Great steaks, but very pricey! The one thing I do not like is that when you pay they start with the TIP screen. For wrapping an expensive streak? read more

It sure would be nice if these people ever replied to their email! I've been trying to find some specific cuts, and they either don't want the business, or don't know how to use email. Of 8 emails sent over the last year, not one of them has ever been responded to. Not a good way to make potential customers happy. read more

Just ordered 11 deli sandwiches to go and they were PHENOMENAL. The guy took the order over the phone early and they were ready before noon. All the sandwiches were a hit. My favorite sandwich place in Augusta read more

First of all you need to go here to take a look at all they have here! From their web site- BEEF SELECTIONS * Porterhouse * Ribeye * Ground Beef (made fresh each day) * New York Strip * Filet Mignon * Flank Steak * Stuffed Flank Steak * Beef Brisket * Filet Tail * Handmade Hamburger Patties CHICKEN SELECTIONS * All Natural Whole Chicken * All Natural Boneless, Skinless Breasts PORK SELECTIONS * Baby Back Ribs * Center Cut Pork Chops * Pork Tenderloin * Bacon Wrapped Tenderloin VEAL & LAMB SELECTIONS * Veal Chops * Veal Cutlets * Lamb Tenderloin * Bacon Wrapped Lamb Tenderloin * Lamb Loin * Leg of Lamb UNCOOKED * Goat Cheese Chicken * Greek Chicken * Stuffed Chicken Dishes * Bacon Stuffed Pork Chops * Chicken Salad * Greek Salads * Green Salads * Pasta Salads Additional cooked or prepared foods available upon request COOKED * Macaroni & Cheese * Chicken Parmesan * Veal Parmesan * Meatball Parmesan * Grilled Vegetables * Twice-Baked Potatoes * Goat Cheese Mashed Potatoes * Lasagna * Eggplant Parmesan * Baked Manicotti * Assorted Quiches * Vodka Penne * Vodka Sauce * Beef Stroganoff * Meatloaf SPECIALTY * Crown Roast * Pork Cradle Roast * Prime Roast * Stuffed Filets * Hot-or-Sweet Italian Sausage * Wine & Cheese Sausage OTHER TEMPTING OPTIONS * Specialty Cheeses * Gourmet Ravioli & Other Pastas * Exotic Sausages * International Grocery Items * Premium Charcoal * High-Quality Vegetables I HIGHLY recommend the Garlic Expressions Vinaigrette Dressing and Marinade. This is delicious on a salad. They also have a nice selections of wines. Bottom line, you can go there and get a meal for two for. About $20.00. I was surprised to see how many options they do have! Especially to pop in for the meal that night. They have great service as they make the meals for the day in front of you. Great ambience of a butcher's shop, but yet vineyard, with so many choices! Great service as soon as you walk in the door. Next time I will take pictures!!! https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Flocal.nybutcher.com%2Fevans%2F%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0J6wDCv9KAPB19o5vEJYmpB-zI2B-FEqd9gSmRNsLe9qGjpbbtZZcylu8&h=AT2u1V_OlMZJCIf5aSpvwbWFJ3sx-ABr4zP12eNwebzZHWRWrJwdXGfhKYXcVKhe4TDo_YVuzpmCIOwU9ReuMfOWzBvtYpWvrb-ewFoKfq2r-gHX1AdgRPgf4VN7gtZMKJn6RyYT read more

I ordered a prime rib and lobster tails for Christmas dinner. I arrived on Christmas Eve morning to pick up my order and they didn't have it and were unable to complete my order. I was honestly so disappointed and what made it all worse was they didn't even seem to care. I was polite and left without a fuss, but I won't be back. read more

Friendly staff. The butcher needs to put on gloves!!!! If it was not the holiday and the only place to find good lamb I would have canceled my order. read more

When selection is low at the other big stores, your local butcher is there to help. First let me say New York Butcher Shoppe, you are wrong that every time I come to stock up, the smoker is going strong with that sweet, savory, smoky aroma of low and slow cooking and every time I ask do you have anything on the pit for a walk-in customer (not even a sample), you tell me it is already pre-ordered by customers. Dang, weekend lake enthusiast, but I digress; you can get a good selection of choice meats to your liking. Try the ribeye, it is a regular cut, but it looks like a Cowboy Steak to me... If you are pressed for time or want to wine and dine, they have pre-made meals which I tried the Jerk Penne Pasta. Do not let the size of the container fool you, there are about six good single servings out of that small container. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Welcome back, but keep your distance! - Butcher Near Me - Augusta, Georgia

See all

It's pricey because of its location. The food is ok, but the sandwiches are not worth the $12-$20, given its portion size. The sides are ok and at times need more seasoning. read more

