you live or work around the Addison circle area, give it a try. read more
3 years ago
If i could give it zero stars i would. It's 11:52am. We walked in stood in line for 10 minutes before anyone came out. We had to yell so someone can hear us in the back. Then as we looked we saw the pizzas stacked on each on a cart. Obviously from the night before which i hoped they would not serve to us. Welp they sure did. It was the worse service and worse food I've had in a long time. Everyone in this establishment should be ashamed of themselves. read more
5 years ago
Been eyeballing this place for a minute. Here's all I can say....to-go, slices for delivery are a biiiig no go. I placed my order about 30min after opening. So you'd think that this would be....fresh-ish pizza, right? Soooo....why did my slices look like the pizza you pull out of the fridge 2 days after ordering it and contemplating the scale of how desperately hungry you are ...to see if you'll eat it or toss it. I got a cheese, a BYO 3 topping and a sausage. But...but...y'all....it just wasn't good. The crust was chewy ... You know the kind you sort of have to gnaw at a little to get it to rip off when you bite? The cheese was sporadic and seemed to miss the edges....the cheese pizza was thrown out bc it was deemed on that scale of 1-10 of leftover pizza, a -1. It was just sad. Now, the slices are GINORMOUS. but a GINORMOUS slice of underwhelmingly bad pizza is just...a whole lotta bad. Now....would my experience have been vastly different if I'd dined in? Perhaps? Are their whole pizzas hugely better than their slices? Quite possibly yes. Was I persuaded by my delivery results to give that a shot. Absolutely not. Definitely dissuaded. So...my rec is...of you're gonna give it a go...perhaps dine in? And avoid the slices like the plague. read more
5 years ago
You know it must not be good if you are feeding 6 teenagers (including teen boys) who are hungry and there is pizza left over. We ordered three medium pizzas on a Saturday night with garlic knots. A whole pizza and a half is still left afterwords. Yes, despite ordering an hour earlier saying that they were hungry for pizza. If teenagers don't want to finish pizzas after they are hungry, you know there must be a problem. And that problem would be "dry, flavorless, overcooked and crusty." We even had to send back the first batch of garlic knots because they were black on the bottom. The second batch wasn't that much better. Almost hockey puck-like. To add to the frustration, the lady that work there was upset that she had to redo the garlic knots. Quality control must be bad. Or finding good workers is hard right now. Good luck. read more
3 years ago
Food was not good. Pizza: very little cheese and then they added a sprinkle of extra cheese (not my request) on top as seen in picture. It was dry and not much sauce. Shaved ribeye focaccia grinder: Menu calls it shaved rib eye but it's actually just deli meat (looked like roast beef) thin sliced on bread. Two slices of deli meat in whole sandwich. Very little cheese and bell pepper wasn't cooked. Fountain soda: tasted flat "stubborn brand is name of it" soda not like regular coke and root beer branded. read more
6 years ago
3 years ago
Pizza was delicious! Easy ordering and service. A nice chill atmosphere, would for sure come again. read more
6 years ago
Not sure if this place is new or not but definitely a new find for me! I was out and about and got a call from my fiancé to go pick up a pizza from this location. It's in Addison circle and has about two to three parks out front. There's a parking garage near by but not ideal if you are alone and it's late. Especially if it's just for pickup. I walked in and there was no line and I let them know I had an order to pick up. I gave them the name and they turned around and placed the LARGEST pizza I've seen on the corner! I was in total shock. This pizza was 24"! Warning: THIS WILL NOT FIT IN YOUR FRONT SEAT! Lol! I had to put this bad boy in my trunk. Any who, I love the cheese they use and the pizza had a good taste to it. Wasn't crazy about the sausage they had, so I'd stick to pepperoni with mushrooms in the future. Oh they're also an authentic New York style pizza, I haven't been to New York so have nothing to compare it to but I thought it was decent. Great for when you have company and have people to feed. read more
4 years ago
Cool place. Cool location. 2 out of 10 pizza. Dry pizza with hardly any sauce or cheese on it. Skimped on toppings. Crust was burnt. Took four bites & walked out. Large portion was a plus but expensive for an underwhelming slice of pizza. Won't be back. read more
