Awful, awful experience -- not to be too dramatic, but it makes me sad about the state of humanity. We started working with New Avenue almost *three years ago* to remodel our kitchen and add an additional half story for a new bedroom. To date, we've paid them $45k (and they're pressuring us to pay another $10k) and we do NOT even have a set of compliant plans that we can submit to permitting. There was constant turnover, lack of supervision and accountability, and ultimately a real failure of management to take responsibility for how badly they missed things up for us: when we pointed out all the problems, the CEO's response was to say he would cancel the contract "because we couldn't work things out" -- leaving us out over $50k total, with three lost years and literally nothing to show for it, no plans, no permit, nothing.
Things started out ok. We began work on the project in 2024 with one designer, who seemed responsive and responsible. She got us through schematic design and we were about to move on to construction documents, when she left the firm. Then we cycled through several different designers, before ending up with someone who I can only think must have been a pathological liar (it seemed like she was used to working with wealthy clients and maybe rules don't actually matter for rich people?). She suggested a bunch of changes to the existing design, racking up additional design fees, but insisting they'd save us money or add value. And when we asked why the original designer had done it differently, she said she had no idea. We kept pressing as to whether there was some rule she wasn't taking into account, and she insisted, there wasn't. She said she'd submitted our plans to the city's permitting office in the summer of 2025 and told us from talking to them that everything looked good and we'd likely be able to start construction by the end of the year. Instead, nothing happened. For nine long months, we kept asking what was going on, and she kept saying permits should come any day now.
That designer then left in spring of this year, and that's when we realized all the problems. New Avenue admitted that they couldn't even find her files or any evidence of communications with the city. We had to do a Public Records Request just to find out what she'd submitted. And then we learned, that within a month of her submission, the city had replied saying the application was incomplete and noncompliant with basic city regulations about setbacks and daylight planes, and that if we wanted to move the project forward, she had to correct those issues. But the designer never responded to that email, never told us about it, and never did anything about it. The rejected application just sat there for nine months, while she kept saying everything was ok.
To add insult to injury, it turned out the problems were all ones *created* when the new designer undid what the original designer had done. We looked back through files and saw that the first designer had spent time identifying the applicable regs and built a design around them; it was all in the file! The new designer apparently never even read our file, never even looked at the regs, and flat out lied about communicating with the city. And her designs were entirely noncompliant.
A few months ago, another New Avenue team took over the project and they spent another $10k discovering all this and trying to argue that the plans could be saved before concluding that they could not. We then asked whether the original designs would have addressed the problems, and the new folks finally looked back to what we'd paid for two years ago and said yes, that would have worked.
We then took the time to meet with the CEO and to express how frustrating this had all been, but we also made clear that our goal was just to finish what we'd started with them at least through permitting, as long as they could figure out how to compensate us for the fact that we'd been misled for over a year and paid for recklessly faulty work. Essentially, we said, just fix everything and we'll forget about it.
This is where it got sad! The CEO came back to us incredibly aggressively, saying that they had done nothing wrong, that the design process was "iterative," and that it's entirely normal to spend money on a range of designs before getting approval. He said if we wanted to move forward, we'd have to pay them at least $30k more ($10k of existing bills plus $20k to transform the original designer's schematic designs into proper construction documents). He indicated they likely would no longer work with us on construction. And he suggested, out of nowhere, that perhaps we should just sell our house instead.
We were on vacation when that email came through and also wanted to think it over before responding. But before we could, the CEO emailed again saying, well we've tried to work this out, but it looks like we can't, so we're terminating the contract...
Long story short, we're suing. read more