Missing Boar's Head deli meats? Try the great selection here! Really good! And while you're at it, check out their entrees and sides. Whether Surrey Center or Evans location, they're a favorite of ours. In fact, I'd almost like to keep them to ourselves, but it just wouldn't be fair! read more

First I have to send a giant thank you to one of our Yelp community members (Ron F.) for telling me for months that I needed to make it out to the monthly wine pairing hosted here. I finally took his advice and I have no regrets from the evening. For anyone local, it can be found in the middle section of the Surrey Center, all the way at the far left end, across from Finch & Fifth. So parking and shops to check out are a plenty. The wine pairing event is after hours (7 pm) so you have the place to yourself and it is only $20 a person (as a guest). Now let me go ahead and mention that if you become a monthly member ($40) it includes this wine pairing event as well as a selected bottle of white and a bottle of red wine. Plus 10% off wine purchases. That pays for itself. Back to this event. You walk in and a Greeter is being served. Pace yourself here. There will be two small plates, a main entree, and a dessert served. All of these will be paired with a different wine. And don't worry about your glass going empty. Their pours are heavy and the team is walking around with the bottle, making sure no glass goes dry. Separately, the dishes and wines were amazing. The pasta, meat, and baking skills were top notch. Everything was plated beautifully as well. The wines each had their own personality and made me mad at myself for not being a member. But the two of them together, pure joy to the palette. A bold Cab with a dense chocolate cake, that is a capstone pairing if I've ever seen one. I will point out that this is a deli by day. That means there are meats, side dishes, tomato pies, of course bottles of wine, and much more available for purchase. That also means there is very little seating. So plan to stand for the entire event (about two hours in all). But due to the nature of the group there and the curiosity to see everything there, you probably won't even care about standing (especially around that third or fourth wine pairing). I am in love with this place and look forward to returning soon (aka, next month). Attend this event, go grab lunch one day, and stop by if you are needing a quality yet affordable bottle of wine. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Wine so fine I had to make it mine. - Butcher Near Me - Augusta, Georgia

See all

I can only comment on their freshly made sandwiches, but I've come here twice for the same thing! A friend who is local to the area recommended this place when he heard I would be driving nearby. He said they were the best, freshest sandwiches in town, and I don't think I can disagree. The sandwich menu sits and the checkout counter. When I walked in, I was not immediately clear on how to order a sandwich as they also sell wine, meats, and some pre-packaged fresh food in coolers. I asked staff and they were very nice in pointing me to the proper location to order the sandwich. There is a list of signature sandwich options or you can make your own. I like my sandwiches kinda simple, so I made my own. I just got turkey, oregano, pepper jack, and tomato on white bread. All sandwiches are the same price - $10.79 with tax - so it is definitely an expensive sandwich for what I order. Still, I've now ordered the same sandwich twice, so I must find it worth the cost :) It takes about 15 minutes to get the sandwich, which I found somewhat surprising because it wasn't that busy the first time I went in there and it's not that complicated of a sandwich. Again, I went back again after my first time so it's obviously not enough to keep me away. It just seemed odd to me, that's all. Not the greatest system to order, especially if someone is already at the counter and you're waiting. They really should find some way to make it more obvious and more efficient to get the order in, but at least everyone who works there is incredibly nice in getting you what you need. read more

New York butcher shop is great. I got some pork chops there recently that were some of the best I have ever had. I had some lamb chops from there last year that a friend of mine cooked and they were great as well. I like their assortment of prepared foods. They also have sandwiches read more

Wonderful, friendly staff! They were very helpful when I called about getting some beef bones, and put some aside for me to pick up the next day. They seem to have a decent selection of meat offerings that are hard to find elsewhere in the area. It's a bit expensive, but that's to be expected. I'll definitely go back when I need meat for special dinners, but I wish I could afford to go there weekly. read more

Visiting from out of town and Jack went above and beyond explaining his meats. The selection is outstanding. We were very pleased with our steaks and sides (lobster bisque and Mac n cheese). Highly recommend! read more

Dinner for 18 prepared by New York Butcher Shop. Beef Tenderloin, gouda bacon mac N cheese, grilled veggies, cranberry goat cheese salad! Amazing dinner! Tender, flavorful & juicy cut of beef. Also, their customer service was phenomenal, Hunter was so very helpful. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! read more

A friend of mine told me about this place as I was having difficulty finding meats during this pandemic . The best pimento cheese I have ever had and my family said the filets were fabulous Will definitely be back read more

If you are looking for a great butcher that is also reasonably price...this is the place you need to be shopping. Not only do they offer a great meat selection, you can also stop in for a deli lunch! Not only do they have meat available, but also dips...you HAVE to try the parm dill dip...super yummy!! Thankful to have a butcher of this quality in Augusta! read more

Better than we expected. We will be using them on a regular. Nothing like the others. They customize your order. There isn't all these people hanging around and making the experience awkward. Just real people buying there items and getting out of the way of others. Very classy. read more

We shop here often. Great selection of fresh meats. They have premise side that are delicious and just require heating. Try the tomato pie. yum! They have a wine tasting every third Thursday of each month. For a small fe, you get 4 wines to try and 4 small plate courses. It's a great time to meet the staff and make new friends. If you plan on attending, please call ahead so they can get an estimated headcount. Not required, but helps them ensure there's enough tasty dishes for all. read more

Way over priced. You people who claim this place is top rank know nothing about beef quality or pricing. And it shows in the reviews.