I've been to the Carrollton location with my family and have had their giant pie, good stuff. Decided to order a pie for a co-worker and myself. After delivery & a service fee I paid over 20 bucks - I have no problem with that if I'm getting what I'm told. 14" pie - no. Off by at least 2". Enough for 2 adults - barely. Not a plate, napkin, cheese or red pepper flakes either. Certainly you guys can do better. read more
7 years ago
We just finished a photoshoot in Addison and my wife looks at me and says babe, I'm in the mood for some pizza... I then look at her and say not Skinny Pizza, and she goes on to say it's not there anymore it's a new place NY Pizza. I rolled my eyes, me being from NY said, come on another pizza joint trying to be NY PizZa in Dallas. Well we called in and ordered a cheese and pepperoni pie. We then drive back to pick it up, and decide to try a slice while they made the made the pies. WOW I was blown away. The dough is perfection, the ratio marinera to cheese is a formula! These people got it right!!! Warning 1 slice is equivalent to 2 slices just so you are aware before ordering. Definitely ordering from here when I'm craving pizza. Welcome to the neighborhood! read more
4 years ago
My wife and I must have hit them on a good day because our Saturday lunch was quite good! I had a 1/2 Caesar salad with ranch dressing and the chef also included a container of Caesar dressing. Both were phenomenal! And the croutons were crispy and well seasoned. Our server also gave each of us plastic flatware and salt and pepper packets sealed in a plastic bag. Very hygienic! Both of us ordered a slice of cheese and burger pizza. It was pretty good but I could have used more cheese and less of the overly seasoned tomato sauce. My wife could not get enough of their iced tea and must have refilled her cup at least 3 times; I liked the ability to customize my tea with the awesome lemonade dispenser nearby! Other than the overly seasoned pizza sauce my only other gripe is that they charge a 3% fee for processing your payment if using a credit card. Nobody said anything about that when we paid; l just happened to request a receipt. read more
5 years ago
4 years ago
7 years ago
This new pizza joint is walking distance from our apartment and we couldn't be more excited!! Great food, friendly service, and good vibes! Come hungry! I ordered the chef's special which is a GIANT slice, Caesar salad, pickle, and a drink. Then I went back and got the tiramisu which was also very good. The prices were very reasonable. They're currently waiting on a liquor license which I hope comes soon, because I saw they also had some fun bar games (cornhole, Jenga, and a NY themed chess set). read more
4 years ago
7 years ago
GREAT pizza and a great price! The staff was very friendly and the pizza really hit the spot! Took mine to the local park and had a fun picnic :) read more
5 years ago
3 years ago
5 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
Worst excuse for cheese pizza I have ever seen and tasted!!! I complained and they just looked at me and walked away!!!! Will NEVER order from there again!!!! Gross!!!!! read more
Business owner information
Adrian C.
That is not right…
6 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
5 years ago
They are telling the truth about their NY Pizza. It is delicious with that thin crust, perfect sauce and mouth watering cheesiness that we have in the northeast. I didn't know what to expect so I was crazy to order 2 slices plus a Greek Salad. What was I thinking? I couldn't even finish one of their enormous pieces and a bite of the salad. I had to take the rest to go. It's making me want to eat it now! The music is great. 60's and 70's tines for old rock and rollers. It was like stepping back into High School and Junior high in NY. Love the spot. So great to just be able to get a great slice anytime! read more
2 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
Slices are Huge, Sodas are great, and Nice environment! However, the consistency in taste has been a little off. read more
4 years ago
Page 1 of 3
More info about New York Pizza and Pints
5026 Addison Cir
Addison, TX 75001
Directions
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - New York Pizza and Pints
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
7 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
6 years ago
5 years ago
7 years ago
6 years ago
4 years ago
7 years ago
6 years ago