What a great find in Augusta. I went here specifically for the subs and I was not disappointed. Now they are not cheap, $9, but you get your money's worth. This place is not comparable to that underground railroad store that slaps subs together like an assembly line. This place has sandwich artists. This good of a sub is hard to find in the south. Tons of meat, a little veggie, and great bread. I cant wait to go back and try another style. Don't skip this place if your in town. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Augusta, Georgia

Was totally wowed by the service and quality of meat. I went in (after looking at different meat packages online) and they were out of a certain cut in the package. After talking with the owner (Jack) he was more than happy to make a substitution - of a higher quality at the same price - for what I needed it for without me having to come back the next day. We also made additional purchases which included a fresh, made to order sandwich (super yummy). Will totally be revisiting, but will be sure to call in advance if I want something specific. read more

Wow -- this place has gone downhill! I stopped in last week after not having been there in a while and was shocked at what I found! The wine shelves were practically empty, food that was past it's "best by" date was being sold at half price in the pre-made food case. The portion size on the sandwich had gone way down as well. I don't know what happened, but I was thoroughly disappointed. The only reason I'm still giving it two stars is they still do have a nice selection of steaks. I felt really dejected though when I left! read more

Top notch customer service. Came in on a whim just as they were closing and they still whipped me up a savory sandwich to go.

This place is great. If you're looking for meats that are a cut above (ha...see what I did there?), look no further. They have a good selection of beef, pork, and other vegan-friendly treats, as well as occasionally stocking special items (like the Duroc pork I got yesterday). They are also able to order special items (venison, etc), though some foresight and a healthy wallet may be necessary. They even carry prepped foods, though I admittedly have never tried any of them. The location is pretty good, as well, being set up in Surrey Center. read more

Great Butcher Shop. Quality of meat and quality of customer service cannot be beat. Jack did a great job with procuring a GREAT suckling pig for our Rec Tec Grill. I've also been there for their sandwiches during a work lunch and they are very tasty. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

We have been wanting to stop in this place for a long time and did today...boy did we hit the jackpot!!! Besides Jack and Margaret (owners) being really, really nice people the steak and stuffed potato we had were wonderful!! Jack offered to season the steak with his special seasoning and it was delicious! They have so much to offer that we will have to go back multiple times to try everything! I look forward to the next visit and one of their wine tastings! Thank you Jack and Margaret!! read more

Finally a place that understands the concept of quality and service. I stop by once a week for lunch and each time I am greeted warmly, served quickly and enjoy truly delicious sandwiches. All the ingredients are clearly top quality and made fresh to order; great prices too! read more

We'd had our eye on this shop for awhile, but it was a victim of 'out of sight, out of mind' due to its location on Surrey Center. I was reminded of it when someone was raving about their chicken salad last week. I stopped in to pick up a quick dinner for my husband and I. They have a short menu as well as a build to order option, we tried both. First of all, their meats and cheeses are among the finest we've ever eaten. There are only two small ways that the sandwiches could be improved. We are northern transplants, and were largely raised on hard rolls. I get that this is a regional preference, but I hear often from fellow transplants that you can't get a decent sandwich roll down here. Our favorite deli in our last town solved this by offering both hard and soft rolls. Second, they used leafy greens as lettuce. I'm looking for crunch from my lettuce, and the kind they use wilts the second it hits the meat. In spite of these two things, it was the best sandwich I've had in the four months I've lived here. read more

I expected better customer service from a small business. I like to see what my choices are when purchasing instead of just calling in an order to be picked up later, which this business would prefer you to do. I went in to get a prime rib for my family Christmas dinner and they were "to busy to cut that right now". So I placed an order to be picked up 24 Dec. on 24 December when I went in to get it they did not have it. I was told "you should have made a reservation for that earlier we don't have any now." It took them awhile to actually find my order paperwork. Turns out they had sold my rib the day before. While I was stressing about what I was going to do for Christmas dinner now, they finally came up with a smaller one. My Christmas dinner is to important to me to trust my business to someone like this. I waited to post until I thought I want so mad, turns out I'm still a little fired up about this service. read more